PR Comments

Photo Source: Dawn

Pakistan Reader# 270, 10 January 2022

Justice Ayesha: Breaking the Legal Ceiling

Judicial Commission of Pakistan approving the nomination of Justice Ayesha Malik to the Supreme Court

Her appointment is a first big step; but to make it meaningful, there has to be constitutional provisions and practices to have women judges at the higher level, and also a conducive legal  environment for them to practice.

D. Suba Chandran

On 6 January 2022, the Judicial Commission of Pakistan approved the nomination of Justice Ayesha Malik to the Supreme Court. She would be the first woman judge to be approved for the highest court in Pakistan. She would remain in the Supreme Court until March 2031; a report in Dawn mentioned that she would even have a chance to become the first woman chief justice of Pakistan.

It is a moment to celebrate, wrote Dawn subsequently, in its editorial on 8 January. Indeed. As Pakistan celebrates 75 years of its independence in 2022, it was a glass ceiling until now for the women judges. And it is broken now. Justice (Retd) Fakhar-un-Nisa Khokhar, should be smiling; she could have become the first woman judge to be appointed to the Supreme Court two decades ago, but could not. She was quoted to have stated: “…no women in the Supreme Court, and those who were to be elevated to the Supreme court, were sacrificed at the altar of gender bias.” Another retired woman judge, Justice Nasira Iqbal was quoted to have stated: “Five female judges were appointed to the high court in 1994; two of them had legitimate expectancy to become the chief justice[s] of the high courts of Punjab and KP [Khyber Pakhtunkhwa] respectively; however, both of them were superseded and were allowed to retire without being elevated to the Supreme Court of Pakistan.” In this background, Justice Ayesha’s elevation is a moment to celebrate.

Justice Ayesha Malik’s elevation from the Lahore High Court to the Supreme Court of Pakistan is expected to add two specific issues. Dawn’s editorial (“Debating Seniority,” Dawn, 8 January 2022) referred to what she brings in – “a woman judge who would be able to empathise more deeply than her male colleagues with the hardships and trauma faced by women seeking justice” and addressing “gender equality in the highest echelons of the judiciary.”

Both are much needed. During recent years, one could see the rise of a women movement creating ripples in the patriarchal society of Pakistan. The rise of Aurat March in Pakistan and the popularity of the “Mera Jism, Meri Marzi” (My body, my choice) slogan would highlight the progress of a critical gender movement in Pakistan. Further progress to this movement would not be easy and has serious obstacles. A case in point would be the response, especially the institutional statements, after the physical assault of a mother by two men, in front of her children in September 2020. While a section of the nation got extremely angry at the incident (the Lahore-Sialkot highway rape case), another section, including the police chief of Lahore, decided to blame the victim. The police officer was quoted to have stated: “First, I am surprised that she, a mother of three children, chose to go without a driver. You left Defence, you (should) take the straight GT Road where there is population and go home.”

In this context, the elevation of a woman judge to the Supreme Court would play an important role – to bring the much-needed sanity and empathy in the arguments over gender violence. Justice Ayesha Malik is also the right person for her position while delivering her judgment on gender violence. Last year, in January 2021, she delivered her judgment on virginity tests, especially on the two-finger test. Judge Malik made crucial observations on the validity and usefulness of the test, the illegality of the same vis-à-vis the constitutional provisions, and, more importantly, on the dignity of the victim. Dawn, in its report dated 4 January 2021, quoted her judgement saying the virginity test offending “the dignity of the female victim,” and also “discriminatory against the female victim as they are carried out on the basis of their gender [and] therefore offend Article 25 of the Constitution.” She also instructed the provincial governments to “ensure that virginity tests are not carried out in medico-legal examination of the victims of rape and sexual abuse,” and devise “appropriate medico-legal protocol and guidelines and standard operating procedures” to “recognise and manage sensitively the care of victims of sexual violence.” The provincial government in Punjab subsequently abolished the test.

The other issue is related to gender parity in the legal system in Pakistan. Ayesha Siddique Khan, a practising lawyer in Islamabad, wrote (The Express Tribune, 13 September 2020) in September 2020: “As a lawyer, myself, working in a patriarchal and male-dominated profession, I cannot stress more on the need for making the legal profession gender-inclusive. Till today there has been no female Supreme Court judge or Attorney General of Pakistan. As per statistics by the Ministry of Law, only 6 out of 113 judges of high courts across the country are women; and out of 198 members of 7 bar councils across the country, only 6 happen to be women, reflecting the gender disparity in the litigation and judiciary. There is dire need to increase representation of women in law.” Another woman lawyer, Zaeem Mumtaz Bhatti, then practicing in Lahore, wrote (Daily Times, 27 July 2019) in 2019: “Despite making inroads in every institution in Pakistan, female members of our society still have to face these issues on a day-to-day basis. For the most part, they don’t get a levelled playing field to compete with their male peers. When it comes to the superior judiciary, it is no different.”

Zaeem Mumtaz Bhatti also wrote: “The history of the superior judiciary is steeped in gender bias and discrimination.” Now a first step is taken to address that discrimination, by making Justice Ayesha Malik the first woman judge to be appointed for the Supreme Court, there need to be further measures.

Zia Ullah Rajah, another lawyer wrote in April 2018 (The Express Tribune, 10 April 2018) on steps that could be taken to eradicate gender imbalance in Pakistan’s superior judiciary: “Article 175A could be revised to ensure due representation of women — both in the Judicial Commission of Pakistan and in the Parliamentary Committee. A specific quota for women in the superior judiciary may also be prescribed within the mandate of Article 25 of the Constitution.” Besides, he also wrote: “Women lawyers should be provided a conducive environment so that they may grow as professional lawyers and then be considered for judicial appointments.”

While the first one refers to the constitutional amendments and practices, the second one refers to the legal environment in Pakistan. Both need to be addressed. Though Justice Ayesha Malik has now been elevated to become the first judge in the Supreme Court, it was not an easy walk for her. There was opposition within the Judicial Commission of Pakistan that appointed her as the Supreme Court judge. The decision was made with a 5-4 majority in a nine-member commission. The primary opposition stemmed from her seniority at the Lahore High Court; she is not the first in terms of seniority. There has been a threat from Pakistan Bar Council to boycott the courts if she was elevated. In this context, the above recommendation by Zia Ullah Ranjah makes sense. Pakistan should work towards having a specific quota for women in the superior judiciary and in the Judicial Commission of Pakistan.

Equally important is providing a conducive environment for women lawyers and judges. While the first one has to come from the Parliament through a constitutional amendment, the second one has to come from the legal community through a gender mandate. Both are crucial; the former cannot succeed without the latter.

Back to Justice Ayesha Malik. Congratulations, my lord.

Recent PR Comments

Provincial politics, federal-provincial differences and economic woes will dominate the province in 2022

Sindh in 2022: Three issues to look for

Political change, social issues and economic growth are likely to dominate the KP during this year

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa in 2022: Three likely issues

Local government elections, extremism and debate over the South Punjab province are likely to be the most prominent in 2022

Punjab in 2022: Five developments to look for

Political engineering, violence and protest for better governance will dominate the province in 2022

Balochistan in 2022: Three likely issues

Few political changes are taking place. But, a deeper analysis would reveal, the template remains the same

Internal Politics: The more it change…

The release is an attempt to enlighten citizens on the Government’s policy objectives to deal with traditional and non-traditional security threats

National Security Policy of Pakistan (2022-2026): Six Highlights

The  war against America and support of Pakistan for the Taliban has not pacified the tribal Pashtuns in their border claims on the Durand line

Durand Line: A dead horse or a deepest fear for Pakistan

Judicial Commission of Pakistan approving the nomination of Justice Ayesha Malik to the Supreme Court

Justice Ayesha: Breaking the Legal Ceiling

Three hits and three misses

Pakistan's Foreign Policy in 2021

Despite suffering from structural problems there were moments of cheer

Pakistan’s economy in 2021: Major highlights

It was a rollercoaster year for Pakistan. Like the previous year. And the previous years

2021: Where the PTI scored, missed and floundered, and what it means for 2022

The downfall of PTI in the KP local body polls is an indication of its own mistakes. Find out why?

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa LB polls: Shocking yet predicted loss for PTI

Approximately one-tenth of Pakistan's external public debt servicing was paid to the ADB.

Pakistan and the Asian Development Bank

The sense ranges from feebleness of the media to frustration about misaligned coverages of issues

Pakistani media’s response to the Justice Saqib Nisar audio leak| Major takeaways

The state officials must address long-standing student issues because the Student Solidarity March is only the beginning.

Student’s Solidarity March in Pakistan: A step in the right direction

Protests highlights that the unrest among the people of Gwadar is not only going unaddressed, but is also aggravating the situation.

Protests in Gwadar: Four major highlights

Pakistan has agreed to various conditions of IMF for continuation of a loan of USD 4.268 billion only while avoiding further Chinese loans

Mini budget, IMF and a contemporary puzzle.

The fortunes of the Pakistani cricket team in the recent ICC T20 World Cup are mirrored in some intense social media battles

Pakistan cricket: Social media an outlet for inflamed passions

PM Khan appoints Lt. Gen. Nadeem Anjum as DG Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) in consonance with the Army Chief

Impasse over next ISI Chief over after 20 days of cordial silence

The judicial activism balances increasing curbs on digital media in the country. However, it’s a long road ahead

The fragility of Digital Media Freedom in Pakistan

A secret government deal with the TLP refers to releasing those who were arrested, and allowing the party to contest in elections

PTI’s TLP flip-flop and a secret deal

Time tested relationship in shifting sands of geopolitics of Gulf

Post IMF Review: Saudi Arabia to bolster Pakistan

Inflation is not just a number, but rather a multi-dimensional problem. If unattended, might create “a make or break” situation for the PTI

Pakistan’s prolonged Inflation problem

Why would the government accept most of its demands in October 2021?

TLP: The government caves in again

The recurring protests staged by the TLP highlights the fact that the state has failed to address political-religious issues

TLP is back again

In the recent past, several positive measures have been initiated to assist transgender persons; however, Pakistan has a long way to go.

Pakistan’s transgender community: The long road ahead

Another Chief Minister, another no-confidence motion

Political instability in Balochistan

The absence of a telephone call between President Joe Biden and Prime Imran Khan is an expression of the current US-Pak ties

Since January 2021: Why the US President has not called Pakistan’s Prime Minister so far?

The recent spate in honour attacks in Pakistan shows there is no end in sight to the problem.

No honour in honour killing

Achieving full potential in hydropower is an elusive dream given its declining water availability, inadequate infrastructure and finance.

Pakistan's Hydropower Sector: Contribution, Challenges and Prospects

Neither Imran Khan is powerful, nor his party is strong to take on the Establishment

Appointing the new ISI Chief: Why is Imran Khan delaying the notification? Who will blink?

Recent military reshuffle and the possible reasons behind it

The Military Reshuffle: A strategic or routine decision?

Dr Khan may have died a disappointed man on how the State treated him, but he would remain a hero for the nation

Dr AQ Khan: Between a national hero and a nuclear proliferator

The data driven world is tending to Pandora leaks by glossing over the common man’s syndrome of big personalities

Tax avoidance: From Panama papers to Pandora Papers

Poverty, taboos, societal norms, and a weak State response fuel the prevalence of child sexual abuse in the country

Rising child abuse in Pakistan: Five reasons why

The Hazaras in Pakistan have faced endless persecution despite state measures to protect the community

Hazara Persecution in Pakistan: No end in sight

Is the rest of Pakistan ready for the same?

Talking to the Pakistani Taliban: What did Imran say? And what does it mean?

Socio-economic pressures, limitations of healthcare sector, and lack of institutional mechanisms fuel the mental health crisis in Pakistan

Pakistan’s mental health crisis: Of apathy and State failure

Baloch nationalist opinion that the current initiative lacks seriousness

Dialogue with Baloch Insurgents: Will Imran Khan Succeed where others have failed

Four major challenges

Fighting Polio in Pakistan

A case study of TikTok

Social Media Censorship in Pakistan

The political rise and fall of a sugar baron

The curious case of Jahangir Khan Tareen

PR Debate

The Future of PDM: Will the Opposition alliance break up?

Between the government and the opposition, there are no winners

Senate Chairman Elections in Pakistan: Eight Takeaways

A tactical arrangement or a broader political goal?

Ceasefire at LoC: Understanding Pakistan's motivations

Three takeaways on PTI, PDM and the Election Commission

NA 75 Sialkot Daska By-Election

The Federal Government Employees’ demand a 40 per cent hike

Another protest in Islamabad

Why does the government want to change the voting procedure in the Parlaiment?

Pakistan's Senate problem

Will the PPP's no-confidence motion against Imran Khan succeed?

Is the PDM slowing down?

The people want to get rid of the constitutional and political limbo. Five reasons why

Gilgit Baltistan


Pakistan bans three more organizations as proscribed, but the problem remains


Smart Lockdown, SOPs vs Social Realities


Khalilzad meets Gen Bajwa: What is Pakistan’s Afghan Endgame?

After Doha

The US-Taliban deal will lead to an Afghan Civil War

RIP Stephen Cohen

Call me Steve

Election 2018 Analysis -02

The Tehreek-e-Labbaik: Rise of the Radical

Election 2018 Analysis -01

The Naya Pakistan: Five Major Trends


Fighting Taliban and the Islamic State: Don't prioritize


Indo-Pak Dialogue Options: Importance of Back Channel


De-securitizing the Indus


Cross-LoC Interactions: Low Hanging Kashmir Fruit


Honouring Younis and Misbah


Scarcity, Institutions, Securitization: Our “Other” Water Issues


Fighting the Daesh: A Regional Counter IS Strategy


The Husain Huqqani Revelation


Deep-rooted Misogyny: Offend her; she will forgive in the name of tradition


The Standing Passengers of PIA


Tehmina Janjua: Internal Challenges for the New Foreign Secretary


Shahid Afridi: Well Played Hero


Court, Society and Valentine Day: Is expression of love against our culture?


Operationalising the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor


Pakistan’s Afghan Policy: What Shapes? Who Shapes? And through What Strategies?


And Now, They Are Coming For Our Children


The Axact Scam: Demands for Fake Degrees


Pakistan’s Panama Paradox: Demanding Accountability vs Fixing Sharifs