loader

Daily Briefs

Government raises USD 2.5 billion from international market


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Government raises USD 2.5 billion from international market
IMF disburses USD 498.7 million tranche

On 30 March, the PTI government ventured into the international capital market for the first time and “raised $2.5 billion in three dollar bonds of five, 10 and 30 years.” A source in the ministry of finance and debt said, “The government had contracted a USD one billion five-year bond at an interest rate of six per cent. Additionally, the government also contracted a USD one billion 10-year bond at 7.375 per cent. Lastly, it contracted USD 500 million of 30-year bond at 8.875 per cent. 

Dawn reports that “Deutsche Bank, Emirates NBD Capital, JPMorgan, Standard Chartered, Credit Suisse and BOC International were the arranger to the transaction.” (Khaleeq Kiani, “$2.5bn raised in govt’s first foray into international market,” Dawn, 31 March 2021)

Meanwhile...
On 30 March, the State Bank of Pakistan said it had received a USD 498.7 million tranche from the IMF as part of the USD six billion programme that was revived recently. With the latest tranche, Pakistan has received USD two billion of the total amount, (“Pakistan gets $499m IMF tranche,” The News International, 31 March 2021)

 

Hafeez deserved a better farewell, says Dawn
Replacing finance minister not a solution to inflation, says opinion

Image Source: The Express Tribune

An editorial in Dawn says the government’s decision to relieve Hafeez Sheikh of his duties as finance minister was unfortunate and ungracious. The editorial cites the government’s explanation behind his removal - high inflation rate - and says that had Hafeez won the Senate elections, the government would have retained him regardless of the inflation. This, it says, is evident because if it were not the case, “the government would not have cashed its chips in a bid to get him elected” in Islamabad. Therefore, the editorial opines that Hafeez deserved a better farewell. 

Next, it outlines the possible cabinet reshuffle and says, “If the reshuffle is confined to replacing one tried and tested person with another, it may not inspire too much confidence.” On the other hand, if Imran Khan introduces “a radical change by ushering in fresh blood, it could mean that he is prepared to come out of his crease for the final overs.” (“Finance minister’s removal,” Dawn, 31 March 2021)

“Holding the finance minister responsible for rising prices is absurd,” says opinion
An opinion, critical of the removal of Hafeez Sheikh, says that the decision is reflective of a “government completely losing its bearings.” Referring to the government’s justification, the author says that inflation is not a recent problem and that replacing Hafeez will not resolve the issue. Instead, he says, policies of the government, timing of the policies, matter in addressing inflation. He reiterates, “The government’s failure on all these fronts is apparent. Holding the finance minister responsible for the rising prices is absurd.”

Further, he opines that there is something larger behind the move. He explains that Hammaz Azhar is the third finance minister under Imran Khan’s tenure and, “It remains to be seen how long he can enjoy the trust of the prime minister and implement his so-called ‘vision’.” (Zahid Hussain, “Unceremonious departure,” Dawn, 31 March 2021)

 

FM Qureshi meets with President Ghani 
Voices concern over violence in Afghanistan

Image Source: Dawn

On 30 March, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi met President of Afghanistan Ashraf Ghani in Dushanbe, Tajikistan. During the meeting, the two sides discussed matters of mutual interest, including the Afghan peace process. Qureshi also expressed concern over the rising incidents of violence in Afghanistan and said that Pakistan’s position remained the same that the Afghan problem could not be solved through military option, adding that Pakistan supported a political solution to the Afghan problem through comprehensive dialogue. 

Meets with FM of Afghanistan and Iran
Qureshi also met with Afghan Foreign Minister Haneef Atmar to discuss bilateral relations and the Afghan peace process. Further, during the meeting with the Iranian FM Dr Javad Zarif, the two ministers reviewed their bilateral relations and exchanged views on regional issues as well as progress on the opening of a new border crossing point. (“FM meets Ghani, voices concern over violence in Afghanistan,” Dawn, 31 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Opposition calls for Hafeez and Babar to be put on the ECL
On 30 March, the opposition parties, mainly PPP and PML-N called for reviewing all the agreements which were signed by Dr Abdul Hafeez Shaikh as finance minister with international donors. They also called for placing Hafeez’s as well as former special assistant to the prime minister (SAPM) on petroleum Nadeem Babar on the Exit Control List (ECL) to prevent them from flying abroad. (“Opposition wants Hafeez, Babar on ECL,” Dawn, 31 March 2021)

ECONOMY
World Bank predicts a 1.3 per cent growth rate
On 30 March, the World Bank in its annual flagship South Asia Economic Focus report stated “Pakistan’s exposure to debt-related shocks will remain elevated.” Further, it said that it does not see a speedy economic turnaround in Pakistan, projecting a 1.3 per cent growth rate with public debt peaking at 94 per cent size of the nation’s economy in the current fiscal year. (“World Bank paints bleak picture of economy,” The Express Tribune, 31 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
‘Peace in South Asia hinges on Kashmir settlement,’ says PM
On 31 March, The Express Tribune reported that PM Imran Khan in response to PM Modi’s letter for National Day said “The people of Pakistan also desire peaceful, cooperative relationship with all neighbours, including India.” Further, he said, “We are convinced that that durable peace and stability in South Asia is contingent upon resolving all outstanding issues between India and Pakistan, in particular, the Jammu and Kashmir dispute.” (“‘Peace in South Asia hinges on Kashmir settlement’, Imran tells Modi,” The Express Tribune, 31 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
"Women are the primary casualties of the pandemic whether or not they were infected with the virus," says opinion 
An opinion in Dawn says that women everywhere have been the primary casualties of the coronavirus pandemic, having had to pay the price regardless of being infected with the virus. Citing recent peer review statistics that highlight the previous statement the opinion says that in the post-pandemic world women will be at an even greater disadvantage than they were before it started. The opinion says that men must be held answerable for the cruelty and selfishness they have exhibited this past year, attitudes that they have never questioned or considered, arguing that the women of Pakistan cannot be expected to shoulder all the burden of housekeeping, childcare, studies and work from home. (Rafia Zakaria, “Women during the pandemic,” Dawn, 31 March 2021)

ON GILGIT-BALTISTAN
Govt approves multi-billion development package for GB
On 30 March, the government approved a multi-billion development for Gilgit- Baltistan. The details of the plan are to be unveiled by PM Imran Khan during his visit to the region later this month. During the meeting, PM Khan stressed on the need for exploiting the huge potential of tourism; he also directed the chief minister of GB to give special attention to protecting the environment and promoting tourism in the region. (“Multi-billion development package for GB approved,” Dawn, 31 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                     
 
An opinion in The Express Tribune says that it is possible that one many be reading too much into the issue of Prime Minister Imran Khan not being invited to the climate summit by United States President Joe Biden, arguing if this be so, it is unfortunate, as mixing politics with matters related to climate change, which pose a universal challenge spread over future generations, should have been avoided.
 
 




"Democracy is, at its heart, a popularity contest, and Shaikh was clearly not popular."
-An editorial in The Express Tribune on 'Shaikh out, Azhar in' 

 


PM replaces Hafeez Shaikh over inflation


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PM replaces Hafeez Shaikh over inflation
Cabinet reshuffle likely to take place

On 29 March, Prime Minister Imran Khan removed Hafeez Shaikh from the position of Finance Minister allegedly due to the rising inflation; the latter has been replaced by Minister of Industries Hammad Azhar who is, now, the third finance minister in a span of two and a half years. However, there are speculations that Imran’s decision came over differences with the former minister on the IMF programme. Further, Information Minister Shibli Faraz said that Imran was dissatisfied Shaikh's performance and said the PM  “had formed a new economic team to provide relief to the masses.”(“Hammad Azhar notified as finance minister,” The Express Tribune, 30 March 2021)

Hafeez Shaikh’s removal
While the removal of Hafeez comes as a surprise, it was also unavoidable. Hafeez was appointed as the finance minister in December 2020 after serving as the SAPM since 2018. “However, as per Article 91 (9) of the Constitution, he cannot remain a minister for more than six months until he is elected to one of the houses.” If Hafeez had been elected to the Senate during the upper house’s elections earlier in March, he could have retained the position after June. (Shahbaz Rana, “Rising inflation costs Hafeez Shaikh his job,” The Express Tribune, 30 March 2021)

Upcoming cabinet reshuffle
On 30 March, Imran concluded a consultation meeting on introducing changes to the cabinet. The News International quoted a source who said that “changes in the Information, Power, Aviation, Economic Affairs and Kashmir Committee have been mulled over.” Sources says that Fawad Chaudhry and Shibli Faraz too will be shuffled. (“PM concludes consultations on cabinet reshuffle,” The News International, 30 March 2021)

Previously...
On 26 February, Imran had asked his SAPM on petroleum to resign “to ensure transparency in the fuel crisis probe.” This charge has also been given to Hammad. 

 

Opposition objects to ordinance on tax reforms
PML-N calls it violation of constitution 

Image Source: Dawn

On 29 March, the opposition objected to the Income Tax Ordinance and Nepra Ordinance during the National Assembly session. PML-N’s Ahsan Iqbal said neither the president nor the prime minister has no right to amend the tax system; it can be done only through the parliament. He alleged, “However, the government has imposed new taxes of Rs700b by introducing ordinances which is a violation of the Constitution.” Following this, another PML-N leader suggested to the Speaker that to halt implementation of the ordinance and asked him to arrive at a decision after consultations “with the legal experts from the treasury and opposition benches.” 

PML-N’s logic will nullify SROs, saying Hammad Azhar
However, the new finance minister alleged that the previous government, including PML-N, introduced new taxes through Statutory Regulatory Orders (SROs). He said, “If we accept this argument [of Ahsan Iqbal] then all the SROs will become void.” (Saqib Virk, “Opposition parties object to tax ordinances,” The Express Tribune, 30 March 2021)

 

PM, Saudi Arabia Crown Prince have telephonic conversation
Reiterate need to address climate change

Image Source: The News International

On 29 March, Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman had a telephonic conversation with Imran Khan. The Prince invited Imran to visit Saudi Arabia. Apart from discussing bilateral ties, the two discussed climate change and the need for bilateral cooperation to address the same. Imran appreciated the “Saudi Green Initiative and Green Middle East Initiative” and the “Green Middle East Initiative.” Further, Imran emphasised on Pakistan’s “Clean and Green Pakistan” programme. He said,  “While our two countries maintain close cooperation on climate change issues at all multilateral forums, a meaningful and structural bilateral engagement can help advance our shared vision...We would also be happy to share experience, knowledge and lessons from our nature-based approaches and initiatives.” ("Saudi prince calls PM Imran, invites him to Riyadh," Dawn, 30 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PPP, PML-N parted ways due to conflict of interests, says Interior Minister
On 29 March, Interior Minister Sheikh Rashid Ahmed alleging that there is a split in the PDM says that both the PPP and PML-N had parted ways due to a conflict of interests. He claimed that both the parties had remained arch political rivals in the past but made the alliance under the PDM's banner only to oust PM Imran Khan. Further, he added that the PDM’s political moves posed no threat to the PTI led government. (“PPP, PML-N parted ways due to conflict of interests: Sh Rashid,” The News International, 30 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Pakistan committed to supporting a peaceful, sovereign Afghanistan, says Qureshi
On 30 March, during the 9th Heart of Asia–Istanbul Process ministerial conference FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi stated that Pakistan will continue to support a peaceful, sovereign and prosperous Afghanistan, at peace with itself and with its neighbours. He said, "The Heart of Asia – Istanbul Process is an important platform bringing participating countries together to advance shared goals of peace, stability and prosperity in Afghanistan." (“Pakistan will continue to support a peaceful, sovereign Afghanistan: Qureshi,” Dawn, 30 March 2021)

Pakistan, Denmark forms a joint technical working group to enhance energy cooperation
On 29 March, Pakistan and Denmark formed a joint technical working group to formulate the terms of reference (ToRs) for government-to-government agreements in the field of energy. This took place after a virtual meeting where the two sides deliberated on the findings and recommendations of the Danish energy team for G2G (government-to-government) collaboration between Denmark and Pakistan in the energy sector, keeping in mind Pakistan’s newly approved alternative energy policy. (“Pakistan, Denmark to enhance energy cooperation,” The Express Tribune, 30 March 2021)

ECONOMY
Pakistan and ADB agree to expand their development partnership
On 30 March, The Express Tribune reported that Pakistan and the Asian Development Bank (ADB) have agreed to continue deliberating on ways to deepen their development partnership and ensure effectiveness of the ongoing portfolio. During a virtual meeting between Federal Minister for Economic Affairs and ADB Central and West Asia Department Director-General, the minister appreciated the ADB’s role in terms of quality of the portfolio and support keeping in view the emerging needs of the country to fight the pandemic. Similarly, Director General acknowledged the Pakistan government’s commitment to the reform process and economic recovery. (“Pakistan, ADB agree to expand partnership,” The Express Tribune, 30 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                    
An opinion in Dawn says that there is still much to be gained by the PML-N and PPP putting their differences aside arguing that both parties stand to gain by keeping the PDM alive, with all its components.

An opinion in The News International says that a failed higher education sector may make Pakistan less of state and less of society arguing that the graduates of the Pakistani system of education are not competitive, do not have saleable cognitive or non-cognitive skills, and cannot innovate or operate outside the box. Further, an editorial in The Express Tribune says that the issue of unemployed and under-employed highly educated youth is common to most developing countries, and Pakistan is no exception arguing that several universities in Pakistan are facing a financial crunch thus are unable to absorb PhDs.
 
 


"Families have a right to justice without carrying the bodies of loved ones from one place to another.This is a question of humanity and not of politics or revenge...It is time to restore rule of law in the area and bring it back into the mainstream of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa so that justice can be delivered."
-An editorial in The News International on 'Protesting for justice'

 


COVID-19 test positivity rate surpasses 11 per cent


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
COVID-19 test positivity rate surpasses 11 per cent
PML-Q criticises ally for slow vaccination rollout

On 29 March (today), Pakistan’s test positivity rate of COVID-19 crossed 11 per cent. According to the National Command and Operation Centre, 4,525 positive cases and 41 deaths were recorded in the last 24 hours. 

The NCOC has also identified 19 districts with high test positivity ratios. Swat has the highest test positivity ratio at 23 per cent, followed by Peshawar with 22 per cent. Keeping this in mind, the NCOC said the government was deliberating on restrictions on inter-provincial travel. (“Coronavirus situation worsens in Pakistan,” The News International, 29 March 2021)

“Talk less and arrange more doses of vaccines,” PML-Q tells government
On 28 March, PML-Q leader and Punjab Assembly’s Speaker Chaudhry Pervaiz Elahi said that Pakistan was lagging behind in inoculating its population. He said, “Talk less and arrange more doses of vaccine to deal with coronavirus.” The PML-Q is the PTI’s ally. (“‘Talk less, do more’: PML-Q criticises PTI govt over ‘slow vaccine rollout’,” The Express Tribune, 29 March 2021)

Meanwhile...
On 29 March, The National Assembly’s spring session began amid the increasing number of COVID-19 cases. The government’s decision to call the session has garnered a degree of surprise from the Opposition, who were expecting the session to begin from April. The PPP’s Information Secretary opined that the government may be trying to introduce new legislation hurriedly. She mentioned that the current government “only convened the sessions when it had some emergency and wanted to bulldoze some legislations or carry out some business without a consensus.” Similarly, a PML-N leader said “the government had made the parliament redundant by not allowing any meaningful debate on any public matter.” (Amir Wasim, “NA session begins today amid spike in Covid-19 cases,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)

 

PM asks SBP, NBP to ease terms of Naya Pakistan housing scheme
Information Minister terms housing scheme as beginning to a welfare state

Image Source: The News International

On 28 March, Prime Minister Imran Khan instructed the State Bank of Pakistan and the National Bank of Pakistan to ease housing loans “so that people can get maximum benefit of the government’s flagship Naya Pakistan Housing Programme (NPHP).” His request came after several people raised complaints about the complicated process of application for the loan. 

NPHP as the foundation to a welfare state
Addressing the people’s concerns, Imran promised that the government would place widows and differently-abled as a priority in the programme. Further, he outlined the importance of the NPHP in boosting the economy. He maintained that the programme would help in wealth creation. He added, Information Minister Shibli Faraz said the NPHP was the stepping stone to fulfill the dream to develop Pakistan as a welfare state. 

The NPHP scheme
Imran said the NPHP would ensure that “the beneficiaries currently paying house rent would be using the rent amount to pay housing loan’s installments.” This would, therefore, benefit the salaried class and people with no money. Under the NPHP, beneficiaries would “pay a monthly installment of Rs6,600 for Rs1 million loan, Rs13,199 for Rs2m loan, Rs19,799 for Rs3m loan, Rs26,398 for Rs4m loan and Rs32,998 for Rs5m loan." (Syed Irfan Raza, “Imran asks SBP, NBP to soften housing loan terms,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)

 

Janikhel tribe ends protests after talks with KP govt
Signs agreement after CM agrees to all demands

Image Source: Dawn

On 29 March, the Janikhel tribe of Bannu, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa decided to end protests after signing an agreement and holding talks with the government. The Special Assistant to Chief Minister said that the CM had accepted all the demands, stating that members of the provincial cabinet, as well as mediators, were part of the dialogue. (“Jani Khel tribe ends protests following talks with K-P govt,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)

Previously…
The residents have been protesting over the brutal killing of the four teenage boys whose bullet-riddled bodies were found in a field on 21 March. Since then, tribesmen and relatives staging a sit-in in their area, demanding the immediate arrest of the culprits involved in the kidnappings and murder of four teenagers. On 28 March, around 10,000 people began a protest march towards Islamabad demanding action against anti-state elements. (“Janikhel protesters begin march towards Islamabad with bodies of 4 teenage boys,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
JI holds another rally in Karachi
On 28 March, the Jamaat-i-Islami held a big rally from Quaidabad to Governor House. They warned that a sit-in would be held outside the Chief Minister House in the next phase if its demands regarding a fresh census, end to job quota system and an empowered local government system were not met. (“JI holds another power show for due rights of Karachi,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)

A group of unidentified people attack a 100-year-old temple in Rawalpindi
On 27 March, a group of unidentified people attacked a 100-year-old Hindu temple at Purana Qila on causing damage to its ongoing renovation work, stairs and doors. Further, a security officer of the Evacuee Trust Property Board (ETPB) said that legal action will be sought against the people who had caused damage to the temple and its sanctity. (“100-year-old temple attacked in Rawalpindi,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)

Lack of reforms in Pakistan’s criminal justice befitted Omar Sheikh in the Daniel Pearl case, says Editorial
An editorial in Dawn critical of Pakistan’s criminal justice system says that the recent verdict in the Daniel Pearl cases proves that investigation and prosecution remain in shambles, ravaged by corruption, incompetence and habitual manipulation. Further, the editorial argues that the judiciary and the executive both share the blame for their inability and unwillingness to cleanse the criminal justice system of the rot that has now seeped deep. (“Weak prosecution,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Iran hands over 113 Pakistani nationals to the Levies Force
On 28 March, the Iranian authorities handed over 113 Pakistani nationals to the Levies Force at Raahdari Gate of the Taftan border in Chagai district. These people are said to have been arrested in different parts of Iran for not having valid travelling documents. Further, these detainees have been handed over to the Federal Investigation Authority (FIA) who will investigate and prosecute the illegal migrants. (“Iran hands over 113 illegal migrants to Pakistan,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)

“No meeting has been finalised or requested” with India, says FM
On 28 March, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi stated that “no meeting has been finalised or requested” with regard to the speculations of the meeting of the foreign ministers of Pakistan and India in Dushanbe, Tajikistan on the side-lines of a ministerial conference of the Heart of Asia — Istanbul Process. (“No meeting planned with Indian FM, says Qureshi,” Dawn, 29 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                        
An opinion in Dawn says that with every successive Aurat March, antagonism against the movement is becoming more and more venomous, arguing that "all it takes for patriarchy to unravel and become entangled is the mere sight of women congregating in public."
 


"When the highest court in the land takes such an unequivocal stance on a woman’s inherent right to dignity, without pandering to regressive notions of ‘culture’ and ‘tradition’, it cannot but nudge society a little more towards a humane ideal."
-An editorial in Dawn on 'An enlightened verdict'

 


PML-N expresses disappointment over PPP’s move in the Senate


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PML-N expresses disappointment over PPP’s move in the Senate
Will demand answers from PPP, says Maryam 

On 26 March, PPP’s Yousuf Gilani was announced as the Leader of the Opposition of the Senate. Following this, the rift between the PPP and PML-N within the PDM widened. Gilani said he contested for the position keeping in line with the PPP’s stance that “the voice of parliament is the voice of the people of Pakistan and we should not ignore it.” Further, he reiterated that linking the PDM’s long march with resignations was new to the PPP. This, however, he said was “the spirit of democracy. When you agree to disagree, it is democracy.” 

PML-N unhappy over developments
The PML-N expressed displeasure over the PPP’s decision to nominate Gilani after it was decided earlier that the post would go to the former’s candidate. Maryam Nawaz said that “the PML-N and the JUI-F would be sufficient to stage a long march against the government.” Further, she said she would ask PDM chief Fazlur Rehman to demand answers from the PPP as it went against the PDM’s decisions. (“Senate of Pakistan: Political storm brews up as Yusuf Raza Gilani becomes opposition leader,” The News International, 27 March 2021)

A PML-N leader, who is quoted anonymously, told The Express Tribune that “The PPP has stabbed all PDM parties in the back.” She said the PPP should have approached Nawaz Sharif if they wanted the Senate position and “Sharif would never have refused.” Further, she accused the PPP of using the PDM for short-term gains which would, eventually, “be counterproductive for the entire nation.” (Rameez Khan, “PPP is using PDM for personal gains: PML-N,” The Express Tribune, 27 March 2021)

PML-N Senator says PDM is dead
The Express Tribune quotes a PML-N Senator on the condition of anonymity who said the “PDM is now dead and today it’s been given an indecent burial.” The Senator added that amid the power politics between the PPP and the PML-N, the fight against the ruling party is now in shambles. Further, the Senator opined that the PML-N had no “Plan B” and also that opting for the extreme approach was the party’s fault. (Rizwan Shehzad, “‘Dead as a dodo, PDM gets indecent burial’,” The Express Tribune, 27 March 2021)

 

Pakistan to borrow USD 1.3 billion from World Bank
Government to borrow USD two billion through Eurobonds

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 26 March, Pakistan signed an agreement with the World Bank to avail a loan of USD 1.3 billion to “boost the country’s foreign exchange reserves and help support social sectors.” The agreement entails six projects: Crisis-Resilient Social Protection Programme (CRISP) of USD 600 million, Locust Emergency and Food Security Project (USD 200 million), Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Human Capital Investment Project (USD 200 million), Sindh Resilience Project (USD 200 million), Balochistan Livelihood & Entrepreneurship and Balochistan Human Capital Investment Projects (USD 86 million), and Institutional Interventions for Management of Refugees Project (USD 50 million). 

The CRISP programme is aimed at developing crisis resilience in poor and vulnerable households, expansion of the Ehsaas scheme, assisting the informal sector and the like. The Locust Emergency Fund would include locust surveillance, rehabilitation of affected communities and farmers. The KP project would ensure “availability, utilisation and quality of primary healthcare services and elementary education services” in districts that host refugees. The Sindh project will deal with mitigation of flood and drought risks “and strengthen Sindh’s capacity to manage natural disasters and public health emergencies.” The Balochistan project aims to boost “employment opportunities for rural communities, achieve sustainability of enterprises and improve utilisation of quality health and education services.” Lastly, the Institutional Interventions programme would deal with improving “organisational and institutional capacity for managing refugees and host communities.” (“World Bank, Pakistan ink deals for $1.3bn aid,” Dawn, 27 March 2021)

Meanwhile…
Pakistan will borrow USD two million through the Eurobonds in the coming week. The developments come after the revival of the IMF project. The Express Tribune explains that the public debt of Pakistan is nearly 90 per cent of the economy, and is “far higher than the statutory limit set by parliament and also above the sustainable level.” (Shahbaz Rana, “Pakistan takes another $1.3b loan from World Bank,” The Express Tribune, 27 March 2021)

 

Pakistan tests Shaheen 1-A surface-to-surface ballistic missile
Test flight aimed at re-validating various design and technical parameters 

Image Source: Dawn

On 26 March, the Pakistan Amy conducted a successful flight test of the Shaheen 1-A surface-to-surface ballistic missile having a range of 900 kilometres. Further, Shaheen 1-A with its sophisticated and advanced guidance system is said to be a highly accurate missile system. According to the ISPR, the test flight was aimed at re-validating various design and technical parameters of the weapon system, including an advanced navigation system. (“Pakistan test-fires Shaheen 1A missile,” The News International, 27 March 2021)

Previously…
In March, the army had test-fired Babur cruise missile IA, a short-range surface-to-surface ballistic missile capable of hitting land and sea targets with high precision up to 450km away. Previously February, the army had conducted the ‘training launch’ of nuclear-capable ballistic mis­sile Ghaznavi as part of its annual field training exercise. Earlier in January, a test of the surface-to-surface ballistic missile Shaheen-III was carried out. (“Pakistan successfully test-fires Shaheen 1-A ballistic missile,” Dawn, 27 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Entire evidence in Daniel Pearl case doubtful, says Supreme Court
On 26 March, the Supreme Court issued a detailed verdict in the January 28 decision to release Ahmad Omar Saeed stating that the entire evidence in the case is full of doubts and the prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of all the four accused. In its judgement, the court said that the evidence furnished during the trial was full of factual and legal defects. The court “Hence Criminal Appeal No 602/2020 filed by Ahmed Omar [Saeed] Sheikh is allowed. He is acquitted of all the charges. He shall be released from jail if not required to be detained in any other case.” (“Entire evidence in Daniel Pearl case doubtful: Supreme Court,” The Express Tribune, 27 March 2021)

SAPM Nadeem Babar to step down over the fuel crisis
On 26 March, Federal Minister Asad Umar announced that Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on Petroleum Nadeem Babar has been asked to resign over last year's fuel crisis. He stated Babar has been asked to step down from the position for a 90-day period, during which the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) will conduct a forensic investigation into the “criminal acts” that led to the fuel crisis. Further, the FIA is to submit its report within 90 days based on which prosecution will be done. (“SAPM Nadeem Babar asked to step down over fuel crisis: Asad Umar,” Dawn, 27 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Flag meeting of brigade commanders from Pakistan and India held
On 26 March, a Brigade Commander level flag meeting was held between India and Pakistan Army at Rawalakot-Poonch Crossing Point to discuss implementation mechanism as per understanding. According to the ISPR, this meeting took place as a follow-up to an understanding reached between Directors General Military Operations (DGMOs) of Pakistan and India to strictly observe the ceasefire at the Line of Control (LoC). (“Pak-India Brigade Commanders flag meeting held at Rawalakot-Poonch Crossing Point,” Associate Press of Pakistan, 26 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
SC asks courts to use proper language for rape victims
On 27 March, The Express Tribune reported that the Supreme Court has asked courts neither to use inappropriate expressions for rape victims nor to drag the sexual history of a rape survivor into a case of sexual assault. The SC said, “The courts should also discontinue the use of painfully intrusive and inappropriate expressions, like ‘habituated to sex’, ‘woman of easy virtue’, ‘woman of loose moral character’, and ‘non-virgin’, for the alleged rape victims even if they find that the charge of rape is not proved against the accused,” adding that “Such expressions are unconstitutional and illegal.” Further, the court stated, “No one has the license to invade her person or violate her privacy on the ground of her alleged immoral character. Even if the victim of rape is accustomed to sexual intercourse, it is not determinative in a rape case; the real fact-in-issue is whether or not the accused committed her rape.” (Hasnaat Malik, “Use proper language for rape victims: SC asks courts,” The Express Tribune, 27 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                   
An opinion in Dawn while answering the question ‘What if PTI fails?’ says that today, PTI may be a failure in terms of its own targets, but the final judgement should await the end of the term, arguing that if PTI wants to resurrect its fortunes, it may need to look closer to home.

An editorial in The News International says that the return of local government will have major implications for the government in Punjab, arguing that it is a constitutional and democratic right of the people to have a well-functioning local government system. In the absence of such mechanisms, the people suffer for the most basic of services they need at the local level. Similarly, an editorial in Dawn says that the Supreme Court of Pakistan made the right decision in ordering the restoration of local government institutions in Punjab. 
 
 


"While, on paper, an IMF programme is all about bringing economic stability through structural reforms, the conditionalites should not be harsh enough to affect the implementation capacity of the reforms themselves…In Pakistan’s case however, the reform measures suggested – rather forced upon – by the IMF are getting more and more difficult for the common man to put up with."
-An editorial in The Express Tribune on 'The cost of $500m tranche'

 


Yousuf Gilani declared as opposition leader in the Senate


Photo: The News International



In Focus
Yousuf Gilani declared as opposition leader in the Senate
PDM engaged in negotiations to resolve internal issues, say sources

On 26 March (today), Yousuf Gilani was declared Leader of the Opposition in the Senate. The development comes amid differences between the PPP and the PML-N. The PML-N termed Gilani's nominations as a "setback" for the PDM. ("Setback for PDM as PPP gets prized post of Senate Opposition leader," The News International, 26 March 2021)

Previously...
On the same day, the PPP had submitted Yousuf Gilani’s nomination for the Senate’s opposition leader position. Sherry Rehman said Gilani’s nomination was backed by 30 Senators - 21 from the PPP. The rest of the Senators belonged to the Awami National Party, Jamaat-i-Islami, and some belonged to Fata and Dilawar Khan’s independent group. 

On the other hand, the PML-N had nominated Azam Tarar for the post, backed by 21 Senators, of which 17 belong to the PML-N. The rest of the Senators backing Tarar’s nomination belong to the JUI-F, National Party,  and the Pakhtun­khwa Milli Awami Party. (Nadir Guramani, “PPP submits Gilani's nomination papers for Senate opposition leader,” Dawn, 26 March 2021)

PPP, PML-N trying to resolve issues, say sources
On the same day, Dawn reported that the PDM is engaged in behind-the-scenes negotiations to resolve the issues between the PPP and PML-N on the issue of the opposition leader. According to Dawn’s sources, though the two parties claimed the position, they were trying to chart out a middle path to resolve the differences. (Amir Wasim, “PPP, PML-N trying to resolve differences over Senate slot,” Dawn, 26 March 2021)

 

More than 4,000 COVID-19 cases recorded in a single day
PMA pushes for suspension of social activities 

Image Source: The News International

On 25 March, Pakistan crossed 14,000 covid-related deaths after 63 deaths were recorded in the last 24 hours. On 26 March, Dawn reported that more than 4,000 COVID-19 cases were recorded in a single day for the first time since 2 July 2020; 4,368 cases were recorded. Overall, the test positivity rate in the country stands at 10.2 per cent. The highest number of cases were from Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. 

Meanwhile…
The Pakistan Medical Association requested the Prime Minister to suspend all social activities and gatherings to curb the spread of the virus. However, provinces have already begun to take measures to address the rising number of cases; Punjab has been implementing smart lockdowns; KP has ordered the closure of markets on Fridays and Saturdays and the like. (“Pakistan records over 4,000 cases for first time since July as Punjab, KP drive spike,” Dawn, 26 March 2021) (Ikram Junaidi, “Deaths from Covid cross 14,000 mark in Pakistan,” Dawn, 26 March 2021)

 

Maryam's hearing suspended over ‘virus fears’
Anti-corruption NAB has withdrawn notice ‘fearing public backlash,' says Maryam

Image Source: The News International

On 25 March, the National Accountability announced putting off the interrogation of Maryam Nawaz after the Lahore High Court rejected its plea seeking to limit the number accompanying her to its office on 26 March (today) to two. According to a press release issued by NAB, “The decision has been made in view of NCOC guidelines against coronavirus and in wider public interest.” Adding that it was observed that the NCOC had banned all types of gatherings.

“If there is rule of law in the country, the PM House should also be closed,” says Maryam
In response to the NAB announcement, Maryam said that she would not become an easy prey for the anti-graft body anymore. She added, “The days for using NAB for political victimisation are coming to an end.” Further, she said, “If there is rule of law in the country, the PM House should also be closed.” (“NAB suspends Maryam's hearing over ‘virus fears’,” The Express Tribune, 26 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
SC orders restoration of local government institutions in Punjab
On 25 March, the Supreme Court ordered the restoration of local government institutions in Punjab after declaring their dissolution as unconstitutional. The CJP ruled that “For reasons to be recorded later, Section 3 of the Punjab Local Government Act 2019 (PLGA) whereby the local bodies were dissolved is declared ultra vires of the Constitution and the local governments as were existing in Punjab before the promulgation of the Section 3 stand restored and it shall complete its term in accordance with the law.” (Nasir Iqbal, “SC orders restoration of LG institutions in Punjab,” Dawn, 26 March 2021)

ECONOMY
Shouldn’t the government focus more on real reforms instead of cosmetic changes to qualify for IMF dollars? asks editorial
An editorial in Dawn critical of the country’s re-entry to the $6bn IMF programme says that both the IMF and the government are not being direct about the impact of these ‘adjustments’ that Islamabad has already made or is required to make in the next few months on citizens. It says that although there is little doubt that these adjustments would bring a semblance of “macroeconomic and debt sustainability” in the near term, the question is do short-term gains justify the costs that people will have to bear. Additionally, questioning that shouldn’t the government focus more on real reforms instead of cosmetic changes to qualify for IMF dollars? (“IMF: tough ‘adjustments’,” Dawn, 26 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Pakistani team returns after holding Indus water talks in New Delhi
On 26 March, Dawn reported that on the return of the Pakistan delegation from India, Pakistan’s Commissioner for Indus Waters Syed Mohammad Mehr Ali Shah said “It was a good but difficult meeting. But, finally, we succeeded in making headway by raising/reiterating our objections to the design of Pakal Dul and Lower Kalnai hydropower projects being constructed at the Chenab basin by India.” Further, he said “And finally, they [the Indian side] provided some information, in writing, duly signed and stamped by them regarding the design of the aforementioned two projects. We may seek more information regarding the design [if required] as our engineering experts will examine the information provided to us.” (“India shares information on two power projects,” Dawn, 26 March 2021)

PM Khan extends felicitations to PM Sheikh Hasina Wajed
On 25 March, PM Imran Khan in a letter extended felicitations to PM Sheikh Hasina Wajed on the 50th anniversary of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh. In the letter, he said, “Let us renew our resolve to jointly work for a better future for our peoples and even closer ties between our two countries.” Further, he added, “Pakistan deeply values its fraternal ties with Bangladesh, which are based on shared history, common faith, and convergent of interests in promoting lasting peace and security as well as sustainable prosperity in our region and beyond.” (“Imran felicitates BD premier on anniversary,” Dawn, 26 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
US govt needs to amend laws and invest in the manufacture of non-lethal weapons, says editorial
An editorial in The Express Tribune critical of the recent shootings in the US says that throughout history, the US has notoriously been known for gun violence. In this regard, the editorial suggests that the government needs to amend laws and invest in the manufacture of non-lethal weapons as a suitable substitute. Further, it states that with many claiming the issue to be a “public health crisis”, the problem of mental health and racism needs to be equally addressed, adding that the safety of citizens should be the topmost priority. (“US gun violence,” The Express Tribune, 26 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                         
Najam Sethi in his editorial in The Friday Times argues that Pakistani and the Indian Establishments have not demonstrated any evidence at all of changing their strategic spots or putting their houses in order.

An opinion in Dawn says that in the struggle for women’s rights, the battle will be against ‘classism.’
 


"The PDM’s existential crisis is underpinned by questions of what path to take; is the alliance adamant on bringing down the system, or is there room to discuss a more nuanced approach? Veteran politicians in the alliance have experience navigating such crises and should be able demonstrate whether or not the PDM will become a force to reckon with."
-An editorial in Dawn on 'PPP's politics'

 


PDM leaders agree to keep alliance together


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PDM leaders agree to keep alliance together
PPP to show solidarity with Maryam during hearing

 

On 24 March, PDM Chief Fazlur Rehman intervened between the ongoing differences within the alliance and asked the PPP and the PML-N leaders “to stop making statements against each other.” He conveyed to the two parties that they “have to think beyond the politics of the ’90s” and urged them to respect the PDM’s decision. (Rizwan Shehzad, “Fazl asks PPP, PML-N to calm down,” The Express Tribune, 25 March 2021)

PPP to show support to Maryam during hearing 
On the same day, the PPP assured the PML-N of its presence during Maryam’s hearing on 26 March in Lahore. The announcement came after Fazlur had spoken to Asif Zardari wherein both agreed to keep intact the alliance. According to Dawn’s sources, Fazlur and Zardari opined that breaking the alliance now “would benefit the rulers and strengthen the present set-up” against whom the PDM had been rallying for several months. (Amir Wasim, “Fazl, Zardari vow to keep PDM intact,” Dawn, 25 March 2021) However, PPP leader Qamar Zaman Kaira said the party’s presence at the hearing is only a token gesture of solidarity. (Rameez Khan, “PPP to join PDM’s power show outside NAB tomorrow,” The Express Tribune, 25 March 2021)

PTI, PML-N hostage to their own rhetoric, says opinion
An opinion in Dawn says the opposition and the ruling party are equally clueless in the current scenario. The author says, on one hand, there is “the opposition attempting to put up a brave face in a quasi-hopeless situation.” On the other hand, “the PTI government grinning over its survival and nothing more really. Amid this, the establishment wonders, “What next?” 

He draws parallels between the PTI and the opposition, especially the PML-N and says both these parties are now hostage to their own rhetoric of wanting to bring change but their ambitions are larger than their ability to translate the rhetoric to reality. However, he says, “The incessant incestuous infighting between the political stakeholders, and the increasingly small and tactical nature of the political battlefield, is pushing political parties off the strategic table.” He therefore concludes by asking whether the ‘PTI and PDM together dumbed down politics in Pakistan.” (Fahd Hussain, “RED ZONE FILES: Good, bad & the clueless,” Dawn, 25 March 2021)

 

IMF agrees to release USD 500 million tranche
President signs ordinance on corporate tax withdrawal

Image Source: The Nation

On 24 March, sources told Dawn and The Express Tribune that the IMF had agreed to release a USD 500 million tranche as part of its USD six billion programme which had been suspended for a year. The decision was made after four reviews were approved by the Fund. 

Previously…
On the same day, President Alvi had signed an ordinance seeking “withdrawal of corporate tax exemptions and rationalise taxes.” This was one of the conditions of the IMF to revive the programme. Corporate tax exemptions are expected to generate a revenue of USD 140 billion per year. (Mubarak Zeb Khan, “Alvi signs ordinance to withdraw corporate tax exemptions,” Dawn, 25 March 2021)

Other conditions implemented
In February, the government had hiked electricity prices by 16 per cent; the tariffs will be increased by 36 per cent by October. Further, the government also allowed for the amendment of the Regulation of Generation, Transmission and Distribution of Electric Power Act, commonly known as NEPRA Act. This will “give powers to the government to impose a new surcharge equal to 10% of the electricity revenue requirements or Rs1.40 per unit.” (Shahbaz Rana, “IMF programme back on track,” The Express Tribune, 25 March 2021) (Anwar Iqbal, “IMF board agrees to release $500m for Pakistan,” Dawn, 25 March 2021)

 

SC bench says disappearance of 20 presiding officers a serious lapse
Asks why ECP called for re-polls in entire constituency

Image Source: The Daily Times

On 24 March, Justice Bandial said the Supreme Court understood the disappearance of the 20 presiding officers during the NA-75 Daska polls as a “serious lapse which had no precedence in the country’s election history.” However, the bench asked why the Election Commission of Pakistan had decided to conduct re-polls in the whole constituency and not just the 23 polling stations in question. Further, Justice Bandial questioned why the Rangers had not been deployed “at sensitive polling stations” at the first hint of trouble. He opined, “The services of Rangers were available but their deployment as a last resort was a mistake.” (Nasir Iqbal, “Disappearance of 20 presiding officers a serious lapse: SC judge,” Dawn, 25 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
FIA register an FIR against Tareen and Hamza in the sugar scandal
On 24 March, the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) anti-corruption circle registered an FIR against estranged PTI leader Jahangir Tareen’s JDW group and Gourmet Bakers & Sweets Pvt Ltd, Lahore. Further, the agency has detected Rs110 billion earning by the sugar mafia during the last one year through ‘speculative pricing’ and on Wednesday constituted 20 teams to lay hands on those involved in it. (Zulqernain Tahir, “Tareen, Hamza face arrest in sugar scandal,” Dawn, 25 March 2021)

Pemra asks TV channels to avoid airing “unsubstantiated, judgemental and unipolar remarks” about the NAB
On 24 March, The Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (Pemra) issued a statement in which it asked news and current affairs satellite channels to refrain from airing “unsubstantiated, judgemental and unipolar remarks” about the National Accountability Bureau (NAB), “with an alleged intent to malign the state institution”, without getting the bureau’s point of view. Further, it stated that the airing of such unsubstantiated and unipolar remarks was in “absolute disregard” of previous instructions. (“Pemra asks TV channels to avoid ‘maligning’ NAB,” Dawn, 25 March 2021)

Interior Ministry refuses Nawaz’s passport renewal application
On 25 March, The News International reported that the Interior Ministry in a letter instructed the Ministry of Foreign Affairs against processing the passport renewal application of Nawaz Sharif, stating that Nawaz has been declared an absconder and proclaimed offender by the Islamabad High Court. The letter states, “Nawaz Sharif is thereby required to return to Pakistan and appear before the relevant courts to face charges. He being a fugitive of law and absconder cannot seek any further relief unless he surrenders before the courts in Pakistan.” (“Nawaz seeks passport renewal, Interior Ministry refuses,” The News International, 25 March 2021)

Rangers, police to be deployed outside the NAB office
On 25 March, Dawn reported that “Rangers and Punjab police will secure the NAB building and the outside area that has been declared a red zone on Thursday (today). No one else will be allowed to enter the red zone except Ms Nawaz on Friday (tomorrow) to record her statement in both inquiries.” Further, the NAB stated that its provincial headquarters might “come under attack” from political workers and others on the occasion of Maryam Nawaz’s appearance before the bureau and thus, “To ensure foolproof security, NAB seeks help from law-enforcement agencies -- Rangers and police.” (“NAB office surroundings declared red zone,” Dawn, 25 March 2021)

ECONOMY
Govt registered all tax returns-filing real estate dealers as DNFBPs to meet FATF criteria
On 25 March, Dawn reported that the government unilaterally decided to registered all tax returns-filing real estate dealers as Designated Non-Financial Business and Professions (DNFBPs) and directed them to provide full details of their clients and property transactions after completing customer due diligence to meet the requirements of the Financial Action Task Force (FATF). As a result, more than 20,000 real estate brokers, who are tax filers and have now been designated as DNFBPs and have been given a four-page questionnaire containing 86 questions to submit online within seven days by which “In case of non-compliance or partial compliance, action as per law will be initiated.” (“Govt seeks property deals details to meet FATF criteria,” Dawn, 25 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Permanent Indus Commission talks conclude
On 24 March, Pakistan and India concluded the two-day talks of the Permanent Indus Commission (PIC). Following the meeting, both sides agreed to interact more frequently to resolve the issues through bilateral discussions. According to the Ministry of External Affairs, “The meeting was held in a cordial manner. Both the Commissioners reaffirmed their commitment to interact more frequently in an attempt to resolve the issues by bilateral discussions under the Treaty. It was agreed to hold the next meeting of the PIC in Pakistan on mutually convenient dates.” (“‘Cordial’ water talks: Pakistan, India agree on frequent meetings,” The Express Tribune, 25 March 2021)

COAS meeting with Senior UK general
On 24 March, Commander Strategic Command UK General Sir Patrick Nicholas Yardley Monrad Sanders met with COAS General Qamar Javed Bajwa. According to the ISPR, “During the meeting, matters of professional & mutual interest and regional security issues were discussed.” Further, the commander also acknowledged and appreciated the Pakistan Army’s efforts in the fight against terrorism and efforts for bringing peace and stability in the region, especially the Afghan peace process. (“Senior UK general meets COAS, appreciates army’s role in Afghan peace process,” The Express Tribune, 25 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                                  
An editorial in Dawn argues that Pakistan and the rest of the countries in South Asia possess huge potential to tap into one another’s markets and enhance the value of their trade. However, that will not be possible unless they, especially India and Pakistan, take serious steps to start a conversation aimed at settling political and other disputes in the larger interest of their people.

An editorial in The Express Tribune says that While the history of Indo-Pak dialogue does not offer much hope, that still is the only way forward. But for it to be different this time, the two sides would need to break away from their stubbornly-held positions on the contentious issues. However, whether they are both ready for such a serious shift remains unanswered.
 
 


"In many countries, including Pakistan, intra-government accountability mechanisms have been eclipsed by the loosening of parties’ hold on their governments...As a result, democracy has suffered a certain devaluation. Immature societies view accountability as a form of punishment or a drag on the parties’ smooth functioning. Nothing could be a greater error as accountability acts as a lubricant does for machinery."
-An opinion in Dawn by I. A. Rehman on 'Accountability: an endless affair'

 


Amid differences between PML-N and PPP, opinion asks if the PDM will survive


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Amid differences between PML-N and PPP, opinion asks if the PDM will survive
Zardari linking resignation with Sharif’s return brought out old demons of distrust

 

As the differences within the PDM widen, an opinion in Dawn asks whether the alliance will survive. The author, Zahid Hussain, says the fragmentation process of the PDM is noticeable. He says the force with which it rattled the PTI government has waned away due to the difference over strategies. 

The differences between the PPP and PML-N
The author outlines that the two parties always had contentions, especially with the Sharif family’s attack on the establishment in contrast to the PPP’s preference for a nuanced approach. Further, he opines that Gilani’s win in Islamabad proved the PPP’s stance “that the government could be defeated within the system;” the party has also called for a no-confidence motion. However, the PML-N has expressed no interest in the strategy. The two parties also differ in their opinion on the role of the establishment wherein the PPP believes in its neutrality while the PML-N thinks otherwise. The final blow was the alliance’s loss in the Senate chairman elections and its strategy to submit mass resignations; the PML-N and the JUI-F could not convince the PPP on the same. This is because,  For the PPP, resignation from the assemblies would create an uncertain political situation that could lead to extra-constitutional intervention.”

Opening old wounds
Following this, Asif Zardari’s demand for Nawaz Sharif to return to Pakistan in return for resignations has brought “out the old demons of distrust between the two erstwhile political rivals.” With this, “The floodgates of accusations and counter-accusations have now been opened and involve the new generation of leaders representing the two powerful political dynasties.” 

Therefore, Zahid Hussain concludes that if the alliance continues without the PPP, as suggested by the PML-N, it could result in the complete breakdown of the PDM. He asks, “It may be good news for the PTI but will that save it from breaking under the burden of its own blunders and incompetence?” (Zahid Hussain, “Can the PDM survive?,” Dawn, 24 March 2021)

 

Investment in securities by foreigners increase, reports The Express Tribune
Net foreign investment stands at USD 17 million

Image Source: Dawn

On 24 March, The Express Tribune reported that investments in T-bills and Pakistan Investment Bonds (PIBs), by foreigners, has been increasing. It cites “surge in rate of profit on the securities, return of stability in rupee-dollar parity,” and the government’s decision to resume the IMF loan programme as the reasons behind the same. 

The developments come nearly a year after investors withdrew their investments during the outbreak of COVID-19 in Pakistan in February 2020. 

Divestment falls

Currently, until 20 March, the net foreign investments stood at USD 17 million. However, the divestments in comparison to 2020 has fallen drastically. The Express Tribune explains that the net divestment reduced to USD 83 million during 1 July 2020 to 21 March 2021 in comparison to net divestment worth USD 162 million during 1 July 2020 to 2 February 2021.  (Salman Siddiqui, “Foreign inflows in securities surge,” The Express Tribune, 24 March 2021)

 

Pakistan to make first purchase of vaccine from China
Privately imported vaccines to cater to those not on priority list, says govt

Image Source: Dawn

On 23 March, Planning Minister Asad Umar said Pakistan will conduct its first purchase of COVID-19 vaccines from Sinopharm and Cansino vaccines. The first batches will be delivered by the end of March. Further, The News International quoted a source in the Ministry of National Health Services; he said Pakistan will be receiving vaccines from the Covax alliance for 20 per cent of the population. (Ikram Junaidi, “Islamabad approaches Beijing for more vaccine,” Dawn, 24 March 2021)

Government to fix prices of privately imported vaccines
On 24 March, the Ministry addressed a query regarding the private imports of vaccines. The Ministry said, the government decision to allow private imports was to ensure that the “population segments which were not part of the government's priority inoculation campaign could be catered to.” The Ministry’s Secretary also said that the government would be fixing prices of the same.  Previously, on March 17, Pakistan received its first batch of private imported Sputnik-V vaccine. (Naveed Siddiqui, “Allowing private imports of Covid vaccines is a 'deliberate policy tool': govt,” Dawn, 24 March 2021)

 

In Brief
INTERNAL
Chaman bomb blast leaves three killed and several injured
On 23 March, three people were killed while 13 others injured after a bomb attached to a motorcycle exploded in front of the Levies Lines in Chaman. According to the deputy commissioner, the blast was carried out by “an improvised explosive device attached to a motorcycle which targeted a police vehicle carrying the SHO of Saddar police station.” The Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan has claimed responsibility for the bombing. (“Three killed, 13 injured in Chaman bomb blast,” Dawn, 24 March 2021)

'Unsettled land' belongs to local tribes, says BHC
On 23 March, the Balochistan High Court (BHC) declared that the “unsettled land” of the province belongs to the indigenous tribes who inhabited these plains and mountains for centuries and not to the provincial government. The court said, “The government can frame policies, introduce land reforms and make enactments to deal with land issues, accordingly. This judgment shall have no effect upon past and closed transactions.” (“Landmark judgment: 'Unsettled land' belongs to local tribes: BHC,” The Express Tribune, 24 March 2021)

ECONOMY
Traders says mango exporters failed to take advantage of the US GSP facility for 10 years
On 24 March, The Express Tribune reported that traders have lamented that even after 10 years since the US approved a zero-rated facility under the Generalised System of Preferences (GSP), Pakistani mango exporters have failed to grab a modest slice of the American market. Similarly, the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI)’s Standing Committee on Agriculture former chairman regretted that the mango exporters had failed to take full benefit of the scheme in the past 10 years. In 2020, the mango export from Pakistan stood below USD 90 million as the US imported of mangoes stood at USD 719 million. (“Traders lament low mango exports to US,” The Express Tribune, 24 March 2021)

Pakistan’s exports to regional countries declined 22 per cent
On 24 March, Dawn reported that according to the State Bank of Pakistan exports to regional countries declined 22 per cent in the first eight months of the current fiscal year due to the impact of Covid-19. The bank’s data stated that exports to Afghanistan, China, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, India, Iran, Nepal, Bhutan and the Maldives fell to USD 1.171 billion in 8MFY21, from USD 1.504 billion the previous year. (“Pakistan’s regional exports slump 22pc,” Dawn, 24 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
All parties to the Yemen conflict must silence their guns and reach a negotiated settlement, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn says that all parties should take advantage of the peace opportunity and continue the dialogue process, adding that Saudi Arabia should take the lead, announce a ceasefire and allow the much-needed humanitarian assistance. Further, the editorial adds that if this is done, the Houthis must respond in good faith. Therefore, all parties to this conflict must silence their guns and reach a negotiated settlement. (“Yemen truce offer,” Dawn, 24 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                
 
An opinion in Dawn says that a strategic and potentially transformative shift is occurring in Pakistan, as the country’s policymakers try to pivot away from geopolitics to geoeconomics. However, it argues that to achieve success at geoeconomics, Brand Pakistan must capture the imagination of the global business press and investment community, but Brand Pakistan is only as good as Product Pakistan with the latter needing significant improvement. 
 
 


"For the survival of the alliance now, the PDM parties must first end their public spats which are unsavoury and leave their supporters in a quandary of indecision. The current situation has put the PDM in an uncomfortable position and it is up to all constituent parties to resolve their issues amicably, if they want to see their efforts come to fruition in the future."
-An editorial in The News International on 'End of the alliance?'

 


JI to support PPP for nomination of Senate’s opposition leader


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
JI to support PPP for nomination of Senate’s opposition leader
Bilawal takes a dig at PML-N, calls Sharif family “selected” 

 

On 22 March, the Jamaat-i-Islami announced its support to the PPP’s Yousuf Gilani for the post of Senate’s opposition leader. The development came after Bilawal Bhutto made his maiden visit to the JI headquarters the same day. Further, the decision to approach JI was taken amid differences between the PPP and the PML-N for the post wherein it was previously decided that a candidate from the latter would become opposition leader. However, the PPP later said that the situation had changed after Gilani’s defeat in the Senate chairman elections. The JI’s vote is crucial for the PPP. 

Bilawal targets Sharif family 
While announcing the JI’s decision, Bilawal took the opportunity to respond to Maryam’s tweet wherein she said, “maybe another selected being anointed.” Bilawal said the blood that runs in his veins cannot be that of a “selected.” Instead, he said, it was the “Lahore family that was once selected.” He added, “Accountability of the generals may be a new-found slogan for Nawaz Sharif and the PML-N, but this has been the demand of the PPP leadership for three generations.” (Ahmad Fraz Khan, “Bilawal wins JI’s crucial vote for Senate office,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)

JI, PPP share common interests
Bilawal emphasised that the PPP shares interests with the JI. He listed the following as the parties’ common interests: “electoral reforms, accountability and Kashmir dispute, and both the parties had never joined the game of becoming selected.” (Asim Hussain, “Family from Lahore always ‘selected’, we weren’t: Bilawal,” The News International, 23 March 2021)

Editorial says spat between PML-N and PPP will undo six months of progress
An editorial in Dawn says the latest spar over the opposition leader’s nomination will “undo much of the goodwill generated by the opposition parties since the formation of the alliance six months ago.” The editorial says, though the PPP “subsumed its partisan agenda” during the initial months of the PDM, the party leaders are likely to have felt that the alliance’s agenda “are unlikely to come to fruition.” It outlines that even if the PPP decides to hold its ground, the alliance could remain in the parliament; however, for this, the PML-N and PPP should resolve their contentions. It concludes, “The war of words raging between the two parties has ominous overtones for what lies ahead for PDM.” (“Opposition alliance in trouble,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)

 

Maryam’s tone devoid of understanding, alleges Shibli Faraz
NAB cites reports of possible attack on office prior to Maryam’s hearing

Image Source: The News International

On the same day, Information Minister Shibli Faraz said Maryam’s “threat to use political force during her appearance in NAB” was an encouragement to criminals and the corrupt. Further, he alleged “Maryam Nawaz’s tone seemed to be that of a person devoid of understanding and foresight.” According to Faraz, Maryam’s behaviour could encourage “land mafia, hoarders and criminal elements to join a political party.” He added, “The whole nation is watching a woman using a political platform instead of responding to legal queries regarding attack on institutions” and warned against “violent tactics.” (Kalbe Ali, “Maryam’s threatening tone will encourage criminals: Shibli,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)

Meanwhile…

On the same day, the NAB requested the Lahore police and Rangers for help ahead of Maryam Nawaz’s hearing on 26 March, citing reports of a possible attack on its  Lahore office. Further, the NAB also asked authorities to declare their office a “Red Zone.” (“NAB Lahore asks police, Rangers for help at Maryam's upcoming hearing,” The News International, 22 March 2021)

 

Broadsheet probe reveals anomalies in disbursement of USD 1.5 million 
Report submitted to PM’s office

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 22 March, the one-man commission to probe the Broadsheet payments identified discrepancies in the disbursement of USD 1.5 million to the firm. Justice Azmat Saeed Shaikh has submitted the report to the PM’s office; however, no additional details from the report have been revealed. The report includes 26 witness statements from serving and former officials of the army, NAB and so on. Dawn’s sources said “the record of payment of $1.5m to Broadsheet was not available with the finance ministry, law ministry, the office of the Attorney General of Pakistan and the Pakistan High Commission in the UK.” (“Anomalies spotted in disbursement of $1.5m to Broadsheet: report,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
The country celebrates ‘Pakistan day’
On 23 March, the country commemorated Pakistan Day with all events held while ensuring strict compliance with the standard operating procedures (SOPs). However, the ISPR said that the Pakistan Day parade has been postponed due to “inclement weather and rain” over the next two days and that the parade will now be held on 25 March “as per programme and timings already specified.” Further, the President in his message reaffirmed the resolve to make Pakistan an economically stronger and prosperous country. (“Nation observes Pakistan Day as Covid, weather cast shadow on celebrations,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)

PHC extends the interim pre-arrest bail of Captain Safdar
On 22 March, a single-member Peshawar High Court bench extended the interim pre-arrest bail of PML-N leader retired Captain Mohammad Safdar until 5 April in a case registered against him here last month on the charges of committing sedition and inciting the personnel of the armed forces to mutiny. Previously, the high court had granted Safdar an interim pre-arrest bail on 10 March on the condition of producing two surety bonds. (“Capt Safdar’s pre-arrest bail extended in sedition case,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)

Senior Parliamentarians Council meeting proves to be unsuccessful
On 22 March, the newly formed 15-member Senior Parliamentarians Council (SPC) held a meeting, however, along with the opposition majority of the treasury members did not see any utility as only three members, including its convener, attended its maiden meeting. The meeting is said to have ended within a few minutes after reading out of the terms of reference of the council. This meeting was planned to take up the incident of opposition lawmakers’ manhandling by activists of the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf outside the Parliament House. (“Senior Parliamentarians Council meeting proves a nonstarter,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Pakistan delegation head to India for talks on Indus waters
On 23 March, an eight-member Pakistani delegation headed by Pakistan Commissioner for Indus Waters Meher Ali Shah departed for New Delhi to hold talks on the Indus waters. During the two-day talks, Islamabad is likely to raise objections to four power projects on the Chenab River, one of the six rivers jointly shared by the two. (“Pakistan team sets off to New Delhi for talks on Indus waters,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)

The US to further strengthen partnership with Pakistan says, Biden
On 22 March, US President Joe Biden in a letter to President Arif Alvi, Biden highlighted that Washington will further strengthen its partnership with Islamabad adding that the US-Pak relations were based on the common goal of regional peace and prosperity and that “both countries will continue to work together to address common challenges, especially peace in Afghanistan, the coronavirus pandemic, and climate change.” (“Washington to further strengthen partnership with Pakistan: Biden,” The Express Tribune, 23 March 2021)

US Defence Secretary praises Pakistan’s role in Afghan peace process
On 22 March, US Defence Secretary Lloyd J. Austin in a telephone conversation with Army Chief Gen Qamar Bajwa “expressed gratitude for Islamabad’s continued support for the Afghan peace process.” Further, Austin reassured the COAS that the US would like to continue its cooperation with Pakistan in areas of “common interest.” (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Pentagon chief praises Pakistan’s role in Afghan peace process,” Dawn, 23 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                  
 
An opinion in Dawn on the PDM’s future says that the political see-saw has again tilted in the PTI’s favour after the failure of the PDM’s latest meet. However, it argues one cannot write off the PDM as the factors fuelling its rise still exist. Similarly, an editorial in Dawn says that if the dispute over resignations symbolised the first crack within the opposition alliance, the disagreement over which party has a claim on the office of the leader of the opposition in the Senate poses a graver threat to the unity of the alliance

 


PPP, PML-N disagree on Senate opposition leader nomination


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PPP, PML-N disagree on Senate opposition leader nomination
Maryam reiterates opposition leader will be from her party

 

On 21 March, two major parties of the PDM, the PPP and the PML-N, both “claimed their right to the position” of Opposition leader in the Senate. The development comes amid other differences within the PDM wherein the PPP had expressed its reservation against the alliance’s strategy of mass resignations from the assemblies. 

Promised PML-N opposition leader post in return for Gilani’s win, says PPP
The PPP argues that it had agreed to let the PML-N have the office of the Opposition leader in return for Gilani’s nomination as Senate chairman. However, the PPP says that “the situation has changed” after Gilani’s defeat. Further, the PPP now claims that as the single largest opposition party in the Senate, the post of opposition leader should be allotted to it. PPP’s Raja Pervez Ashraf also justified the PPP stance saying that the PML-N held the position of opposition leader in the National Assembly and also the chairman’s position of the Public Accounts Committee. 

Another concern of the PPP is PML-N’s nomination of Azam Nazeer Tarar for the position of the Senate’s opposition leader. Tarar was previously the “lawyer for the accused police officials in Benazir Bhutto murder case.” His nomination was rejected by the PPP. (Amir Wasim, “PML-N, PPP spar over Senate opposition leader slot,” Dawn, 22 March 2021) (Ramees Khan, “PML-N, PPP at loggerheads over Senate slot,” The Express Tribune, 22 March 2021)

Maryam insists that opposition leader post belongs to PML-N
On the same day, Maryam Nawaz disputed the PPP claims about Gilani’s nomination and said “Winning or losing [the Senate chairman poll] was not discussed as a factor for any change in the decision.” She also reiterated that the PML-N claims to the position were decided prior to the Senate chairman and deputy chairman elections. Maryam has taken up the matter to PDM chief Fazlur Rehman. (“Senate opposition leader will be from PML-N, insists Maryam,” The Express Tribune, 21 March 2021) 

 

NCOC meets to discuss measures to curb spread of COVID-19
DRAP issues notification on MRPs of vaccines

Image Source: The News International

On 22 March, the National Command and Operation Centre met to discuss the imposition of restrictions amid the surging COVID-19 cases. NCOC Chief and Planning Minister Asad Umar said provincial administrations have been told “to tighten implementation of SOPs and crackdown on violations which are taking place.” (“NCOC increases restrictions on ‘activities contributing to Covid cases surge’,” The Express Tribune, 22 March 2021)

Education Minister to discuss reopening or closure of educational institutions 
On the same day, Education Minister Shafqat Mehmood said all education and health ministers will meet on 24 March to discuss “the reopening or further closure of educational institutions.” However, he outlined the demerits of online education and said the decision on closure of institutions will be “very difficult.” (“Coronavirus in Pakistan: Shafqat Mehmood says decision to close schools is very difficult,” The News International, 22 March 2021)

Meanwhile...
The Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan issued a notification to cap maximum retail prices of the COVID-19 vaccine. Dawn says, the notification approves two formulas “for sale of vaccine with 40 per cent mark-up for companies and additional 15pc for retailers/hospitals.” A summary submitted to the federal cabinet has suggested that the Sputnik V be sold at Rs 8,449 per pack (two injections)  CanSino at Rs 4,225. However, the "vaccine will not be sold or distributed in the market and will be administered in private hospitals and institutions." (Ikram Junaidi, “Drap notifies formula for sale of Covid vaccine,” Dawn, 22 March 2021)

 

Transboundary water cooperation, pillar for sustainable water management: SAPM
Indus Water Treaty meeting begins on 23 March

Image Source: Dawn

On 22 March, Dawn reported that Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on Climate Change Malik Amin Aslam reiterated to the UN General Assembly session on Water that Islamabad was a signatory to the 1960 Indus Water Treaty (IWT) between Pakistan and India. He said, “And as a signatory, we believe in transboundary water cooperation as a pillar for sustainable water management.”
Further, Pakistan’s Ambassador to the UN Munir Akram stated, “Cooperation at all levels is required for a holistic, systemic and multilateral response to confront and overcome the water challenge,” adding, “The focus of our efforts should be to fully implement this fundamental right (to water) for all the world’s people.” Additionally, he warned that without effective transboundary water cooperation, “inclusive sustainable development is severely curtailed, and the potential for threats to peace and security are ever present.”

Upcoming talks on Indus waters
These statements come ahead of a two-day Indus Water Treaty (IWT) in Delhi on 23 and 24 March. Pakistan is expected to present its objections to India’s contentious water projects on the Chenab river and other issues. (Anwar Iqbal, “Transborder management of water key to progress, UN told,” Dawn, 22 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Opposition parties decided to stay away from the legislator’s panel 
On 22 March, the Senior Parliamentarians Council (SPC) constituted by National Assembly Speaker Asad Qaiser aimed at improving the working environment in the house, however, opposition parties decided to stay away from its proceedings. PML-N Information Secretary said, “We are not living in a village where cases are decided through jirgas.” Further, Raja Pervez Ashraf of the PPP who is a member of the council, said that the party leadership has not sent directives regarding participation in the meeting, however, said the PPP would go with the decision of the combined opposition on the matter. (“Opposition won’t attend meeting of legislators’ panel today,” Dawn, 22 March 2021)

ON PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
Pakistan's first transgender-only madrassah in Islamabad
On 22 March, Dawn reported that Pakistan's first transgender-only madrassah in Islamabad which she set up Rani Khan has become an important milestone for the trans community in the country. This comes amid the marginalization of the transgender community, even though there is no official restriction on them attending religious schools or praying at mosques. Additionally, although being recognised as the third gender, the transgender community remains on the margins in the country, and often have to resort to begging, dancing and prostitution to make a living. (“A transgender madrassah in Islamabad breaks barriers,” Dawn, 22 March 2021)

PML-F hold power show in Karachi, vows to win over Karachiites
On 21 March, Pakistan Muslim League-Functional (PML-F) held its ‘power show’ in Karachi in connection with the death anniversary of the spiritual leader of Hurs Soreh Badshah. During the rally, Sindh PML-F Secretary-General Sardar Rahim stated that Karachi was in a pathetic state as successive governments had destroyed it. Further, Rahim criticised the PDM stating that those who wanted to hold a ‘long march’ could not now muster the courage to hold a ‘short march.’ (“PML-F holds first-ever power show in city, vows to win over Karachiites,” Dawn, 22 March 2021)

ECONOMY
SNGPL and SSGCL demanded up to a 220 per cent increase in price
On 22 March, Dawn reported that Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL) and Sui Southern Gas Company Limited (SSGCL), the two gas utilities of Pakistan have demanded up to 220 per cent increase in the prescribed prices of gas with effect from July 1 to meet estimated revenue requirement (ERR) during the fiscal year 2021-22. In formal petitions filed with the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (Ogra), SNGPL demanded that its prescribed price for the next fiscal year be increased by Rs1,416 per unit. Similarly, SSGCL has sought Rs153 per unit or 20pc increase in its prescribed price for the next fiscal year, from about Rs779 per unit to about Rs932. (Khaleeq Kiani “Gas firms seek up to 220pc hike in prices,” Dawn, 22 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Kissinger recognises Pakistan’s ‘key’ role in establishing China-US ties
On 22 March, Dawn reported that former US secretary of state Dr Henry Kissinger recognised Pakistan’s ‘key’ role in arranging his secret visit from Islamabad to Beijing in 1971 for making a breakthrough in China-US relations. Additionally, Senator Mushahid Hussain, representing Pakistan, stated that this historic breakthrough in China-US relations became possible due to the ‘indispensable role of Pakistan. (“Kissinger recognises Pakistan’s role in establishing China-US ties,” Dawn, 22 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
The US peace plan for Afghanistan faces critical tests ahead, says Maleeha Lodhi
An opinion in Dawn by Maleeha Lodhi says that recent efforts of the Biden administration to accelerate the negotiations in Afghan signals three things. First, a renewal of the US commitment to withdraw from Afghanistan. Second, its desire to do so after securing a peace settlement among the warring Afghan parties. Third, the willingness to use pressure to quickly achieve this. However, she says, the US peace plan for Afghanistan faces critical tests ahead, however, it would be up to the Afghan parties to grab the opportunity as the US plan starts to unfold and faces critical tests in the months ahead. (“Challenging roadmap to peace,” Dawn, 22 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                              
An editorial in Dawn says that there has been a long record of ‘known unknowns’ in Pakistan keeping tabs on individuals, with successive governments in the past arbitrarily expanded the role of the spy agencies into domestic politics to keep the opposition in check

An opinion in The Express Tribune highlights the strategic shift in Pakistan’s foreign policy stating the shift in Pakistan’s approach focusing on the economy is necessitated by harsh realities.
 




"The conflict around advocacy of women’s rights seems to be deepening with each passing year...Despite concerted efforts, they cannot be shut down unilaterally."
-An opinion in Dawn
on 'Conservative anxieties'

 


Government to promulgate ordinances to fulfill IMF conditions


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Government to promulgate ordinances to fulfill IMF conditions
Cabinet approves ordinance to increase power tariffs by Rs 5.65

 

On 20 March, Dawn reported that the government will be promulgating ordinances for withdrawal of tax exemptions and a “mechanism for automatic electricity power tariff increases of about Rs 5.36 per unit” over the next 27 months. The decision comes prior to the IMF executive board meeting on 24 March; the above two conditions are necessary to secure the IMF tranche of USD 500 million. Therefore, the proposed changes are being presented as ordinances to meet the deadline.

Ordinance on power tariffs awaits National Assembly’s nod
On 19 March, the federal cabinet approved the promulgation of an ordinance to increase power tariffs by Rs 5.65 till October 2021. A summary by the federal power division says a National Assembly Standing Committee has already cleared the bill for “introduction of automaticity in the notification of such tariffs determined by Nepra.” This bill is pending to be approved by the National Assembly. 

With the increase in power tariffs, the government is likely to generate a Rs 150 billion surcharge. 

Corporate tax exemptions
An ordinance on the corporate tax reforms is expected to be promulgated on 20 March (today). With the introduction of tax exemptions, the government estimates it will generate Rs 140 billion annually. The tax reforms will come to effect from 1 July. (Mubarak Zeb Khan and Khaleeq Kiani, “Govt moves swiftly to secure $500m IMF tranche,” Dawn, 20 March 2021) (“Ordinances soon for Rs290 bn taxes,” The News International, 20 March 2021) 

If all conditions are met on deadline, the IMF will release the tranche in the coming week, said a source for The Express Tribune. (Shahbaz Rana, “Cabinet gives nod to Rs5.65 power tariff rise,” The Express Tribune, 20 March 2021)

 

Pakistan to import one million vaccine doses from China
COVID-19 cases continue to surge 

Image Source: Dawn

On 19 March, Planning Minister Asad Umar announced that the government will import one million COVID-19 vaccine doses from two Chinese firms. He said, the first batch will arrive by 25 March followed by the second batch on 30 March.

Meanwhile...
The National Command and Operation Centre said the spread of COVID-19 was rising after the test positivity rate rose to eight per cent on 19 March and more than 3000 cases were recorded for the second consecutive day. Asad Umar, also the head of the NCOC, warned against non-compliance to the SOPs and said the government would be forced to impose stricter regulations. (Amir Yasin, “1m doses of vaccines to be imported from China: Asad,” Dawn, 20 March 2021)

 

On climate change
Climate activists organise strike; say no to empty promises

Image Source: Dawn

On 19 March, climate activists gathered across different cities in Pakistan for a climate strike, emphasising on a common theme #NoMoreEmptyPromises. The organisers raised concerns that Pakistan was the fourth most vulnerable country. They highlighted issues faced by common people, like urban flooding, heatwaves, and so on. 

Call for inclusivity in decision making
A common problem highlighted was the lack of representation in decision making with respect to environmental issues and climate change. One person at the rally opined that “those who really do care about the environment are not included in the government committees that make all the decisions concerning climate.” They alleged that the government was development-centric and not people-centric. 

The organisers believed climate strikes, held twice every year, were one way to express their concerns. (Shazia Hassan, “‘Climate change does not discriminate between rich and poor’,” Dawn, 20 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Sindh govt asks PIA asked to speed up the compensation payment
On 19 March, the Governor of Sindh asked the Pakistan International Airlines to speed up the process of compensation payment to families of the May 2020 plane crash victims and those who suffered losses on the ground. Further, the governor said, “Precious lives have been lost. Considerable time has already passed. The PIA should remove the impediments and bottlenecks in order to ensure compensation process, without delaying the matter any further.” (“PIA asked to speed up compensation payment,” Dawn, 20 March 2021)

Lal Masjid moves IHC seeking ban on Aurat March
On 19 March, Dawn reported that Shuhada Foundation of Lal Masjid has moved the Islamabad High Court to “ban the organisations particularly ‘Open Society Foundation’ which were involved in the Aurat March and the organisers of the event be dealt with in accordance with law.” Further, the petition requested the court to refer this matter to the Council of Islamic Ideology to examine whether the women in Pakistan are deprived of any legal right in any field and whether such event conducted aligned with the injunctions of religion and the provisions of the Constitution. (“Lal Masjid moves court seeking ban on Aurat March,” Dawn, 20 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
President meets with Sri Lankan Chief of Defence Staff and army commander
On 19 March, President Dr Arif Alvi met with the visiting Chief of Defence Staff and Commander of the Sri Lankan Army, General Shavendra Silva. During the meeting, President Alvi said that Pakistan was an attractive destination for Buddhist tourists and invited people from Sri Lanka to visit the religious and scenic sites in the country. Further, he said that the two countries shared the same opinion on regional and international issues and enjoyed excellent relations in all areas of mutual interests. (“President urges Sri Lankans to visit Buddhist tourist spots in Pakistan,” Dawn, 20 March 2021)

ON THE DANIEL PEARL CASE
Daniel Pearl murder case to resume on 25th, says SC
On 20 March, Dawn reported that the Supreme Court will resume the hearing of the Sindh government’s petition involving Ahmed Omer Saeed Sheikh, the principal accused in the murder of Daniel Pearl on 25 March. Previously, in February 2020, the Supreme Court had ordered placing Saeed Sheikh in a residential environment like a government rest house. (“SC to resume hearing in Daniel Pearl murder case on 25th,” Dawn, 20 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                          
An opinion Dawn says that at a time when the opposition alliance PDM is dissolving in its own acidity, the ruling party is struggling to bottle up the volcanic lava of discontent bubbling dangerously inside its own government in the country’s largest province. It argues, that PM Imran Khan has a problem in Punjab and that it could open up dangerous fault lines.

An opinion in Dawn argues that if fair polls are the goal, the ECP’s powers must be jealously guarded.
 
 




"If Mr Khan’s support to the missing persons’ cause goes beyond lip service and delivers tangible results, it will be a praiseworthy achievement."
-An editorial in Dawn on'PM’s assurance'
for the families of missing persons

 


"Bury the past and move forward," says COAS on India-Pakistan relations


Photo: Geo News



In Focus
"Bury the past and move forward," says COAS on India-Pakistan relations
Editorial says restarting of dialogue could be major achievement

 

On 18 March, Chief of Army Staff Gen Qamar Bajwa said as long as the Kashmir issue remains unresolved, “peace in the sub-continent will remain elusive.” Speaking at the Islamabad Security Dialogue, he said India and Pakistan should “bury the past and move forward.” He said, “The Kashmir issue is obviously at the heart of this. It is important to understand that without the resolution of Kashmir dispute through peaceful means, [the] process of sub-continental rapprochement will always remain susceptible to derailment due to politically motivated bellicosity." Further, he urged India to make the first move and “create a conducive environment, particularly in occupied Kashmir."

COAS emphasises on regional peace
Apart from the above, the COAS conveyed that the potential of South Asia and Central Asia has not been explored because of the problems between India and Pakistan, the two "nuclear neighbours." He also claimed that unsettled disputes are pulling South Asia “back into poverty and underdevelopment.” 

He expressed concerns that South Asia was one of the least connected regions in terms of “trade, infrastructure, water and energy cooperation.” He claimed that despite the level of poverty in the region, countries spent more on defence, “which naturally comes at the expense of human development." 

He claimed Pakistan, despite being in “a hostile and unstable neighbourhood” had resisted from entering an arms race. (“Time to bury the past and move forward: COAS Bajwa on Indo-Pak ties,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)

FM accuses India of backtracking from steps for peace 
On the same day, Foreign Minister Qureshi said India had taken “several steps backwards” from peace, despite Pakistan’s offer in 2018 which was: “if India took one step forward for peace, Pakistan will take two.” He accused India of causing “incalculable damage” to possibilities of peace by her alleged “illegal and unilateral actions of 5 August 2019 in IIOJK, and the ensuing military siege and indiscriminate repression of Kashmiris.” 

Further, he said India should rethink the “policy of fomenting destabilisation in the region” and adopt a more inclusive agenda and, like the COAS, asked “India to create an enabling environment.” (Mariana Baabar, “Won’t be part of any regional conflict: India has backtracked on steps for peace, says Qureshi,” The News International, 19 March 2021)

Perpetual conflict in South Asia benefits none, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn highlights that perpetual conflict in South Asia does not benefit no one and says even restarting a dialogue process would be a major achievement between India and Pakistan. The editorial highlights that the first signs of a thaw was the recommitment to the LoC ceasefire, and the second the PM’s and COAS statements at the Islamabad Security Dialogue. It agrees with Imran Khan and says India should make the first move. However, it opines that celebrations about possible talks are premature and says previously similar situations ended up collapsing. Therefore, it urges both the countries to build on the previous discussions and soft approaches like people-to-people connections. (“South Asia peace,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)

 

PDM is likely to go ahead if PPP quits, says sources
PPP, PML-N engage accuse each other for chaos in PDM 

Image Source: Geo News

On 18 March, Fazlur Rehman talked to Asif Zardari and Nawaz Sharif separately. According to Dawn’s sources, the three leaders spoke about the long march and resignations from the assemblies. The sources said Fazlur and Nawaz agreed that  “PDM should continue its struggle against the government and should go ahead with its plan, even if the PPP decided to formally part ways with the alliance.” 

The conversation between the two took place after Fazlur had spoken to Asif Zardari who, according to sources, said PPP would convene its Central Executive Committee meeting after its public meeting on 4 April. Zardari reiterated that resignations should not be submitted as it would strengthen the establishment. 

At another function on the same day, Fazlur said, “It is a weakness to say that I can’t go to jail now. How will I fight? If you can’t fight then why you have joined politics?...If you are in politics then you can find both power and jail.” (Amir Wasim, “Fazl, Nawaz agree to go ahead even if PPP leaves PDM,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)

Meanwhile… 
The PPP and the PML-N were engaged in back and forth accusations. The PPP said PML-N was responsible for the contentions within the PDM; on the other hand, the PML-N accused the PPP of backtracking on its commitments. A PPP lawmaker said the party “will not let the PTI bulldoze everything, especially, after the PML-N couldn’t make the PPP understand what will be the outcome of en masse resignations and long march.” (Rizwan Shehzad, “PPP, PML-N at loggerheads over Senate opposition leader,” The Express Tribune, 19 March 2021)

 

Imran meets families of missing persons
Bill to criminalise enforced disappearances will be fast tracked, says Imran

Image Source: Dawn

On 18 March, Imran Khan met with a representative committee of families of missing persons. According to the Minister for Human Rights, Imran has asked the committee’s principal secretary to find out the status of the missing persons.  He assured the family members that they would be updated on the same.

Further, Imran also said a bill to criminalise enforced disappearances would be fast-tracked. (“PM Imran meets relatives of missing persons, issues directions to 'quickly' ascertain their status,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
SC reserves ruling on the application seeking live streaming of Isa case hearing
On 18 March, the Supreme Court reserved its ruling on the application seeking permission for live streaming of the hearing of review petitions in the Justice Isa case. However, Justice Isa requested the court to consider issuing a short order in case it was considering allowing live streaming since the writing of the judgement may take some time. (“SC reserves ruling on live streaming of Isa case hearing,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)

ECPs scrutiny committee defers decision in PTI accounts case
On 18 March, the Election Commission of Pakistan’s (ECP) scrutiny committee deferred the decision on summoning account details of four paid employees of the PTI who had been authorized to collect party donations in and outside the country. Further, the panel is set to meet again on 19 March (today) to scrutinise the PTI’s foreign funding. (Iftikhar A. Khan, “ECP panel defers decision in PTI accounts case,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)

K-2 nuclear power plant connected to grid, says PAEC
On 18 March, the Pakistan Atomic Energy Commission (PAEC) announced that it had connected the 1,100MW Karachi Nuclear Power Plant Unit-2 (K-2) to the national grid. The PAEC termed it as a ‘Pakistan Day’ gift to the nation, adding that its addition to the national grid will “surely help improve the economy of the country.” Further, it stated that the nuclear power plant (NPP) had achieved criticality at the end of February and was undergoing certain safety tests and procedures before it could finally be connected to the national grid. (“K-2 nuclear power plant connected to grid,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)

ECONOMY
Govt moves summary to save USD six billion IMF deal
On 18 March, the government moved a summary to secure the federal cabinet’s emergency approval for immediately withdrawing Rs140 billion worth of income tax exemptions to save the one-month-old staff-level agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF). The members of the federal cabinet are to record their opinion for promulgating ‘Tax Laws (Second Amendment) Ordinance 2021’ within 24 hours. (“Cabinet nod awaited to cancel tax break,” The Express Tribune, 19 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Kuwait committed to developing stronger relations with Pakistan
On 18 March, Foreign Minister of Kuwait Dr Ahmed Nasser Al-Sabah stated that his country was committed to developing stronger relations with Pakistan. The minister met with PM Imran Khan, during which he identified education, economy, trade and investment, and people-to-people linkages as priority areas in which Kuwait intended to intensify cooperation with Pakistan. Further, FM Qureshi on meeting with his Kuwaiti counterpart reaffirmed Pakistan’s strong commitment to strengthening and diversifying bilateral cooperation with Kuwait in all fields, adding, “The resolve to continue close collaboration in multilateral fora, in particular the United Nations and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, was reaffirmed.” (“Kuwait seeks stronger ties with Pakistan: minister,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
Pakistan joins the US, Russia and China in the call for Afghan ceasefire
On 18 March, Pakistan joined the US, Russia and China in calling Afghanistan’s warring sides to reach an immediate ceasefire. Further, they urged the Taliban to refrain from launching “spring offensive.” Further, Pakistan’s special envoy for Afghanistan Ambassador Muhammad Sadiq said, “Pakistan believes in exclusive approach towards negotiations and governance will significantly help the cause of sustainable peace in Afghanistan. The international community needs to remain engaged in Afghanistan and help the country at this critical juncture.” (Kamran Yousaf, “Taliban urged not to launch ‘spring offensive’,” The Express Tribune, 19 March 2021) (“Pakistan, US, Russia, China call for Afghan ceasefire,” Dawn, 19 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                    
An opinion in Dawn, critical of the divorce laws in Pakistan, says that divorce laws in Pakistan do not treat men and women with even the faintest trace of parity. It argues that parity is paramount and all people deserve to exit the unions of their choice — gracefully, peacefully and above all, equally.

An opinion in Dawn says that the country has done nothing to remove the rot in the education sector, arguing that the future is bleak with no sense of urgency attached to the matter.

Najam Sethi, in his editorial, says that unless the PDM decides to go ahead without the PPP, there is no getting back to the Long March and Resignations for some months.
 
 


"Constituencies for peace need to be strengthened so that the complicated issues poisoning ties since independence are resolved, and South Asia can move forward on the journey of human development and economic progress."
-An editorial in Dawn on 'South Asia peace'

 

 


PPP says no post-resignation strategy was given by the PDM


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PPP says no post-resignation strategy was given by the PDM
PTI has reasons to celebrate, says editorial 

On 17 March, the PPP rejected claims that they had charted out an understanding with the establishment; instead, the PPP said other parties in the PDM had “failed to provide a clear roadmap and the post-resignation strategy.” The PPP Secretary General said if the party had come to an understanding with the establishment,  Yousuf Gilani “would not have faced such a defeat in the election for Senate chairman office.” He regretted the fact that the PPP was being “blamed for everything” and said they were still committed to the PDM declaration of September 2020. 

PPP’s Raja Pervaiz Ashraf said the party would use all democratic options before resigning from assemblies. He opined that “resignations are not the first or the second option but the last option to send government packing.” 

PML-N dismisses PPP’s claims
On the other hand, the PML-N Secretary General denied the failure to provide a post-resignation strategy. He said the PML-N had “thoroughly talked about it in the PDM meeting and even the worst-case scenarios were discussed.” He was critical of the fact that the PPP dismissed the opinion of the rest of the parties in the PDM. He justified the PDM strategy of resignation saying the government would not have had legitimacy with an “opposition-less house.” With this, the PDM expected the whole system to collapse. (Amir Wasim, “PPP says allies failed to convince it on post-resignation strategy,” Dawn, 18 March 2021)

PDM is united, says Fazlur Rehman
Meanwhile, Fazlur Rehman, though disappointed over PPP’s attitude, hoped the party’s Central Executive Committee will consider and respect the opinion of the remaining nine parties of the PDM. However, he also insisted that the alliance was still united and would wait for the PPP CEC’s decision. A new date for the long march will also be announced soon. (“Fazl insists PDM stands united,” Dawn, 18 March 2021) Differing with Ashraf’s opinion that resignation was the last option, Fazlur said “Resignations were never meant to be the last option or the atom bomb. Nine parties [of the alliance] were in favour of submitting resignations. If the resignations are tendered, half of the parliament would be empty that would call for re-elections.” (“Leaders seek to reassure fears about fate of PDM,” The Express Tribune, 18 March 2021)

Meanwhile…
A source in Dawn said the PPP and PML-N had a difference of opinion on the latter’s decision to nominate Azam Nazeer Tarar for the position of opposition leader in the Senate, leading to Zardari’s outburst on Nawaz Sharif on 16 March. Tarar was previously a “lawyer for the accused in the Benazir Bhutto murder case.” The source said the PPP had also formally conveyed their reservations against the nomination. (“Tarar’s nomination another reason for PDM rift,” Dawn, 18 March 2021)

PTI has reasons to celebrate rift in the PDM, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn says components in alliances like the PDM would have some irritants but at the end of the day, have interest falling in the same arc. The editorial outlines that the PML-N, JUI-F and PPP have their own stakes in the current situation; PML-N will be most demoralised, while Fazlur Rehman has nothing to lose. The PPP, on the other hand, may benefit from the slowing down the PDM campaign. It concludes, “While the PDM may want to reflect on whether it created unrealistic expectations among the public regarding its capacity to bring down the government, the PTI for now has reason to celebrate.” (“Rift in the PDM,” Dawn, 18 March 2021) 

 

Government’s demand for resignations is unprecedented, says PPP
State cannot control instruments of governance it created, says I A Rehman

Image Source: Dawn

On 17 March, the PPP said the government’s demand for resignation of the Chief Election Commissioner and ECP members was “an unprecedented and inexplicable attack on the ECP’s authority and independence.” The party’s parliamentary leader, Sherry Rehman, said the government was demanding the resignations only because the election body refused to follow Imran Khan’s “dictation.” She said, “Expecting an autonomous institution to obey the government’s whims is not how things work in even hybrid democracies. If there was any conflict, the government should have taken it up constitutionally, but pressurising and forcing the CEC and members of the ECP reflected the extreme environment of unstable and unsustainable authoritarianism of this government.” (“PPP slams govt for seeking ECP members’ resignations,” Dawn, 18 March 2021)

Opinion highlights importance of independence of instruments of governance
An opinion in Dawn, by I A Rehman, says the reason behind the government’s demand is the defeat of Hafeez Shaikh in the Islamabad Senate seat. The author justifies the ECP’s ruling on secret ballots saying the election body’s hands are tied as long as the relevant laws are not changed. He said Imran Khan’s demand for an open ballot has no research backing or cogent arguments. He appreciates the ECP’s resolve and says if the government wants the election body to work according to his whims, then it can introduce amendments; however, the system will cease to be democtatic. 

He urges the government to not ignore the fact that its “authority can be circumscribed by the demands of public good.” He stresses the importance of institutions like the ECP which “are vitally needed to prevent states from undermining citizens’ basic rights.” He concludes, “It is a happy paradox of democracy that the state cannot control the instruments of governance created by it.” (I A Rehman, “An irrational demand,” Dawn, 18 March 2021)

 

Imran Khan calls on India to make first move to normalise ties 
Stresses on the need for regional peace 

Image Source: Dawn

On 17 March, Imran Khan, at the inauguration of the Islamabad Security Dialogue, called on India “to make the first move to normalise ties with Pakistan.”  However, he did not mention what he expected for the first move from India. He, however, said Pakistan’s relations with India underwent a “breakdown” when “India forcibly and illegally annexed Occupied Jammu and Kashmir on Aug 5, 2019.” Other than this, he abstained from being critical of India, and maintained that “Pakistan could not fully exploit its geo-economic potential unless it improved its ties with neighbours” and ensuring regional peace. Further, he said India could build its connectivity to Central Asia through Pakistan. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “India must make first move to normalise ties: PM,” Dawn, 18 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
No legal ground for challenging proceedings of parliament, says Sanjrani 
On 17 March, Senate Chairman Sadiq Sanjrani responding to the question about plans of the opposition parties to challenge his election as Senate chairman said, “There’s no legal ground for that,” adding, “I am now the custodian of the house and let me assure you that the Senate will be run according to the Constitution and with the cooperation of the members.” (“Sanjrani sees no threat from opposition,” The News International, 18 March 2021)

ACM Zaheer appointed as PAF chief
On 18 March, The News International reported that Air Marshal Zaheer Ahmad Babar Sidhu has been promoted as Air Chief Marshal and appointed as the new Chief of the Air Staff of Pakistan Air Force (PAF). He is set to assume command on March 19. (“ACM Zaheer to take over as PAF chief,” The News International, 18 March 2021)

NA panel asks for details of the action taken against ‘offensive’ Aurat March banners 
On 17 March, the National Assembly Standing Committee on Religious Affairs and Interfaith Harmony directed the ministries of interior and law and justice to produce details of the action taken against those displaying the ‘objectionable’ material in the Aurat March. During the meeting, the committee presided expressed resentment over “sacrilegious” banners, placards and slogans displayed in the women march and declared it unethical, contrary to the constitution and against the teachings of Islam. (“‘Offensive’ Aurat March banners irk NA panel,” The Express Tribune, 18 March 2021)

Justice Isa cautions judges that it was not him alone but files were ready against each of them
On 17 March, Justice Qazi Faez Isa cautioned the Supreme Court judges while referring to the June 2020 video clip of cleric Agha Iftikharudin Mirza who had threatened and hurled abuses at the former as well as the institution of judiciary saying, “I can honestly say that files are ready against each one of you and it could be the turn of any one of you against whom it could be said that he should be put before the firing squad.” (Nasir Iqbal, “Justice Isa cautions judges files ready against them,” Dawn, 18 March 2021)

Maryam’s bail cannot be suspended, says LHC
On 18 March, the Lahore High Court (LHC) issued a written order on the application moved by the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) for the cancellation of Maryam Nawaz's bail. The written order states that the order granting Maryam bail cannot be suspended immediately. The order stated that the NAB claimed that despite repeatedly summoning Maryam did not appear. Further, the federal home secretary has been directed to file a detailed reply on NAB's request by 7 April. (“Chaudhry Sugar Mills case: Maryam’s bail can’t be suspended, says LHC,” The News International, 18 March 2021)

ECONOMY
TIP Lodges complaint with PM over changes in SBP Act
On 17 March, Transparency International Pakistan (TIP) lodged a complaint with PM Imran Khan over the proposed amendments to the State Bank of Pakistan, which recommends unbridled powers, indemnity from omission and commission and does not ensure accountability. However, in response, the Ministry of Finance on Wednesday again defended the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) Amendment Bill 1956 and insisted that the legal changes ensured accountability. (“TIP protests over changes in SBP Act,” The Express Tribune, 18 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Kuwait to lift visa ban amid delegation visit
On 18 March, the Kuwaiti foreign minister is set to arrive in Pakistan for a two-day visit. According to the Foreign Office, the Kuwaiti foreign minister would lead a delegation comprising senior officials from the ministries of foreign affairs, health, interior and trade and industry. Further, Interior Minister Sheikh Rashid Ahmed stated that Kuwait is set to will a ban on work visas for Pakistan, the formal announcement of which is expended to be made during the visit. (“Kuwait to lift visa ban, says govt on eve of FM’s visit,” The Express Tribune, 18 March 2021) (“Kuwaiti foreign minister due on two-day visit today,” Dawn, 18 March 2021)

FM urges UNSG to convene global dialogue to counter the rise of Islamophobia
On 17 March, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi urged the United Nations Secretary-General (UNSG) to convene a global dialogue on countering rising Islamophobia and promoting inter-faith harmony, as a step to foster engagement. He said, “The way forward is dialogue and understanding. Only if we are able to better understand each other’s perspective, will we be able to create peaceful and harmonious societies. The United Nations is the best platform to nurture this understanding.” (“FM urges UNSG to convene global dialogue to combat Islamophobia,” Dawn, 18 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                          
An editorial in The Express Tribune on the PDM being a divided house argues that it has been the PPP’s divergent position that rendered the alliance to a confused lot. However, it asks would it not have been better for the PDM to have shown a little more political maturity and played the role of a genuine opposition, by avoiding confrontational politics and pressing the government for true electoral reforms instead? Likewise, an opinion in Dawn lists out ten key takeaways regarding the PDM, highlighting that the PDM chapter may be closing, but the book is a long one. All stakeholders have to fight their own demons now.

An opinion in The Express Tribune says that Democracy in Pakistan is yet to take firm root for many reasons arguing that it is disconnected from the demo (the people); political parties, in general, are undemocratic in their character and the rise of hooliganism and vulgarity.
 


"It is essential that we are able to establish peace in Balochistan and also win back the people of the province so that the federation of Pakistan can stand fully united once again, and thereby grow in strength and in its ability to combat enemies from outside, or others who may seek to take advantage of the unrest and uncertainty in Balochistan."
-An editorial in The News International
on ensuring Baloch people their rights.

 


PDM postpones long march amid differences over mass resignation


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 17 March 2021
The PDM’s predicament, as it postpones the Long March
After a meeting with the PDM leaders yesterday (16 March 2021, Tuesday), a visibly upset Maulana Fazlur Rahman, leader of the Pakistan Democratic Movement, announced the postponement of the Long March, that was originally scheduled on 26 March 2021.

While there was a general expectation, after the debacle at the Senate Chairman elections, in which the joint candidate of the PDM – Yousuf Raza Gillani was defeated, there would be a joint push by the opposition parties. The opposite of it happened, when Fazlur Rahman announced the postponement, and left the press conference in a hurry. Obviously, he is upset.

The PPP and Zardari are being projected as the culprits. But they are not the only ones. PML-N and especially Fazlur Rahman should also take the blame in forcing the PPP to resign. The issue is over mass resignations by the Opposition parties from the national and provincial assemblies. In the current national assembly, the ruling PTI is the single largest party with 116 seats, followed by the PML-N (64). The PPP has only 43 seats. Rest of the components of the PDM have in single digits, including the JUI-F. However, at the provincial level, the PPP is the only party, that has a Chief Minister; none of the other parties are ruling in any of the other three provinces. So, the mass resignations would affect the PPP more, than the other parties. Though the PML-N has 166 seats in Punjab provincial assembly, the PTI (181 seats) along with PML-Q (10 seats) have formed the government. 

While rest of the PDM components want to launch the Long March, the PPP would also be fine with the idea, minus the question over resignation. Maulana Fazlur insists on mass resignations, before the Long March launch.

The PPP, according the reports available, has asked for more time to decide on the resignations. As a result, as of now, it is advantageous to the PTI, as the Long March stands postponed.

 

In Focus
PDM postpones long march amid differences over mass resignation
Maryam, Fazlur express disappointment over PPP

 

On 16 March, PDM chief Fazlur Rehman announced the postponement of the long march which was initially scheduled to be held on 26 March. The decision was made at the PDM’s meeting wherein the PPP expressed its reservations over mass resignations and said it would consult with the Central Executive Committee. Fazlur said, “We have given them the chance and we will await their decision. Until then, the March 26 long march will be considered postponed.” (Javed Hussain, “Long march postponed as PDM unable to see eye to eye on resignations,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)

Will submit resignations if Nawaz returns, says Zardari
Asif Zardari asked Nawaz Sharif to come back to Pakistan if he wants to fight the government. Sources in The News International quoted that Zardari said, “You have to return to the country if you are prepared for a war against the government, be it the long march or resignations from the assemblies. We will submit our resignations to you.” Zardari opined that by resigning en masse, the alliance would strengthen the Establishment. (Amir Wasim, “Setback for PDM as Zardari snubs Sharifs on resignations,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)

Responding to this, Maryam Nawaz asked if Zardari would guarantee the safety of her father. She told Zardari that her entire party had voted for PPP’s Gilani and reiterated that PML-N has always fully supported the PDM. (Asim Yasin, “PPP links resignations with Nawaz’s return,” The News International, 17 March 2021) (“Zardari tells Maryam he 'didn't mean to hurt her feelings' with Nawaz remarks,” The News International, 17 March 2021)

PPP’s attitude was undemocratic, says Fazlur
Reacting to the differences with PPP, Fazlur termed the party’s attitude “undemocratic.” He expressed his displeasure that despite the rest of the nine parties in the alliance agreeing on the resignations, “PPP went against the decision.” He also abruptly left the press meeting saying he had nothing more to say. (Muhammad Anis, “'Attitude of PPP during the PDM meeting was undemocratic,' says Fazl,” The News International, 17 March 2021)

 

Govenrment hints at contempt proceedings if CEC, ECP members do not resign
Opinion calls government’s demand a manifestation of authoritarian mindset

Image Source: Dawn

On 16 March, the government said it would move contempt proceedings if the Chief Election Commissioner and ECP members do not resign. The Minister for Science and Technology reiterated that the PTI was only conveying the people’s demands, and said the government had already started working with the Attorney General of Pakistan. Further, he emphasised that PTI had objectives in its manifesto: “accountability and transparency in elections.” (Syed Irfan Raza, “Govt to initiate contempt case if CEC, ECP members don’t resign,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)

Attempt to intimidate constitutional body will weaken regime itself, says opinion 
An opinion in Dawn says the government’s demands for resignation of the CEC and ECP members is “an attempt to undermine the authority and independence of a constitutional body” and a “manifestation of an authoritarian mindset.” The author recalls the root of the government’s differences with the ECP: the election body’s decision on the secret ballots and the PTI’s various suggestions to make votes identifiable. He warns that if the government attempts to intimidate a constitutional body, it will “end up further weakening the regime itself.” He also conveys that instead of blaming the ECP for the PTI’s Senate elections loss in Islamabad, Imran should remember that “it is parliament’s responsibility to make laws.” 

Referring to the ECP’s response to the government’s criticism of the body, the author says it is proof that CEC and the members are courageous “to stand up to the government’s pressure.” He recalls that the government had appointed the CEC, a man of experience, known for his uprightness. Therefore, he urges the government to not make its differences with the ECP a matter of ego and asks Imran to think rationally. (Zahid Hussain, “A new battlefront,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)

 

PM inaugurates Islamabad Security Dialogue
Imran says food security and climate change are new security challenges 

Image Source: Dawn

On 17 March, PM Imran Khan inaugurated the first Islamabad Security Dialogue as well as launched an advisory portal aimed at unveiling Pakistan’s new strategic direction. The new strategic direction is stated to be based on a comprehensive security framework in line with PM’s vision of peace, regional connectivity and development partnerships with the world. During the inauguration, he said, “We are slowly realising that national security relates to areas which no one thinks about.” He also outlined the changing dimensions of national security which now include "climate change, food security and economic prosperity." He said climate change is a "frightening thing" the effects of which will be seen by future generations. Further, he reiterated the necessity of a programme to address food security issues. (“Food security, climate change among new national security challenges, says PM Imran,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PAF chief makes farewell calls to COAS, DG ISI
On 16 March, Chief of the Air Staff (CAS) Air Chief Marshal Mujahid Anwar Khan made a farewell call on COAS General Qamar Javed Bajwa as well as the ISI DG Lt Gen Faiz Hameed. The COAS thanked the CAS for his service saying, “Because of his immense efforts and quality leadership, Pakistan Air Force today is a force second to none.” (“PAF chief calls on COAS, DG ISI,” The News International, 17 March 2021)

ECONOMY
11 per cent growth in imports while exports drop in February
On 15 March, data released by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) showed that Pakistan’s imports including major kitchen items like cooking oil and sugar have continued to increase ahead of the fasting month of Ramazan, while exports led by the textiles sector have dropped in February. The import bill of eatables ballooned by 50.29 per cent to USD 5.344 billion year-on-year during the first eight months of 2020-21, whereas the export value of textile sectors fell to USD 1.23 billion in February from USD 1.27 billion over the corresponding month of last year, showing a decline of 3.12 per cent. (Mubarak Zeb Khan, “Textile exports fall by 3pc in February,” “Import bill of eatables up by 50pc amid farm sector woes,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)

ECC may stop payments to IPPs amid probe into excess profits
On 17 March, the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) is set to take up the matter of approving the withholding of billions of rupees worth of payments to the independent power producers (IPPs) following an investigation launched by the National Accountability Bureau (NAB). This comes after the Inquiry Committee on Power stated that the IPPs received excess payment of Rs1,000 billion. (“ECC may stop payments to IPPs,” The Express Tribune, 17 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Pakistan keen to improve ties with Bangladesh, says President
On 16 March, President Dr Arif Alvi stated that Pakistan is keen to improve ties with Bangladesh and called for using all avenues for improving the bilateral relationship. While speaking to Pakistan’s High Commissioner to Bangladesh Imran Siddiqui he said, “Pakistan highly values its ties with Bangladesh and wants to further expand cooperation by using the existing bilateral mechanisms.” Further, Siddiqui had been called from Dhaka by the government for consultations on Bangladesh’s golden jubilee celebrations later this month. (“Pakistan wants to improve ties with Bangladesh, says Alvi,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)

Pakistan gives a six-month extension to a helicopter deal with Turkey
On 17 March, Dawn reported that a US defence publication said that Pakistan has given another extension to a helicopter deal with Turkey, giving Ankara six more months to deliver the aircraft. Previously, in 2018 Pakistan signed a USD 1.5 billion deal with Turkey for buying 30 Turkish-made T129 Atak helicopters, however, the delivery date was pushed back due to the Pentagon’s refusal to issue export licenses for engines and other parts made in the US. (Anwar Iqbal, “Pakistan gives another extension to helicopter deal with Turkey,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Among the Xenophobic trends spreading is Islamophobia, says Editorial
An editorial in Dawn critical of the rise of Islamophobia across the globe says that the OIC should emphasise that discrimination against Muslims will not be tolerated, adding that those who indulge in hate crimes must be charged accordingly. Further, it argues that while terrorists acting in the name of Islam must be brought to justice, their misguided acts should not be used as a cover to tarnish all Muslims. More importantly, the civil rights of Muslims must be ensured, and they must be allowed to practise their faith freely. (“Muslims targeted,” Dawn, 17 March 2021)

‘US Policy Ignores Palestinian Human Rights,’ says opinion
An opinion in The News International critical of the American policymakers toward the Israeli-Palestinian conflict says that successive architects of the policy have been Israel-centric with near-total disregard for the suffering endured by the Palestinian people. The opinion states that Palestinians were judged as less human than Israelis, thus there were not entitled to make demands to have their rights recognized and protected. Further, the opinion concludes by saying that Israel has the leverage to do as it pleases with US backing, however, when the Palestinians then they are at fault. (James Zogby, “Palestinian rights,” The News International, 17 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                      
An opinion in Dawn, critical of the forever struggle that women across the world face, argues that global primitivism prevails where the lives, welfare and choices of women are concerned.

An opinion in Dawn says that corruption is one of the biggest enemies of healthy ecosystems arguing that corruption adds to the climate exposure of a country’s population much more than the simple prevalence of poverty or low-income levels.


"Not a single activity in Pakistan that involves power or money is not tainted by accusations and counter-accusations...The reality is that poor governance coupled with corruption is relatively far more prevalent in poor countries which is seriously hurting their economies and adversely affecting political development and social behaviour."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'Our national contradictions'

 

 


Government demands resignation of CEC and ECP members


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 16 March 2021
The government vs the Election Commission: Demand for the resignation of ECP members is a bad strategy
Shafqat Mehmood, the Minister for Education, yesterday asked for the resignation of the entire members of the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP). According to Dawn, he said: “There is no option left now. The election commission cannot continue to function in its current state. The ECP [members] should collectively resign.” 

The stated and the unstated reasons for the above demand is obvious. The government feels that the Election Commission should take responsibility for the recent Senate elections, in which the party’s candidate Hafeez Shaikh got defeated by the Opposition supported Yousuf Gillani. That is the stated reason; the unstated one is, what is happening after the NA-75 by-poll fiasco. The Election Commission has made the entire by-poll null and void, following malpractices in a few polling booths. The Election Commission’s initial statements and the reports, though do not state explicitly, but hints at rigging the Daska by-poll (obviously by the PTI). The ECP is likely to probe further, and any detailed report will be a complete embarrassment for the PTI government. Further, any negative report by the ECP on the Daska by-poll will provide the necessary ammunition for the Opposition to target the PTI. The Opposition is already fuming over what happened in the Senate last week, with the election of the Chairman and Deputy Chairman.

So, the government’s demand for resignation of the Election Commission members is to upset any report, and its political fallout. 

But, the government’s demand would go against the very idea of strengthening institutions and electoral reforms, that the PTI leadership has been emphasising. Second, the government can only ask for the resignation, but cannot force it. According to the Constitution, only a Supreme Judicial Council can remove the members of the ECP. Such a Council, according to the Constitution, shall be headed by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, along with two more senior judges. 

The government cannot remove the members of the ECP; but, it can politicize their functioning. And that is precisely what the PTI is attempting with the demand for their resignation. A bad strategy.
 
In Focus
Government demands resignation of CEC and ECP members
Opposition calls it “act of revenge” and "mala fide intentions" 

On 15 March, the government called on the ECP members, including the Chief Election Commissioner, to resign, claiming that the election body had failed to ensure transparency in the Senate elections on 3 March. 

Federal Minister Shafqat Mehmood said, “There is no option left now. The election commission cannot continue to function in its current state. The ECP [members] should collectively resign.” He accused the ECP of not taking any action during the Senate polls despite “clear evidences of corruption and use of money.” 

Opposition comes out in support of ECP 
The opposition leaders said the government demands were “unconstitutional and illegal” and said the government was playing “an act of revenge” because of the ECP decision to hold re-elections in Daska. The opposition’s stance comes in contrast to its recent criticism of the ECP and the protests it held outside the Commission office. Maryam Nawaz deemed the demand “an attack on the country’s institutions.” The PPP Secretary General said, the government’s demands had elements of “mala fide intentions and victimisation.” (Amir Wasim, “Govt calls for resignation of CEC, other ECP members,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)

Dawn explains CEC, ECP members can be removed only through SJC
An explainer in Dawn says, the CEC and the ECP members can be removed only through the Supreme Judicial Council for which the government will have to file a reference. The SJC is headed by the Chief Justice of Pakistan, “comprises two senior most judges of the apex court and two chief justices of the high courts.”  

An ECP official told Dawn the government’s claims that the ECP failed to use technology to trace the votes, “was a clear violation of Article 226 of the Constitution which provides for secret ballot.” (Iftikhar A Khan, “CEC, ECP members can be removed only through SJC,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)

Editorial terms government demands inappropriate
An editorial in Dawn says the government calling on the ECP to resign collectively is inappropriate. The editorial recalls that the ECP Chief was appointed by Imran Khan himself and appreciates the fact that under the current CEC, the ECP has been able “to stand up to pressure from the government.” It urges the government to “do itself a favour if it were to take a holistic view of the situation before rushing to make statements that are difficult to take seriously.” (“A genuine offer?,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)

 

Pakistan to begin vaccination through walk-in facilities today 
NCOC records more than 2500 cases in last 24 hours 

Image Source: Dawn

On 15 March, the National Command and Operation Centre (NCOC) decided to arrange for walk-in vaccination centres for people aged 70 and above across the country, from 16 March (today). The decision was taken in light of the rising COVID-19 cases. The NCOC urged people to ensure that senior citizens took the vaccination as “most mortality cases were being reported in the old age group.” The walk-in facility will be available in “Azad Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan” as well. (Ikram Junaidi, “Walk-in vaccination facility for citizens aged 70 from today,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)

COVID-19 cases on the rise
Meanwhile, Pakistan recorded 2,511 cases in a single day and 58 deaths. Most of the deaths were recorded in Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. (“Pakistan reports over 2,500 new COVID cases,” The Express Tribune, 16 March 2021)

 

Review meeting of Pakistan-Afghanistan Border Fence Project held
Balochistan Home Minister terms border fence project matter of country’s security 

Image Source: Dawn

On 15 March, a review meeting on the Pak-Afghan Border Fence Project was held in Balochistan’s Chaman town. Balochistan Home Minister Ziaullah Langove asked the officials present at the meeting to consider the project as a priority as it was concerned with Pakistan’s security. He said the project was key to improving the “law and order situation in the province” as well as important to Afghanistan’s interest. He said, “it would help curb illegal movement and negative activities on the border.” (“Pace of work on Pak-Afghan border fence project reviewed,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Opposition alliance should use resignation option like an ‘atom bomb’ or ‘last option,’ says Bilawal 
On 15 March, the PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari said that that recent gains made due to the opposition’s unity proved that democratic forces could not only snatch their ‘space’ but get success. Further, he stated that he felt that the opposition’s resignations should be used like an ‘atom bomb’ or a ‘last option’ as the PDM’s strategy within parliament had paid off. (Mohammad Hussain Khan, “Bilawal wants PDM to focus on options within parliament,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)

Election of leaders from Balochistan and merged tribal districts to help boost federation, says PM
On 15 March, PM Imran Khan after meeting with the newly-elected chairman and deputy chairman of the Senate expressed the hope that the election of leaders from Balochistan and merged tribal districts would help strengthen the federation. Further, Sadiq Sanjrani and Mirza Mohammad Afridi stated that their election was a matter of pride for the people of their areas. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Election of Sanjrani, Afridi to help boost federation: PM,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)

PTM chief and three others booked for treason
On 16 March, Dawn reported that the police have booked the Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement leader Manzoor Pashteen and his three others under the treason charge for allegedly raising slogans against the country when activists of Tehreek-i-Inqilab chanted pro-Pakistan and pro-army slogans during a demonstration. (“PTM leader, three others booked for treason,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)

Decision to increase number of federal bureaucrats on provincial posts rejected
On 16 March, Dawn reported that the association of provincial bureaucrats has rejected the federal government’s decision to increase by three times the number of federal bureaucrats on provincial posts and vowed to challenge the decision in high courts. The spokesperson of the All Pakistan Provincial Civil Services Association (APPCSA) said that the association had rejected the so-called reforms and termed them encroachment upon the right of the provincial bureaucracy. (Malik Asad, “Provincial bureaucrats up in arms against centre’s move,” Dawn, 16 March 2021)

ECONOMY
Rupee hits 13-month high closes at 156.99 against the dollar
On 15 March, the Pakistani rupee hit over a one-year high at Rs156.99 against the US dollar in the inter-bank market as the flow of foreign currencies remained high compared to outflows. With a fresh gain of Rs0.14, the currency has recovered almost seven per cent or Rs11.44 during the last seven months to date since it touched an all-time low of Rs168.43 on 26 August 2020. Further, the steady inflow has kept the country’s foreign currency reserves stable at a 13-month high of USD 13 billion allowing Pakistan to make international payments mainly on import and foreign debt repayment counters. (“Rupee hits 13-month high,” The Express Tribune, 16 March 2021)

Govt to fix food prices through an ordinance
On 16 March, The Express Tribune reported that PM Imran Khan has directed his team to fix the prices of essential items through an ordinance as the federal and provincial governments have failed to check inflation. According to the PM’s office, the government has prepared the draft of the Pakistan Food Security Flow and Information Ordinance 2021. However, the measure is likely to backfire due to constitutional limits. (Shahbaz Rana, “Govt seeks to fix food prices through ordinance,” The Express Tribune, 16 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Pakistan and India’s Indus commissioners to meet in New Delhi
On 16 March, The Express Tribune reported that the Indus Water Commissioners of Pakistan and India have agreed to meet on 23 and 24 March in New Delhi after a two-year hiatus. Indus Water Commissioner Syed Muhammad Mehr Ali Shah and Foreign Office Spokesperson Zahid Hafeez Chaudhri are set to represent Pakistan. This would be the 116th meeting of the Pakistan-India Indus Water Commissioners. (Khalid Mahmood, “Thaw in Pakistan, India ties as ‘Indus water officials to meet next week’,” The Express Tribune, 16 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                       
An opinion in Dawn, arguing that each political challenge can be used to predict the beginning of the end, says that the Yousuf Raza Gilani victory on the NA Senate seat had sealed Imran Khan’s fate at the beginning of March and Sadiq Sanjrani’s smooth sailing in the Senate chairman’s election just nine days later has put paid to the prime minister’s departure till the next cliffhanger event.

An editorial in Dawn, commending the trend adopted by the national cricket selectors to induct promising youngsters in the Pakistan team, says that an independent selection committee is quite rare in Pakistan cricket which has repeatedly grappled with favouritism and nepotism at the expense of merit for decades.

An editorial in The Express Tribune, critical of the rise of the third wave of COVID-19 in the country, says that it is disappointing to see how the government has not yet completely catered to the most at-risk population.
 
 



"Wise men and women must learn from the experience of their predecessors. Dialogue abroad and dialogue at home. It is the only way forward for Pakistan.."
-An opinion in The New International on
'Dialogue: at home and abroad'

 


Government offers to hold talks on electoral reforms


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Government offers to hold talks on electoral reforms
PML-N, JUI-F see resignations as way forward, PPP differs

On 14 March, the government offered to hold talks with the opposition on electoral reforms for future elections. However, the government placed a condition that the opposition should accept “the PTI-led government's mandate to govern for five years.” The Minister for Science and Technology said, “We want to make future elections fair and transparent” and conveyed that the Adviser to the Prime Minister on Parliamentary Affairs and Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs had begun working on the issue. (“After Senate success, govt asks opposition to come to the table for electoral reforms,” Dawn, 15 March 2021) The announcement came after the opposition said it would challenge the results of the Senate chairman and deputy chairman elections. 

PML-N, JUI-F to push for resignation from assemblies, say sources
On 15 March (today), Dawn quoted sources who said that the PML-N and JUI-F will push for submitting resignations to the assemblies in its next meeting. The JUI-F believes that after the loss of PDM in the Senate chairman and deputy chairman elections, “it has become imminent for the opposition parties to come out of the assemblies.” Further, there are speculations that the JUI-F sees a no-confidence motion as a futile exercise. Similarly, a senior PML-N member told Dawn that the party would insist on the resignations. (Amjad Mahmood and Amir Wasim, “PML-N to press for resignations at PDM meeting tomorrow,” Dawn, 15 March 2021)

Meanwhile…
The PPP appears to have made it clear that its party members would not resign. A Senator quoted Bilawal Bhutto who said, “Boycotting the system and resigning from assemblies shouldn’t be the way forward. If there is one thing I have learned from my mother it is that we should stay in the system and fight...We shouldn’t give a walk-over to the other side; we [PPP] fought even when we had only 18 lawmakers in assembly in 1997.” (Rizwan Shehzad, “PPP in no mood to ‘give govt a walk-over’,” The Express Tribune, 15 March 2021)

The PDM will convene on 16 March to discuss the options. 

 

Pakistan among the biggest importers of arms in the region
China remains biggest exporter to Pakistan, Bangladesh, Algeria

Image Source: Dawn

On 15 March (today), the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute released a report on international arms transfers based on arms transfer from 2016 to 2020. According to the report, Pakistan was 10th among the largest importers of arms in Asia and Oceania region, along with India, Australia, China, South Korea. 

China remains the fifth largest exporter of arms, and “Pakistan, Bangladesh and Algeria were the largest recipients of Chinese arms.”

Pakistan's arms import
Globally, Pakistan accounts for 2.7 per cent of the imports. Further, 74 per cent of Pakistan's arms were imported from China. However, compared to the previous period, there was a 23 per cent decrease in Pakistan's arms import. The report also mentioned that Pakistan has large outstanding orders for arms to be completed by 2028. This includes "50 combat aircraft, eight submarines and four frigates from China, and four frigates from Turkey." (“Pakistan among biggest importers of major arms in Asia and Oceania: report,” Dawn, 15 March 2021)

 

Olive plantation drive kicks off in Nowshera
Will attract foreign exchange, create employment, says PM

Image Source: Geo News

On 15 March, Imran Khan launched an olive plantation drive in Nowshera, as part of the 10 billion Tree Tsunami. The Special Assistant in Climate Change said the programme is designed for “areas that face water shortages and droughts.” However, olive plantation is a priority plan for the government “to make the farmers prosperous and save valuable foreign exchange.” Similarly, Imran reiterated that food security is the biggest challenge Pakistan faces. He said, climate change is the second challenge and third, creating employment. He said olive plantation could be one way to attract foreign exchange. (“PM Imran terms food security Pakistan's biggest challenge,” The Express Tribune, 15 March 2021) (“PM Imran Khan kick starts olive plantation project in Nowshera,” The News International, 15 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Govt orders probe into controversial material related to Aurat March on social media
On 14 March, the Federal Minister for Religious Affairs stated that the federal government has ordered an investigation into the alleged issue of raising blasphemous slogans and display of objectionable banners during the ‘Aurat March.’ The minister said, “Whosoever is involved in the activity will be exposed and punished according to the law,” adding that those responsible for photo-shopped banners on social media will also be taken to task. Further, the minister stated, “Pakistan is the country of faithful and no such activity in this part of the world can be allowed.” (Muhammad Anis, “Govt orders probe into objectionable activities of Aurat March,” The News International, 15 March 2021)

Maryam lashes out at the NAB before LHC hearing
On 15 March, PML-N Vice President Maryam Nawaz lashed out at the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) for making an issue about her statements. While speaking to the media before a hearing in the Lahore High Court on a NAB petition for cancellation of her bail in the Chaudhry Sugar Mills (CSM) case she said, “Who gave you the right to judge statements? Your job was to supposedly stop corruption. Now that you've failed in that, you have changed your responsibilities?” (“'Who gave you the right to judge statements?': Maryam hits back at NAB before LHC hearing,” Dawn, 15 March 2021)

ECONOMY
SE-100 index opened higher following an upsurge in world markets
On 15 March, the benchmark KSE-100 index opened higher following an upsurge in world markets on increasing bets on faster economic recovery. This comes after the KSE-100 index plunged 2,049 points, or 4.5 per cent, to settle at 43,788 points the previous week. (“KSE-100 index rises 747 points following surge in global markets,” Dawn, 15 March 2021)

Govt to increase the power tariff to comply with IMF plan
On 15 March, Dawn reported that the government might have to increase the electricity tariff for consumers two times before December along with making monthly fuel price adjustments and diverting substantial funds from taxpayers’ money to the power sector, to keep the International Monetary Fund programme going. Officials have stated that Rs220 billion will be raised through two adjustments before December and about bout Rs130bn worth of additional funds would have to be diverted out of federal revenue in the shape of higher subsidy. (Khaleeq Kiani, “Power tariff may go up to comply with IMF plan,” Dawn, 15 March 2021)

ON CLIMATE CHANGE
Government’s environment-friendly policies had been recognised globally, says PM
On 14 March, PM Imran Khan on Sunday via Twitter said, “Globally PTI’s (Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf) environment policies are being recognised especially our green recovery programme from the Covid 19 pandemic and our climate action plan.” Further, he posted a video of the World Economic Forum which showed three ways that Pakistan had adopted for building a greener future. The video said that Pakistan has trained 5,000 young people to be ‘nature guardians’ adding that Pakistan had invested in green spaces and attracted USD 180 million funding. (“Government’s environment policies recognised globally: PM,” Dawn, 15 March 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
Peace in Afghanistan is not possible without consensus among internal and external players
An opinion in The Express Tribune argues that peace in Afghanistan is only possible if there is consensus among the different groups within Afghanistan and regional players including between Pakistan and India. For this reason, the opinion suggests that Pakistan and India along with other regional players have open and candid discussions on their respective concerns. Further, it adds that Islamabad’s concerns over India’s negative role in Afghanistan can only be addressed if there are direct talks between all the parties concerned. (Kamran Yousaf, “Should we oppose India’s role in Afghanistan?,” The Express Tribune, 15 March 2021)

 

Also read...                                                                                   

An opinion in Dawn critical of the blasphemy charges against the Aurat March argues that no one has the right to spread lies and threaten lives by inventing and weaponising blasphemy charges. Similarly, an opinion in The Express Tribune says social media went into overdrive with the numerous videos and posts going viral, aimed to smear the women’s rights movement. But what is worrisome is that many of that content was fake or misleading or both, which is a very dangerous trend.

Maleeha Lodhi in an opinion in Dawn says that in Pakistan’s deeply polarised and fraught environment the tone and content of political discourse have plunged to a level not witnessed before. She says it is not just the political discourse that is debased. Democracy too is debased.

 


PDM to challenge election of Sanjrani as Senate chairman


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 13 March 2021
Senate election and the big picture: Travails of a democracy
While yesterday’s election results for the Senate is likely to be debated in the media, Parliament and even in the Court, is there a big picture? Clearly, there is a problem over the seven votes, that the Opposition Senators have casted yesterday. Was it intentional? Was there a government ploy with the same? Was the rejection of these seven votes incorrect?

There is a problem with the seven votes. But, there is also a problem “of” the seven votes, in terms of what they signify, and what they demand. What they signify is the larger problem of how the Senate elections are held, how the seats are distributed, who gets elected as a Senator, and why. If these questions signify the problem, it also demands, what needs to be done – addressing the larger problem, through electoral reforms. An editorial in The News, hit the problem on its head: “When people with money and the ability to win influence through wealth are chosen over those who have served their fields and their party loyally then there will always be trouble and a great deal of acrimony.”

Even during this Senate election, there was a problem with the selection within the parties. For example, both in Balochistan and Sindh, the PTI members were unhappy with the nominations by the party. The PTI had to rework the nominations, as the PTI members objected their party giving seats to those who were outsiders. The problem of “buying” a Senate seat by individuals who can afford it, and the problem of “selling” a Senate seat by the political parties, is an unfortunate reality. While not all Senators “buy” their seats, and not all seats were “sold” by the parties, the issue exists in Pakistan. Even if the number of “buying” and “selling” is small, that number makes a huge impact, as it has done yesterday in the latest Senate elections. When you buy a seat, what loyalty would you have? One is likely to be loyal to himself, than the party.

So what does the above practice for the Senate elections demand? The answer is obvious: reforms. Easier said than practiced in Pakistan. One of the multiple travails of democracy in Pakistan.
 
 
In Focus
PDM to challenge election of Sanjrani as Senate chairman
Government says parliamentary proceedings not challengeable

 

On 12 March, the PDM rejected the victory of Sadiq Sanjrani as the Senate chairman; the alliance claimed that seven votes in favour of Yousuf Gilani were “illegally” rejected and said the elections were “stolen.” In this context, the PDM announced they would challenge the rejection of the votes in court on 13 March (today). 

Bilawal Bhutto said, “A vote is ‘cast’ when the intention of the voter becomes clear. Seven votes were invalidly rejected (but) if these seven votes are added, then Yusuf Raza Gilani has won. Gilani has become the chairman of the Senate.” If the seven votes were counted, Gilani would have won 49 to 48 votes. (Asim Yasin and Muhammad Anis, “Opposition says Gilani’s win stolen, result to be challenged,” The News International, 13 March 2021)

Opposition leaders lash out
Reflecting Bilawal’s statements, Raja Pervaiz Ashraf termed the results “a big joke” on democracy. Similarly, Fazlur Rehman said, “no good could be expected from an ‘incompetent government’” and pushed for overthrowing the government. Maryam Nawaz, on the other hand, congratulated Gilani and said his “victory” would be announced. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Opposition to challenge Sanjrani’s victory in court today,” Dawn, 13 March 2021) (“Opposition cries foul after losing Senate battle by ‘seven rejected votes’,” The Express Tribune, 13 March 2021)

Establishment not involved in Senate chairman elections, says Gilani
Gilani alleged the Presiding Officer was allied with the ruling party and said the Establishment had no role in Sanjranji's election. He said, "The presiding officer knew that I was winning with seven votes so he did what he should not have done." ("Presiding officer played nasty role, alleges Gilani," The News International, 13 March 2021)

Meanwhile…
PTI Senator Mohsin Aziz cited the Rules of Procedure & Conduct of Business in Senate 2012, and said it is not possible to challenge the Senate and National Assembly proceedings. Similarly, Shibli Faraz said, “Gilani’s defeat was in fact the defeat of old corrupt system and the narrative of corrupt politicians and their promoters.” (“Parliament’s proceedings can’t be challenged in court: govt,” Dawn, 13 March 2021)
The News International reported that the government said the opposition was “shedding tears as its politics are buried.” Further, Mirza Mohammad Afridi was elected as the deputy chairman against the PDM candidate. 

PM congratulates Sanjrani and Mirza
Prime Minister Imran Khan congratulated Sanjrani and Mirza for their victory; they are from Balochistan and erstwhile FATA respectively. He said, "I am happy Balochistan and former FATA got these two slots in line with my policy of mainstreaming those parts of Pakistan that have been marginalised or left behind in the past." ("Sanjrani, Afridi's win in line with policy of mainstreaming marginalised parts of Pakistan: PM," The News International, 13 March 2021)

 

Roshan digital payments attracts USD 671 million, says SBP 
Data shows growing interest in RDA among non-resident Pakistanis

Image Source: Dawn

On 12 March, the State Bank of Pakistan tweeted that the recently-launched Roshan Digital Account (RDA) had attracted USD 671 million and recorded over 100,000 accounts from overseas Pakistanis. The SBP said accounts have been opened from more than 100 countries. 

Increasing reach of RDA
Initially, RDA was launched in September 2020 with the aim of making remote banking easier for non-resident Pakistanis (NRPs). It was launched in collaboration with eight banks but over time, other banks have joined. Further, the SBP also launched the Naya Pakistan Certificate savings scheme to attract more investments. 

The RDA also provided greater returns on deposits. As per the SBP, most of the USD 671 million have come in over the last eight weeks therefore reflecting growing interests in the RDA among NRPs. (Shahid Iqbal, “Roshan digital account attracts $671m in six months,” Dawn, 13 March 2021)

 

Pakistan and China celebrate 70 years of diplomatic ties
Opinion highlights "all-weather" cooperation and mutual trust

Image Source: Dawn

An opinion in The Express Tribune by Talat Shabbir notes that Pakistan and China are in the 70th year of their diplomatic ties. The author begins by citing the virtual ceremony between the two countries to commemorate the same and describes the bilateral relation as “an all-weather cooperative partnership” which has survived “vicissitudes of times and changes in the international system.” 

Steady relations between Pakistan, China reflects a measure of reliability
The author says “mutual trust and all-encompassing cooperation” has been central to the diplomatic ties between the two countries. He opines that China has “always supported Pakistan in political, strategic and economic spheres” thereby displaying a measure of reliability. Similarly, he says, Pakistan is central to China’s economic and political advancements, in the region as well as globally. He says Pakistan has shown solid support to China in any crisis. He highlights that both the countries are at a historic crossroads and says they should  “eye higher goals of shared future that has peace, stability and prosperity at its core.”(Dr Talat Shabbir, “Pakistan-China at the crossroads of history,” The Express Tribune, 13 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Total number of Covid-19 cases hit the 600,198 mark
On 12 March, the total number of Covid-19 cases in Pakistan hit the 600,198 mark with 2,701 new cases being reported over the last 24 hours. Meanwhile, Special Assistant to Prime Minister on National Health Services, Regulations and Coordination stated that effective measures were being taken to curb the spread of the virus across the country. (Aamir Yasin, “Alarm as single-day Covid tally hits 2,701,” Dawn, 13 March 2021)

SC to hear PM’s plea against IHC order upholding ECP stance ON 18th
On 13 March, Dawn reported that the Supreme Court will commence the hearing of a petition moved on behalf of PM Imran Khan against the Election Commission of Pakistan’s (ECP) declaration that Akbar S. Babar was still a member of PTI. Previously, in 2019, the IHC upheld the ECP declaration, challenging this order, Imran Khan in his petition said the high court had indulged in fact-finding and argued that the IHC decision came without defining the ambit and power of the ECP. (“SC to hear PM’s plea against ECP declaration on 18th,” Dawn, 13 March 2021)

CTD arrests two BLA suspects in Quetta
On 12 March, the Counter-Terrorism Department (CTD) arrested two suspects belonging to the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) in Quetta. CTD spokesperson said that they were acting on a tip-off about the arrival of two suspected BLA terrorists in the city, the CTD personnel raided a place in the Sariab link road area and arrested them. (“Two BLA suspects arrested in Quetta,” Dawn, 13 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
UNDP in Pakistan suggests measures to close the gender gap 
On 12 March, the UNDP in Pakistan hosted a webinar on ‘Closing Pakistan’s Gender Gaps through the Economic Empowerment of Women’ suggested measures to overcome structural barriers and provide actionable policy recommendations to close the gender gap. During the meeting, matters related to the need for women's economic empowerment to ensure the sustainable economic growth of Pakistan, the legal and policy reforms required for inclusion of women in the economy, protection of women's rights in the informal sector, mitigating the gendered impacts of COVID-19, and the private sector's role to help the government address structural barriers for the economic emancipation of women in Pakistan were discussed. (“UNDP webinar suggests measures to close gender gap in Pakistan,” The News International, 13 March 2021)

ON CLIMATE CHANGE
Tree chopping by influential timber mafia going on unnoticed in Swat
On 13 March, The Express Tribune reported that although the Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa has announced a large-scale plantation drive to increase forest cover across the province, the timber mafia has actively been engaged in deforestation in Swat without inviting any attention from the quarters concerned. Especially in Malam Jabba, the timber mafia has been active once again and several very large trees have been cut down overnight, similarly in Matta. (Shiraz Khan, “Tree chopping going on unnoticed in Swat,” The Express Tribune, 13 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
China transferred its technology, knowledge and skills through Metro Train Project, says envoy 
On 13 March, Dawn reported that the newly-appointed Chinese Ambassador to Pakistan, Nong Rong said, “Through Orange Line and other projects completed under the China Pakistan-Economic Corridor (CPEC), we transferred our all technology and knowledge to people of Pakistan.” Further, during his visit to the project site, he said, “We think this way will be helpful for the economic improvement of Pakistan.” This was the first official visit of the ambassador to the very first operational CPEC project in Pakistan. (Khalid Hasnain, “China transferred technology, skills to Pakistan through CPEC: envoy,” Dawn, 13 March 2021)

COAS meets Australian High Commissioner to Pakistan
On 12 March, COAS General Qamar Javed Bajwa met with the Australian High Commissioner to Pakistan, Dr Geoffrey Shaw. During the meeting, matters of mutual interest were discussed as well as the overall regional situation, including the Afghan Peace Process and bilateral cooperation in various fields. General Bajwa stated that Pakistan values the strong diplomatic, economic, and defence relations that it shares with Australia, similarly, the Australian High Commissioner appreciated Pakistan’s positive role in regional peace and stability. (“COAS Bajwa meets Australian High Commissioner to Pakistan,” The News International, 13 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Pakistan seems to be hoping for a reset in ties with the US says opinion
An opinion in Dawn suggests that Pakistan should not seek across-the-board change in its ties with the US, rather Pakistan should start modestly with Afghanistan and counterterrorism and build mutual confidence, and then expand the dialogue and agree to cooperate on points of convergence while trying to manage areas of divergence. Further, it says Pakistan should revisit Zulfikar Ali Bhutto’s great idea of ‘bilateralism’ and that instead of being worried over losing China in pursuit of America, Islamabad should worry about gaining internal strength to enhance its appeal to both sides so neither can afford to lose Pakistan, adding that a weak Pakistan would need both China and the US. However, it would have no option but to choose one. (Touqir Hussain, “Re-engaging America,” Dawn, 13 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                        
An opinion in Dawn lists 10 takeaways from the closely contested Senate chair elections stating that there could yet be some twists and turns in the saga. An editorial in The News International, critical of the unusual set of events that unfolded at the senate chair polls. says that the government will need to think seriously about electoral reform, hopefully in a dialogue with the opposition as such matters cannot be managed in isolation.

An editorial in Dawn on the TikTok ban argues that with the government struggling to create jobs amid stagnant growth, the country’s decision-makers should be more concerned with facilitating those who are using talent and innovation to generate revenue and opportunities, instead of taking it upon themselves to turn the country into a nanny state.

An editorial in The News International, critical of the accusations against the Aurat March argues that "the fact that people are willing to allow real harm to come to Aurat March organisers is a very disturbing reminder of the lengths to which they can go just to malign something they seem to be afraid of: emancipated women."

 


Chaos marks beginning of elections to the Senate chairman


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 12 March 2021
Senate election shocker: Despite not having the numbers, the PTI gets its nominee elected
Today (Friday), in a surprise (and perhaps shocking for the Opposition) result, the government supported candidate - Muhammad Sadiq Sanjrani has won the election for the position of Chairman of the Senate. According to initial reports, seven votes casted in favour of Gilani, were rejected. As a result, Gilani today has received only 42 votes, whereas Sanjrani received 48. The seven votes were rejected on a technicality, on where they stamped on the ballot.

After the election of Senators last week, the election for the seats of Chairman and Deputy Chairman was hotly contested. Today morning, 48 new Senators, who have been just elected last week, took their oath. They also took part in the elections today.

Given the numbers, the outcome should have been simple. The Opposition had 51 seats, while the ruling PTI coalition only 47 seats. Two Senators – one each from the PML-N and JI would not be voting today. Despite that, the results should have been straight forward; but, according to the results, it was anything but that. 

The Opposition led by the PDM had nominated PPP’s Yusuf Raza Gilani and JUI-F’s Maulana Abdul Ghafoor Haideri for the positions of Chairman and Deputy Chairman. For the PDM, this was a great move – to have one from the PPP and another from the JUI-F as a common candidate. The PTI had nominated Muhammad Sadiq Sanjrani and Mirza Muhammad Afridi for the same positions. 

Yusuf Raza Gilani, a former Prime Minister (2008-12) of Pakistan, belongs to the PPP, and has been a party loyalist. He recently won as a Senator, during last week’s elections from Islamabad against PTI’s Hafeez Shaikh. Though the numbers favoured Shaikh in Islamabad, Gilani’s election was a surprise. The PTI has been complaining about horse trading on Gilani’s election last week. He is PDM’s joint candidate; by allowing Gilani and Maulana Haideri (for the Deputy Chairman post), to be the joint candidates, the PML-N has taken a back seat. Within the PDM, the PML-N (17 Senators) is the second largest party, after the PPP (21 seats). The JUI-F has only five Senators.

Sanjrani was elected in 2018 as the Senator, but as an independent from Balochistan; he was later made as the Chairman and has been since 2018. In the previous election, he defeated PML-N’s Raja Zafar-ul-Haq. Then in 2018, the PPP supported Sanjrani. 

Today, the contest was not between two candidates – Gilani and Sanjrani. It was between two actors – the ruling coalition and the opposition. The larger question on the eve of the elections was whether the contest was also between the Establishment and the PDM. A few reports today in the media talked about PML-N Senators getting phone calls from intelligence officers, asking them to vote in favour of a particular candidate. There were also complaints about hidden cameras.

If the loss of Hafeez Shaikh last week was a shocker for the PTI, the loss of Gillani should be a shocker not only for the PPP, but the entire PDM. Despite the numbers, how did he lose? Did the Establishment play a role, as the PML-N leaders have complained yesterday? Did those whose ballots was declared invalid, inadvertently stamped in the wrong place, or otherwise?

The PTI may have won the election for the Senate Chairman. But, would have to face the wrath of the PDM on the streets.

 

In Focus
Chaos marks beginning of elections to the Senate chairman
Opposition claims hidden cameras found in polling booth

 

On 12 March (today),  prior to the elections for Senate chairman and deputy chairman, members of the PPP and PML-N shared photos of “secret cameras” installed in the polling booth. They took to Twitter denouncing the incident. The presiding officer called for setting up a new polling booth. 

The Minister for Science and Technology, reacting to one of the images shared said the cables look like that of a CCTV camera and conveyed that "spy cameras are far more sophisticated.” However, he urged the Senate secretary to probe into the matter. (“Spy cameras at polling booth cause outrage ahead of Senate chief election,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

Maryam Nawaz said, "Those trying to rob Senate votes have lost their final battle today...Shame on you for stealing the votes; leave the office." She said the government was forced "to eat their own words" due to its failure to amend the Constitution with regard to secret ballot controversy. She said, the Constitution demands a secret ballot, and not secret cameras. ("Those trying to rob Senate votes have lost their final battle: Maryam," The Express Tribune, 12 March 2021)

Sadiq Sanjrani promised to join PPP in 2018, says Bilawal 
On 11 March, Bilawal Bhutto said PPP had supported Sanjrani during the 2018 elections on the promise that he would join their party after getting elected. Bilawal said that Sanjrani, who was an independent candidate from Balochistan, “had come to his house and sought help for getting elected as the Senate chairman.” Bilawal expressed regret that Sanjrani “did not keep his word.” (Amir Wasim, “Sadiq Sanjrani was backed in 2018 as he pledged to join PPP: Bilawal,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

48 news Senators sworn in
In the morning session, Senator Syed Muzaffar Hussain Shah administered the oath to 48 new Senators, most of them belonging to the PTI. The 48 will serve as Senators until 2027. ("48 newly elected members of Senate sworn in," The News International, 12 March 2021) 

 

Government clears NEPRA bill to implement IMF conditions
Consumers should not punished for weakness of power sector, says MNA

Image Source: Dawn

On 11 MArch, the government was successful in getting passed the NEPRA bill “empowering it to impose surcharges on electricity consumers to meet another ‘prior action’” in connection to the revival of the IMF programme. Under this, the government can “impose up to 10 per cent of the average electricity tariff on consumers.” 

Opposition sceptical about surcharge 

Though the bill was passed with a majority vote, the opposition was apprehensive about the surcharge. They maintained that the common people should not be burdened with these conditions. MNA Shazia Marri said “consumers should not be punished for the weaknesses of the power sector.”

However, the Finance Secretary said the government has no option but to implement these conditions; otherwise, the Pakistani economy would “sink tomorrow.” He reiterated that it was not the government which imposed the surcharges; rather, the reform is shared with the IMF and said small power consumers will not be charged. (Khaleeq Kiani, “Govt gets cleared Nepra bill to revive IMF programme,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

 

Pakistan receives remittances worth USD 2.26 billion in February
Remittances cross USD two billion for ninth consecutive month

Image Source: Dawn

On 11 March, the State Bank of Pakistan reported that the country received remittances worth USD 2.26 billion in February, which was 24 per cent higher than USD 1.82 billion in February 2020. Further, the SBP stated that the flow of remittances into Pakistan remained strong at above $2 billion for the ninth successive month in February 2021, enabling the government to maintain the country’s foreign currency reserves at stable levels and strengthened its capacity to make international payments smoothly. (“Remittances surge 24% to $2.26b,” The Express Tribune, 12 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PAF Air War College Institute inaugurated by President 
On 11 March, President Dr Arif Alvi inaugurated the Pakistan Air Force (PAF) Air War College Institute in Karachi. On his arrival, he said “Pakistan is a peaceful country and the world has witnessed that we returned the Indian pilot without any pressure,” and appreciated the efforts of the team that has completed the project as per the standards of the Higher Education Commission. (“President Alvi inaugurates PAF Air War College Institute,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

Police arrest ‘TTP militant’ involved in terror cases arrested in Karachi
On 11 March, the Malir police arrested a suspected militant, who was allegedly planning to carry out a suicide attack on the police training centre. Officials said, “The suspect received military training in Afghanistan. He conducted reconnaissance of Razzaqabad police training centre in 2012 along with another militant, Javed Swati, and was also involved in firing on a vehicle during bank robbery in Orangi Town in the same year,” adding that the suspect belonged to Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan. (“‘TTP militant’ involved in terror cases arrested in Karachi,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

Another police official shot dead in Rawalpindi
On 11 March, another police officer was shot dead by unidentified motorcycle riders at a checkpoint near Railway Carriage Factory in Rawalpindi. This is the third incident during the last five days with two other police officials being targeted earlier in a similar way. (Mohammad Asghar, “Another police official shot dead in twin cities,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

Nawaz Sharif accuses establishment of threatening Maryam Nawaz
On 11 March, in a public video message, Nawaz Sharif accused elements in the country’s security establishment of threatening Maryam Nawaz. He said, “First you broke open the Karachi hotel room door where Maryam was staying, and now you are threatening her, that if she does not stop she will be smashed.” Further, he stated that democracy is being undermined in Pakistan alleging that the “help given” during the PM’s confidence vote in parliament is “no secret.” (Atika Rehman, “Nawaz decries ‘threats’ to Maryam,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
FO welcomes renewed US efforts in Afghanistan
On 11 March, the Foreign Office spokesperson said, “We welcome the US efforts to re-energise the peace process and expedite the final political settlement.” Further, the spokesperson called on all parties to contribute to a comprehensive and inclusive settlement of the dispute. This is the first formal statement from Islamabad on the latest American diplomatic effort. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Pakistan welcomes renewed US push for Afghan peace,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

ON INDIA
Haider asks Kashmiris to “categorically and unanimously” reject bilateral talks between Pakistan and India
On 11 March, PoK’s PM Raja Farooq Haider asked the Kashmiris to “categorically and unanimously” reject bilateral talks between Pakistan and India on the Kashmir issue “because any exercise sans their involvement, as primary party to the dispute, will as usual end up in futility.” (Tariq Naqash, “AJK premier asks Kashmiris to reject Pak-India bilateral talks,” Dawn, 12 March 2021)

Strong evidence indicates India's involvement in Col (retd) Zahir's abduction. says FO
On 11 March, Foreign Office spokesperson alleged, “There is strong evidence pointing towards the involvement of Indian hostile agencies in the abduction of Habib Zahir, including involvement of Indian nationals who reportedly received him at Lumbini, made his hotel reservations and booked his tickets.” Further, the spokesperson said, “Pakistan has repeatedly called upon the Government of India to cooperate and assist in locating Habib Zahir, but unfortunately, we have not received any positive response as yet.” (“FO says strong evidence indicates India's involvement in Col (retd) Zahir's abduction,” The News International, 12 March 2021)
 

 
Also read...                                                                  
An opinion in Dawn on the Aurat March says that Pakistan has a stratified society in terms of mindset and there is no will to tolerate one another. Therefore, the Aurat March has to rethink its strategy and ducation has to be moved to the top of their agenda. Another opinion in The Express Tribune on the power of Womenomics says that Womenomics is not just a good social move, it is also good for business. 

An opinion in Dawn says the recent political setback for the government is an opportunity to reset some of its policies.

An opinion in The Express Tribune critical of the ‘Gutter politics’ in the country says that the institutions have been forced-muted and neutered under the fear of betraying partiality.
 
 
 


"It appears that the head of government is threatening institutions of governance which he is required to protect and use in the interest of the people...The government will only harm itself by trying to fight shadows. It faces no real threat from the opposition, at least not in the immediate future"
-An opinion in Dawn by I A Rehman on the
'Unfair assault on institutions'

 


Supreme Court rejects PTI plea to suspend re-polls in Daska


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Supreme Court rejects PTI plea to suspend re-polls in Daska
ECP calls for re-elections in Daska on 10 April

 

On 10 March, the Supreme Court rejected PTI’s plea seeking suspension of the Election Commission of Pakistan’s decision to conduct fresh by-polls in the entire NA-75 Daska constituency. However, the SC bench has directed the ECP to submit complete records based on which it made the decision to hold by-polls in the entire constituency. 

New by-polls without legal justification, alleges petitioner
The counsel for the PTI said Prime Minister Imran Khan does not object to re-polls as long as they are held in only 23 polling stations where the election process has been controversial. The petitioner maintained that the PML-N complaint was also limited to the “illegality and irregularity to the extent of 23 polling stations.” Therefore, he said it is beyond comprehension as to why Daska should have a “second by-election without any legal justification.” (Nasir Iqbal, “SC rejects plea against re-poll in entire NA-75,” Dawn, 11 March 2021)

Previously…
On the same day, the ECP announced that re-elections in Daska will be held on 10 April. The announcement comes after the ECP previously scheduled the re-elections for 18 March. However, the ECP postponed it after “the Punjab government sought time to fill the vacant positions of administrative officers in the region where the polls will be held.” (Fahad Chaudhry, “ECP reschedules Daska re-election to April 10 on Punjab govt's request,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

 

NCOC announces restrictions as COVID-19 cases rise
45 million vaccine doses will be imported from India

Image Source: Dawn

On 11 March, The Express Tribune quoted the National Command and Operations Centre (NCOC) data which showed that Pakistan had recorded 2,258 COVID-19 cases in a single day; the highest since 20 January. Further, 53 people had died over the day. However, the NCOC data said, there was “no active case was reported in G-B.” (“Country records over 2,200 Covid-19 cases for first time since Jan 20,” The Express Tribune, 11 March 2021)

NCOC re-imposes restrictions
On 10 March, the NCOC re-imposed several restrictions which had been in place before 24 February. It reiterated that smart and micro smart lockdowns will continue and has called for 50 per cent work from home functioning. Further, the NCOC has allowed a two-week break for educational institutions in 10 cities and limited attendance to 50 per cent in Balochistan and Sindh. (Ikram Junaidi, “NCOC re-imposes restrictions as Covid cases surge,” Dawn, 11 March 2021)

Pakistan to order vaccine from India
On the same day, the Planning Minister said Pakistan would be importing 45 million doses of vaccine from India under theGlobal Alliance for Vaccinations & Immunizations scheme. A formal announcement of the same is expected on 17 March. He said the two countries had arrived at an agreement in 2020; 15 million doses will be ordered in the first phase and 30 million between July and December. (“Govt to import 45m doses of Indian vaccine,” The Express Tribune, 11 March 2021)

Meanwhile…
On 10 March, the vaccination drive for senior citizens commenced. However, the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences witnessed a confused and chaotic situation when more senior citizens than expected turned up. The hospital expected an average 200 people but received “400 additional citizens, majority of who were retired bureaucrats, parliamentarians and influentials who wanted to get the jab at the earliest.” 

Doctors blamed the National Database and Registration Authority (Nadra) and the hospital management for the situation. (Munawer Azeem and Ikram Junaidi, “Mismanagement at Pims as vaccination for senior citizens begins,” Dawn, 11 March 2021)

 

Imran announces direct subsidy for 30 million families from June
Beginning of Pakistan’s transition to a welfare state, says PM

Image Source: The News International

On 10 March, Imran Khan launched the “Koi Bhuka Na Soye (No one goes to bed hungry)” scheme under the Ehsas programme. In this scheme, 30 million families are expected to get direct subsidies on essential food items; poor and labour class families will be provided “free meal boxes twice a day through mobile trucks” in Rawalpindi and Islamabad. 

During the launch, Imran said, “Koi Bhuka Na Soye programme is the beginning of Pakistan’s transformation into a welfare state.” He mentioned that gradually farmers will acquire fertilisers and required agricultural inputs through a similar scheme. (Syed Irfan Raza, “30m families to get direct subsidy from June: PM,” I, 11 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PM meets with ministers and leaders of the coalition
On 10 March, PM Imran Khan held a meeting with leaders of PTI coalition parties just ahead of the election of the Senate chairman and deputy chairman. During the meeting, the current political situation in the country and coalition issues were discussed, Further, the coalition parties are said to have expressed full confidence in the leadership of PM Imran Khan, reiterating their full support for PM's decision on chairman and deputy chairman. (“PM meets ministers, allies ahead of Senate chairman’s election,” The News International, 11 March 2021)

Speaker sets up a ‘council of senior parliamentarians’ to improve NA working
On 10 March, National Assembly Speaker Asad Qaiser constituted a ‘council of senior parliamentarians’ for “promoting democratic and parliamentary norms across the party divide line.” The formation of the 15-member council and its terms of reference (TORs) has been formally notified by the speaker, who will be the head of the council whereas NA secretary Tahir Hussain will act as its secretary. The council would “ensure issue-based debate and avoidance of any sexist, religious or ethnic slogans during the proceedings of the House,” as well as “The TORs of the council include promotion of established parliamentary norms and to encourage the young parliamentarians to participate in the proceedings of the house.” (Amir Wasim, “Speaker sets up senior MPs’ body to improve NA working,” Dawn, 11 March 2021)

PROVINCE
Govt rules out the replacement of KP chief minister
On 10 March, spokesperson for the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government ruled out the replacement of Chief Minister Mahmood Khan, stating that he is enjoying the full trust and confidence of PM Imran Khan. Further, the spokesperson said that the PM appreciated Mahmood Khan’s role in the Senate elections and termed him an outstanding chief minister, terming the speculations about the replacement of Mahmood Khan as baseless reports. (“Replacement of KP chief minister ruled out,” Dawn, 11 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
COAS and ISI chief attend Bahrain talks on Afghanistan
On 10 March, the COAS and Director General of Inter-Services Intelligence Lt Gen Faiz Hameed attended a session on the Afghan peace process in Bahrain. According to a statement released by ISPR, during the meeting “Current developments in the Afghan peace process, border security and necessary steps to be undertaken to facilitate an Afghan-led and Afghan-owned peace process were discussed.” Additionally, “During the meetings, issues of mutual interest and regional security situation came under discussion. COAS offered Pakistan’s complete support in achieving shared interests in bilateral security cooperation including training and capacity building.” (“Bajwa, ISI chief participate in Bahrain talks on the Afghan issue,” Dawn, 11 March 2021)

PM meets Uzbek counterpart, offers access to Pakistani ports
On 10 March, PM Imran Khan met with the Foreign Minister of Uzbekistan Dr Abdulaziz Kamilov, who was on a two-day visit to Pakistan. During the meeting, PM Khan assured Uzbekistan of complete facilitation in access to Pakistani ports, stating that Pakistan’s Karachi and Gwadar ports could become “the gateway to the landlocked Central Asia as Pakistan provided the Central Asian Republics the shortest route to international seas.” Further, during the delegation-level talks, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi and Kamilov exchanged views on the enhancement of economic cooperation, mutual support in international fora, regional connectivity and tourism promotion. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Uzbekistan offered access to Pakistani ports,” Dawn, 11 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
Bridal gifts remain wife's property, says SC
On 10 March, the Supreme Court in the 12-page judgment ruled that gifts given to the bride at the time of marriage are her personal property, and they cannot be taken away from her, according to Sharia law. During the hearing, Justice Qazi Faez Isa said “a woman has every right to own property and run a business,” adding “A woman's right to inherit from her parents and husband is clearly defined in [Islamic law].” Further, the SC said that the husbands should make an inheritance will for their wives. (“Bridal gifts remain wife's property, cannot be taken away: SC,” The News International, 11 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                   
I.A. Rehman, in his opinion in Dawn on the unfair assault on institutions, argues that the prime minister has attacked are vital pillars of governance. Pulling them down will only lead to the government’s collapse and that would serve nobody’s purpose.

An opinion in Dawn, sceptical of the ‘Storm clouds’ ahead of the elections in the Senate, says that this is a heavy agenda for any government even in the best of times. For a government consumed by political challenges emanating from within its fractured ranks as well as from the opposition, they can be crippling.

An opinion in The Express Tribune on the political culture in Pakistan argues that an effective political finance monitoring and enforcement system also needs to be instituted and horse-trading in Senate elections checked urgently.

 


GB Legislative Assembly passes resolution demanding provincial status


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 10 March 2021
GB’s desire to become the fifth province
Yesterday (Tuesday), the Gilgit Baltistan Legislative Assembly passed a resolution demanding a provisional provincial status. In other words, they want to become the fifth province of Pakistan.
 
The reason is simple. For the last few years, there has been a demand from the region to give them a provincial status, so that they can have access to Pakistan’s Parliament, Supreme Court and all related institutions. The provincial status would give them access to all constitutional provinces that the four provinces in Pakistan have. As of now, GB functions more as Pakistan’s colony.
 
Though this has been a long-standing demand from the region, during recent years, there has been a debate within Pakistan towards granting the same to Gilgit Baltistan. This was one of the primary issues that were discussed and promised during the latest elections in Gilgit Baltistan held in November 2020. Imran Khan, Bilawal Bhutto and Maryam Nawaz – all these leaders discussed the case of granting provincial status to GB.
 
How will Islamabad respond to now? If Gilgit Baltistan is to become a province, it would be the only one within Pakistan, with a Shia majority. As a fifth province, it would also demand control to the Indus river waters, China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) and other economic resources. If GB has to become a province, it would also affect the status of J&K, and Pakistan’s international position.

 

In Focus
GB Legislative Assembly passes resolution demanding provincial status
Will continue to push for “India-held” Kashmir’s self determination

On 9 March, the Gilgit-Baltistan Legislative Assembly (GBLA) passed a joint resolution demanding provincial status for the region, and “representation in the National Assembly, Senate and other federal institutions.” The resolution was tabled by the GB Chief Minister and other leaders from the ruling PTI as well as PML-N, PPP, JUI-F, and the Majlis Wahdat-i-Muslimeen (MWM).

GBLA highlights Kashmir issue
The GBLA pushed for an amendment in the Constitution without altering Pakistan’s stance on the Kashmir issue. It also maintained that it “would continue their moral and political support to the people of India-held Kashmir in their struggle for self-determination.” 

Unity displayed in GB should be reflected at the federal level, says CM
Thanking the opposition members for their support, the GB CM said, “The unity we’ve shown on this issue needs to be repeated again at federal level.” (Jamil Nagri, “GB Assembly demands provincial status for region,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

 

ECP rejects PTI petition seeking Gilani’s disqualification
PDM nominates JUI-F’s Haideri for deputy chairman position in Senate 

Image Source: The News International

On 9 March, the Election Commission of Pakistan rejected the PTI’s petition which sought the disqualification of Yousuf Gilani on the grounds that he won the Senate seat through rigging. The counsel for PTI said the video of Gilani’s son explaining how to cancel votes to PTI lawmakers is evidence of pre-poll rigging. 

However, the ECP said those who take bribes are equally responsible for the offence and asked the PTI to submit an amended petition with the names of the PTI lawmakers who took the bribe. However, the counsel said the PTI lawmakers could be present as witnesses, not as party to the offence. (Iftikhar A Khan, “ECP rejects plea to block Gilani’s victory notification,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

PTI Senator says at least three statements confirm opposition’s wrongdoing
On the same day, a PTI Senator alleged that Gilani, his son, and Maryam Nawaz “had made statements confirming that lawmakers had been lured by money and offers of party tickets.” He therefore pushed for review of the PDM’s nomination of Gilani for the position of Senate chairman. (“PTI questions Gilani’s eligibility to become senator,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

PPP approaches MQM-P seeking support for Gilani
The Sindh Information Minister announced that the PPP sought the support of the MQM-P for electing Gilani as the Senate Chairman. However, the MQM-P will make the final decision based on the discussions that will take place in the Rabita Commission. (“PPP seeks MQM-P’s support for Gilani,” The Express Tribune, 10 March 2021)

Meanwhile…
The PDM nominated JUI-F Secretary General Maulana Abdul Ghafoor Haideri as the alliance’s joint candidate for the post of deputy chairman. The alliance also maintained that PML-N will hold the leader of the opposition position in the Senate. However, Dawn reported that sources believe some PPP members are unhappy with the decision and “believed that it should not have surrendered their claim over the opposition leader’s slot.” (Amir Wasim, “Haideri gets PDM nomination for Senate deputy chief,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

Prior to the PDM’s announcement, Defence Minister Khattak said the PTI had offered Haideri the nomination for the same position. However, Haideri dismissed this and said since the opposition does not recognise the government, the offer was “meaningless.” 

Khattak’s offer comes as a shock, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn says the Khattak’s offer to nominate Haideri is a shocker and reflects the lengths to which parties are willing to go to secure its victory. The editorial says the PTI will have a lot to answer “if its candidate wins despite trailing in numbers.” This is so because the party has been disputing Gilani’s win claiming he did not have the required numbers in proportion to the party positions. It says, “The PTI government needs to be ready to answer these questions, or see its narrative get degraded in the court of public opinion.” However, it urges the political parties to address these issues once the Senate elections are over. (“Senate chair contest,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

 

Cabinet clears three bills in line with IMF terms
State enterprises to be free from ministries’ interference

Image Source: Dawn

On 9 March, the federal cabinet cleared the introduction of three bills in parliament. The three bills include allowing autonomy to the State Bank of Pakistan to target inflation, withdrawal of corporate income tax exemptions (Income Tax Second Amendment Act 2021) to generate Rs70-140 billion in additional revenue with effect from July 1, 2021, and State-Owned Enterprises (Governance and Operations) Bill 2021.

The Finance Minister stated, “We will take these bills to fast-track legislation,” adding that the relationship with the IMF, which had been under a “pause” for about a year, had formally started. Further, the IMF board is set to meet and complete the review and its lending to Pakistan. (Khaleeq Kiani, “SBP to be made autonomous in line with IMF terms,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Government to start vaccine inoculation for senior citizens today
On 10 March, Special Assistant to Prime Minister on Health stated, “Pak Covid-19 vaccination, next phase — starting 10 March, inshallah. Beginning with the senior-most citizens, who will receive SMS with instructions on their cell phones.” (Ikram Junaidi, “Vaccination for senior citizens to begin today,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

Educational institutes to close in seven Punjab cities
On 10 March, Education Minister stated that all educational institutions in seven cities of Punjab will close down from 15 March for two weeks amid the rise of COVID-19. The minister said, “Educational institutions in Faisalabad, Gujranwala, Lahore, Gujarat, Multan, Rawalpindi, and Sialkot will be closed from March 15 for spring holidays until March 28.” (“Educational institutes to close for two weeks from March 15 in seven Punjab cities,” The Express Tribune, 10 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Russia invites Pakistan for meeting on Afghanistan
On 10 March, Dawn reported that Pakistan has been invited by Russia to a meeting of ‘extended troika’ on Afghanistan being held on 18 March in Moscow. The Russian presidential envoy for Afghanistan said, “It is not even a conference, it is consultations of the expanded trio: Russia, the US, China and Pakistan. Yes, we have invited [Afghan] government representatives, Afghan statesmen and the Taliban delegation as well.” Responding to the invite Pakistan announced its backing for Russian efforts for peace and reconciliation in Afghanistan. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Russia invites Pakistan to meeting on Afghan peace,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
No foreign-dictated peace can succeed in pacifying Afghanistan, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn critical of development in Afghanistan says that as efforts are underway on the diplomatic and political fronts to reach a lasting peace agreement in Afghanistan, on the military front things are not looking good. The editorial argues this is Afghanistan’s dichotomy, it has been unable to govern itself for the past few decades and is dependent on foreign forces to provide security, while on the other side, despite the presence of foreign troops, there has been no reduction in violence. In this regard, the editorial stated that no foreign-dictated peace can succeed in pacifying Afghanistan, unless the various Afghan stakeholders decide that is it high time to bring peace to the country, adding that which is why the sooner the Afghans reach a workable peace deal, the better. (“Afghan peace push,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

ON THE LOC CEASEFIRE
A shared Nobel Peace Prize should await the leaders if they can rise to the challenge says opinion
An opinion in The News International commenting on the recent LoC agreement responds to six questions. First, the opinion terms the joint statement by the DGMOs as positive development considering the significant casualties and tragedies suffered on either side of the LOC which was also further hardening opinion and resolve in both Pakistan and India. Second, whether the ceasefire will lead to re-engagement and dialogue will depend on other necessary developments. Third, whether the Biden Administration played a role behind the scenes, it could be a possibility. Fourth, the numerous reasons behind the two countries reaching the agreement, for India its international image and alleged human rights violations, for Pakistan, the leaders in Pakistan may have realised that they can never lead to the kind of isolation and pressure that could compel it to reverse its 5 August 2019 decision. Fifth, looking into the response for the Kashmiris, the ceasefire was welcome because of the immediate reprieve it grants to the Muslims living on either side of it. Finally, was the LOC agreement a zero-sum or win-win development? The opinion argues that it is a win-win development in the small, and in the short-run. However, the challenge would be to convert a zero-sum longer-term prospect into a positive-sum or win-win prospect for the Kashmiris, and Pakistan and India. If this is achieved, a shared Nobel Peace Prize should await the leaders of the two countries. (Ashraf Jehangir Qazi, “A shared Nobel Peace Prize?,” Dawn, 10 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                    
There were multiple opinions and editorials on Afghanistan. Commenting on Biden’s latest political push on Afghanistan, Zahid Hussain comments, that the US “will also be increasing pressure on Pakistan to remove the Taliban’s military structures and officers from its soil.” An editorial in Dawn argues, “if foreign troops stay, the Taliban will continue to fight, and if they leave without a peace agreement in place, the brutal civil war will only intensify.”
 
On the military ceasefire between India and Pakistan, Jahangir Ashraf Qazi argues “whether this ceasefire will last will be clearer in the days ahead and, from Pakistan’s point of view, it will depend on the ground and human rights situation in Indian-held Kashmir.”
 


"If PDM succeeds in removing this govt, no govt will be strong enough to stabilise the political and economic situation...Lessons from the past should be kept in sight while taking political decisions that are more likely to result in a power vacuum and an instable governing arena which is in no one’s interest. This time history should not be allowed to repeat itself.."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'Is history repeating itself?'

 

 


Pakistan observes Aurat March across cities


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Pakistan observes Aurat March across cities
Jamaat-i-Islami calls for establishing a religious society 
 

On 8 March, Pakistan marked International Women’s Day with the Aurat March. Women from different walks of life gathered in different cities, demanding an end to patriarchy, toxic masculinity, and gender-based violence. The theme of the march for 2021 was “to highlight the burden faced by women amid the Covid-19 crisis” and highlight the wage disparity among men and women carrying out the same job in particular sectors. 

The women, and men who participated in the march, shouted slogans like “Continuing marginalisation of women means war.” One of the marchers said, “If you have to win my heart, you have to give up toxic masculinity. That’s all.”

Various unions organise rally
Under the banner of Aurat March, various unions and organisations took the opportunity to hold their own rallies. For example, in a rally organised by the Home-Based Women Workers Federation (HBWWF) and the National Trade Union Federation (NTUF), speakers reiterated that without having equal participation of women in decision making roles, development of society is impossible. 

Issues such as violence against women belonging to minority communities, forced conversions and the like were raised during the rally. They also pushed for equal work with wages that are raised in proportion with price hike, and asked for proper implementation of maternity leave. 

Representation of transgender people

The Aurat March also served as a platform to raise awareness about trans rights. For instance, tableaus representing transgender were dismissing the misplaced belief that transgender people are immoral. The message of the tableau said, “immoral are those who ridicule and make fun of their child.” (Oonib Azam, “Marchers mark International Women’s Day with demands for equality, end to violence,” The News International, 9 March 2021)

Jamaat-i-Islami participates in the march
In a strange turn of events setting the largely left-wing led rallies in the capital city of Islamabad, Jamaat-i-Islami organised a march too. The group called for setting up a religious society which would create an environment for women to exercise the rights guaranteed to them by Islam. (Kalbe Ali, “Women’s day rallies held amid strict govt guidelinesDawn, 9 March 2021)

 

PDM nominates Gilani for Senate chairman’s position
Government files petition seeking his disqualification 

Image Source: Dawn/The Express Tribune

On 8 March, the PDM announced that the alliance had nominated Yousuf Gilani as their candidate for the Senate Chairman’s position. The PDM warned the “establishment and the intelligence agencies” against any interference in the upcoming Senate chairman elections. The alliance said they would “bring all the facts before the nation if any such attempt is made.”

Opposition puts on hold nomination for deputy chairman
Meanwhile, sources told Dawn that the PDM had deferred from nominating a candidate for deputy chairman when Baloch parties in the alliance claimed their right to the position. (Amir Wasim, “Govt senators being approached to change loyalties: PM,” Dawn, 9 March 2021)

Government files petition seeking Gilani’s disqualification
On the same day, the government filed a petition in the Election Commission of Pakistan which sought the disqualification of Gilani. The government argued that he had won the Islamabad Senate seat through money. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Govt senators being approached to change loyalties: PM,” Dawn, 9 March 2021) 

Fazlur criticises PM
Reacting to the above development, Fazlur Rehman termed the government’s decision a “foolish step.” He asked, “If Mr Gilani’s election had been wrong, what bothered the prime minister to secure a fresh trust vote.” Fazlur said, Imran Khan calling a National Assembly session to conduct a vote of confidence was unconstitutional. (Muhammad Anis, “Senate chairman’s election: All facts will become public in case of foul play, says PDM,” The News International, 9 March 2021)

Meanwhile…
The Interior Minister said Imran knew that 17 PTI members were disloyal to the party. He said, “In this trade of selling their loyalties,”  13 of the 17 had taken money. Imran also said the “government Senators are being approached to gain their support for the opposition’s candidate in the upcoming election for Senate chairman.” (“‘17 PTI MPs disloyal, 13 took money’: Imran knows those who did not vote for him, says Sh Rashid,” The News International, 9 March 2021)

 

Khalilzad, Gen Scott Miller call on COAS
Discuss matters of mutual interest 

Image Source: The News International

On 8 March, US Special Representative for Afghanistan Reconciliation Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad and Commander Resolute Support Mission in Afghanistan General Austin Scott Miller called on Chief of Army Staff (COAS) General Qamar Javed Bajwa. During the meeting, issues of mutual interest, regional security and the ongoing Afghan reconciliation process were discussed. (“Khalilzad, Gen Scott Miller call on Gen Bajwa,” The News International, 9 February 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Five courts illegally built on private land, says SC 
On 9 March, Dawn reported that according to a testimony filed by the Islamabad High Court to the Supreme Court, five courts of Islamabad judiciary have been illegally constructed on private land. The letter came as a response to the SC’s directives in a football ground case. Further, the IHC chief justice ordered a forensic audit by the Auditor General of Pakistan (AGP) of the illegal construction of courts. (Malik Asad, “Five courts illegally built on private land, SC told,” Dawn, 9 February 2021)

Cases of violence against women in Pakistan doubled in the last six months of 2020, says report
On 8 March, Sustainable Social Development Organization (SSDO) released a report titled “Tracking Numbers: State of Violence Against Women and Children in Pakistan” in which it stated that the cases of violence against women and rape in Pakistan were doubled in the last six months of 2020 as compared to the first six months of the year.

Further, the report cites that the number of child abuse cases reported was three times more in the second half compared to the first half of 2020, adding that Punjab reported maximum cases of child abuse followed by Sindh and Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa. The report also pointed out the government's failure in preventing child abuses and violation against women. (Myra Imran, “Report on violence against women statistics in 2020 launched,” The News International, 9 February 2021)

Forcing an SNC will heed no benefits, says editorial 
An editorial in The News International, critical of the government’s rush to implement the Single National Curriculum says that the Ministry of Federal Education and Professional Training appears to be hasty despite there being some serious issues to ponder regarding the implementation of the SNC. Further, it says that forcing an SNC which does not have support from the opposition and education experts will lead to its cancellation by the next government. The editorial advised that a uniform system of education must aim at providing equitable opportunities to all children irrespective of their capacity, caste, colour, community and creed. (“Inadvisable SNC,” The News International, 9 February 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
"Women should have the right to choose what they wear," says editorial Swiss burqa ban
An editorial in Dawn critical of the ban on face-covering in Switzerland says that although concerns about violent extremism are genuine, in many situations such incidents become disguises of Islamophobia. The editorial says such moves do not help curb extremism rather they only help propel the agenda of far-right parties in Europe, who see Muslims, people of colour and racial minorities as ‘outsiders’ trying to change the continent’s ‘pure’ culture, adding that such moves would only deepen the divide between ethnic and religious majorities and minorities in Europe. Further, the editorial argues that women should have the right to choose what they wear, and not be compelled by the State to dress a certain way. (“Swiss ‘burqa ban’,” Dawn, 9 February 2021)

 



"The parliament in Pakistan has never played a role in nation-building, institution-building or formulating policies and in ensuring accountability...Last week’s election to the upper house or Senate of Pakistan was another blot on the so-called democratic institutions of the country."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'The Senate election that shamed Pakistan'

 


Editorials and Opinions reflect on International Women Day in Pakistan


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Editorials and Opinions reflect on International Women Day in Pakistan
Media reiterates legislation not the end of struggle against gender-based violence

 

On 8 March, on International Women’s Day, Pakistan is gearing up for the Aurat March which has been titled “Patriarchy ka Pandemic” (the pandemic of patriarchy). The first Aurat March was held in 2018 in Karachi and has spread to other cities over the years. 

Meanwhile, Pakistani media is giving their perspectives on Women’s Day in their opinions and editorials. Some of them entail the significance of the Aurat March, while others recognise the journey so far and say, there is still a long way to go. 

Aurat march provokes gatekeepers of honour and culture, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn highlights the evolution of the Aurat March, from starting as a representative platform for women; the Aurat March has now extended to  “Transpeople, Baloch women whose loved ones have been forcibly disappeared, internally displaced women, women from urban centres and rural areas.” The editorial says, every year, the march succeeds to “provoke the gatekeepers of honour and culture.”

Demands in 2021

This year, Aurat March demands state investment for rehabilitation of victims of gender-based violence and formation of sexual harassment committees in hospitals, clinics and the like. It says, it is time to reflect on how to implement women-friendly laws; while passing a legislation is one side of the battle, the other is to bring out societal change and address internalised misogyny. (“A celebration of women,” Dawn, 8 March 2021)

A march “for the right to live as an equal human being,” says opinion

An opinion in The News International says the Aurat March is for the right to say no, the right to nutritional equality, the right to education - “for the right to live as an equal human being.” The author blames the societal norms for gender-based discriminations and urges the society “to correct the mistakes of the past if possible and stand with those who are raising their voice for not any privilege but for their right.” (Dr Rizwan Saigol, “Understanding why women march,” The News International, 8 March 2021)

Aurat March a platform for the battle against patriarchy, says editorial
An editorial in The News International outlines that women’s activism has come a long way, cutting across borders, and is currently an element of  global conversation. The editorial, in the case of Pakistan, says “women have seen a mixed bag as far as their fight for rights goes.” It reiterates that women’s struggle for equality does not end by passing legislation. It, however, highlights that the increasing reach of the Aurat March provides a platform for women to take forward the battle against the inherent patriarchy in Pakistan. It concludes that “only with a spirit of inclusivity will the rights of all women in Pakistan will remain protected, across societal classes. (“Marching on,” The News International, 8 March 2021)

Opinion highlights political inequality as fundamental gender-based inequality
An opinion in Dawn says political inequality is a fundamental form of gender inequality in Pakistan. The author opines that even in the most basic act of political participation like voting, there is an element of political inequality. He cites that “Out of Pakistan’s nearly 106 million registered voters, only 44 per cent are women. That’s at least 6pc less than their actual proportion in the overall adult population.” Further, he highlights a difference in the electoral participation of women in urban spaces and rural areas. Contrary to the popular perception, “women’s electoral participation is between 8–10 per cent lower in big cities compared to rural areas.” 

Some of the reasons, he says, is gatekeeping by male members in the household who believe it is inappropriate for women to vote in general elections. Externally, political parties’ engagement with women is also restricted. Therefore, he calls for legislation and mobilisation to address the inequality. (Umair Javed, “Women and political inequality,” Dawn, 8 March 2021)

The Express Tribune and Dawn highlight misogynistic environment in journalism 
An opinion in The Express Tribune, keeping the Aurat March in focus, talks about the discrimination faced by women journalists. This includes threat of sexual violence, obscene slurs, which have the “the potential to incite violence and lead to hate crimes, putting the physical safety of the women journalists at risk.” Similarly, a special report by Dawn highlights that women journalists in Pakistan work in a misogynistic environment; they have to “hold onto spaces within male-dominated newsrooms and public places while fighting misinformation, deeply personal attacks and misogyny — both offline and online.” The Dawn report cites various examples of journalists who have been targeted by political parties, including the ruling party PTI. (Kamal Siqqiqui, “Aurat March and other worries,” The Express Tribune, 8 March 2021) (Sumaira Jajja, “DAWN Special Report: In the crossfire,” Dawn, 8 March 2021)

Meanwhile… 
Asif Zardari emphasised that the PPP is proud to have been led by a woman - Benazir Bhutto - and reiterated on the need to create an environment for women to come forward without feeling threatened. Similarly, Bilawal Bhutto said the PPP manifesto focuses on gender equality and empowerment of women. He said, “A nation that does not give women equality will not be able to compete with other nations.” (“World Women’s Day: ‘PPP takes pride a great woman led this party’,” The News International, 8 March 2021)

 

Senate chairman’s election
Govt and Opposition engage in meetings to secure support

Image Source: Dawn

On 7 March, a government delegation met Awami National Party (ANP) leadership at Wali Bagh to seek their support for the upcoming election of chairman Senate. At the meeting, the two sides expressed their interest to strengthen democracy and working for the welfare of the people. Further, the ANP leadership told the delegation that their party believed in the supremacy of democracy and parliament and their party was ready for cooperation with all the democratic forces for continuity and strengthening of democracy.

Bilawal meets with Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain and Ch Pervaiz Elahi
Similarly, PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari visited the residence of Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain and Ch Pervaiz Elahi in Lahore to seek their support for the election of Yusuf Raza Gilani as the Senate Chairman. (“Senate chairman’s election: Political manoeuvring at its peak,” The News International, 8 March 2021)

 

Terrorist killed in North Waziristan and Quetta operations 
Wanted BLA cell part of the deceased 

Image Source: Dawn

On 7 March, four terrorists were killed after security forces conducted two intelligence-based operations at Datakhel in North Waziristan tribal district and Zoida in South Waziristan tribal district. The ISPR stated that in an intense exchange of fire, terrorist commander belonging to the banned Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan’s Bismillah group, and terrorist commanders who were associated with the TTP Sajna group, were killed. (“Four terrorists killed in two operations, says ISPR,” Dawn, 8 March 2021)

In Quetta, around five terrorists of the Baloch Liberation Army were killed in Splinji, District Mastung, during an operation by the CTD Quetta. Further, the five were wanted for several attacks against labourers and personnel of the law enforcement agencies. (“Five wanted BLA terrorists killed in Mastung,” The News International, 8 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Speaker terms manhandling of PML-N leaders as “regrettable and condemnable”
On 8 March, National Assembly Speaker Asad Qaiser regretted the manhandling of the PML-N leaders by activists of the PTI outside the Parliament House. Terming the incident as “regrettable and condemnable” he stated that the incident will be thoroughly probed. Further, he stressed on adopting a culture of tolerance and patience in politics and urged the political leadership to play their role in this regard. (Amir Wasim, “Manhandling of PML-N leaders to be probed: Asad Qaiser,” Dawn, 8 March 2021)

Two PTI MNAs detained before the vote of confidence says, Maryam
On 7 March, PML-N vice president Maryam Nawaz stated “This is in our personal knowledge. Their [PTI’s] MNAs are in touch with us. Two MNAs who were not willing to vote for them [the government] till last moment were taken to a compound of an institution at Golra (Islamabad) and they were placed in a container for four hours. They were forced by the agencies’ people to vote for Imran Khan.” Further, she alleged that PM Imran Khan had managed the trust vote with the help of “secret agencies.” (“Two PTI MNAs detained to manage trust vote: Maryam,” Dawn, 8 March 2021)

47 incidents of violence against women were reported in Balochistan during 2020
On 7 March, the Director of the Aurat Foundation, Balochistan stated that there were around 47 incidents of violence against women were reported in Balochistan during 2020, of which 16 women lost their lives and seven were subjected to rape. Further, the investigation report for 2020 showed that overall, 2,297 incidents of different natures, including human rights violation, murders, women harassment, were reported in 25 districts of the province. (Saleem Shahid, “Balochistan reports 47 incidents of violence against women in 2020,” Dawn, 8 March 2021) 

PDM to work on two-pronged strategy to challenge PTI
On 8 March, The News International reported that the PDM is working on a two-pronged strategy to challenge the PTI in Punjab. The two strategies include, first, offering Chauhdry Pervaiz Elahi the slot of chief minister or second, capitalizing on the already managed around 18 members of the ruling party. (Ali Raza, “To turn tables on PTI in Punjab: PDM working on two-pronged strategy,” The News International, 8 March 2021)

Saraiki Culture Day celebrated in Lahore
On 7 March, a cultural show based on Saraiki Culture was held in Lahore. On the occasion, Provincial Minister for Culture said, “We are all gathered to celebrate Saraiki Culture Day, which is very stunning and colorful. It is a day of happiness, and in Punjab, we are determined to celebrate all the days with full zeal and zest, and this trend will continue.” Further, the programme included national anthem, narration about Saraiki culture, Dharees dance by Jampuri Party, singing performance by famous singer Rahat Multanikar, performance by Kafi singer Memoona Sajid, folk song by Jamil Parwana, performance by Cholistani singer Aado Bhagat and Sanam Sheikh. (“Saraiki Culture Day celebrated,” The News International, 8 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                              
Maleeha Lodhi in her opinion in Dawn on the Season of political challenges says, pore political tests loom for the government which could be consequential.

An editorial in The Express Tribune on securing the vaccine argues that officials need to stop playing the ‘poor card’ and put their money where their mouth is for the benefit of the nation. 
 



"In parliamentary politics nothing can ever be taken for granted. The election of the Senate chairman and deputy chairman is the next political test that looms for the government. But its toughest and most consequential test could come in the Punjab Assembly if the opposition decides to move a no-confidence motion there. That could yet be a game changer."
-An opinion in Dawn by Maleeha Lodhi on 'Season of political challenges'

 


Imran secures vote of confidence in National Assembly


Photo: The Express Tribune



PR Editorial, 6 March 2021
The PSL heartbreak
An editorial in Pakistan Reader congratulating the return of the cricket super league also warned the need to keep the game away from controversies. And that is precisely what the PSL has got into now, with the leagues games postponed due to more players testing positive for COVID-19.

Pakistan is witnessing a second COVID wave during recent weeks. But, that should not be the reason for players contracting the virus. The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) should have taken enough measures in advance to ensure, that the game and the environment is sanitized, rules are framed and that the restrictions are strictly imposed.

To be fair to the PCB, it has got the rules framed and created a playbook on dos and donts. A bio-bubble was put in place in paper, and the leagues and players are to adhere to it. Based on initial reports, it appears everything went wrong. Too many matches in the same venues (all matches in the first league) were scheduled in Karachi. The leagues hosted the players in hotels, where it is reported multiple marriages were taking place. Imagine the South Asian marriages in hotels and the nature of interactions! One can only fathom how many of them were wearing masks and practising social distance. In other words, players in these hotels should have been sitting ducks.

On the other hand, the players should have also exercised caution. There could be many writings in perspective emphasising “if only.”

This is a great loss and a huge disappointment. Cricket was finally returning to Pakistan. International players were returning to Pakistan. The crowd was returning to the stadium. Given the importance of cricket in South Asia, it should be as if life is returning! The PCB should have ensured the smooth conduct of the PSL. It should take responsibility. But, it won't, and find somebody else to blame. It would constitution a commission, whose report will never see the light of the day. Even if it is, no one is going to be held responsible.

 

In Focus
Imran secures vote of confidence in National Assembly
PDM boycotts trust vote, says it will not have political importance

On 6 March (today), Prime Minister Imran Khan won the vote of confidence in the National Assembly securing 178 votes, six more than the required 172 votes. Imran thanked NA members and especially his allies. He said, “Yesterday evening when I saw you, I realised that you were really hurt when we lost the Senate election of Hafeez Shaikh...But when I saw you, I felt very good because I saw a team in you and our team will get stronger.” Further, the NA Speaker remarked that Imran had won 176 votes in 2018 when he was voted leader of the House and today he won 178. (“PM Imran addresses National Assembly after securing trust vote,” Dawn, 6 March 2021)

PML-N, PTI workers clash ahead of NA session
Prior to the NA session, PML-N members and PTI members clashed outside the Parliament House. In the clash, a shoe was thrown at Ahsan Iqbal, a former minister, while he was shouting slogans against the government. Further, PML-N leaders were surrounded by PTI supporters and the situation worsened as the opposing groups started manhandling each other. ("Video: Shoe thrown at Ahsan Iqbal outside National Assembly," The News International, 6 March 2021)

PDM boycotts vote of confidence
On 5 March, the PDM announced their boycott of the trust vote in the NA. The PDM Chief, Fazlur Rehman, said Imran was calling the vote of confidence session in the NA because he had already "lost the trust of the majority." He referred to Imran’s address to the nation and said the PM himself called some of his party members “salable commodities.” He said, “Vote of no-confidence has already been given in the shape of Senate elections... in the victory of Yousuf Raza Gilani.” (“PDM boycotts NA session called for PM Imran’s vote of confidence,” The Express Tribune, 5 March 2021)

Fazlur to Imran’s remarks that he would bring the people out against the opposition if he lost the vote of confidence; he asked, “Whom will you bring the people out against? Against the PDM? Why? On what grounds?” He also alleged that the PTI was in power with a fake majority until now and this would be reflected in the "one-sided" vote of confidence as well as none of the opposition leaders would be present. Therefore, the motion will not have any political importance, he said. (“Opposition to boycott NA session on PM Imran's vote of confidence: Fazl,” Dawn, 5 March 2021)

Opposition should have attended trust vote session to mark its protest, opines editorial 
An editorial in Dawn says Imran’s decision to seek a vote of confidence is bizarre and is “an indication of mistrust” after the government lost the Senate seat in Islamabad. The editorial reiterates that “there are people in his party who defected and voted for his rivals will not change.” It suggests that the no-confidence motion should have been left to the opposition. It highlights that the government and opposition do not seem to be backing down; therefore, “It would have been better if the opposition had attended the session and recorded its protest, as parliament is the right forum for this discussion.” (“Vote of confidence,” Dawn, 6 March 2021)

 

COAS visits Zarb-e-Hadeed exercise area
Troops display professionalism and synergy

Image Source: Dawn

On 5 March, COAS General Qamar Bajwa visited the Zarb-e-Hadeed training area in Cholistan Desert. The exercise will last for two weeks and will focus on improving “operational preparedness of formations by creating synergy among the infantry, mechanised forces, combat aviation, surveillance platforms, army air defence, and artillery.” 

Gen Bajwa appreciates dedication and professionalism
The ISPR statement said, General Bajwa was impressed by the degree of professionalism and dedication displayed by the troops. Further, “Gen Bajwa expressed complete satisfaction over combat readiness and training standards of Bahawalpur Corps.” He said this would improve the “operational capability for effective response to all threats and challenges.” (“COAS visits exercise area in Cholistan, lauds troop performance,” Dawn, 6 March 2021) (“In Cholistan Desert visit, COAS says excellent training enhances capability to respond to threats,” The News International, 5 March 2021)

 

Maritime Affairs Minister announces formation of committee to resolve Gwadar Port issues
Says ‘Great news about Gwadar Port soon’

Image Source: Dawn

On 5 March, the Federal Minister for Maritime Affairs Ali Haider Zaidi announced that an advisory committee will be formed to resolve issues related to demurrage at ports and other related problems. He also expressed hope that the committee would play a vital role in resolving the issues faced by the business community at ports of the country. Further, he stated that the ministry was facing multiple problems and was trying its best to resolve them, adding, “We will give great news to the nation about Gwadar Port very soon.”

Visits Lahore Chamber of Commerce and Industry
The minister also visited the Lahore Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCI), where he said the body would consist of representatives of business chambers, the maritime affairs ministry and relevant departments. Further, he also announced another visit to the LCCI along with the Karachi Port Trust chairman and Port Qasim Authority chairman to resolve the issues facing the business community. (“‘Great news about Gwadar Port soon’,” The Express Tribune, 6 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
An ATC granted bail to six lawyers in the IHC case
On 5 March, an anti-terrorism court (ATC) granted bail to six lawyers in the Islamabad High Court attack case. According to The News International, the report stated that the ATC granted bail to Sardar Najam Abbas, Irfan Chaudhry, Advocate Khizar, Advocate Umar, Advocate Shoaib and Advocate Afshan, while each of them was ordered to submit a bond of Rs50,000. (“Bail granted to 6 more lawyers in IHC attack case,” The News International, 6 March 2021)

ECONOMY
Govt to introduce Income Tax Amendment Bill to meet IMF conditions
On 5 March, PM Imran Khan approved the introduction of a Money Bill in the National Assembly next week to withdraw 80 income tax exemptions and reform the tax laws. The bill is being introduced to meet a prior action for the revival of USD 6 billion IMF programme. The Income Tax (Second Amendment) Bill 2021 would seek to streamline the tax regime for non-profit organisations, listing of firms in the stock market, exemptions for oil refineries, special economic zones (SEZs) being set up under the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor and the Independent Power Producers (IPPs). (Shahbaz Rana, “PM approves withdrawal of 80 income tax exemptions,” The Express Tribune, 6 March 2021)

Pakistan, IMF agree to lower FBR’s tax collection target to Rs246 billion
On 6 March, Pakistan and the IMF agreed to revise downward the annual tax collection target of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to revive the stalled extended fund facility (EFF) programme. The tax collection target is said to be lowered by Rs246 billion, from Rs4,963 billion to Rs4,717 billion, for the current fiscal year, 2020-21. Further, the two sides also agreed to the revival of the programme. (Mehtab Haider, “Pakistan, IMF agree to lower FBR’s tax collection target,” The News International, 6 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Pakistan has substantial leverage to cooperate with Biden’s team, says opinion
An opinion in The Express Tribune says that Pakistan has substantial leverage to cooperate with Biden’s team, especially in areas of convergence, such as countering terrorism and violent extremism, engagement with Afghanistan, China, Russia and the Middle East and other areas. For this, the opinion says that Pakistan needs to analyse the possible scenarios emerging out of a change in the White House and push its intellectual community and Pakistani diaspora in the US to maintain a balanced policy. (Adeela Naureen/Umar Waqar, “Biden’s national security strategic guidance — an analysis,” The Express Tribune, 6 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                               

Fahd Husain in his opinion in Dawn, Counting the cost of compromise, list five reasons why the PTI has frittered away its political, perceptional and populist capital in the last four weeks.

An opinion in Dawn argues that the current system of allocation of cases in Pakistan has grave implications for the right to a fair trial, judicial independence and the rule of law.



Instead of focusing his energy on a show of bravado, Mr Khan ought to reflect on the future of legislative business. The way to prove his strength in parliament is by getting bills passed — something that has proved to
be a challenge time and again."
-An editorial in Dawn on the vote of confidence

 


ECP to meet to discuss PM’s remarks against the body


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 5 March 2021
Senate Elections: Good, Bad and Ugly
Finally, the much-expected elections to the Senate got over. Except for a couple of shocks, especially for the PTI, the results were more or less on the expected lines.

First, the good. The mode of Senate elections, after so much debate, resistance from the Opposition, Presidential reference to the Supreme Court and an Ordinance - everything fell in place just a day before the elections. The Supreme Court made it clear that the elections to the Senate would be considered as a part of Article 226 of the Constitution, hence the secret ballot would apply. The Election Commission on the eve of the election announced, that it would hold the elections accordingly. Hence, the elections were held according to the schedule. The opinion by the Supreme Court and the Election Commission’s conduct (not only in the Senate elections but also in the NA-75 by-poll) should highlight the strength of the institutions. This is a welcome development.

Second, the bad. Though there were not much of drastic changes to what was expected, there were a few upsets. Mostly for the PTI. Even after the elections, and becoming the single largest party in the Senate, the PTI and its allies do not have the majority in the Senate. Of the 100 seats in the Senate, now the PTI has 26, followed by BAP (12) and MQM-P (3). With other parties including the PML-Q and independents, the PTI’s coalition tally is only 47. On the other hand, though the PML-N does not have the majority now, with 18 seats of its own, and PPP’s 20, the Opposition has 53 seats. More than the PTI, the PDM has much to cheer about the Senate elections. What hurts the most for the PTI is its failure to get its finance minister Abdul Hafeez Sheikh elected vis-à-vis the Yousuf Raza Gilani of the PPP from the Islamabad Capital Territory seats. Clearly, some from the PTI have not voted for Hafeez. So, the PTI has a reason to be upset. However, it has to look inwards and see why some of its members voted against the party high command.

Third, the ugly. Whether in Islamabad or Karachi (and even in Peshawar), there are PTI MNAs and MPAs who are unhappy with how the party is moving forward. The party loyalists vs special appointees debate is denting the party. Imran Khan has to understand. Blaming the Election Commission of Pakistan, as he did after the Senate elections, is not the way to move forward. He needs to strengthen the institutions and not criticise them for the internal divide within the PTI. The Election Commission’s latest statement (“Do not sling mud at us”) against the PM’s outburst (“protecting those who made money by holding the Senate elections through secret ballot”) says a lot.

 

In Focus
ECP to meet to discuss PM’s remarks against the body
You protected criminals through secret ballot, Imran tells ECP 

On 5 March (today), the Election Commission of Pakistan will meet “to discuss Prime Minister Imran Khan’s tirade against the electoral body,” said Dawn’s source. The Chief Election Commissioner will be present at the meeting. 

ECP followed laws, says senior official
A senior official in the ECP reiterated the ECP’s commitment to the law, which currently provides for a secret ballot system for the Senate elections. He said, “The Government should amend the constitution, if it wants open voting for Senate elections, but should not expect from the Comm­ission to do the job of legislature.” (“Crucial ECP meeting on Imran’s tirade today,” Dawn, 5 March 2021)

ECP protected criminals and damaged democracy, says Imran
On 4 March, in his address to the nation, Imran Khan said the ECP opposed his suggestion of an open ballot despite the SC’s advice to the ECP to hold “honest and transparent elections.” He emphasised that “the SC also gave an opportunity to the ECP to conduct the elections through secret ballot but have the ballot be identifiable.” He said if this had been the case, then the PTI would have been able to identify “who were sold” from the party. 

He told the ECP, “You protected these criminals through secret ballot, you have damaged our democracy.” He asked why the ECP did not investigate the 2018 bribery video which surfaced recently. In this context, he asked, “When you were given the opportunity by the SC then what was the reason that you couldn't do barcoding on 1,500 ballots?...You gave a complete opportunity to discredit the country's democracy [and] damaged the country's morality and values.” (“ECP protected those who made money by holding Senate elections through secret ballot: PM Imran,” Dawn, 5 March 2021)

Meanwhile…
On the same day, Maryam Nawaz said since Imran has alleged that his party members had sold their vote, he should “tell the names of those MNAs and remove them from the parliament.” She added, “With what face will you (PM) seek vote of confidence from those who, according to you, are available for sale.” Similarly, Bilawal said, "Imran Khan's choice of words shows that he is nervous now." (Amir Wasim, “PDM dares Imran to identify MNAs who ‘sold votes’,” Dawn, 5 March 2021) (“PDM leaders predict doom for PM Imran,” The Express Tribune, 5 March 2021)

 

Imran meets COAS, ISI Chief 
Meeting with PM at this juncture sends out wrong signals, says Maryam

Image Source: Dawn

On 4 March, Imran Khan met with COAS General Qamar Bajwa and the ISI Chief Lt Gen Faiz Hameed. While no official statement was released, an official told Dawn that they discussed “internal and external situation.” 

Maryam criticises meeting
Following this development, Maryam Nawaz said the COAS and DG ISI should not have met the PM; she said, “the meeting at this juncture does not send out good visuals.” She urged the “institutions” to stop backing Imran and “restrict themselves to the constitutional and lawful role.”

Meanwhile…
Speculations have arisen over the meeting as it was held right after the Senate elections and Yousuf Gilani’s win over Hafeez Shaikh in Islamabad. (“COAS, ISI chief call on PM,” Dawn, 5 March 2021)

 

Covid-19 cases rise by 30 per cent in one week
Govt plans tackle the Covid-19 through herd immunity and donated vaccines

Image Source: Dawn

On 5 March, Dawn reported that since the announcement of relaxation in restrictions by the National Command and Operation Centre (NCOC) in February, the number of Covid-19 cases has gone up by around 30 per cent. In response, the Pakistan Medical Association (PMA has urged the government to immediately impose the restrictions to avoid chances of a third wave of the virus. (Ikram Junaidi “Alarm as Covid cases rise by 30pc in a week,” Dawn, 5 March 2021)

Govt has no plan to buy vaccines for this year, says PAC
On 4 March, the National Health Service (NHS) Secretary while briefing the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) stated that the government aims to tackle the Covid-19 health challenge through herd immunity and donated vaccines as it has no plan to buy vaccines at least during the current year. (“Govt has no plan to buy vaccines anytime soon, PAC told,” Dawn, 5 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Sialkot DC, DPO suspended for negligence during NA-75 polls
On 4 March, the Establishment Division suspended the Sialkot deputy commissioner (DC) and the district police officer (DPO) over negligence in maintaining order during the NA-75 by-election. They have been put under suspension until further orders. This comes after the Election Commission of Pakistan ordered the Establishment Division to suspend the two officials. (Malik Asad, “Establishment Division suspends Sialkot DC, DPO,” Dawn, 5 March 2021)

ECONOMY
IMF identifies 44 entities for privatisation
On 4 March, according to a report released by the Ministry of Finance, the International Monetary Fund (IMF)-backed first review of Pakistan’s public sector enterprises has identified 44 entities for privatisation, including the power companies that are causing big losses, despite a 50 per cent reduction in losses in the first year of the current government. This comes as a review of 84 commercial state-owned enterprises (SOEs) was completed as part of the structural benchmarks set by the IMF and supported by the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank (ADB). (Shahbaz Rana, “Govt to privatise 44 entities by 2025,” The Express Tribune, 5 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
FO defends LoC ceasefire agreement with India
On 4 March, the Foreign Office Spokesperson denied the perception that the recent agreement between Pakistan and India to strictly observe the ceasefire along the Line of Control (LoC) would only benefit India. The spokesperson said, “The agreement will help save Kashmiris’ lives and alleviate the suffering of those living along the LoC,” adding, “We have also maintained that escalation along the LOC is a threat to regional peace and security. The recent development is very much in line with Pakistan’s consistent position.” The FO made these statement in response to Kashmiri leader Ali Geelani’s concerns over the ceasefire agreement. (Kamran Yousaf, “Pakistan defends LoC truce with India,” The Express Tribune, 5 March 2021)

ON GILGIT-BALTISTAN 
GB govt forms parliamentary panel formed for reforms
On 4 March, the Gilgit-Baltistan government formed a seven-member parliamentary committee to make recommendations for the proposed constitutional and administrative reforms in the region. The committee is to consult with leaders of all parliamentary parties in GB and to gather confidence in bringing administrative and political reforms in the region and formulate a joint mechanism. (“Parliamentary panel formed for GB reforms,” Dawn, 5 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                      

An editorial in The Express Tribune, outlining the threat of the melting glaciers, says with millions of people at the mercy of prayers and thousands unaware of the looming threat, the Government of Pakistan and the UNDP need to work together to protect and empower local communities.

Similarly, an editorial in Dawn says, the government must develop a comprehensive framework linking its mitigation efforts to its industrial, agricultural, energy-related and other policies and enforce it in letter and spirit to reverse the impact of fast-changing climatic conditions.

Najam Sethi in his editorial in The Friday Times says that Imran Khan’s dismal performance has left the Miltablishment gasping for breath to salvage its pride and credibility after Nawaz Sharif’s stinging attacks on its leadership… It is to Nawaz Sharif’s credit that he has pushed the Miltablishment back to the wings and to Asif Zardari’s for pulling it to the drawing board again.

 



"The PSL is not just a cricket festival for Pakistan, it means much more than that for the whole nation. The PCB should have done everything to keep it safe from the coronavirus onslaught. But the genome has played the spoilsport with the greatest cricket gala in the country — yet again.."
-An editorial in The Express Tribune
on 'Covid blow to PSL'

 


Senate elections conclude, Imran to seek vote of confidence


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Senate elections conclude, Imran to seek vote of confidence
Opposition secures 53 seats, PTI-led alliance 47

On 4 March, PTI secured 18 seats in the Senate, including the five it had won in Punjab previously. The PPP meanwhile secured eight new seats and the PML-N has five seats which it had earlier secured unopposed in Punjab. From the PPP, eight had retired and from the PML-N, 17. Further, The Balochistan Awami Party, an ally of the PTI, won six seats against the three who retired. Totally, the opposition together has 53 seats in the Senate and the PTI-led alliance has 47. 

Gilani bags hotly contested seat, opposition asks Imran to resign
Meanwhile, in what was perceived as the hottest contest between Hafeez Shaikh and Yousuf Gilani for the Senator seat in Islamabad, Gilani won the seat with 169 votes against Shaikh who won 164 votes. Gilani’s win comes despite a controversy over a video involving his son who was seen explaining to PTI MNAs how to cancel their votes. Though the government urged the Election Commission of Pakistan to disqualify Gilani, no action was taken. Gilani said, "This win is a win for democracy." Bilawal Bhutto said, “Democracy is the best revenge…”(“PTI makes substantial gains in Senate but suffers major setback in lslamabad,” Dawn, 4 March 2021)

On the same day, the opposition alliance referred to Shaikh’s loss and asked Imran Khan “to resign in an honourable way.” Shehbaz Sharif expressed that “Gilani’s victory was the expression of a no-confidence by lawmakers in Imran Khan’s government.” Similarly, the PML-N Secretary General said, “Imran Khan was a selected prime minister and now he has become a rejected prime minister.”(“Opposition asks PM to resign with honour,” Dawn, 4 March 2021)

Imran to seek vote of confidence
Foreign Minister Qureshi said the ECP had failed to implement transparent elections. In this context, he said Imran Khan would seek a vote of confidence. Further, questions were raised within PTI regarding the votes for Shaikh and the party’ candidate, Fozia Arshad for Islamabad women seat. The News International explains that Shaikh lost by 16 votes and though Fozia managed to win, she secured 10 less votes than the reciprocal strength of the party and allies, which is 180. 

Gilani, on the other hand, secured “169 votes, nine more votes than the total number of total MPs with the opposition alliance.” There are speculations that there is an internal divide within the PTI and party workers were unhappy with Shaikh being chosen as candidate. (“Imran to seek trust vote: Political setback for govt,” The News International, 4 March 2021) (“Who dissented in the ruling coalition?,” The News International, 4 March 2021)

 

Pakistan witnesses second-highest COVID-19 deaths in single day
Number of active, hospitalised cases falls

Image Source: Dawn

On 4 March, Dawn reported that Pakistan had recorded 75 COVID-19 deaths in a single day, the second-highest figure so far. The highest number of deaths were recorded on December 21, 2020 with 78 people succumbing to the virus. Dawn accessed a document of the National Command and Operation Centre (NCOC), which said, “the death figure of over 75 has been reported only two times since July 6, 2020.” 

Number of active cases come down
Meanwhile, the NCOC data showed that the number of active cases had come down to 16,648 as of 3 March. This is in contrast to over 50,000 cases in December 2020. Further, since February, the number of hospitalised COVID-19 patients stands at less than 2000. However, test positivity rate slightly increased from 3.3 per cent on February 22 to 4.21 per cent on 3 March. (Ikram Junaidi, “Pakistan sees over 75 Covid deaths in single day after three months,” Dawn, 4 March 2021)

 

Anti-terrorism court indicted suspects in the motorway gang-rape case
Suspects plead not guilty

Image Source: Dawn

On 3 March, an anti-terrorism court indicted two suspects in the motorway gang-rape case. The two suspects pleaded not guilty while the judge directed the prosecution to present its witnesses. Further, the court also recorded statements of 10 prosecution witnesses. A special team of prosecutors produced the witnesses who recorded their statements before the judge adjourned the hearing till 4 March (today). Further, around 53 prosecution witnesses had been enlisted in the investigation report with the investigation officer claiming that the suspects had confessed to their crime.

Previously…
The Gujjarpura police lodged the first information report under sections 376, 392 and 427 of the Pakistan Penal Code and Section 7 of the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997. (“Motorway gang-rape suspects indicted,” Dawn, 4 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Bahawalpur Corps troops practising drills as part of Zarb-e-Hadeed
On 4 March, Troops of Bahawalpur Corps troop are set to take part in the practising drills and procedures as part of the annual winter collective training exercise “Zarb-e-Hadeed.” Exercise is aimed at enhancing operational preparedness, synergy amongst various components of forces. Further, the ISPR stated, “the exercise area covers a vast expanse of desert and plains, where the participating units are rehearsing various response measures under testing weather conditions, challenging terrain and actual battlefield environment.” (“Bahawalpur Corps troops practicing drills as part of Zarb-e-Hadeed: ISPR,” The Express Tribune, 4 March 2021)

IHC orders removal of Durrani's from ECL 
On 4 March, the Islamabad High Court (IHC) ordered to remove the name of the former chief of the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) Lt Gen (retd) Asad Durrani from the Exit Control List (ECL). According to Justice Athar Minallah, Durrani has the same rights as any other citizen of the country and stated that the federal government does not have the powers to put anyone’s name in the ECL. (“IHC orders removal of Asad Durrani's name from ECL,” The Express Tribune, 4 March 2021)

ECONOMY
73-paisa gain pushed Rupee to the highest level against dollar in FY21
On 3 March, the 73-paisa gain pushed the rupee to its highest level during the current fiscal year against the US dollar at Rs157.12 in the interbank market. Currency dealers attributed the strengthening of the rupee to the low demand due to the increase in the inflows into the banking system. Further, the local currency has so far recovered 6.8 per cent in 2020-21 against the greenback on the back of higher inflows and slow demand for US dollars. (“Rupee hits highest level against dollar in FY21,” Dawn, 4 March 2021)

EXTERNAL
Qatari land forces commander meets with COAS
On 3 March, the Qatari land forces commander Maj Gen Saeed Hassen Mohammad Al-Khayareen met with COAS Gen Qamar Bajwa. According to the ISPR, “Visiting dignitary appreciated Pakistan Army’s sincere efforts for regional peace and reiterated that Pakistan and Qatar share brotherly relations which over a period of time are transforming into mutually beneficial ties.” Further, the COAS told the commander that Pakistan Army greatly valued its “brotherly relations” with Qatar, “its time-tested friend.” (“Ties with Qatar, Afghan peace discussed,” Dawn, 4 March 2021)

PM to open the 14th ECO Summit virtually
On 4 March, PM Imran Khan is said to open the 14th Economic Cooperation Organization (ECO) virtual Summit. PM Khan would be opening the session in Pakistan’s capacity as the Chair of the 13th Summit; however, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan will Chair the 14th Summit. Further, the theme of the Summit is “Regional Economic Cooperation in the Aftermath of Covid-19.” (“PM to open 14th ECO Summit virtually today,” Dawn, 4 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                 

I A Rehman in Dawn argues that the run-up to yesterday’s Senate elections showed that nothing has changed in the country’s politics except for an increase in reliance on violence.

An opinion in The Express Tribune highlighting the voting secrecy and internal political party democracy says that internal democracy in almost all leading political parties of Pakistan does not exist.

 


"University campuses must be avenues for the intellectual and ideological grooming of young men and women to allow them to be part of a vibrant political discourse...The authorities, instead of suppressing the voices of young people, should listen to them. Dissent only grows when voices are silenced."
-An editorial in Dawn on 'Students’ protest'
in Karachi and Hyderabad

 

 


Polls underway for 37 Senate seats


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Polls underway for 37 Senate seats
Friction between Gilani and Shaikh increases 

On 3 March (today), Pakistan is conducting its Senate elections for 37 seats. The 37 will be elected from Balochistan, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Islamabad. Sindh assembly will elect 11 Senators while Balochistan and KP will elect 12 each. In Islamabad, two will be elected by the National Assembly. 

Previously, on 26 February, 11 Senators had already been elected unopposed “after disqualification or withdrawal of papers by other contestants.” At the time, PTI and PML-N secured five seats each and PTI’s ally, PML-Q secured one seat. (Amjad Mahmood, “All Senate candidates from Punjab elected unopposed,” Dawn, 26 February 2021)

Government, opposition optimistic about results
On 3 March, the Minister for Science and Technology expressed confidence that the PTI will emerge victorious in the Senate elections. He predicted that Minister for Finance Hafeez Shaikh will win "more than 180 votes" and the opposition parties combined would secure around 155 votes. Similarly, other Cabinet Ministers also expressed their hopes on the outcome of the elections. 

Meanwhile, Bilawal Bhutto said the government is worried that it is losing. This, he said, was evident when the government allegedly attempted “to delay the election the night before” and tried to “disqualify the opposition's candidates.” (Nadir Guramani, “Govt, opposition express optimism over chances of success in Senate polls,” Dawn, 3 March 2021)

Political temperatures rise
Hafeez Shaikh and Yousuf Gilani are competing against each other and this is seen as the “hottest contest.” Dawn reports that the race between the two became controversial after “a video of Gilani's son, Ali Haider, explaining to lawmakers how to cancel their votes” was circulated. Reacting to this, the government called on the Election Commission of Pakistan to declare Gilani as ineligible and also “filed a reference with the ECP seeking Gilani's disqualification for being involved in ‘corrupt practices’.” (“High-stakes polling for 37 Senate seats underway,” Dawn, 3 March 2021)

 

Justice Isa to argue in his own review petition
“I am not waging a war for myself but also my institution,” says judge

Image Source: Dawn

On 2 March, the Supreme Court approved Justice Isa to argue in his own review petition. The SC bench made the decision after Justice Isa’s counsel Munir A Malik said he could not be present due to his health conditions. 

On this, Justice Isa further requested for live coverage of the proceedings during the review petition. However, Justice Bandial who headed the bench declined the suggestion citing logistical issues and also said, “It’s not a judicial but administrative and police matter.” However, he said the matter could be presented before a full court. 

Already been subjected to humiliation, says Justice Isa
Justice Isa said he would prefer explaining the background of the case during the review petition if there is a new judge on the bench. He justified his stance claiming that “he and his family had already been subjected to humiliation.” He also added that “an organized ridiculous campaign had been launched against them and the whole world had witnessed it.” 

He also said the propaganda against him and his family had been carried out through official channels, and emphasised, “I am not waging a war for myself but also my institution." (“SC allows Justice Isa to argue in his review petition,” The News International, 3 March 2021)

 

Pakistan to receive free vaccines through Covax
Will receive more than 10 million doses before June

Image Source: Dawn

On 2 March, the global vaccination scheme, Covax, announced that Pakistan will be among the biggest recipients of free vaccines through the scheme before June, along with countries like Nigeria, Brazil, Indonesia and Bangladesh. The scheme aims to deliver 14,640,000 doses of the vaccine to Pakistan. (“Pakistan to get 10m doses of vaccine under Covax,” Dawn, 3 March 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
COAS calls for vigilance against hostile attempts to back-pedal operation gains
On 2 March, COAS Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa during his visit to the North and South Waziristan districts called for a need to remain vigilant against hostile attempts to reverse the gains of Operation Radd ul Fasaad. Further, he said, “Pakistan is committed to peace and stability in the region and playing its part by solidifying border security and capacity enhancement of FC/LEAs,” adding, “Peace has largely returned to these areas. The hard-earned normalcy will be retained and enhanced through the collective efforts of the local population, civil administration, and LEAs.” (“In Waziristan visit, army chief calls for vigilance against hostile attempts to back-pedal operation gains,” The News International, 3 March 2020)

SC orders CDA to remove illegal lawyers’ chambers within two months
On 2 March, the Supreme Court directed the Capital Development Authority (CDA) and the district administration of Islamabad to remove the lawyer's chambers and courtrooms that were illegally constructed on the football ground in F-8 within two months. Further, the Islamabad High Court (IHC) suspended the licences of 21 lawyers who stormed into the Chief Justice Block in February after the CDA demolished their illegal chambers. (Malik Asad, “SC directs CDA to remove illegal lawyers’ chambers, courtrooms,” Dawn, 3 March 2020)

ECONOMY
Private sector rises by 80 per cent in the first eight months of the current fiscal year
On 1 March, the State Bank of Pakistan’s latest data showed that the private sector borrowed Rs352 billion during the first eight months of FY21. This was 80.5 per cent higher than the borrowing of Rs195bn made during the same period in FY20. Although the government is apprehensive about the economic growth rate, the pace of borrowing from the private sector indicates economic activities are higher than they were in the previous fiscal year. (Shahid Iqbal, “Private sector borrowing rises by 80pc,” Dawn, 3 March 2020)

ON INDIA
Pakistani envoy asks the UN to conduct an impartial investigation into alleged human rights violations in Kashmir
On 2 March, Junaid Suleman, a second secretary in the Pakistan Mission to the UN in Geneva told the UNHRC “India has failed and will continue to fail in hiding its brutal repression of the Kashmiri people behind the self-serving smokescreen of terrorism.” Further, he added, “As Pakistan highlights India’s atrocities in Occupied Jammu & Kashmir, which have been well-documented by the office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, UN mandate holders (rights experts) and international NGOs, the Council has yet to hear any response from India - a country that claims to be the world’s largest democracy but has shamelessly violated every human rights principle, norms and laws.” (“Pakistan exposes India’s atrocities in IIOJK in verbal clash with India,” The Express Tribune, 3 March 2020)

 
Also read...                                                                                           

An editorial in Dawn critical of the vaccination challenged, says that with the government easing restrictions, the vaccination drive cannot afford to be sluggish rather the inoculation campaign need to rev up.

An opinion in The Express Tribune on ensuring durability of the peace process, says that unending Indian
antagonism leaves Pakistan with no other option but to get closer to China.

 


"The PDM appears much more confident despite the fact that it is lacking in numbers...Surely the stakes for the PTI are much higher; the defeat of a key member of the cabinet could prove far more consequential for the government. But it is equally important for the PDM to win the contest to keep itself united."
-An opinion in Dawn on the stake
for PTI and PDM in the Senate elections

 


Political temperatures rise as Senate elections close in


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 02 March 2021
On the eve of the Senate elections. The question of Secret ballot again, as the ECP confirms it
Tomorrow (3 March 2021), the Senate would have the elections for the retiring members. Never before the Senate elections got this much attention during the recent decades, as has been the case now.
 
Why is there so much anxiety in Pakistan for this Senate elections? First, the PTI wants to have a majority, and control the Senate. And there is a worry, if not fear, or both, that the Senate elections would witness some horse-trading, and it would not get the desired numbers. Any such development would also impact the intra-party equations within the PTI. Since winning the 2018 elections, the PTI leadership is perhaps facing a lot of questions from within – from KP to Punjab, where it has won a maximum number of seats of the national and provincial assemblies. Second, the Opposition under the PDM banner stands united; though there was an early expectation that the PDM would dissipate, it has not happened.
 
For the PTI, an open ballot would help the party control the outcome of Senate elections, so that there is no horse-trading. While in principle everyone would agree that the elections should be transparent, the PTI went about in a circular way. It asked the Supreme Court through a Presidential reference, and in between passed an ordinance on the subject. The issue should have been discussed in the Parliament, and an amendment made through political consensus.
 
Following the Supreme Court’s “opinion” yesterday, the Election Commission has announced that it would be held through a secret ballot. The ECP is standing up; while the PTI would have preferred a strong and neutral ECP while in opposition, as a ruling party, it does not. Unfortunately, for the PTI, the ECP has taken a position.
 
So, it would be a secret ballot for the Senate elections. Given the numbers, PTI should get the majority, if it could keep its flock together. The second one is a bigger issue for the PTI, than the PDM.

 

In Focus
Political temperatures rise as Senate elections close in
Editorial calls for discussion in Parliament on voting system for Senate elections

On 1 March, Imran Khan held an emergency meeting with National Assembly members of the PTI. According to Dawn’s sources, the MNAs requested Imran for development funds for their constituencies. Similarly, the Finance Minister, who is running against Yousuf Gilani, “went door to door to meet members of the National Assembly in the Parliament Lodges.” (Syed Irfan Raza, “PM holds back-to-back meetings with lawmakers,” Dawn, 2 March 2021)

PTI experiencing fallouts within party in Sindh, hints insider
On 2 March,  three PTI MPs in Sindh announced their decision to not vote for the PTI. After this, an insider told the media house that the PTI could not contact “three more MPAs, including a lawmaker elected on a minority seat.” In this context, the PTI called on its MPs at a hotel on 2 March (today) “from where they would be taken together to cast vote in the Sindh Assembly to avoid any ‘poaching of its votes’.” 

Meanwhile, the party has accused the PPP of pressurising the PTI MPs through the Sindh Police using tactics such as filing baseless cases against them. (Zia Ur Rehman, “PTI bracing for upheavals in Sindh Senate polls,” The News International, 2 March 2021)

Previously…
On 1 March, the Supreme Court, in response to the presidential reference on Senate elections, said the polling has to be carried out through a secret ballot. However, the SC said secrecy is not final and the change in election process can be passed through a constitutional amendment. It asked the ECP to ensure a transparent election process with the use of technology. The government and the opposition appreciated the Court’s opinion. Maryam said the Constitution was above “the ‘conspiratorial’ ordinances and ‘ill-intentioned’ references.” Similarly, the PPP called it “the triumph of law, justice and Constitutionalism.” Meanwhile, a government delegation pledged to support the ECP in its process and called the SC opinion a validation of the PTI stance and a step “forward against the environment of corruption with regard to the Senate polls.” (“Govt, opposition hail SC’s opinion,” The News International, 2 March 2021) (Iftikhar A Khan, “Apex court ruling vindicates our stance: govt, opposition,” Dawn, 2 March 2021) (Nasir Iqbal, “Senate polls be held through secret ballot, rules SC,” Dawn, 2 March 2021) On the same day, the ECP called on the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) “for consultation on the use of technology in the Senate elections to ensure transparency.” The ECP is expected to draw out a strategy on 2 March (today). (“ECP ropes in FIA for technology use in Senate polls,” The News International, 2 March 2021)

Controversy over Senate elections’ could have been avoided, suggests editorial
An editorial in Dawn says the Court should not have burdened itself with controversies like the above. It opines that the Parliament could have averted this by perhaps amending the Constitution if it deemed it necessary. It urges political parties to now come forward and discuss the issue. This could help introduce electoral reforms before the next Senate elections. (“SC on Senate polls,” Dawn, 2 March 2021)

Senate elections
Elections will be held for 48 seats in the Senate: “12 each from KP and Balochistan, 11 each from Punjab and Sindh and two from Islamabad.” The four provinces will elect “seven members on general seats, two women and two technocrats.” Further, KP and Balochistan will elect one person each for a minority seat. (Amir Wasim, “PTI to emerge as largest party in a hung Senate,” Dawn, 1 February 2021)

 

Pakistan gears up to fulfill remaining FATF conditions 
Pakistan received international recognition, says FMU 

Image Source: Dawn

On 1 March, the Federal Minister for Finance and Revenue met with the National Executive Committee on anti-money laundering. He asked the Financial Monitoring Unit (FMU) and FATF Coor­dination Committee and Industries and Production’s Chairman to chalk out a timeline to achieve the remaining three items on the 27-point action plan within 30 days. 

According to sources in Dawn, it was revealed in the meeting that Pakistan had made progress on one of the three remaining items. The Director-General of the FMU said the international community has recognised Pakistan’s efforts and also offered support to achieve the three targets. 

The three targets
Pakistan has to prove that it is “(i) demonstrating that TF investigations and prosecutions target persons and entities acting on behalf or at the direction of the designated persons or entities, (ii) demonstrating that TF prosecutions result in effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions, and (iii) demonstrating effective implementation of targeted financial sanctions against all designated terrorists, specifically those acting for or on their behalf.” (Khaleeq Kiani, “Legislation still needed to meet FATF benchmarks,” Dawn, 2 March 2021)

 

Foreign militaries participate in another joint exercise 
Fourth international PATS competition begins

Image Source: Dawn

On 1 March, the Fourth International Pakistan Army Team Spirit (PATS) Competition-2021 commenced at the National Counter-Terrorism Centre. Apart from the domestic teams of the Pakistan Army, teams from eight allied countries will be participating in the three-day competition. The teams from Jordan, Sri Lanka, Turkey and Uzbekistan will take part as participants, whereas Morocco, Indonesia, Kaza­khstan and Tajikistan are set to join the exercise.

Agenda for the exercise 
The competition is designed to test tactical skills in physical and professional domains along with the agility of the participating teams to generate responses in challenging real-time field scenarios. Further, the teams will be subject to various cross-domain scenarios and encompass tasks, including physical endurance, water obstacle crossing, close target reconnaissance and protective approach under chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear environment. (“Fourth international PATS competition kicks off,” Dawn, 2 March 2021) 

Previously…
In February 2021, Pakistan hosted a week-long multination naval exercise starting from February 11-16 in the Arabian Sea. Naval forces from 45 countries, including the US, China, Russia and Turkey are participating in Aman-2021. The Pakistan Navy stated the exercise is aimed at “fostering international cooperation to fight piracy, terrorism, and other crimes,” which pose a threat to maritime security and stability. (“In diplomatic triumph, Pakistan hosts multinational military drill,” Dawn, 11 February 2021) 


In Brief
INTERNAL
180,000 of around eight million senior citizens have registered for vaccination 
On 1 March, the Ministry of National Health Services stated that only 180,000 (2.25 per cent) of around eight million senior citizens in the country have registered for COVID-19 vaccination, terming it as a slow response. Further, this comes as the government is set to begin its vaccination campaign for over 65-year-old citizens is this week. (Ikram Junaidi, “180,000 senior citizens registered for vaccination,” Dawn, 2 March 2021)

Justice Isa says he will defend his own case
On 1 March, Justice Qazi Faez Isa stated that he and his family would argue the case instead of his counsel Muneer A. Malik. Justice Isa stated that he wanted this case to finish Justice Manzoor Malik, reaches superannuation next month, adding, “And this case is extremely important since I want accountability of the judges as well as of the government and Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) and that the eyes of the entire nation are on this case.” Further, he reiterated his application seeking a live telecast of the hearing. (“Justice Isa tells SC he will argue case himself,” Dawn, 2 March 2021)

ON CLIMATE CHANGE
Govt signs MoU with Suparco to mitigate the effects of climate change
On 1 March, the Ministry of Climate Change and the Pakistan Space and Upper Atmosphere Research Commission (SUPARCO) signed an MoU for use of satellite imagery received by SUPARCO to mitigate the effects of climate change in the country. The MoU is said to provide an overall clearer picture of the current glacial lakes and associated threats. Due to the rise in temperatures, glaciers in Pakistan’s northern mountain have been melting at a rapid rate. A total of 3,044 glacial lakes have developed in Gilgit-Baltistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, of which 33 glacial lakes are said to be prone to hazardous glacial lake outburst of flooding. (Amin Ahmed, “MoU signed with Suparco to get clearer picture of glacier lakes,” Dawn, 2 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Khashoggi case is far from closed says editorial
An editorial in Dawn stated that amid the web of claims and allegation around the Khashoggi killing, the killers remain unpunished. With Biden taking office it was expected that there would be a condemnation to the crime, however, this was not done either. Conversely, while the Saudi government claims innocence and then changed its statements regarding Khashoggi’s murder gives the impression that the Khashoggi case is far from closed, and a transparent trial is needed to punish all the perpetrators. (“Khashoggi report,” Dawn, 2 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                 

Following Supreme Court’s opinion on the Senate elections, there was so much of focus on the same in the Pakistani media. And editorial in Dawn says that the Parliament should have taken the responsibility and not burden the judiciary. On a similar note, another editorial in the News explains why the PTI government should not have opted for a presidential reference. The Express Tribune feels that the Supreme Court’s judgement has made the job difficult for the government.
 
AN opinion by a former Ambassador, Javid Hussain looks into how will US-India ties impact Pakistan. He argues: “it would be unrealistic to expect that under Biden, the US would resume large-scale economic and military assistance to Pakistan or would be helpful in the search for a just settlement of the Kashmir dispute in accordance with the UN Security Council resolutions and the aspirations of the Kashmiri people.”

 


"Now that the Supreme Court has clearly stated that the mode of voting in the Senate elections is under the Constitution, it would be better if the political parties brought back the issue for discussion in parliament and legislated electoral reforms, including the mode of voting for the next Senate elections."

-An editorial in Dawn on 'SC
on Senate polls'on 'The throes of politics'

 

 


Senate polls will be held through secret ballot, says SC


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 01 March 2021
Senate elections, Presidential reference and the Supreme Court’s Advice
Today (01 March 2021), the Supreme Court of Pakistan gave its “opinion” to a “reference” by the President of Pakistan. The reference asked: whether the “secret ballot” mentioned in Article 226 of Pakistan’s constitution is applicable only for the elections held “under” the Constitution; and not to “other elections such as the elections for the members of the Senate…which may be held by way of secret or open ballot.”
 
The Supreme Court’s “opinion”, according to the five judges (with one dissenting) are as following. First, the elections to the Senate are held “under the Constitution” and the law; hence, Article 226 holds good. According to Article 226, “All elections under the Constitution, other than those of the Prime Minister and the Chief Minister, shall be by secret ballot.”
 
Second, according to the Supreme Court, “it is the duty of the Election Commission of Pakistan” to ensure that the elections are conducted “honestly, justly, fairly and in accordance with law.” The Court also says that the Election Commission should guard against corrupt practices, and to “take all available measures including utilizing technologies” in doing so.
 
Third, in terms of secrecy of the ballot, the Supreme Court is of the opinion, that it is not absolute; according to SC, “the secrecy of the ballot, there has not be implemented in the ideal or absolute sense, but to be tempered by practical considerations necessitated by the processes of election.”
 
So what does the above “opinion” of the Supreme Court mean to the larger question of Senate elections and secret ballot? First, this is an “opinion” under the advisory jurisdiction of the judiciary. Second, while the opposition is likely to emphasis the first two issues that the Senate election should be conducted in accordance with Article 226 (through a secret ballot), the government is likely to emphasis the third issue mentioned above that the secrecy of the ballot is not absolute.
 
So, it is back to square one?
 
In Focus
Senate polls will be held through secret ballot, says SC
Urges ECP to ensure transparency

On 1 March, the Supreme Court in its opinion on the presidential reference on Senate elections, said the polls should be held through the secret ballot system. The SC also urged the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) to ensure transparency in the process and use the latest technology “protect the election from corruption.” It however maintained that secrecy cannot be final and said the parliament can however pass constitutional amendments, if need be. 

Shibli Faraz welcomes Court’s advice
Reacting to the SC statement, the Information Minister justified the presidential reference saying it was filed “to find out what practical steps can be taken to end corruption in Senate elections.” Though he termed the court ruling as “historic” he urged the ECP to "use technology — in the form of a bar code or a serial number on the ballot paper — to ensure that these [Senate] elections do not become secret as per the SC's opinion.” (Haseeb Bhatti, “SC says Senate elections to be held through secret ballot under Article 226 of Constitution,” Dawn, 1 March 2021)

Previously…
On 23 December 2020, President Alvi sought the SC’s opinion on Imran Khan’s “proposal to hold the elections using open ballot/show of hands.”  The Court started hearing the case on 4 January 2021. (Naveed Siddiqui, “President Alvi seeks SC opinion on show of hands for Senate polls,” Dawn, 23 December 2021)

 

On Pakistan-US relations
US likely to look at Islamabad through Pakistan’s immediate neighbours, says Burki 

Image Source: Dawn

An opinion in The Express Tribune traces out the likely policy of the US towards Pakistan under the Biden administration. The author, Shahid Javed Burki, says Biden is unlikely to have direct concerns about Pakistan; instead, “His policy towards Islamabad will be the sum total of how he handles Pakistan’s immediate neighbours.”

Looking at Pakistan through Afghanistan, China, Iran
With respect to Afghanistan, the important issue would be the 1 May deadline by which the US is supposed to complete its withdrawal. In this regard, COAS General Qamar Bajwa reiterated that Pakistan does not want a 1988-89 scenario wherein the US withdrew from Afghanistan and Pakistan felt the repercussions. Similarly, with China, Burki says, there might be consequences for Pakistan which started leaning towards Beijing during the Trump administration. Lastly, with Iran, Burki says, Pakistan’s relation with the US would depend on how Washington behave’s in Islamabad’s neighbourhood. 

India and the US 
Burki looks at India exclusively and says, the liberal press in the US “has become wary of the direction in which Modi’s India is moving.” He refers to an editorial in The Washington Post which describes some of Modi’s policies as “Mr Modi’s Assault on Dissent.” Burki wonders whether all these descriptions of Modi will be enough to shape Biden’s policies towards India. (Shahid Javed Burki, “Pakistan-US relations in the Biden era,” The Express Tribune, 1 March 2021)

 

Pakistan’s reflections on the LoC ceasefire
Opinions highlight likely reasons behind ceasefire 

Image Source: Dawn

An opinion in Dawn, while outlining that recommitment to the 2003 ceasefire would benefit people on both sides of the LoC, says “one ceasefire does not make for a comprehensive peace agreement.” He says, those who think the government or establishment has abandoned their Kashmir cause should also understand that “no amount of bloodshed at the LoC brings the liberation of Kashmir even an inch closer, and never will.” He outlines that even in the worst possible times, India and Pakistan have some contacts and channels open and this ceasefire is a result of the same; however, it is uncertain how long the countries will adhere to it. He speculates that if Pakistan placed a condition that restoring the former status is a prerequisite for peace, then it is “politically impossible for the Modi government to walk back on such a crucial policy plank.” Therefore, “The current arrangement, then, is a step forward, but it is not peace.” (Zarrar Khuhro, “A cold peace?,” Dawn, 1 March 2021)

Opinion highlights timeline of developments prior to DGMO talks
An opinion in The Express Tribune traces the developments between India and Pakistan prior to the DGMO announcement about the LoC ceasefire. He says, after a year of deteriorating relations and tweets personally attacking Modi, Imran Khan abruptly stopped these rhetorics. On 2 February, the COAS offered a resolution on Kashmir through peaceful means. Similarly, India allowed Pakistan to use its airspace when Imran was traveling to Sri Lanka. He also quotes the Indian MEA’s statement to address bilateral issues with Pakistan. He concludes, all of this cannot be a mere coincidence. However, he concludes by asking, “why are the two countries now seeking a thaw?” and “what will Pakistan get or has got in return for this favour?” (Kamran Yousf, “Decoding the Pakistan-India thaw,” The Express Tribune, 1 March 2021)

 

In Brief
INTERNAL
MQM-P skips meeting with PTI due to “organisational engagements”
On 28 February, Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) skipped an important meeting with the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) on the upcoming Senate election a day after the MQM-P got an offer from PPP. However, the MQM-P stated that their representatives did not attend the meeting because of “organisational engagements.” The development is said to highlight the deepening cracks in the ranks of joint opposition in Sindh. (Azfar-ul-Ashfaque, “MQM-P skips meeting with PTI, GDA leadership,” Dawn, 1 March 2021)

Establishment Division seems reluctant to implement the ECP’s decision on the NA-75
On 1 March, Dawn reported that the Establishment Division seems reluctant to implement the ECP’s landmark decision on the NA-75 (Daska) by-election controversy and instead wants the Punjab government to take action against the officers of the federal government. Further, an official of the Establishment Division stated that they were awaiting instructions from the PM’s Office and the officers nominated by the commission would be suspended by next week. (Malik Asad, “Daska fiasco: no action on ECP recommendation,” Dawn, 1 March 2021)

Strike observed over ANP leader’s killing 
On 28 February, a strike was observed in Quetta = and several other cities and towns of Balochistan in protest against the killing of provincial information secretary of the Awami National Party (ANP) Asad Khan Achakzai. In September 2020, Achakzai went missing, his bullet-riddled body was found after police arrested a member of the Levies’ Force who confessed to the killing. (Saleem Shahid, “Strike observed in Balochistan over ANP leader’s killing,” Dawn, 1 March 2021)

Govt working towards promoting tourism and generate employment opportunities says PM 
On 28 February, after inaugurating the heritage trail at the Al Biruni point at the Nandana, PM Imran Khan stated “The preservation and protection of our historical sites and national heritage is also essential to keep the coming generations informed about history.” Further, he added that the government was doing all to promote tourism and generate employment opportunities for youth in Pakistan, which was bestowed with abundant natural resources including sea, high mountains, salt ranges and historical sites. (Saleem Shahid, “Tourism can resolve issue of unemployment: PM Imran Khan,”  The News International, 1 March 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
Society does not like feminism because the ideology demands equal opportunities for all humans, says opinion
An opinion in The News International critical of how ‘Feminism’ has been interpreted in society says that efforts to disassociate from the term stems from two reasons, first, the foreign and anti-religious characteristic of the term and second, the term being equated with an ideology which leads women to an immoral path. Further, the opinion explains Feminism as an ideology that is not against a particular gender rather it is against the system which creates the oppressive values upheld by such individuals. It adds feminism stands for ending the systematic violence which robs women of the opportunities to live a life dictated by one’s own informed decisions. The opinion highlights, that feminists have perhaps failed to communicate the concept, however, this misconception has been repeatedly called out by feminists. The opinion concludes by stated that society does not like feminists because they ask uneasy questions, however, instead of dismissing these questions it is important to ask why there is fear around an ideology that demands equal opportunities for all humans without the discrimination of gender. (Safia Bano, “Who’s afraid of feminism?,” The News International, 1 March 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                              

Maleeha Lodhi writes about the multiple blows to the PTI, in the Daska by-poll for the National Assembly seat. She says, “the political fault lines in the ruling party go beyond this and should be a source of worry for its leadership — as well as cause for correction.” On the same issue, Ahmed Bilal Mehboob writes on the successes of the PPP, as it had retained all three provincial and one National Assembly seats in Sindh. On Daska, he writes: “It is for the first time since 1977 that such election-day manipulation has been attempted with the connivance of polling staff and the local and provincial administration although pre- and post-poll rigging has been alleged in many past elections.” Shahzad Chaurdhry offers an interesting thesis to the same election story, linking the Daska election and the biradari politics.
 
Sri Lanka’s recent decision on cremation is credited to Imran’s visit, as Dawn in its editorial says “it was primarily due to the prime minister’s persuasion that the Sri Lankan government decided to lift the ban and allow Muslims to fulfil their religious requirements.”

 

 

"Leaders need to transform their parties in their democratic outlook as well as their own approach to democratic values. Merely harking for more doesn’t get us anywhere."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'The throes of politics'

 

 


Click below links for month wise archive

2023 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May
2022 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec
2021 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec
2020 - May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec