Will the military courts get re-established? And what will be its long term political implications? For Nawaz Sharif, allowing the military courts to return may be a short term gain and based on political expediency. It will come back to haunt him and the subsequent democratic governments in the long term.Photo Source: The Express Tribune
D. Suba Chandran
International Strategic and Security Studies Programme (ISSSP)
National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bangalore
During the first week of January 2017, many in Pakistan were surprised, when the government allowed the earlier Parliamentary legislation on the military courts to elapse. The civil society in Pakistan, to a large extent, responded positively to this development and wanted the government to take control and initiate a political and legal process to address terrorism. However, two press releases - post 7 January 2017 from the PMO and the military's ISPR hint at the return of military courts.
Will the military courts get re-established? And what will be its long term political implications?
21st Amendment and the Military Courts
The military courts were established through the 21st constitutional amendment (Pakistan Army (Amendment) Bill, 2015) passed with huge support following the tragic terrorist attack on an Army Public School in December 2014 in Peshawar. The TTP led massacre witnessed the killing of nearly 140 persons in a School in Peshawar, most of them children. In January 2015, both houses of the Parliament passed the bill unanimously thereby establishing military courts for speedy trials of terrorists. The bill had a clause providing for the closure of military courts by 7 January 2017.
The military courts also became a part of the Pakistan's National Action Plan (NAP); along with the Zarb-e-Azb, these three were seen as Pakistan's primary counter terrorism strategy. While the Army is still continuing with the Zarb-e-Azb, the achievements and failure of the NAP have become a political issue during the recent months, whereas the military courts technically came to an end on 7 January 2017.
According to media reports, close to 270 cases were tried by the military courts; of which majority of them (around 160) were sentenced to death (though a small number were actually executed) and the rest to prison. Despite a 90 percent conviction, civil society does complain about lack of transparency in the above trials.
Though, there were discussions in the media during the late 2016 itself on the impending deadline, there were no political debates within the Parliament on providing an extension to the military courts. With no action, the tenure of the military courts automatically came to an end in early January.
However, a press release from the Prime Minister's Office on 09 January 2017, referring to a high level meeting chaired by Nawaz Sharif mentioned about a review of internal and regional security situation “with a view to further strengthen the gains made through counter-terrorism operations” and emphasised the following: “...the Military Courts have played an extremely important role at a very crucial juncture of one action against extremism and terrorism and translated the actions under operation Zarb-e-Azab to meaningful and tangible national gains. The Federal Government has already initiated consultations for constitutional amendment to continue the Military Courts for a period which is agreed by all political parties represented in the Parliament."
The above meeting was attended by ministers of finance and interior, and by the Chief of Army Staff and DG ISI besides Special Advisor to PM on Foreign Affairs and the National Security Advisor. Separately, the recent Corps Commanders' meeting at the GHQ in Rawalpindi on 10 January 2017, according to an ISPR press release “appreciated performance of Military Courts during the prescribed duration which resulted into reduction of terrorism.” Clearly, the GHQ would want the military courts to continue.
So what is likely to happen? Will the military courts return, through another amendment?
Most likely, yes.
Outside the GHQ, a section within Pakistan also wants to extend the military courts for the following reasons. They consider that the regular courts are not fool proof, take time and allow the militants to escape from getting convicted. They also argue that the military courts dispense justice at a faster pace and death sentences will convey a strong message to the terrorists and prevent them from pursuing a violent course.
On the other hand, a section also argues that despite the military courts, terrorism continues unabated. A military trial and any subsequent death penalty is unlikely to prevent suicide terrorists who care less about their own lives. This section argues in favour of strengthening political and legal processes as a counter-terrorism strategy, through strengthening existing institutions. This section also is worried about the misuse, fairness, especially arbitrary detention without any charge. There was also an argument that instead of military courts, the government should consider establishing special courts under the regular judicial process, but with a speedy trial.
The two meetings (PMO's Office and the Corps Commanders) mentioned above, hint at the likely course that this government will pursue - leading to re-establishing military courts. Given the fact there is pressure on Nawaz Sharif relating to the Panama scandal (now continuing on a day to day basis in the Supreme Court) he is less likely to take any political decisions against what the GHQ wants. Outside, though militant attacks have come down during the recent months, the TTP and other sectarian organizations still continue to remain a potent force. A bigger headache for Nawaz Sharif also relates to Pakistan's two borders in the east and west relating to India and Afghanistan. In the recent months, both borders have become volatile.
Nawaz Sharif seems to have outsourced Pakistan's foreign policy towards India and Afghanistan to the military establishment. And so is the counter terrorism strategy within Pakistan. The Zarb-e-Azb has been conceived, expanded and executed by the military directly, with less or no political inputs. Until the Zarb-e-Azb comes to an end (or military says it has come to), Nawaz Sharif is less likely to question military's counter terrorism strategy.
The military as an institution in most parts of the world will need solid legislations to continue its operations especially on the civilian space. Pakistan's military is no exception; given its political role since the inception, it is unlikely to voluntarily return that space to the political establishment. With the government willing to provide that space, Pakistan's military be only too willing to grab the opportunity and expand its boots on civilian grounds.
Return of the military courts in Pakistan now is a foregone conclusion. The question is what the short term challenges are for Sharif (in getting the extension through another Parliamentary amendment) and long term issues (in terms of shrinking political space in domestic governance and external relations).
His primary challenge will be to get the political parties on the same page – both within and outside the Parliament. Imran Khan and the PTI have been on a war path against Sharif, and it is highly unlikely that Imran would agree to any proposal from Nawaz Sharif. Not all political parties are on the same platform in reviving the military courts. The PPP, generally having been at the receiving end from the military would like to look into some principles to hide its own prejudices against the military. Fazlur Rehman and Amir Siraj ul Haq of the JUI-F and JI respectively have already expressed their reservations on reviving the military courts. Ideologically JI and JUI are closer to the other side; they may have the street power, but not enough numbers to vote against in the Parliament. The PPP and PTI holds the key.
Though the opposition political parties are likely to object the extension on some principles, or try to corner the Sharif government for not doing enough, they are not likely to stand in the way of the military courts from getting re-established. Perhaps there will be another time bound extension, with a mandate to strengthen the regular judicial process in the mean time. Also, the ISI is strong enough to manipulate what the military would want on this issue.
Return of the Military Courts: What are the likely implications?
Implications of the return of military court are bound to be substantial in terms of the space the political leadership has to deal with counter terror strategy and also the larger civil-military equations on governance questions.
Political Role in Countering Terrorism: Shrinking?
The larger challenge for Sharif in the long run, in re-establishing the military courtswill be on the shrinking role political institutions in dealing with terrorism. Today, the military has aggrandized most of the decision making process in Pakistan's counter terrorism strategy; the civilian government has been happy to abrogate the same as well. If violence – either led by terrorist or by sectarian groups has a political objective, firing from military's shoulders is unlikely to address the core issue. Is Sharif likely to regain this space, even if he wants to
How many Legal Systems within a Country?
Also, in a democracy, there cannot be parallel judicial systems led by different actors with different ideologies. Besides the regular legal framework led by the Supreme Court and High Courts, Pakistan has been known for its Shariah Courts, Tribal Jirgas (especially in FATA), and the extra judicial (and illegal) local jirgas especially in rural Punjab and Sindh.
Expanding footprints of the Military
The military courts, adding to the above should have been an exception and time bound. One could understand the emotional decision to establish them especially after the December 2014 massacre of children. But allowing them to continue even two years after their establishment needs caution.
Escaping the Judicial Reforms
Though the military courts may be effective in terms of time taken to disperse justice, it will not address the real problems of the larger judicial process and reforms. This is a case not only in Pakistan, but also in rest of South Asia. Instead of addressing the larger question of judicial reforms for timely and effective justice, looking at the military as a solution—short term or otherwise, may end up denting the institutions meant for delivering justice.
Narrowing role of the Political
How many social, legal, religious and military institutions can dispense justice within a single country? And won't they shrink the political space for democratic actors further, which is actually the primary cause for breakdown of governance?
Parliamentary leaders fail to arrive at consensus on delimitation legislation
Dawn, 9 November 2017 | Politics
Govt, opposition differences over census jeopardise timely polls
The News, 7 November 2017 | Politics
Rustam Shah Mohmand, “Cost of ignoring Afghanistan’s ground realities”
The Express Tribune, 5 November 2017 | Af-Pak
Raza Rumi, “Don’t turn CPEC into another holy cow. Transparency is a must”
Daily Times, 5 November 2017 | CPEC
Rejection of minus-Nawaz fomula shows PML-N’s internal strength
The News, 3 November 2017 | Politics
Security apparatus to continue its role in national interest: corps commanders
The News, 3 November 2017 | Military
Diplomatic row erupts over posting of video about Sheikh Mujeeb
Dawn, 2 November 2017 | Pakistan & Bangladesh
Chinese President Xi’s rise a boost for CPEC, causes concerns in India
The News, 26 October 2017 | Pak-China
Dr Hasan Askari Rizvi, “The options for Nawaz Sharif?”
The Express Tribune, 22 October 2017 | Politics
Mystery shrouds US drone strikes near Pak-Afghan border
Daily Times, 19 October 2017 | Drone Attacks
8 killed, 24 others wounded in blast targeting police vehicle in Quetta
Dawn, 19 October 2017 | Balochistan
Sheraz Raza, "The conundrum that is Pakistan-Russia ties"
Daily Times, 16 October 2017 | Pakistan & Russia
Shaheen Sehbai, "Options before the country are ‘very limited’"
Daily Times, 16 October 2017 | Civil-Military
Deadlock in Pak-US ties ends as both sides agree to continue talks
The News, 13 October 2017 | Pakistan & US
US-Canadian couple, three children freed from terrorist custody in Kohat
Dawn, 13 October 2017 | Extremism
If Sharif convicted, Shehbaz will be PML-N candidate for PM slot
The Express Tribune, 8 October 2017 | Politics
Raza Rumi, “Mainstreaming militants? Not without a political strategy”
Daily Times, 8 October 2017 | Politics/Extremism
US State, Defence secretaries to convey Trump’s tough message to Pakistan
The News, 8 October 2017 | Pakistan & US
Seven-hour-long corps commanders meeting discusses security situation
The News, 4 October 2017 | Military
Will resign if I can't find out who deployed Rangers at court: Ahsan
The Express Tribune, 3 October 2017 | Politics
Mubashir Akram, “From the days of Pakistani jihad incorporated”
Daily Times, 3 October 2017 | Extremism
Senator Rehman Malik, “Pak-Afghan conflict — Ray of hope from holy land of Saudi Arabia”
The News, 3 October 2017 | External Relations
Jamaat’s hesitation to quit KP govt delaying MMA’s revival: JUI-F
The News, 1 October 2017 | Politics
Raza Rumi, “Beijing has signaled. Is Islamabad listening?”
Daily Times, 1 October 2017 | Pakistan & China
Talat Masood, “Is mending relations with the US possible?”
The Express Tribune, 28 September 2017 | Pakistan & US
Sohail Warraich, “The Sharifs and the religious right”
The News, 26 September 2017 | Politics/Extremism
Dr Raza Khan, “Decline of some groups means rise of others”
The Express Tribune, 24 September 2017 | Politics/Extremism
Zainul Abedin, "The Panama drama: an unabashedly political view"
The News, 15 July 2017 | Domestic Politics
Imtiaz Gul, "Panamagate: time to face up the reality?"
Daily Times, 12 July 2017 | Domestic Politics
Aziz Ali Dad, "The sectarian spectre in Gilgit-Baltistan: Part - I"
The News, 11 July 2017 | Gilgit-Baltistan
Raza Rumi, "This summer Pakistan enters into another phase of instability"
Daily Times, 25 June 2017 | Domestic Politics
Babar Ayaz, "The good, the bad, and the ugly of the Panama Leaks"
Daily Times, 22 June 2017 | Domestic Politics
Imdad Hussain. "Pakistan left with limited options in Saudi-led Islamic military alliance"
The Express Tribune, 26 May 2017 | Pakistan and Middle East
Houbara bustard no more protected bird, govt tells LHC
Dawn, 11 February 2017, 11 February 2017 | Houbara
JI to observe ‘black day’ for FATA reforms on 16th
Daily Times, 10 February 2017, 9 February 2017 | FATA Reforms
Strict implementation of immigration laws on Afghan border
Dawn, 8 February 2017, 8 February 2017 | Af-Pak
Interior Ministry approves issue of red warrant against Altaf Hussain
Daily Times, 8 February 2017, 8 February 2017 | Politics
22 tons coal get lost on transport by the Pakistan Railway
The Nation, 7 February 2017, 7 February 2017 | Energy
Grand jirga of Khyber elders opposes FATA-KP merger
Daily Times, 7 February 2017, 6 February 2017 | FATA Reforms
Parliament should not outsource justie to the panchayats: Dawn
Dawn, 6 February 2017, 6 February 2017 | Justice
Second Edition of Pakistan Super League (PSL) all set to begin
The News, 7 February 2017, 6 February 2017 | Cricket
As Ladla’s brother steps in, Rangers chief vows gang-free Lyari
The News, 4 February 2017, 4 February 2017 | Crime
Asfandyar flays Achakzai for opposing Fata-KP merger
Dawn, 4 February 2017, 3 February 2017 | FATA Reforms
Quetta commission report violates justice: ministry
Dawn, 4 February 2017, 3 February 2017 | Terrorism
India wants to presurize Pakistan through SAARC: Dawn
Dawn, 2 February 2017, 2 February 2017 | Indo-Pak
Chinese frustrated by legal hurdles surrounding OLMT
The Express Tribune, 2 February 2017, 2 February 2017 | CPEC
Work on TAPI pipeline to kick off in Pakistan this month
The Express Tribune, 2 February 2017, 2 February 2017 | TAPI
Opposition boycotts Punjab Assembly uover Hafiz Saeed`s arrest
Dawn, 1 February 2017, 31 January 2017 | Terrorism
"This (action) is part of the international conspiracy": Hafiz Saeed
The Nation, 31 January 2017, 30 January 2017 | Terrorism
Hafiz Saeed among five leaders put under house arrest
The News, 31 January 2017, 30 January 2017 | Terrorism
Court acquits 112 in case of torching Christian homes
Daily Times, 30 January 2017, 30 January 2017 | Minorities
Act against JuD or face sanctions, US tells Pakistan: The News
The News, 30 January 2017, 30 January 2017 | Terrorism
PIA needs another Rs60 bn revival plan for next two years: The News
The News, 26 Jan 2017, 26 January 2017 | PIA
Pakistan tests its first Surface to Surface ballistic missile - Ababeel
ISPR Press Release, 24 Jan 2017, 24 January 2017 | Military
"Pakistan aims for water treaty with Afghanistan": The Nation
The Nation, 23 Jan 2017, 23 January 2017 | Af-Pak
"Islamabad aims to woo new US administration, improve ties": The Nation
The Nation, 23 Jan 2017, 23 January 2017 | Pak & US
Carnage at Parachinar market; 25 killed, 87 injured
Dawn, 22 January 2017, 21 January 2017 | Terror in Kurram
China acquires strategic 40% stake in Pakistani stock exchange
MoneyControl.Com, 21 January 2017, 21 January 2017 | CPEC
Afghan transporters protest against requirment of visa documents at Torkham
Daily Times, 21 January 2017, 20 January 2017 | Af-Pak
HR groups in Punjab shut down for 'anti-state activities'
The News, 21 January 2017, 20 January 2017 | Social
India asked to stop work on Kishanganga and Ratle projects
Dawn, 21 January 2017, 20 January 2017 | Indus Waters Treaty
Pakistan will continue to fulfil its obligations: Dar
Source: The Nation, 20 January 2017, 19 January 2017 | Indus Waters Treaty
Disqualification of PM is a matter of public interest: SC
Source: Dawn, 20 January 2017, 19 January 2017 | Panama Politics
No imminent threat to Indus treaty, minister tells Senate panel
Dawn, 18 January 2017, 17 January 2017 | Indo-Pak
Al-Qaeda-like groups can raise heads again: Pakistan Ambassador to US
The News, 15 January 2017, 15 January 2017 | Pakistan and US
Two Chinese built Maritime Patrol Vessels for Pakistan
The News, 15 January 2017, 14 January 2017 | Pakistan Maritime
Separate laws to deal with terrorists,sectarian elements: Nisar
The News, 15 January 2017, 14 January 2017 | Terrorism
Chinese exports to Pakistan increase following CPEC
The News, 15 January 2017, 14 January 2017 | CPEC
“Activities of Indian RAW and NDS nexus remains a matter of deep concern to Pakistan”
MOFA Press Release, 13 January 2017, 13 January 2017 | Pakistan and Afghanistan
“Citizens will continue to disappear with impunity”: Senator
Dawn, 14 January 2017, 13 January 2017 | Disappearences
New Pak-Afghan border controls slow trade to a crawl
Dawn, 11 January 2017, 11 January 2017 | Pakistan & Afghanistan
Govt to exempt Chinese hydropower projects from sales tax
Dawn, 11 January 2017, 10 January 2017 | CPEC
Banned sectarian organisations could not be equated with other banned terrorist organisations
The Nation, 11 January 2017, 10 January 2017 | Sectarianism
Pakistan conducts the first test of Submarine Launched Cruise Missile (SLCM) Babur-3: ISPR
Press Release, ISPR, 9 January 2017 | Military
Pakistan to revive the Military Courts
Press Release, Prime Minister's Office, 09 Jan 2017, 9 January 2017 | Terrorism & Military
JUI threatens agitation if decisions `imposed` on Fata people
Dawn, 9 January 2017, 8 January 2017 | FATA & KP
Chinese firm encroached on domain of policy matters: SC
The Express Tribune, 8 January 2017, 7 January 2017 | CPEC
Parliamentary parties give consent to Fata merger plan
Dawn, 7 January 2017, 6 January 2017 | KP & FATA
Ex-COAS Raheel likely to head Saudi-led military alliance
Dawn, 7 January 2017, 6 January 2017 | External
SC to ascertain 'conflict of interest' in PM's actions
Dawn, 5 January 2017, 4 January 2017 | Panama Politics
"Violence-related fatalities in Balochistan, Punjab increased in 2016"
Dawn, 4 January 2017, 3 January 2017 | Terrorism
Tribesmen protest delay in implementation of FATA reforms
Daily Times, 3 December 2017, 2 January 2017 | FATA & KP
Senators press govt to implement Quetta commission report
Daily Times, 3 January 2017, 2 January 2017 | Terrorism
Chaman-Kandahar highway blocked against closure of border
Dawn, 3 January 2017, 2 January 2017 | Pakistan and Afghanistan
First phase of census to cover 11 divisions of four provinces
Dawn, 3 January 2017, 2 January 2017 | Census