loader

Daily Briefs

US seeks custody of Omar Sheikh


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 30 January 2021
More questions than answers over the Supreme Court’s order to release Omar Sheikh
The Supreme Court’s decision to release those accused of beheading Daniel Pearl can be interpreted as a legal failure to prove without any doubt. However, it raises other questions.

If Omar Sheikh is not responsible for the beheading of Daniel Pearl, then who killed him? If Omar Sheikh cannot be convicted for the killing of Daniel Pearl, then what can he be convicted? If he is indeed innocent, will he then be allowed to go free? If the US demands that Omar Sheikh be extradited to the US, will Pakistan agree to the demand?

What about India? Omar Sheikh was serving a prison sentence in India for the kidnapping of American and British tourists. He was released by India in return to secure the release of passengers of the Indian Airlines plane hijacked from Kathmandu to India.

Will the release undermine Pakistan’s FATF chances? Isn’t one of the primary demands by the FATF is related to investigation and conviction in Pakistan?
 
Pakistan Today at 1900 hrs

China launches the second warship for Pakistan with latest surface, sub-surface, anti-air weapons, combat management system and sensors 
On Saturday, in the Hudong Zhonghua Shipyard, China launched the 2nd Type-054 Class Frigate for Pakistan Navy. According to a Pakistan Navy tweet, Cdre Azfar Humayun on the occasion, “highlighted that induction of warship will enhance Pak maritime defence and deterrence capabilities.” According to the same tweet, the new ship has a technologically advance platform that is fitted with latest surface, sub-surface, anti-air weapons, combat management system and sensors.


US Secretary of State calls for ensuring accountability for Daniel Pearl
Antony Blinken, the US Secretary of State has tweeted on Daniel Pearl that he spoke the same with Pakistan’s foreign minister “on ensuring accountability for convicted terrorist Ahmed Omar Saeed Sheikh and others responsible for Daniel Pearl’s murder. The Foreign Minister and I underscored the importance of continued U.S.-Pakistan cooperation in supporting regional stability.”

Opposition to question the new amendment on Senate elections
According to a Geo TV report, the Opposition parties have decided to act against the amendment proposed by the government to amend the election procedure for the Senate. The government wants an open election, while the opposition wants the same to conducted through a secret ballot, as has been the norm until now.
 
In Focus
US seeks custody of Omar Sheikh
Order to release Omar reflects sorry state of LEAs: Dawn
 
Image Source: Dawn
 

On 29 January, the Acting US Attorney General Monty Wilkinson said the US would like to take custody of Omar Sheikh on the grounds that Omar should not “evade justice for his charged role in Daniel Pearl’s abduction and murder.” Raising concerns over the Supreme Court’s judgement, he said releasing Omar would not bring justice to Daniel Pearl’s family and other victims of terrorism across the world. 

The statement came a day after US Secretary of State Antony Blinken offered to prosecute Omar in the US. He had conveyed that Pakistan should review all its legal options to ensure justice. 

Editorial highlights sorry state of Pakistan’s LEAs
An editorial in Dawn, critical of the order for release of Omar, says the two to one ruling is a testimony to the “sorry state of Pakistan’s law-enforcement agencies” which failed to required and convincing evidence against him. The editorial says this is not just the case of Omar, but other criminals have also hoodwinked investigations and the justice system. It maintains that the Court, if it decides to release Sheikh and other accused, should reveal who the real killers of Daniel Pearl are. If it fails to do so, it would mean “there is no justice for those who harm journalists in Pakistan, and that their killers continue to roam free.” (“Sheikh’s acquittal,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)

Meanwhile…
The Sindh government has filed a review petition against the release of Omar and the other three accused. The review petition holds that the SC overlooked key facts including evidence like the video footage, confessions of the accused, impersonation by Omar etc. (“US seeks Sheikh’s custody as Sindh wants Pearl case reviewed,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)

 

Pakistan not bound by latest nuclear weapons treat, says FO
Reiterates consensus-based process for treaty negotiations 

Image Source: Dawn

On 29 January, the Foreign Office said Pakistan does not consider itself bound under the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons which came into effect on 22 January. The FO held that the treaty was negotiated "outside the established UN disarmament negotiating forums” and many countries, including Pakistan had not participated in the same. 

Cardinal objective can be achieved through consensus
The FO said the treaty failed to form a consensus of the stakeholders as none of the nuclear-armed states were present during the negotiations. It emphasised that “cardinal objective can only be achieved as a cooperative and universally agreed undertaking, through a consensus-based process.” Further, the FO also said security concerns of the above states are indispensable. (Naveed Siddiqui, “Pakistan not bound by treaty for prohibition of nuclear weapons: FO,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)

 

Vaccines to be administered to frontline workers, assures minister
Aviation Authority extends travel ban on six countries

Image Source: Dawn

On 29 January, the Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs said COVID-19 vaccine would first be administered to the healthcare workers, elderly and teachers - the frontline workers. He was responding to the Senators’ fears that priority would be given to politicians, generals and judges and whether private players would procure the vaccines thereby leaving the poor lurching. (Iftikhar A Khan, “No elite group to get priority in vaccination, Senate assured,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)

Meanwhile…
On the same day, the Pak­is­tan Civil Aviation Autho­rity (PCAA) extended its travel ban on South Africa, Brazil, Ireland, Portugal and the Netherlands and UK till February 28 following the surge in coronavirus cases in these countries. (Mohammad Asghar, “Travel curbs on six countries extended till Feb 28,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
“We are only against those who are involved in creating insecurity for our people,” says PTM
On 29 January, PTM leader Manzoor Pashteen stated that they are not against any individual, community or institution, however, that they will keep raising their voice against alleged extra-judicial killings. Further, he said, “we are only against those who are involved in creating insecurity for our people,” adding, “we want to walk along with people from all walks of life to raise the voice of unvoiced and helpless people.” (Kalbe Ali “PTM not against any community, institution: Pashteen,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)

Fafen warns govt against hasty legislation on Senate poll process
On 29 January, the Free and Fair Election Network (Fafen) in a statement cautioned the federal government and political parties to ensure detailed consultations to reach a consensus decision on reforming the Senate election process instead of opting for hasty legislation without weighing its pros and cons. The statement added, “Fafen considers it unwise to rush through a constitutional amendment for allowing an open ballot with only a month remaining for fresh elections.” (“Fafen cautions govt against hasty legislation on Senate poll process,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)

Special plane to bring back first batch of Covid-19 vaccines from China, says NCOC
On 30 January, the NCOC announced that a special plane will fly to China on 31 January to bring back the first batch of the 500,000 does of Covid-19 vaccine that China earlier promised to send. Further, the NCOC said, “All necessary measures have been put in place for vaccine storage at Islamabad and [transporting] of vaccine to various federating units particularly to Sindh and Balochistan through air.” (“Special plane to fly to China tomorrow to bring back first batch of Covid-19 vaccines: NCOC,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)

Sindh government was doing negative politics, says Shibli Faraz
On 29 January, Shibli Faraz, Minister for Information and Broadcasting stated that corruption is deep-rooted in Pakistan that it could not be eliminated in two and a half years. Further, he stated that instead of creating hurdles in the projects, adding that the Sindh government was doing negative politics, rather he stated that the Sindh government should ensure that province develops. (“Corruption deep-rooted in Pakistan: Shibli Faraz,” The News International, 30 January 2021)

EXTERNAL
COAS meet with Qatar leadership
On 29 January, COAS General Qamar Javed Bajwa, who is on a two-day official visit met with the Emir of Qatar Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani and military leadership. During the meetings, the two sides discussed matters of mutual interest, defence and security cooperation and regional geopolitical environment. Further, the COAS emphasised on the importance of enhancing cooperation between the armed forces of the two countries. (“Bajwa holds security talks with Qatar leadership,” Dawn, 30 January 2021)

 

"Pakistan has failed to take adequate measures to enhance the wellbeing, prosperity and conveniences for its ordinary citizens. We need to lift our exploitative and callous knees from the necks of our poor and downtrodden so they too can breathe more freely."
- An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'Social Security for all'

 

 


Supreme Court orders release of Omar Sheikh


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 29 January 2021
The present Establishment charges a former ISI Chief
Lt Gen Asad Durrani, a former Director-General of the ISI (1990-91) and Director General of the Military Intelligence (1988-99), and later Pakistan's Ambassador to Germany and Saudi Arabia, never would have thought, he would be placed in the Exit Control List (ECL) of Pakistan. The ECL prevents an individual from leaving the country; and that is precisely what the Defence Ministry of Pakistan wants to do now with Gen Durrani, on charges of "interacting with hostile elements."

Gen Durrani's offence was co-authoring a book titled The Spy Chronicles: RAW, ISI and the Illusion of Peace, with an India – Mr AS Dulat; the latter was head of India's RAW during 1999-2000. After retirement, Dulat also served as an advisor on J&K in the Prime Minister Officer. Later, both Dulat and Durrani became a part of numerous Indo-Pak Track-II dialogues organised by various institutions within the region and outside. These dialogues took place in various venues from Dubai to Bangkok; people from various fields from military to media took part in these dialogues.

Unfortunately, Gen Durrani is being singled out inside Pakistan. Other senior officers from police, military and bureaucracy, and former Ambassadors took place in these dialogues. While not all of them have written, there were occasional joint writings. But none have elicited the response that the book by Durrani and Dulat has. According to a Dawn report, "After the book's publication, the Military Intelligence (MI) had written to the interior ministry to put Durrani's name on the ECL and the same was done in May 2018." Gen Durrani was summoned in 2018 by the GHQ following the above book. The DG-ISPR tweeted: "Lt Gen Asad Durrani, Retired being called in GHQ on 28th May 18. Will be asked to explain his position on views attributed to him in book 'Spy Chronicles'. Attribution taken as violation of Military Code of Conduct applicable on all serving and retired military personnel." 

Why should the Establishment target only Gen Durrani? What about the other military and police officials who have also interacted with the Indians in various Track-II dialogues? This contradicts what Pakistan says in public – that it wants to have a dialogue with India.
 
Pakistan Today at 1900 hrs

On Daniel Pearl’s case, the Sindh government files a review petition
A day after the Supreme Court ordered the release of Omar Sheikh, accused of kidnapping and beheading Daniel Pearl, the Sindh government has filed a review petition in the Supreme Court. A three member bench of Pakistan’s Supreme Court gave its verdict on Thursday; a detailed verdict is expected later.

The Secretary of State calls the decision on Daniel Pearl’s killers as “an affront to terrorism victims everywhere, including in Pakistan”
Following the Supreme Court’s order on Thrusday, the US Department of State released a statement by the new Secretary of State – Antony Blinken. According to the statement: “The United States is deeply concerned by the Pakistani Supreme Court’s decision to acquit those involved in Daniel Pearl’s kidnapping and murder and any proposed action to release them. Ahmad Omar Saeed Sheikh was indicted in the United States in 2002 for hostage-taking and conspiracy to commit hostage-taking, resulting in the murder of Pearl, the South Asia Bureau Chief for the Wall Street Journal, as well as the 1994 kidnapping of another United States citizen in India.  The court’s decision is an affront to terrorism victims everywhere, including in Pakistan. The United States recognizes past Pakistani actions to hold Omar Sheikh accountable and notes that Sheikh currently remains detained under Pakistani law. We expect the Pakistani government to expeditiously review its legal options to ensure justice is served. We take note of the Attorney General’s statement that he intends to seek review and recall of the decision. We are also prepared to prosecute Sheikh in the United States for his horrific crimes against an American citizen.  We are committed to securing justice for Daniel Pearl’s family and holding terrorists accountable.”

Cricket: Pakistan wins the first test against South Africa in Karachi
Finally, there are smiles in the cricketing field. After a torturous New Zealand tour earlier, Pakistan beat South Africa in the first test match with a comfortable margin. The second and final test match would be played during the first week of February in Rawalpindi.
 
In Focus
Supreme Court orders release of Omar Sheikh
A complete travesty of justice, says editorial

Image Source: Dawn
 

On 28 January, the Supreme Court, in a majority judgement by a three-member bench,  acquitted Omar Sheikh of Daniel Pearl’s murder. The bench was headed by Justice Mushir Alam and comprised Justice Sardar Tariq Masood and Justice Yahya Afridi. The judgement called for the release of Omar and other accused “if not required to be detained in connection.” 

Justice Afridi dismissed Omar’s appeal
Justice Afridi, however, allowed for the appeals against acquittal of Syed Salman Saqib and Shaikh Muhammad Adil under various sections of the Pakistan Penal Code and the Anti-Terrorism Act of 1997. Dismissing the appeal of Omar to overturn the Sindh HC judgement which sentenced him to death, Justice Afridi, maintained the acquittal of Syed and Shaikh (by the HC) “on all the charges and said they would be released from jail forthwith if not required to be detained in any other case.” 

Petition to review and recall of acquittal on the cards
Dawn reported that a review petition to recall Omar’s acquittal will be filed soon. A spokesperson of the office of the Attorney General said that the federal government would support the Sindh government for the same. 

Utter failure of criminal justice system, says editorial
An editorial in The Express Tribune says the mystery behind Daniel’s murder is a reflection of the “utter failure” of those associated with Pakistan’s criminal justice system. The editorial terms this a matter of great shame and concludes, “A complete travesty of justice!” (“Pearl murder mystery,” The Express Tribune, 29 January 2021)

 

Pakistan loses four points on corruption index
Imran says report used data from 2017 and 2018

Image Source: Dawn

On 28 January, the Transparency Interna­tional released its Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) 2020 was released and Pakistan ranked 124 out of 180; 0 being “very clean” and 180 being “highly corrupt.” Pakistan slipped four positions - from 120 in 2019 to 124 in 2020 - indicating that the level of corruption had worsened. Further, Pakistan’s score fell from 32 to 31. This has been attributed to the low scores in these categories: Rule of Law Index and Verities of Democracy. 

Imran discusses report with party and government 
Despite the low scores and fall in ranking, PM Imran Khan appreciated the report. He said the report was prepared based on data from 2017 and 2018. The SAPM Shahbaz Gill explained Pakistan’s score was lowered because in the Rule of Law Index, Pakistan scored 25 points in 2020 against 27 points in 2019; in the Verities of Democracy, Pakistan was given 22 points compared to 27 points in 2019. 

However, Transparency International has not clarified Imran's claims on the period covered in the report. (Amin Ahmed, “Pakistan loses four points on graft perception ranking,” Dawn, 29 January 2021)

 

Present proof of Asad’s alleged anti-state activities, says editorial
Book does not leak any secret, opines Dawn

Image Source: Dawn

An editorial in Dawn, written in the backdrop of the Defence Ministry’s claims about Asad Durrani’s alleged links with RAW, says such claims should be made only if they can be backed by solid evidence. The editorial says if the Ministry has any proof against Asad having indulged in anti-state activities, then it must present the evidence to strengthen its case. According to Dawn, the book does not leak any “secret” and does not reflect that Asad was “involved in anti-state activities.” Therefore, it suggests that the best way to resolve the issue is to try Asad in an open court, in order to keep the process transparent and also set a precedent that nobody, including a former general, is above law and can be held accountable. (“Where’s the proof?” Dawn, 29 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
FM Qureshi hopeful that Pakistan will be delisted from FATF grey list next month
On 28 January, FM Shah Mehmood Qureshi expressed confidence that the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), would delist Pakistan from its grey list at its next plenary meeting scheduled for February 22 to 25. Further, he said that he was optimistic that no politically motivated decision would be taken and that he is expecting a positive decision as the country has made “substantial progress” on the remaining six items that are pending from the 27-point action plan. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Qureshi hopeful country will get out of FATF grey list next month,” Dawn, 29 January 2022)

Govt notifies terms of reference of the Broadsheet Inquiry Commission
On 28 January, the government notified the terms of reference (ToR) of the Broadsheet Inquiry Commission authorising it to investigate corruption cases surfaced since 1990. According to the ToR, the commission would “identify the incidents and cases relating to recovery efforts and legal proceedings pursued by the government of Pakistan since the year 1990 in foreign jurisdictions for recovery of unlawfully removed money or illegally acquired assets, but were closed, abandoned and/or withdrawn without any valid reason or justification resulting in colossal losses to the country.” Meanwhile, PBC, SCBA have express serious reservations over the appointment of Azmat Saeed as head of the inquiry panel. (“Broadsheet probe body ToR notified,” Dawn, 29 January 2022)

Mangal Bagh killed in a mine explosion in Nangarhar province of Afghanistan
On 28 January, Mangal Bagh, chief of Lashkar-i-Islam (LI) was killed in a mine explosion in Nangarhar province of Afghanistan. Nangarhar’s Governor confirmed the news via Twitter saying, “Mangal Bagh, also known as Mangal Bagh Afridi, the leader of Lashkar-i-Islam, a militant organisation operating in (erstwhile) Khyber Agency, has been killed in a roadside explosion in Achin district along with three others.” (Ibrahim Shinwari, “Blast in Afghanistan kills Mangal Bagh,” Dawn, 29 January 2022)

ECONOMY
ADB to provide about USD 5.4 billion assistance to Pakistan
On 28 January, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) announced that it would provide about USD 5.4 billion assistance to Pakistan over the next three years (2021-2023) as part of the ADB’s five-year Country Partnership Strategy (CPS). The back stated that this would include USD 3.6 billion for regular OCR (ordinary capital resource) lending and USD 1.8 billion for concessional OCR lending. Further, an additional grant resource has been allocated for a project in 2021 from the Asian Development Fund thematic pool worth USD 5 million to increase gender equity. (“ADB to provide $5.4bn assistance to Pakistan in three years,” Dawn, 29 January 2022)

EXTERNAL
FO emphasises on the need for a closer engagement with the US for regional stability
On 28 January, Foreign Office spokesman stated that Pakistan wants closer engagement with the United States for regional stability, adding that Islamabad valued its ties with Washington, which had helped maintain regional peace and stability. Further, the spokesman said, “We have achieved a lot by working together in the past. The logic for continued engagement and coordination is even more compelling in the context of shared geopolitical and security challenges.” (“Pakistan wants closer engagement with US for regional stability,” Dawn, 29 January 2022)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Increasing the number of non-permanent members in the UNSC is a better option, says editorial
An editorial in The Express Tribune critical of the debate over the expansion of the UN Security Council (UNSC) says that a move without consensus would risk the further bogging down the good work the UN does. In this regard, the editorial reiterates Pakistan’s stance which is to increase the number of non-permanent members and increase their terms, as this would be a better approach to help smaller nations make their voices heard while avoiding letting a fascistic government further constrain the body. (“UNSC expansion,” The Express Tribune, 29 January 2022)

 

"Resurrecting Pakistan is a Herculean task...But if divisions keep driving us apart, there is no prospect of coming together around a mutually agreeable formula to make progress. In such an event, the only choice left would be to move forward because a stage comes when falling back is no longer an option."
- An opinion in The News International
on 'Resurrecting Pakistan'

 

 


Former ISI chief had links with RAW since 2008: Defence Ministry


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 28 January 2021
Releasing Daniel Pearl’s killer
Today (Thursday), the Supreme Court of Pakistan ordered the authorities to release the primary accused – Ahmad Omar Saeed Sheikh in the case of brutal beheading of Daniel Pearl in February 2002. Pearl was a journalist with the Wall Street Journal, when he was kidnapped in Karachi, and subsequently beheaded, his body cut into multiple pieces. Omar Sheikh has been accused of his kidnapping, which even he had agreed to. Omar Sheikh, was a British citizen, born to Pakistani parents who had migrated in the late 1960s. Despite getting an admission in the prestigious London School of Economics, Omar Sheikh got radicalized, after his tours to Bosnia in early 1990s. He was caught by the Indian security forces, and was serving a prison sentence, when he was released following the hijacking of an Indian Airlines flight to Kabul in 1999.

Why was Omar Sheikh asked to be released by India? Who asked for his release, in return for the release of Indian Airlines flight and its passengers? How did he end up in Karachi? And what was his connection to Daniel Pearl? Since Sheikh himself has agreed (a three page letter that he wrote in 2019) that he had a limited or minor role in Pearl’s killing, how limited or minor was that role?

The above questions should have been probed and proved without any doubt. Unfortunately, the investigation and the trial could not satisfy the learned Sindh High Court on Omar Sheikh’s involvement. In 2020, the Sindh High Court asked the government to release Sheikh, for his role in the beheading could not be proved. The case went to the Supreme Court, which has today ordered for the release of Omar Sheikh.

Investigation has been one of the primary problems inside Pakistan, that has let many accused go free – whether in social crimes, gender violence and acts relating to terrorism. One of the primary question that the FATF also has raised is the quality of investigation. 

Omar Sheikh’s release should open more questions, than solving any.

 

Pakistan Today at 1900 hrs


Pakistan slides further in the Corruption Index
According to the latest report published by the Transparency International, Pakistan has moved from 120 in 2019, to 124 in 2020. In 2018, it was ranked 117. The slide in ranking should be a cause for concern for the PTI government, questioning the latter’s accountability drive and the lofty claims. Sherry Rahman, the PPP Senator has rightly questioned the government, when she claimed: “The focus is on NAB and the government's political opponents, not corruption.”

PIA plane to leave for China tomorrow to bring the vaccines on Saturday; vaccination expected to begin next week
According to the health ministry, a PIA plane would leave on Friday to Beijing to get 500,000 vaccines that are being donated by China. Asad Umar, a federal minister and the head of the National Command and Operation Centre (NCOC), tweeted: “Inshallah, the vaccination of frontline health workers will start next week.”

In Focus
Former ISI chief had links with RAW since 2008: Defence Ministry
Durrani claims to have been punished accordingly
 
Image Source: Dawn
 

On 27 January, the Ministry of Defence alleged that former ISI Asad Durrani has been “interacting with hostile elements specially Indian RAW [Research and Analysis Wing] since 2008.” The allegation was made when Asad requested the Islamabad High Court to remove his name from the Exit Control List (ECL). 

Already been punished, claims Durrani 
Asad had been placed on the ECL in 2018 after he co-authored a book “The Spy Chronicles: RAW, ISI and the Illusion of Peace” with Amarjit Singh Dulat. The Defence Ministry said the book had contents regarding  Pakistan’s security  and was a violation of the Official Secret Act.

In his latest petition before the IHC, Asad said his name has not been removed from the ECL despite the fact that the probe into the book had been concluded and he had been “punished accordingly.” 

Ministry refuses to remove name from ECL
The Ministry, on the other hand, justified keeping Asad on the ECL saying the inquiry was still in the final stage. It held that the Asad was intending to travel abroad to participate in international conferences and other platforms which could lead to “serious national security implications.” The Ministry cited his new co-authored book, Honour Among Spies, as a bargaining point and said this book was also published “through Indian publishers/RAW supported elements.” (Malik Asad, “Ministry links ex-ISI chief to RAW,” Dawn, 28 January 2021) (Zahid Gishkori, “Asad Durrani was affiliated with RAW since 2008: MOD,” The News International, 28 January 2021)

 

Kuala Lumpur HC orders release of PIA plane
Peregrine Aviation agreed for out-of-court settlement, says Aviation Minister

 
Image Source: Dawn

On 27 January, Kuala Lumpur High Court ordered the release of the PIA aircraft that had been seized earlier this month. The Court made its decision after the PIA and Peregrine Aviation Charlie Limited reached an agreement over the non-payment of lease by the PIA. Pakistan’s Federal Minister for Aviation said it had reached an agreement with the lessor Peregrine Aviation to hold  an out-of-court settlement. 

Meanwhile… 
The Minister blamed the PML-N government for acquiring the two planes in question for ‘expensive’ lease that PIA could not pay during the pandemic in 2020. He accused the previous government for implementing “poor policies” with regard to the PIA. He  claimed that previous governments appointed people with fake degrees thereby ruining the organisation. (“Malaysian court releases PIA’s grounded plane,” Dawn, 28 January 2021)

 

Azmat was part of a conspiracy against Nawaz government: Maryam
Says former judge must quit the commission


Image Source: Dawn

On 27 January, Maryam Nawaz told retired judge Azmat Saeed to “bow out respectfully from the Broadsheet scam probe or risk more revelations about his role against the elected [PML-N] government,” adding, “Who does not know how he [Justice Azmat] influenced the formation and working of the Joint Investigation Team (JIT) against an elected government. It was he who made [in]famous WhatsApp calls to get people he can influence in the JIT and ensure desired results against an elected prime minister.” Further, she accused him of being part of a conspiracy against an elected government and then prime minister Nawaz Sharif, adding that he must quit the commission. (Ahmad Fraz Khan, “Quit or face revelations, Maryam warns Azmat,” Dawn, 28 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
COVID-19 vaccination drive to start next week 
On 27 January, Minister for Planning, Development and Special Initiatives tweeted, “The system for vaccination is in place. Hundreds of vaccination centres in the country will be administering covid vaccine. Inshallah the vaccination of frontline health workers will start next week.” Further, the minister the general population in the age group of 65 and above will receive their shots from March. (Ikram Junaidi, “Pakistan to start vaccination next week, says minister,” Dawn, 28 January 2021)

ECONOMY
Circular debt in the power sector not new but must be addressed says editorial
An editorial in The News International critical of the power sector in the country says that circular debt in the power sector has been a problem that goes back decades. To address these issues the federal government has taken a new measure to try and prevent this debt and to bring it down, both under pressure from the IMF and IPPs. With issues continuing to persist, the editorial says that if the circular debt is lowered by forcing industries to buy electricity from the grid, things should get better. However, the government should ensure that no further damage is caused to the economy and exports. (“Challenging circular debt,” Dawn, 28 January 2021)

EXTERNAL
China and Pakistan agree to form joint parliamentary panel soon to oversee CPEC
On 27 January, National Assembly Speaker and Chairman of the Chinese National Peoples Congress (NPC) agreed on the formation of a joint parliamentary committee for effective oversight and monitoring of the CPEC. Further, the two agreed that enhanced parliamentary and economic cooperation between the two parliaments would give impetus to the existing bilateral relations. (“Pakistan-China joint parliamentary panel soon to oversee CPEC,” Dawn, 28 January 2021)

Pakistan to contribute 25,000 USD for UN peacekeeping fund
On 27 January, FM Shah Mehmood Qureshi pledged a contribution of 25,000 USD from Pakistan to the UN Secretary General’s Peace-Building Fund (PBF) stating that the move highlighted Pakistan’s longstanding political, human and financial commitment to the UN’s endeavours for peacekeeping and peace-building. Further, he reiterated Pakistan’s support for the UN’s peacekeeping and peace-building efforts while calling for addressing the root causes of conflicts for ensuring sustainable peace. (Baqir Sajjad Syed “Pakistan pledges $25,000 for UN peacekeeping fund,” Dawn, 28 January 2021)

Pakistan and Kuwait keen on expanding ties
On 27 January, Pakistan and Kuwait stated that they were keen to expand their bilateral relations. This statement cames as a meeting took place between FM Shah Mehmood Qureshi and Kuwait’s Assistant Foreign Minister on Asian Affairs Ambassador Ali Suleman Al-Saeed. The meeting was part of the third round of Bilateral Political Consultations (BPC), which are taking place after over four years. Further, the two sides showed keenness on enhancing ties in diverse areas. (“Pakistan, Kuwait vow to expand ties,” Dawn, 28 January 2021)

 

"If Pakistan positions itself as a key player on climate change, it can guarantee itself a long-term, strategic voice on climate change priorities in the developing world, as a pathway to a greater say on other matters of international political and economic significance."
- An opinion in in Dawn on 'Climate change'

 


Cabinet to table bill to hold open vote in Senate elections


Photo: The Express Tribune



PR Editorial, 27 January 2021
Not so open reasons for why the government wants an open ballot for the Senate elections
The ruling PTI wants to conduct the forthcoming Senate elections (in February 2021) through an open ballot. The Opposition has been against this, and wants to hold it through a secret ballot. On the issue, the government has already approached the Supreme Court, through a Presidential reference.

Now, the government wants to table a new bill in the Parliament, that would provide the legal space for the PTI to hold the Senate election, through open ayes. The stated reason is, that it would make the elections transparent and ensure, everyone knows who votes for whom. The government says, this would prevent horse trading.

There has been a larger debate across the democracies on the need to hold elections through a secret ballot; and there are stronger reasons why the majority countries have adopted a secret ballot. The reason is simple – it allows one to exercise the vote without fear, one of the basic principles of democracies.

The PTI fears, given the history of Pakistan’s Parliament, the Opposition would use unfair practices to get the votes in the Senate. If there is an issue within the Parliament, or the history of Senate elections, then the ruling party has to sit with the Opposition and finalise a road map. The Opposition parties today, may become the ruling party tomorrow, and may want to use the same argument. Hence a consensus would be better, than bulldozing through an amendment, and win it because the PTI has the necessary votes.

If transparency is a reason, then all elections have to be held through an open ballot! In principle, one may want to accept the PTI’s argument, but a political reasoning of the same would reveal a larger spirit behind it.
 
Pakistan Today at 1900 hrs

PIA: Malaysia Court orders the release of Pakistan International Airlines plane
Today (Wednesday), a Court in Malaysia ordered the release of a Boeing 777 aircraft belonging to the PIA plane. The aircraft was impounded on 18 January 2020, on an earlier verdict by the Malaysian Court relating a leasing case filed. According to news reports, the PIA has settled the issue last week. 

Maryam Nawaz says the disagreements within the PDM are resolved amicably
Today, Maryam Nawaz in Lahore addressed the question of differences within the PDM components. According to a news report, she declared that there is exemplary coordination within the PDM, and “even if there is a disagreement on any matter within the PDM, it is resolved in an amicable manner.”

Is Fazlur Rahman upset with the PPP and PML-N?
According to an ARY report, quoting to sources, Fazlur Rahman has expressed his unhappiness over the unilateral decisions of the PPP and PML-N instead of a consensus-based approach by the eleven-member alliance.
 
 
In Focus
Cabinet to table bill to hold open vote in Senate elections
Approves one-man commission of inquiry for Broadsheet probe
 
Image Source: The Express Tribune
 

On 26 January, the federal cabinet decided to present a bill in the National Assembly to amend the Constitution to hold open votes for the Senate elections. Information Minister Shibli Faraz said the government preferred the Senate elections “to be held in a transparent manner and without horse-trading.” He claimed that Senate elections have always witnessed votes being “bought.” He said, those opposing the open ballot suggestions had previously demanded the same. 

Cabinet approves one-man commission to probe Broadsheet scandal
On the same day, the cabinet gave a green signal to constitute “a one-man commission of inquiry comprising retired Justice Azmat Saeed” to investigate the Broadsheet scandal. Azmat is expected to submit the investigation reports in 45 days. Shibli said it was time for everyone to know “who played what role in the destruction of the national economy.” (Syed Irfan Raza, “Govt decides to amend constitution for Senate election,” Dawn, 27 January 2021)

 

Seminaries hold protests against Waqf Properties Act
Lahore seminaries to submit suggestions on registration process


Image Source: Dawn

On 26 January, clerics and seminary students held demonstrations outside the National Press Club against the Islamabad Capital Territory Waqf Properties Act, 2020. The protesters held that the government had “backstabbed” and felt their integrity had been violated.  They said would continue to boycott the registration process. 

However, Education Minister Shafqat Mehmood said the seminaries had  assured the government that they would follow the registration process. He said registrations “will be done and we will get it done.”

The Waqf Properties Act 
The Act was passed as a law in September 2020 as a part of the FATF legislation. Under this, madrassas were required to register in their respective districts. Since then, the seminaries under the banner of Tehreek-i-Tahaffuz-i-Masajid-o-Madaris Islamabad said the Act was un-Islamic and was an attempt to alter the ideological status of Pakistan. 

Meanwhile..
The five seminary boards in Lahore five mainstream, under the banner of Ittehad-i-Tanzeemat Madaris Pakistan, and decided to suggest procedures on the registration of seminaries. They held that since the government had not yet chalked out a roadmap, they would suggest methods to expedite the process. (Kalbe Ali, “Streamlining of seminaries hits snag, again,” Dawn, 27 January 2021)

 

One-man commission constituted to look beyond Broadsheet 
Commission to have same power of contempt as enjoyed by high courts

Image Source: Dawn

On 26 January, the federal cabinet decided to constitute a one-man commission under the Pakistan Commission of Inquiry Act, 2017 to look beyond the broadsheet case as well as other scandals. Former Supreme Court judge Azmat Saeed Sheikh has been appointed as head of the inquiry commission. (Nasir Iqbal, “Broadsheet probe empowered to dig deep into past,” The Express Tribune, 27 January 2020)

Further, the commission will have the power under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The commission is to complete its probe within 45 days and its terms of reference (TORs) are likely to be formally announced on 27 January (today). (Rizwan Shehzad, “Cabinet gives nod to Broadsheet commission,” The Express Tribune, 27 January 2020)

 

In Brief
INTERNAL
PTI files foreign funding case with the ECP against JUI-F
On 27 January, Dawn reported that the PTI has filed with the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) an application demanding an inquiry into allegations that JUI-F chief Fazlur Rehman and other party leaders frequently visited and received funding Libya and Iraq. In the application addressed to the chief election commissioner a PTI MNA referred to disclosures made by former JUI-F spokesman Hafiz Hussain Ahmed. (Iftikhar A. Khan, “PTI files foreign funding case against JUI-F,” Dawn, 27 January 2020)

PLM-N withdraws NAB bill in accordance with PDM’s decision
On 26 January, the PLM-N withdrew a private member’s bill seeking an amendment to the National Accounta­bility Ordinance, 1999, in the National Assembly in accordance with the decision of the PDM. Previously, the PDM announced that the opposition would not support any government move to change the country’s accountability laws. (Amir Wasim, “PML-N withdraws NAB bill in line with PDM decision,” Dawn, 27 January 2020)

Foreign funding case is more than just a legal question, says article 
An article in Dawn says that over the last few weeks the PTI’s “foreign funding” case has resurged back into the limelight with the Opposition parties relying on the case to question Prime Minister Imran Khan’s patriotism. However, on the other hand, after years of opposing scrutiny of PTI’s financial records, PM Imran Khan is not resorting to calling for open hearings before the ECP to demonstrate the party’s innocence. The article says that it seems like the legal consequences of an adverse finding by the ECP might not be as dire for the PTI, however, this case should not be seen from a myopic legal lens alone. (Reema Omer, “
Twists and turns in PTI’s legal battle for survival,” Dawn, 27 January 2020)

EXTERNAL
PML-N is always a great friend of the Chinese Communist Party says outgoing Consul General China
On 27 January, The News International reported that the outgoing Consul General of the China Long Dingbin in a letter to PML-N President Shahbaz Sharif stated that the PML-N is always a great friend of Chinese Communist Party whether it is in power or opposition. Further, the Consul General said that he was impressed by Shahbaz’s devotion to the construction of the CPEC while being the position of chief minister Punjab. (“PML-N chief submits diplomat’s letter to AC: Chinese envoy impressed by Shahbaz’s devotion to CPEC,” The News International, 27 January 2020)

 


Government is "begging before the opposition for talks" says Maryam


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 26 January 2021
South Africa returns to Pakistan, after 14 years
Today (26 January 2021), the first day of the first test match between Pakistan and South Africa started in Karachi. South Africa has returned to Pakistan after 14 years, to play two test matches in Karachi and Rawalpindi, and three T-20 matches – all of them in Lahore. During November 2020, Zimbabwe cricket team visited Pakistan to play three one day and three T-20 matches. All these matches were played in Rawalpindi. Earlier in January 2020, Bangladesh visited Pakistan for two test, and three T-20 matches; but the later part had to be postponed due to COVID-19 pandemic.

This has been a positive development since the terrorist attack on a visiting Sri Lankan team in 2009. The return of South Africa also highlights the return of big-ticket cricket teams to Pakistan. This highlights both the country's confidence and about playing in Pakistan by the visiting teams. However, the games are being held in a few venues – Karachi, Lahore and Rawalpindi. Expanding the venues need confidence – both by the hosts and the visitors.

Return of international cricket is essential to build the team in Pakistan. Though Pakistan visited New Zealand and England in the recent period, playing at home provides extra confidence. This is much needed for the present team. Also, for Pakistan, cricket is more than just a game. Given the passion and relief that the game brings to Pakistan, the State needs to build further on this.
 
Pakistan Today at 1900 hrs
 
Pakistan Senate Elections: Asif Ali Zardari suggests that the Opposition contest under the PDM banner
Early next month, Pakistan would face elections for the Senate, with more than 50 Senators of the total 104 retiring on 7 February 2021. Zardari has suggested that the Opposition proposing joint candidates would help the PDM members secure more seats. Separately, there is a controversy over whether the Senate election should be held through a secret ballot, or through an open ballot. In December 2020, the President has approached the Supreme Court for an opinion. The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) has informed the SC in January 2021, that under Article 226, the Senate elections were always held through a secret ballot.

Pakistan is against the expansion of the UN Security Council
Amb Munir Akram, Pakistan’s Permanent Representative to the United Nations, while addressing the first meeting of Intergovernmental Negotiations Framework, has stated that Pakistan would oppose creating new permanent seats in the UN Security Council.

Pakistan and South Africa: First test, first day in Karachi
South Africa returned to Pakistan after 14 years to play a test and one day series. At the end of day one of the first test match in Karachi, the visitors were all out for 220. In reply, Pakistan has lost four wickets for 33 runs.
 
In Focus
Government is "begging before the opposition for talks" says Maryam 
Opposition backs out from talks
 
Image Source: The News International
 

On 25 January, Maryam Nawaz told reporters that the Opposition had decided not to hold any dialogue with the government despite the government “begging” the Opposition. The PML-N, after its party meeting, also decided that it was not practical to pass a no-confidence motion against the PM, thereby declining the PPP’s suggestion. She reiterated that the PML-N stands by the commitment of Nawaz Sharif. (Amir Wasim, “PML-N rules out talks with govt on any issue,” Dawn, 26 January 2021) However, Maryam said Bilawal Bhutto would be called on to explain his proposal to hold a no-confidence motion before the PDM to hold further discussions. Further, she confirmed that the Opposition would submit their resignations and conduct their long march. (Asim Yasin and Muhammad Anis, “PDM to discuss Bilawal's idea: There'll be long march, resignations, says Maryam,” The News International, 26 January 2021)

Oppositions drops idea of holding talks with government
On the same day, the Opposition and government were supposed to hold talks to lower the political temperature; however the former backed out. The decision to drop the talks came after the PML-N held its party meeting in the Parliament House. Further, the Opposition placed placards of jailed leaders in the NA and planned to hold protests against the government if they gathered the required quorum. However, due to lack of quorum, the protests were put off. The PPP said they did not meet with the government team because the PML-N was busy with its party meeting. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Opposition backs out from talks with govt,” Dawn, 26 January 2021)

Editorial asks Opposition to arrive at a consensus in its strategy 
An editorial in The News International, attempting to understand the Bhutto-Zardari move to pass a no-confidence motion against Imran, says “there is a distinct difference in the strategy that (opposition) leaders believe should be pursued.” The editorial urges the PDM parties to arrive at a consensus so that it “can play a bigger part in governance,” and serve  “the people, all the parties and their elected representatives serve.” It, however, appreciates the government and opposition parties are making an attempt to hold talks. Further, it calls on the Opposition to provide a plan of action if they come to power. (“Counting the numbers,” The News International, 26 January 2021)

 

"NAB not impartial" says Dawn Editorial
Calls for complete review of organisation’s legal and political mandate


Image Source: Dawn

An editorial in Dawn, says the Broadsheet scandal has revealed that the NAB is not only compromised but is also incompetent. The editorial terms NAB’s hiring of the Broadsheet firm “shady” and its contract with the company “shoddy.” It recalls that over the last few years, the NAB has been hounding Opposition leaders and turning a blind eye to the “shady doings inside the government.” This, it says, has tarnished the credibility of the anti-graft body. It concludes that the “NAB is a deeply flawed entity functioning on the basis of an equally flawed law” and says that to reform the NAB, there needs to be a review of its “entire legal and political mandate.” With this, the editorial debunks the NAB chief’s claims that the organisation is impartial.

Attributes current functioning to weak foundations
The editorial attributes the above to the weak foundation of the NAB; it was initiated by Pervez Musharraf to target opposition leaders and whenever the NAB tried monitoring leaders who supported Musharraf, it was stopped from doing so. It says this trend has been continuing till date and the NAB has been unable to shed the impression that it is a handmaiden for the government in power. (“NAB not impartial,” Dawn, 26 January 2021)

 

Electricity workers hold protests against privatisation of distribution companies
Union leader calls for review and introduction of reforms

Image Source: Dawn

On 25 January, electricity workers belonging across Pakistan held protests against proposed  privatisation of 11 electricity distribution companies and two profitable thermal power houses and the proposed closure of five  Muzaffargarh, thermal power houses. The General Secretary of the All Pakistan Wapda Hydroelectric Workers Union (CBA) requested Imran Khan to review these proposals. He cited that the privatisation of the Karachi Electric Supply Company had failed “despite federal government financing KESC for Rs 1300 billion” over the years. Further, circular debt had increased manifold, from Rs 184 billion from 2013 to Rs 860 billion in 2020. He suggested that instead of privatising electricity, the PM could “introduce reforms, stop heavy capacity payment to the IPPs and provide safety to the field staff against criminals to prevent electricity theft.” ("Privatisation of 11 distribution companies: Electricity workers hold rallies across country," The News International, 26 January 2021)

In Brief
INTERNAL
Opposition would get nothing out of the foreign funding case against the PTI, says PM Khan
On 25 January, PM Imran Khan said that the opposition would not get anything from the foreign funding case against the PTI as they have a clean background, arguing, “We did not receive any funding from ‘banned’ countries — India and Israel.” He said, “The opposition has fallen into the ditch it dug for us.” Further, as reported to Dawn, PM Khan is quite confident that his party would win the foreign funding case as the PTI did not hide anything related to receiving funds from its supporters and members outside the country. (“PTI will win foreign funding case: Imran,” Dawn, 26 January 2021)

PROVINCE 
Afghan Taliban commander killed in Tarnab
On 25 January, media reports claimed that an Afghan Taliban commander was killed in Tarnab by his rivals last week. Reports claimed that the man killed was Taliban commander Mullah Abdul Samad Toor, who belonged to Sarobi area near Kabul. However, the police stated that a report was registered last week of someone named Mullah Toor who was allegedly killed by his rival Mullah Musa and others when he was coming to the mosque. The police then raided Mullah Musa house but he had managed to escape. (“‘Afghan Taliban commander killed in Peshawar last week’,” The News International, 26 January 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
Progress in intra-Afghan dialogue would lead to a reduction in violence, says FM Qureshi 
On 25 January, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi, in a telephone conversation with his Afghan counterpart Hanif Atmar, raised concern over the surge of violence in Afghanistan and called for progress in the ongoing intra-Afghan talks in Doha. According to Dawn, the FO stated that Qureshi emphasised that progress in the dialogue would “facilitate reduction in violence, leading to ceasefire.” Further, the two discussed matter related to the issue of Pakistani prisoners in Afghan jails, trade ties and strengthening of bilateral relations. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Pakistan pins hopes on progress in intra-Afghan dialogue,” Dawn, 26 January 2021)

ECONOMY
Domestic debt servicing increases by 38 per cent in the first five months
On 26 January, Dawn reported that the latest report of the SBP shows that the country’s domestic debt servicing jumped by 38 per cent in the first five months of this fiscal year, indicating excessive borrowing by the government to address the widening fiscal deficit. Meanwhile, the Monetary Policy Information Compendium for January issued on 22 January showed that both stocks of domestic debt and debt servicing increased during the July-November period of FY21. (Shahid Iqbal, “Five-month domestic debt servicing jumps by 38pc,” Dawn, 26 January 2021)

EXTERNAL
Govt issues Houbara hunting permits to UAE royal family
On 25 January, Dawn reported that the federal government has issued around seven special permits to the President of the United Arab Emirates and other members of the royal family to hunt the internationally-protected bird species houbara bustard during the 2020-21 hunting season. According to the permits, hunting has been allocated in Sindh, Balochistan and Punjab to the crown prince and deputy supreme commander of the armed forces of the country, president’s representative, adviser to the president, a member of the executive council and others. (Bhagwandas, “Houbara hunting permits issued to UAE royal family,” Dawn, 26 January 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Biden has no intention of abandoning the deal or stopping backing the Doha talks says editorial
An editorial in The Express Tribune says that President Joe Biden will not pull a ‘Trumpian’ move and tear up the deal arguing that Biden has shown a long history of sanity and maturity, both political and otherwise. Further, it says that the Biden administration has no intention of abandoning the deal or stopping backing the Doha talks, as reaching the deal’s main goal of peace is important enough to allow for timeline tweaking. However, what is uncertain is if the Taliban and the Afghan government’s will be on board to accept those tweaks. (“Doha deal and Biden,” The Express Tribune, 26 January 2021)

 


Government, opposition to meet today


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Government, opposition to meet today
Cracks within PDM emerge after PPP suggests no-confidence motion

On 25 January (today), the government and opposition will meet to “lower down political temperatures” in Pakistan. Apart from this, the PML-N will also convene a party meeting; the PML-N meeting comes a day after the party’s secretary general opposed the PPP’s suggestion to hold a no confidence motion thereby suggesting a divide within the PDM. (Amir Wasim, “Govt, opposition meet today to lower political temperature,” Dawn, 25 January 2021)

The cracks within the PDM
An editorial in Dawn opines that the PPP should explain its position with regard to PDM. The editorial recalls that the PPP was hesitant towards the idea of resignation and seems to be inching away from the long march. In this context, it says the chances of PPP and PML-N together can pass a no-confidence motion are slim; in case, the alliance cannot pass the motion, it “would strengthen the government’s position and undermine if not decimate the PDM.” (“PPP’s plan?,” Dawn, 25 January 2021)

Similarly, an article in The News International says “history is with the prime minister.” The author says the basic flaw with the PDM is its narrative; while Nawaz attacked the establishment, the PPP has a defensive approach and JUI-F, along with other nationalist parties, kept holding one public meeting after another. He says, hence there is a need for unanimity among the parties. He emphasises that the alliance had no unity from the beginning, and lacks “seriousness and commitment.” (Mazhar Abbas, “Flaws in PDM strategy,” The News International, 25 January 2021)

Meanwhile…
On 24 January, FM Qureshi said the PDM was within its constitutional rights to carry out a no-confidence motion; he was confident that the PTI would defeat the motion. However, he admitted that the PTI will have to address the increasing prices. This, he said, would be a challenge for the PTI. (Shakeel Ahmed, “PTI, allies will defeat no-trust move: Qureshi,” Dawn, 25 January 2021)

Opinion suggests course of action for government
Another opinion in Dawn says the PDM has been unable to challenge the government despite its rhetoric. Therefore the government has the time and space to carry out a number of changes. The author suggests that the government can therefore set its agenda for the coming year.  First, it can engage more actively at the leadership level and chart out the vaccination plan. Second, the government can "recast the cabinet and its team in Punjab." Third,  the government could engage with the business community to attract investment thereby boosting the economic indicators. Fourth, she says the government could plan for comprehensive civil service reform and lastly, review its foreign policy. (Maleeha Lodhi, "Back to governance," Dawn, 25 January 2021)

 
 

MNAs call on PM to discuss package for south Punjab
South Punjab has been neglected, says PM

Image Source: Dawn

On 24 January, Members of National Assembly from south Punjab, Dir and Swat called on the PM and discussed a special package for the South Punjab Secretariat and farmers. The PM said the government would soon announce a package for farmers. Further, MNA from Dir discussed employment opportunities from the dams being constructed in Dir, that could be channelised on priority basis to the population. 

PM emphasises on south Punjab
The PM said setting up a South Punjab Secretariat was a way of introducing developmental projects in the region which, he said, had been ignored in the past and people were kept away from “opportunities in education, health and employment.” (Mumtaz Alvi, “South Punjab was ignored in past: PM Imran,” The News International, 25 January 2021)

 

Any minister should have known better, says editorial
One small blunder has brought further disaster for PIA

Image Source: Dawn

An editorial in The News International critical of the situation Pakistan International Airlines says that one small blunder from a minister who should not be making such mistakes on the floor of the House has brought further disaster for PIA. The editorial critical of the minister’s actions says that aviation minister should not have quoted figures from the faulty report unless there was certain of the information before giving out to the public and the world, but because if that blunder, the country is now witnessing the consequences of these actions.

Further, on whether the country did enough to overcome the damage done, the editorial says that it did not, however, currently, there are grave problems that remain and if PIA is to make any kind of recovery these will have to be attended to without further delay says the editorial. (“The PIA blunder,” The News International, 25 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
CCI to approve the census this month
On 25 January, Dawn reported that the Council of Common Interests (CCI) is likely to approve the Census-2017 at its meeting to be held on 27 January with PM Imran Khan chairing the session. This comes as the federal cabinet after three years had approved the National Census with a dissenting note submitted by the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), one of the government’s allies. (Kashif Abbasi, “CCI likely to approve Census-2017 on 27th,” Dawn, 25 January 2021)

COVID-19 positivity rate drops to 3.96 per cent
On 24 January, Pakistan reported that its positivity ratio remained at 3.96 per cent. According to the NCOC, 1,594 more people tested positive for coronavirus and 48 patients died in a single day, with the total number of deaths surging to 11,295. (Ikram Junaidi, “National Covid-19 positivity ratio drops to 3.96pc,” Dawn, 25 January 2021) Meanwhile, members in the government have stated that the economy is on the upward trajectory, as many economic indicators are witnessing positive trends after facing severe blow in the aftermath of COVID-19 pandemic. (“As Covid-19 effects ebb: Economy on upward trajectory,” The News International, 25 January 2021)

PROVINCE 
Five terrorists killed in North Waziristan
On 25 January, The News International reported that five terrorists, including their two commanders, were killed by security forces as part of the intelligence-based operations (IBOs) in North Waziristan. According to the ISPR, the security forces conducted two IBOs in Mir Ali and Khaisur areas of North Waziristan. The terrorist commanders killed by the forces were identified as Syed Raheem, alias Abid, of the TTP-AKK group, and Saifullah Noor of the TTP-Gohar group. (“Five terrorists, including two commanders, killed in N Waziristan,” The News International, 25 January 2021)

 

 

"While PDM has continued efforts to mount political pressure it has been unable to force a crisis to challenge the PTI government or warrant its full-time attention. This means the government has the chance to get down to serious business and set, as well as, elaborate its agenda for the year ahead."
- An opinion in Dawn on
'Back to governance' by Maleeha Lodhi

 


Oppositions demands new head for Broadsheet inquiry committee


Photo: The News International



In Focus
Oppositions demands new head for Broadsheet inquiry committee
Government has nothing to do with Broadsheet, says Imran

On 23 January, Dawn reported that the Opposition has rejected Azmat Saeed as the head of the Broadsheet inquiry committee. The opposition said Azmat had, previously, been part of a Supreme Court bench that convicted Nawaz Sharif in the Panama Papers scandal. Therefore, the PML-N is demanding “an undisputed and non-controversial person” as the head of the committee. The party also prefers the proceedings to be made public. Similarly, the PPP also rejected the inquiry committee. 

Government defends move
However, the Interior Minister and Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs said that the government had appointed Azmat without any “bad intentions.” The Parliamentary Affairs Minister said “If a judge gives any judgement in a case, it does not mean he is biased.” (Syed Irfan Raza, “Opposition rejects Azmat as Broadsheet probe head,” Dawn, 23 January 2021)

Opinion says Imran should reconsider decision to appoint Azmat
Meanwhile, an opinion in Dawn says the PM should reconsider his decision for the following reasons: the government has already declared its decision on the Broadsheet through a political prism - indicting the Sharifs as the culprits. Further, the author says, the government has not shown the level of transparency in its own foreign funding case; how then does it expect other parties to do so? Next, he outlines that though Moussavi’s revelations may be shady, he has written about developments after the new government took over in 2018. Apart from this, Azmat was also working with the NAB previously. The author therefore concludes that though Azmat may have no faults on his professional credibility, “there are some such issues about his perceptional credibility.” Therefore, Imran could reconsider his decision. (Fahd Hussain, “The fog of Broadsheet,” Dawn, 23 Janaury 2021)

Broadsheet contract was signed by Musharraf, stresses Imran
On 22 January, a private TV channel aired PM Imran Khan’s interview recorded earlier this week. In the interview, Imran said the current government has no relation with Broadsheet. He reiterated that the Broadsheet contract was signed by Musharraf who later unilaterally backtracked on it by issuing an NRO to Nawaz Sharif. (Mumtaz Alvi, “Govt has nothing to do with Broadsheet: PM Imran Khan,” The News International, 23 January 2021)

“Government is trying to confound the confusion further,” says opinion
An opinion in The Express Tribune says the inquiry committee set up to investigate the origins of the Broadsheet scandal seems to be the government’s attempt to divert attention from the questionable role of some government officials since. He stresses that the inquiry committee should look into post-verdict developments rather than trace origins of “the irrevocable agreement between NAB and Broadsheet and its illegal revocation.” He also urges the government to investigate Moussavi’s claims including that officials from the current government approached him for bribes. (Muhammad Ziauddin, “Confounding the confusion,” The Express Tribune, 23 January 2021)

 

UN cautions staff against flying by Pakistani-registered airlines
PIA pays partial lease amount to leasing company
 

Image Source: Dawn

On 23 January, The News International reported that the UN Security Management System (UNSMS) had cautioned their staff across the world not to travel by any Pakistan-registered airline, including the PIA, over concerns on the “allegedly dubious flying licences of its pilots.” The UN extended its caution to the WHO, UNDP, UNHCR, FAO, UNESCO and the like. This notification would therefore restrict UN officials from flying domestically in Pakistan. 

However, The News International held that the UNSMS did not flag other airlines of other countries which have  under-performing civil aviation authorities including some registered in Afghanistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan. (Tariq Butt, “Aftermath of dubious pilot licences controversy: UN cautions staff not to fly by any Pakistan-registered airline,” The News International, 23 January 2021)

Meanwhile…
On 22 January, the PIA informed the London High Court it had paid USD 7 million to the Peregrine Aviation Charlie Limited over the lease of two planes, one which had been seized in Malaysia earlier in January. The lawyer for PIA requested adjournment of the case for a later date to complete the payment. 

Peregrine Aviation filed case against PIA in October 2020
The lawyer said the PIA had not paid the lease “since it asked for the amendment to its claim in July.” Following this, in October 2020, the aviation company filed its case against the PIA; however, the PIA asked for reduction in charges claiming that the pandemic had hit the aviation industry. However, the leasing company pursued the movement of the PIA flights in question and “appealed to the Malaysian court to seize the aircraft as per international civil aviation leasing law.” (Murtaza Ali Shah, “Plane seizure in Malaysia: PIA pays Rs1.124 bn to jet company,” The News International, 23 January 2021)

 

Chinese vaccines to arrive by 31 January
Editorial criticises lack of planning on vaccines 

Image Source: Dawn

On 22 January, the Chinese Foreign Ministry Spokesperson announced that China would provide “a batch” of COVID-19 vaccines to Pakistan; the Chinese government would also ask the vaccine producing companies to speed up the “export of vaccines to Pakistan.” The spokesperson emphasised that “One can always count on a ready helping hand from the other in times of need and spoke and appreciated the all weather relation between the two countries. 

On 21 January, FM Qureshi said 500,000 doses of the vaccines from China will arrive by 31 January and more doses are expected to arrive in February 2021.  (“COVID-19: China will actively work to expedite vaccine delivery to Pakistan,” The News International, 23 January 2021)

Editorial highlights bad planning with regard to vaccines
An editorial in The News International says that despite understanding the necessity of a COVID-19 vaccine, Pakistan is struggling to secure them from any source. The editorial raises concerns over logistics of the vaccines - the rollouts and the delivery. It emphasises on the need to train medical workers beforehand and caution them about the side effects; this will take time because Pakistan has always been hesitant towards vaccines. It is critical of the fact that the government had not planned on the above months in advance. (“Procuring vaccines,” The News International, 23 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Fencing along borders with Afghanistan and Iran to be completed this year, says Interior Minister
On 23 January, Dawn reported that the federal Interior Minister Sheikh Rashid Ahmed stated that the fencing along borders with Afghanistan and Iran would be completed this year. The minister said, “It’s [fencing along the border with Afghanistan] almost 90 per cent done,” adding, “Similarly, the fencing along the Iran border is also under progress. Though it’s expected to be completed within the next few months, to be on safe side, I would give a year to complete fencing along both borders.” Further, he said that the fencing along these two borders would help tackle many security-related issues within the country. (Imran Ayub, “Border fencing to complete this year: minister,” Dawn, 23 January 2021)

ECONOMY
Inflation to fall within the previously announced range of 7-9 per cent for FY21, says SBP
On 22 January, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) left the policy rate unchanged at 7 per cent to act appropriately. According to The News International, the SBP said, “Since the last meeting in November the domestic recovery has gained some further traction… there are upside risks to the current growth projection of slightly above 2 per cent in FY21.” The bank said, “On the inflation front, recent out-turns are also encouraging, suggesting a waning of supply-side price pressures from food and still-benign core inflation.” Adding that inflation is to fall within the previously announced range of 7-9 per cent for FY21. Further, the bank said, “The existing accommodative stance of monetary policy remained appropriate to support the nascent recovery while keeping inflation expectations well-anchored and maintaining financial stability.” (“Economy improved, inflation feared: State Bank,” The News International, 23 January 2021)

EXTERNAL
Iranian envoy calls for cooperation in educational research
On 22 January, Consul General of Iran Aga Hassan Golivand Ravishand called for enhancing cooperation and collaboration between educational institutions of Pakistan and Iran, adding that, Further, he said, “we have to promote cooperation in various fields as much as possible and jointly formulate development projects and future programmes, including educational and research activities because educational institutions play an important role in the development and betterment of any society.” The Consul General made these statements during a meeting with Balochistan University Vice-Chancellor where they also discussed joint efforts for promotion of educational and research activities and cooperation in future activities. (Saleem Shahid, “Iranian envoy for cooperation in educational research,” Dawn, 23 January 2021)

Acting US Charge d’ Affairs meets with COAS
On 22 January, acting US Charge d’ Affairs to Pakistan called on COAS General Qamar Javed Bajwa during which the matters of mutual interest, including regional security situation along with cooperation in various domains, were discussed. The COAS expressed hoped that Pak-US bilateral relations will be further strengthened under new Administration. Further, visiting dignitary appreciated Pakistan’s contributions to peace in the region and support provided to intra-Afghan talks and also assured the continued assistance for the common cause of peace in Afghanistan. (“US assures Pakistan of continued assistance,” The News International, 23 January 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
FM urges Biden to follow up with the Afghan process
On 23 January, Dawn reported that FM Shah Mehmood Qureshi in an interview with Al Jazeera stated, “I think they (Biden administration) should realise there is an opportunity in Afghanistan and they should persevere with what was initiated and not reverse things,” adding, “Push them forward, because, after a long time, we have started moving in the right direction.” Further, reiterating Pakistan’s role in the process he said, “Pakistan has done a lot, we have really bent backwards to create an environment to facilitate the peace process.” (“FM urges Biden to persevere with Afghan process,” Dawn, 23 January 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
If the two-state solution is ignored more turbulence is in store for the region says an editorial
An editorial in Dawn says that with Joe Biden taking over, there may be a change in tone, if not substance, from Washington when it comes to Arab-Israeli dispute. Although there may not be a complete reversal US policy in favour of the Palestinians it is hoped that the new US leader will at least temper some of the more overtly pro-Israel policies of his predecessor. The editorial says that if the peace process is to be revived, then the Palestinians must get a fair deal, however, if the two-nation solution is ignored, more turbulence is in store for the region. (“Israeli land grab,” Dawn, 23 January 2021)

 

 

"A modern state is made up of two imperatives: state sovereignty and national integration. It ceases to be a state in the true sense when any of the two is compromised...Toxic leaders destroy the very fabric which makes a nation."
- An opinion in The News International
on 'Allure of toxic leaders'

 


ECP rejects open hearing of cases


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
ECP rejects open hearing of cases
Opposition open to Imran’s challenge

On 21 January, the Election Commission of Pakistan rejected Imran’s suggestions to hold open hearings of the foreign fundings cases against all political parties. The ECP said it enjoyed the status of a joint investigation team (JIT) and ruled out any plans of holding an open hearing. IT justified itself saying that the cases were too sensitive to be held in the public. The institution also clarified that the case was being heard in the presence of all concerned parties and the media. 

PTI founding member criticises ECP
In reaction to the ECP statement, PTI’s founding member Akbar Babar was critical of the scrutiny committee. According to him, the committee “completely failed to perform its duties credibly, transparently and in accordance with the terms of reference (ToR).” Referring to the ECP equating itself to a JIT, Akbar said “This must be the only JIT of its kind that is neither independent nor fair nor proactive to investigate and validate evidence.”

Opposition parties accept the challenge
However, on the same day, the opposition parties had accepted PM Imran Khan’s challenge to conduct open hearings of foreign funding cases against all parties. The PML-N’s Khawaja Saad Rafique said the party has no objection to a live coverage of the hearings as the PTI “had been hiding behind the stay orders and their lawyers made different excuses.” Further, he accused Imran Khan of using the accountability process to target the opposition. Similarly, the PPP also accepted Imran’s challenge on the previous day. (Iftikhar A Khan, “ECP rules out open hearing of foreign funding case,” Dawn, 22 January 2021) (“Foreign funding case: Opposition accepts PM’s challenge,” The News International, 22 January 2021)

 

China to gift half a million COVID-19 vaccine doses to Pakistan
Two more firms apply to Drap for emergency use approval 

Image Source: Dawn

On 21 January, Foreign Minister Qureshi announced that China will gift 500,000 doses of COVID-19 vaccines to Pakistan by the end of January. The announcement was made after Pakistan’s  Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan (Drap) approved the Sinopharm and the AstraZeneca vaccines for emergency use. Qureshi emphasised that the vaccines would arrive “free of charge.” (“China to gift half a million Covid-19 vaccine doses to Pakistan,” The Express Tribune, 22 Jnuary 2021)

Two companies approach Drap
On the same day, the Ministry of National Health Services announced that two companies, including the Russian company Sputnik-V, had applied to the Drap  “for registration and phase-III clinical trial of their Covid-19 vaccines.” A Chinese company, Anhui Zheifi Longcom Biopharmaceuticals Company Limited also applied for the same. 

Prior to this, Astra-Zeneca, Sinopharm, and CanSino had registered with Drap. (Ikram Junaidi, “Two more firms contact Drap for vaccine registration,” Dawn, 22 January 2021)

Previously…
On 20 January, the SAPM had urged the government to procure at least one million doses of the vaccine by March with an aim to vaccinate 70 per cent of its population. 

 

On GB: Opinion highlights nature of relation with federal govt
Suggests local leadership to take part in policy formation

Image Source: The Express Tribune

An opinion in The News International analyses the developments after the politically charged elections in Gilgit Baltistan took place in November 2020. The author quotes, “Following the political euphoria of granting provincial status and determining the political future for more internal autonomy, the people of GB once again proved to be pragmatic in their political choice to go with the ruling party in the federation.” He points out that results in GB had always been predictable. However, it was Bilawal’s relentless campaigning which gave analysts hope that the trend could be altered; but it did not prove to be so. 

Outlining the election campaigns, voting and results, the author points out that many analysts missed out on one dimension in the GB election debate:  the institutional and structural relationship of the federal government and GB. Here, GB is completely dependent on the centre for the same. The author says GB can overcome its economic dependence and political subordination through long-term investments in key areas like hydropower, geology and minerals. He suggests that to transform this strategy into reality, the local leadership has to take the lead for policy formation. (Amir Hussain, "Gilgit-Baltistan: after the elections," The News International, 22 January 2021)

 

In Brief
INTERNAL
Former SC judge appointed to head Broadsheet inquiry committee
On 21 January, the Information Minister tweeted that the government had appointed Azmat Saeed Sheikh, a former SC judge, as the head of the committee formed to probe into the Broadsheet case. The committee is expected to investigate the case and within 45 days should “fix the responsibility on those Pakistanis who...illegally benefited themselves and laundered money to off-shore banks.” (“Ex-SC judge named head of Broadsheet probe body,” Dawn, 21 January 2021)

Electricity tarrifs hiked by Rs 1.95
On 21 January, the Energy Minister announced a 15 per cent increase in tariff rates of electricity. This means the tariff would increase by Rs 1.95 hike per unit. With this, the “base tariff for lifeline consumers using up to 50 units per month would be increased” for the first time in 20 years. The minister said the government was forced to announce the hike amid the tough economic conditions because the current government “inherited an unsustainable level of capacity payments from the PML-N government.” (Khaleeq Kiani, “15pc hike in power tariff announced,” Dawn, 22 January 2021)

Pakistan Bar Council elects vice chairman, discusses Isa and other issues
On 21 January, the Pakistan Bar Council elected Khushdil Khan as its vice chairman. Immediately, he urged the Supreme Court to fix a date for hearing the review petitions in the Justice Isa case. He pushed for the independence of the judiciary and stop the “onslaughts of the executive against independent judges of the superior courts.” Further, the PBC also discussed the delay in appointing judges to the HC, especially the Lahore HC wherein at least 20 posts of judges are vacant. (“PBC asks SC to fix hearing date of pleas in Isa case,” Dawn, 22 January 2021)

PROVINCES
Four soldiers killed in landmine blast
On 21 January, four soldiers were killed and five injured in Sibi district after their vehicle hit a landmine. According to Dawn, officials said unknown miscreants had planted the landmine. Further, Balochistan CM and other ministers said such attacks discouraged security forces posted in the area. (Saleem Shahid, “Four soldiers martyred, five injured in Sibi landmine blast,” Dawn, 22 January 2021) 

ON INDIA
FO accuses India of undermining regional stability
On 21 January, the Foreign Office said the world should hold India accountable for “actions that undermine regional stability.” The FO spokesman accused India of implementing  “irresponsible and irrational policies” and attributed them to the “RSS-BJP regime in India.” He also spoke about the WhatsApp chats of Arnab Goswami and said that Pakistan had “been pointing out that India’s BJP government staged “false flag” operations” to target Pakistan for political gains. (“FO again urges world to make India accountable for its actions,” Dawn, 22 January 2021)

 

 

"It’s a fact that the Pakistani elite is complicit in stealing and taking out its resources. However, carrying out investigation through a dead organization can generate more pain than relief"
- An opinion in The News International
on the Broadsheet case

 


Pakistan conducts another test of Shaheen-III


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Pakistan conducts another test of Shaheen-III 
Test flight aimed at revalidating design and technical parameters of the weapon system

On 20 January, Pakistan conducted another test of surface-to-surface ballistic missile Shaheen-III, having a range of 2,750 kilometres. Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee said, “Pakistan desires peaceful co-existence in the region and its strategic capability is to deter any aggression against the sovereignty of Pakistan.”
According to the Inter-Services Public Relations, “The test flight was aimed at re-validating various design and technical parameters of the weapon system.” Further, an official stated, “This test is part of Pakistan’s resolve to maintain credible minimum deterrence. Pakistan maintains a policy of credible minimum deterrence and its deterrence posture is India-centric.” ("
Pakistan conducts flight test of Shaheen-III missile," The News International, 21 January 2021)

Shaheen-III
Shaheen-III is a surface-to-surface ballistic missile with a range of 2,750 kilometres, the longest-range missile to have been developed in the country. It is solid-fuelled and equipped with Post-Separation Altitude Correction (PSAC) system. In 2015, the missile was first tested however it has not been operationally deployed.

Previously…
On 7 January, the ISPR said that Pakistan had successfully tested its extended-range guided Multi-Launch Rocket System (MLRS) called Fatah-1. The MLRS, produced indigenously, has a range of 140 kilometres and has the capacity to carry a conventional warhead. According to Dawn, with the development of the indigenous weapon, Pakistan appears to respond to India’s “development of its conventional capabilities.” (“Pakistan tests multi-launch rocket system,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

 

Imran visits South Waziristan
Calls for open hearing of opposition’s foreign funding cases

Image Source: Dawn

On 20 January, PM Imran Khan, during a visit to South Waziristan, called for the open hearing of foreign funding cases against all political parties. He emphasised that PTI is the only party that has raised political funds. Apart from this, Imran also suggested that references from accountability courts should also be aired live for the public. 

Imran highlights developments in region
Imran announced that 3G and 4G services will start operating on 20 January. The demands for 3G and 4G network connectivity increased over the pandemic. In view of this, Imran found these demands justifiable, especially for education and development and perceived them as “genuine demands of the youth of the merged districts.” However, he justified the delay in starting the network services here claiming that India is trying to fuel terrorisim in Pakistan by using the youth. ame tactics in Waziristan.

Stresses on economic growth
Further, Imran accused previous governments for the “70 per cent poverty level” in South Waziristan. To address unemployment, Imran said the government would provide more loans and would focus on building infrastructure - schools, universities, colleges etc - as this would help the youth in finding jobs and subsequently boost the country’s economy. (Dilawar Wazir, “PM wants opposition to also face foreign funding trial,” Dawn, 21 January 2021) (“Coming clean on foreign funding: Imran Khan throws debate gauntlet to opposition,” The News International, 21 January 2021)

 

Three men reject Broadsheet claims
Article highlights NAB’s silence on Broadsheet


Image Source: Dawn

On 21 January, The News International reported that three men Barrister Zafar Ali QC, Dr Kersten Pucks, and Shaid Iqbal who is the Solicitor of the Supreme Court of England Wales rejected Moussavi’s claims. 

According to The News International, Pucks is likely to move legally against Moussavi. The three have released a legal paper rejecting the claims by including conversations between Zafar and Moussavi. The legal paper reveals that Moussavi, until 2018, had approached Zafar asking him to persuade the Pakistani government  to pay Broadsheet; however, he declined all offers. 

Later, in 2018, the government had approached Zafar to discuss new asset recovery programmes; the legal paper says  “the PM also wanted to pursue recovery of all stolen money, regardless of political affiliation.” However, it denies suggesting proposals of the above kind to intelligence or the armed forces. Simultaneously, the three said that  Moussavi’s motives were  shifting “recovering billions of dollars in claims against the Pakistani government for his company, Broadsheet.” This worried them. (Murtaza Ali Shah, “Three men reject Moussavi’s claim,” The News International, 21 January 2021)

Between Panamagate and Broadsheet: What happened?

An article in The Express Tribune highlights that the Broadsheet arbitration came in 2016. Around the same time, Pakistan was also managing the Panamagate scandal involving Nawaz Sharif. It points out that even the Joint Investigation Team (JIT) and the NAB seemed oblivious to the Broadsheet case at the time. It also says that the NAB did not even make an attempt to estimate the value of Nawaz’s Avenfield properties. 

On 18 January, the SAPM on accountability briefed the Senate that out of the “USD 21.5 million paid to Broadsheet, USD 20.5 million was paid because of the Sharif family.” In a press conference later, the Minister for Science said the 2016 case was out in the public now because Nawaz was head of government and under him the NAB chief withheld the news. 

Therefore, the article says the Broadsheet scandal questions the JIT’s performance including the evidence it collected which finally led to removal of Nawaz from office.(Rizwan Shehzad, “Award against Pakistan: Why did the UK court’s 2016 order surface now?” The Express Tribune, 21 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Govt in talks with Sinopharm and CanSino to procure the COVID-19 vaccine
On 20 January, Special Assistant to Prime Minister on Health stated that Pakistan is in advanced-level talks with two manufacturers, Sinopharm and CanSino to procure the COVID-19 vaccine. The SAPM said that Sinopharm is being used in several countries, and its efficacy is around 80-85 per cent. Meanwhile, CanSino's Phase-III trails are being conducted in Pakistan, and are expected to conclude shortly. Meanwhile, the Sindh Medical Stores which is one of the largest importers of vaccines and other pharmaceutical products in Pakistan stated, “Since the government has allowed it [the Oxford-AstraZeneca’s Covid-19 vaccine] and given us the nod to import the consignments, we have estimated that it would be available to the government for something between US$6 and US$7.” (“Oxford vaccine may cost around $6 in Pakistan,” Dawn, 21 January 2021)

ECONOMY
Pakistan received a total $5.688 billion external loans during the first six months of FY20-21
On 21 January, The News International reported that according to official figures of the Economic Affairs Division (EAD), stated that the government received $5,688 million total external inflows from multiple financing sources, which are 46 per cent of annual budget estimates of $12,233 million for the entire fiscal year 2020-21. The Asian Development Bank provided $1,120 million, World Bank disbursed $744 million against the budgetary allocation of $2,257 million, further, the bilateral sources came from France, USA and China. (Mehtab Haider, “Pakistan secures $5.688 bn external loans,” The News International, 21 January 2021)

EXTERNAL
Pakistan is ready to engage with the new administration of the US, says FM Qureshi
On 20 January, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi said that Pakistan was ready to engage with the new administration of the United States adding that he considers it as an ‘opportunity to build a long-term, broad-based and multidimensional relationship.’ He said, “such partnership would require an institutionalised and structured engagement, based on mutual respect and cooperation.” Further, he added that President Joe Biden was an ‘old friend to Pakistan’ and would work towards strengthening ties between the two countries. (“Ready to engage with new US admin: FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi,” The News International, 21 January 2021)

Air Chief’s three-day visit to Qatar
Air Chief Marshal Mujahid Anwar Khan who a three-day visit to Qatar called on Chief of Staff, Qatar Armed Forces, Gen (Pilot) Ghanem bin Shaheen Al-Ghanem, and Commander Qatar Naval Forces, Vice Admiral Abdullah Hassan Al-Sulaiti. During the meeting, the two commanders discussed matters of mutual interest and bilateral cooperation. Further, he met with Commander Qatar Emiri Air Force who acknowledged the support of PAF towards the training of QEAF personnel. (“Air chief’s three-day Qatar visit ends,” The News International, 21 January 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Trump would rather ‘reign in Hell, than serve in Heav’n,’ says opinion
An opinion in Dawn says that the agitators and 74 million like-minded Republicans who voted for Trump are the 'incendiary legacy' he is leaving for President Joe Biden, adding that Trump’s dream team of supporters will be for the next four years Biden’s nightmare. The opinion critical of Trump says that he is by nature a spoiler, an unrepentant Lucifer, he would rather “reign in Hell, than serve in Heav’n.” Further, about the ‘domestic terrorists,’ the opinion says that some jurists believe they deserve the same punishment the US government to ‘tinted terrorists’ which was by incarceration, without an open trial, in Guantanamo Bay. (F.S. Aijazuddin, “A horned dilemma,” Dawn, 21 January 2021)

 

"The realisation of the best possible management of public affairs demands constant vigil by a dynamic civil society; regimes that try to pull the rug from under civil society’s feet are no friends of the state or its people. Suppression of civil society organisations is considered necessary by despotic regimes that are afraid of a citizenry that is wide awake."
- I.A. Rehman on 'The hazards of governance'

 


PDM holds protests outside the ECP


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PDM holds protests outside the ECP
Information Minister calls protests a flop show

On 19 January, the PDM held a protest rally outside the Election Commission of Pakistan demanding an immediate decision on the foreign fundings case against the PTI which has been pending for seven years. 

Maryam alleges India and Israel provided funds to Imran
Maryam accused Imran Khan of receiving funds from India and Israel. Further she alleged that BJP’s Inder Dosanjh and Israel’s Barry Schneps funded Imran. She cited that Imran shifted blame to agents for receiving funds; she asked how Imran  remembered the agents “after seven years when people asked questions and pressure was exerted.” (Syed Irfan Raza, “
PDM takes anti-PTI protest to ECP office,” Dawn, 20 January 2021)

PDM questions “silence” of ECP
Maryam asked why the ECP was silent when the most “incompetent” person was “selected” and imposed on Pakistan. She said ECP shares responsibility for the problems faced by the Pakistanis today - whether it is seizure of the PIA plane or the woes of the Hazaras. Further, she listed out that the ECP held 80 hearings for the foreign fundings case but Imran “sought stay of proceedings 30 times, requested for four times to keep proceedings secret, and also moved the high court six times while challenging authority of the ECP.” (Asim Yasin and Muhammad Anis, “PDM tells PTI: 'Come clean if conscience clear',” The News International, 20 January 2021)

Shibli Faraz terms PDM rally a flop show
On the same day, reacting to the PDM’s rally, Information Minister Shibli Faraz said people are not supporting the opposition alliance because it was conducting rallies only to “protect their corruption and vested interests.” Further, he held that the PTI had submitted the list of 40,000 donors in the foreign funding case to the ECP. He accused the PML-N of looting the country.  Similarly, the Minister for Science and Technology and Minister for Human Rights alleged the above and asked for disclosure of donors and assets of the PML-N and PPP. (“PDM demo was a flop show: govt,” The News International, 20 January 2021)

PDM might have to realign their strategies, says editorial

An editorial in The Daily Times highlights that the PPP and PML-N are yet to submit their funding records to the scrutiny committee of the ECP. The editorial highlights that probes regarding the foreign fundings do not fall under the purview of the ECP; rather, the government is expected to make references on the same and forward them to the SC.  Further, the editorial says the PDM;s efforts to pressure the government are coming undone as cleavages within the alliance seem to emerge. Therefore, it urges the PDM “to go back to the drawing board so all opposition parties can realign their strategies.” (“Peculiarities in the foreign funding case,” The Daily Times, 20 January 2021)

 

Cabinet constitutes new committee to probe Broadsheet scandal
The News unravels history behind Broadsheet’s relation with Pakistan 

Image Source: Dawn

On 19 January, the Federal Cabinet appointed a committee to be headed by a former SC judge to probe into the Broadsheet scandal and submit a review report within 45 days. The committee will comprise one representative of the Federal Investigation Agency, Attorney General of Pakistan, and a senior advocate appointed by the PM. While announcing the above, the information Minister reiterated that the PTI had not brought out the “corruption of the Sharif family.” He said it was the Broadsheet LLC which unearthed the family's assets. (“Cabinet orders probe into Broadsheet scam,” The Daily Times, 20 January 2021)

More details emerge on Broadsheet
On 20 January, The News International reported that Tariq Fawad Malik, a textile trader from Lahore, was the person who convinced the NAB Chairman in 2000 that the Broadsheet LLC would help recover the “‘looted wealth’ from overseas.” In 1999, Tariq convinced the then NAB Chairman General Amjad to hire  Trouvons LLC, a French asset recovery firm, for the same. 

Broadsheet was incorporated in the Isle of Man in May 2000 as a shell company by two Panamanian companies named Oxford International Holdings and Berkshire Holdings, and was run by two partners. In June 2000, the Trouvons was set to head the assets recovery drive on the behalf of the NAB outside Pakistan. However, by 2002, the NAB cited lack of progress and in 2003, the NAB unilaterally withdrew from the deal with Broadsheet; but, Tariq kept pursuing the NAB for a settlement. Further, after the partnership of Broadsheet fell apart, Tariq along with one of them “registered a new Broadsheet and became its authorised representative in Pakistan.”  (Murtaza Ali Shah, “Tariq Fawad Malik: the founder of messy Broadsheet deal,” The News International, 20 January 2021) 

Meanwhile...
An editorial in Dawn, written along the above lines, says the many "skeletons in the Broadsheet cupboard need to be brought out" and verify the claims made by Moussavi. The editorial calls for investigation so that those responsible for the current state of Pakistan are held accountable. Therefore, it urges the government to ensure transparency that no fact is "obscured at the altar of political expediency." ("Broadsheet judgement," Dawn, 20 January 2021)
 

Over 40 million children immunised during nationwide anti-polio drive
Strict Covid-19 induced SOPs observed by health workers

Image Source: Dawn

As Pakistan rolled out its five-day anti-polio drive across the country on 11 January, more than 40 million children under the age of five years received vaccination during the latest nationwide anti-polio campaign. A total of 287,000 frontline polio workers were positioned across the country for door-to-door vaccination while observing strict standard operating procedures amid the pandemic.

Further, the National Coordinator for the Polio Eradication Initiative and Expanded Programme of Immunisation said that the fight against poliovirus was recharged through the delivery of successful polio campaigns last year. (“
Over 40m children vaccinated during nationwide anti-polio drive,” Dawn, 20 January 2020)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Lt Gen Bilal Akbar appointed as the new ambassador to Saudi Arabia
On 20 January, Dawn reported that the government has decided to nominate retired Lt Gen Bilal Akbar as the new ambassador to Saudi Arabia. Gen Akbar had retired from the army in December 2019. His last appointment was chairman of Pakistan Ordnance Factory (POF), Wah. His appointment is indicative of the military’s desire to take control and enhance the bilateral ties which have strained in the recent past. (“Gen Akbar appointed ambassador to Saudi Arabia,” Dawn, 20 January 2002)

BBIT calls for policy to boost trade with Iran from a new route
On 20 January, Dawn reported that the Balochistan Board of Investment and Trade (BBIT) called for formulating a policy of a new border crossing point set up between Pakistan and Iran to promote investment in the border area. At a meeting of the audit committee of the BBIT’s board, demands were made for a director’s policy in the context of a new Pakistan-Iran border crossing point established to promote investment in the border area. Further, the meeting stressed that a BBIT’s office should be set up in Gwadar to facilitate the investors who want to invest in Gwadar and the free zone. (Behram Baloch, “Call for policy to boost trade with Iran from new route,” Dawn, 20 January 2002)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Trump’s controversial departure: Opinion
An opinion in The News International critical of Trump’s presidency says that his presidency was marred by several controversies and damaged the prestigious political position that he held for four years. Further, the opinion says the controversial American president will be viewed differently in various parts of the world, however, Trump will go down in history as someone who attempted to divide American society, making attempts to tear its social fabric, driving a wedge between the various sections of the mighty state, and trampling the norms of decency during his tenure as the chief executive of the country. (Abdul Sattar, “Trump’s departure,” The News International, 20 January 2002)

In the end, Donald Trump did make history says opinion
An opinion in The Express Tribune says that at the end of Trump’s presidency, he did make history the way he wanted to. Highlighting that he is the first American president to be impeached twice, the opinion asks whether this impeachment will have a different result from the one that came before. Will the Senate actually vote to convict this time? Apart from the numerous reasons, the opinion says that the factor of Trump’s massive public will make it unlikely that a Senate trial will end in a conviction. (Hassan Niazi, “Trump’s last stand,” The Express Tribune, 20 January 2002)

ON DANIEL PEARL
Omar Saeed would be handed over to the US if acquitted, says counsel
On 19 January, the counsel for Omar Saeed, main accused in the Daniel Pearl case submitted to the SC if his client is acquitted, he would be handed over to the US. To this, the judge asked the counsel to present a new argument instead of going over the same old ones. The case has been adjourned for 20 January (today). ("Defence counsel presents arguments in Pearl case," The Express Tribune, 20 January 2021)

 

 

"The confrontational politics of the opposition may succeed in creating serious problems for the government but will take the country nowhere."

 
- An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'Addressing major national issues'

 


Cabinet constitutes committee to probe Broadsheet scandal


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Cabinet constitutes committee to probe Broadsheet scandal
Government has to pay USD 29 million to Broadsheet, says SAPM

On 18 January, amid the mudslinging between the government and the Opposition, the federal cabinet formed a three member committee to probe into the Broadsheet LLC fiasco. Information and Broadcasting Minister Shibli Faraz will lead the committee. The other two members are: Science and Technology Minister Fawad Chaudhry and Human Rights Minister Shireen Mazari. According to sources in The News International, The committee is expected to submit a review of Pakistan’s agreement with Broadsheet LLC from 2002 to 2018. 

SAPM briefs Senate on liability to Broadsheet LLC
On the same day, citing an agreement signed between Musharraf and Nawaz Sharif in 2000, the SAPM on Accountability Shahzad Akbar told the Senate that the government was liable to pay USD 29 million to the Broadsheet firm. He explained that PPP government had paid USD 1.5 million to a wrong firm in 2008 “and all proceedings of arbitration were held during the last two governments of PPP and Pakistan Muslim league-Nawaz (PML-N).” Further, the Mushrraf regime worked with Broadsheet and International Asset Recovery (IAR), in May 2000 to trace assets of 200 Pakistanis. Then in 2003, the NAB suspended the agreements with Broadsheet and IAR.

The SAPM explained that Broadsheet had fixed USD 100 million as 20 per cent share of the firm for recovering assets of Schon Group, Lakhani, Fouzi Kazmi, retired Gen Zahid Ali Akbar, (Aftab) Sherpao, and Ansari assets. Next, the second part of the liability award is the above mentioned USD 29 million. Of this, USD 1.5 million accounts for tracing Nawaz’s Avenfield properties, and USD 19 million for other Sharif assets. The rest of the USD 29 million was interest due to the delay.  

Opposition lashes out in Senate
In the above context, PPP’s Sherry Rehman raised questions on a number of other names removed from the list. She accused the government of attempting to “break the two biggest political parties of this country: the PPP and PML-N.” Similarly, PML-N Senator Muhammad Abbasi also raised concerns on the figures and called on the committee of the Whole to discuss the same. (Iftikhar A Khan, “Controversy over Broadsheet scandal echoes in Senate,” Dawn, 19 January 2021) (Nasir Iqbal, “UK judge rebukes NAB in Broadsheet ruling,” Dawn, 19 January 2021) (Mumtaz Alvi, “Broadsheet scandal gets graver,” The News International, 19 January 2021) 

 

PDM marches to Islamabad today
Parties call on ECP to deliver decision on fundings case

Image Source: Dawn

On 19 January (today,) the PDM is set to stage protests outside the Election Commission of Pakistan in Islamabad; meanwhile, the election body is expected to hear the foreign funding case against the PTI on 20 January. This is the first rally to be held in the Red Zone. However the PDM has no plan to conduct a sit-in at the protest site. Rallies from Rawalpindi and Islamabad will converge at Serena Hotel Chowk and from here, Maryam Nawaz, Fazlur Rehman Raja Pervez Ashraf, will lead the main rally to the ECP headquarters. Bilawal Bhutto, however, will not attend the rally. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Battle of nerves looms over PDM power show,” Dawn, 19 January 2021)

Fazlur calls on ECP to decide on foreign fundings case
On 18 January, Fazlur said “crores of rupees were collected in the name of party funds and brought to Pakistan through illegal means.” This money, he alleged, was used in election rigging and “creating political anarchy,” and accused Imran Khan of the same. He asked why the ECP was delaying its decision despite having gathered necessary and all possible evidence in the case. (“'Today we demand a decision from ECP',” The News International, 19 January 2021) Further, he pointed out that the decision against Nawaz Sharif came within merely six months while the case against Imran Khan has been pending for six years. Therefore, he called for an unbiased decision from the ECP on what he termed, “the biggest scandal in Pakistan’s political history.” (Kalbe Ali, “Fazl terms foreign funding case biggest scandal of Pakistan,” Dawn, 19 January 2021)

PPP, PML-N seek proof from PTI on funding allegations
On the same day, counsel for the PPP and PML-N appeared before the ECP’s scrutiny committee and claimed that they had not received any foreign funds and submitted all sources of funding, mostly local sources, to the ECP. In this context, the two parties sought proof from the PTI as the ruling party had alleged that they had received foreign funding.

However, the Interior Minister in a press conference said the PTI submitted records of 40,000 transactions and claimed that the opposition parties were “unable to produce records of just 4,000 people from whom they had received foreign funding.” (“PML-N, PPP ask PTI for proof of foreign funding allegations,” Dawn, 19 January 2021)

Meanwhile… 
On the same day, the Interior Minister announced that the government would be giving a free hand to the PDM to conduct its rallies on the condition that they do not violate any laws. He reiterated that the PDM is expected to respect the sanctity of the ECP as it is a constitutional body. (“PDM given ‘free hand’ for today’s protest: minister,” Dawn, 19 January 2021)

 

Imran urges world to stop Modi govt from pushing "India towards war with Pakistan"
Says Goswami’s remarks reveal nexus between Delhi govt and Indian media

Image Source: Dawn

On 18 January, PM Imran Khan urged the world to stop the Modi government from allegedly pushing India towards war with Pakistan. In a series of tweets he said, “Indian sponsorship of terrorism in Pakistan, its abuses in IIOJK & a 15-year Indian global disinformation campaign against us all stand exposed. Now India’s own media has revealed the dirty nexus that is pushing our nuclearised region to the brink of a conflict it cannot afford.” (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “World must stop Modi from igniting war: PM,” Dawn, 19 January 2021)

Further, amid the leak of WhatsApp chats between Arnab Goswami and head of an Indian ratings company he said, “Latest revelations from the communication of an Indian journalist, known for his warmongering, reveal the unholy nexus between the Modi govt and Indian media that led to a dangerous military adventurism to win an election in utter disregard for the consequences of destabilising the entire region.” (“
WhatsApp chat reveals Modi-media ‘dirty nexus’,” The News International, 19 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Govt approves Sinopharm vaccine 
On 18 January, the Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan (Drap) approved another Covid-19 vaccine manufactured by Sinopharm, a Chinese state-owned firm. Further, the Pakistan Medical Association (PMA), has asked the government produced details of the vaccines which are under consideration for import as well as their efficacy rates. Previously, on 16 January, Drap had approved AstraZeneca’s Covid-19 vaccine for emergency use in the country. (Ikram Junaidi, “Pakistan approves another Covid-19 vaccine,” Dawn, 19 January 2021)

Anti-terrorism court jails two JuD leaders jailed for over 14 years each
On 18 January, an anti-terrorism court in Lahore handed down a fourteen-and-a-half-year jail to Jamaat-ud-Dawa leaders Zafar Iqbal and Yahya Mujahid in two cases of terror financing. Further, the court also sentenced Hafiz Abdul Rehman Makki to six-month jail. Previously, the ATC Lahore had sentenced Zafar Iqbal to 26-year imprisonment in three cases. Thus far a total of 41 cases have been registered by the Counter Terrorism Department against the JuD leaders, out of which 28 have been decided while the rest are pending in ATC courts.(“Terror financing: Two JuD leaders jailed for over 14 years each,” The News International, 19 January 2021)

ECONOMY
30 per cent drop in FDI in the first half of FY21
On 18 January, the State Bank of Pakistan reported that Foreign direct investment fell by 30 per cent in the first half of the current fiscal year. The SBP data showed that Pakistan received $952 million foreign investment during July-December FY21 compared to $1.357 billion in the same period of last fiscal year. Further, the data shows that the outflow during July-December was $244m compared to a net inflow of $18.8m the same period last year. Also owing to this drop was the shrinking of inflows from China in July-December. (Shahid Iqbal, “Foreign investment drops by 30pc in first half of FY21,” Dawn, 19 January 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
If Trump is acquitted, it would set a dangerous precedent for US, says opinion 
An opinion in The Express Tribune highlights that convicting Trump may be easier this time since the charges against him include inciting violence against the US government, which is an attack on democracy. The author says conviction could happen since it would set a precedent - a loser can overturn results by violence - if Trump is acquitted. Further, the Republicans could see this as a chance to get rid of Trump thereby “eliminating the spectre of his assault on democracy looming over them in the future.” Next, he says senior Republicans could help convicting him if they do not want him contesting the 2024 elections. However, he warns that since Trump has a loyal cult of followers, Republicans may also want to hold on to him to amass followers thereby bringing down the chances of conviction. (Hassan Niazi, “Trump’s last stand,” The Express Tribune, 18 January 2021)

 

"To invest in policing is to invest in peace."
- An opinion in Dawn on Internal security
and the fight against terrorism.

 


PDM to discuss ECP protests plan today


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PDM to discuss ECP protests plan today
Shibli accuses PML-N, PPP of paralysing institutions

On 18 January (today), the steering committee of the PDM will meet with Fazlur Rehman to discuss their final plan of action for the protest outside the Election Commission of Pakistan on 19 January. The PML-N Information Secretary said that Maryam Nawaz will lead the rally from Rawalpindi to the ECP. However, on 19 January, the ECP is set to hear the foreign funding case against the PTI. Therefore, this has increased the political temperature in the country. 

PDM fell in its own traps, says Shibli Faraz
Shibli Faraz said the PDM had to explain the source of their finds while they tried to trap the PTI in the foreign fundings case. He said the opposition parties were now “caught in their (own) web.” He claimed that the PDM was out of choices and their last resort was to” lie so much that it will be taken as the truth.” Further, he accused the PML-N and PPP of paralysing national institutions by appointing “cronies” who would work in the interest of the parties. 

Any one who opposes PM lands in jail, says Maryam
Maryam said the current Broadsheet fiasco was a political witch hunt than an accountability drive. She referred to Shahbaz Sharif and claimed that he landed in jail after he refused to yield under the government’s pressure to abandon Nawaz. However, this trend will not last long, she promised. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Govt, opposition trade barbs as ECP hears funding case tomorrow,” Dawn, 18 January 2021) (Mumtaz Alvi, “PML-N, PPP to appear in ECP today,” The News International, 18 January 2021)

Meanwhile…
In order to prevent any chaos during the PDM protest, the Islamabad Police will deploy more than 1,800 personnel in the city. Previously, on 15 January, the Interior Minister had reiterated that the government will not stop any one from exercising their constitutional rights as long as they abide by the law. (“Islamabad police devise security plan for PDM protest outside ECP on January 19,” The News International, 18 January 2021)

 

PIA crew members to arrive today
Investigation against three officers launched

Image Source: Dawn

On 18 January (today), 18 crew members of PIA flight seized in Kuala Lumpur on 15 January over a USD 14 million lease case will arrive in Islamabad on Monday. A working group headed by the senior joint secretary of the aviation division will review the situation and study other concerns of the PIA over “air services agreements with other countries.” (Mohammed Asghar, “Stranded crew of seized plane due today,” Dawn, 18 January 2021)

Editorial highlights problems faced by the PIA
Meanwhile, an editorial in Dawn says that “mismanagement, nepotism and political opportunism” has led to the dire condition that the PIA finds itself in today. The editorial says the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) should bear a large share of the responsibility for all the problems and tragedies under the PIA, including the Karachi crash in May 2020. It reiterates that the latest seizing at Kuala Lumpur is a big embarrassment given that the PIA was just recovering from previous ones. It concludes by asking whether the PIA has any game plan. (“More ignominy for PIA,” Dawn, 18 January 2021)

Previously…
On 17 January, the PIA launched an investigation against three officers of the marketing, engineering and flight operations departments. On the same day, the CAA asked why the PIA operated the aircraft despite knowing that the said Boeing 777 was involved in a court case. Condemning the PIA’s maladministration, the CAA asked “Wasn't PIA aware of the fact that violating international civil aviation laws will embarrass the country?" (“Three PIA officers under probe after plane seizure in Kuala Lumpur,” The News International, 17 January 2021)

 

Polio vaccination drive in KP ends; 95 per cent vaccinated
Punjab surpasses national average with 99 per cent vaccinated

Image Source: Dawn

On 17 January, the seven day polio vaccination drive in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa came to an end. The authorities said 95 per cent of the 745,863 target children were vaccinated. According to a press release, district administration officials, including the Deputy Commissioner, visited areas where parents refused to vaccinate their children. After the death of a police officer escorting a polio team on 12 January, better security was arranged for the officials deployed in the vaccination drive. 

Further, the coordinator of National Emergency Operation Centre for Polio said that they have achieved 98 per cent target at the national level. Punjab leads the figures with 99 per cent targeted children being administered with the vaccine, followed by 95 per cent in KP and Islamabad, Sindh and “Azad Jammu and Kashmir.” (Ashfaq Yusufzai, “95pc children vaccinated against polio in KP, claim officials,” Dawn, 18 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Govt to register more COVID-19 vaccines 
On 17 January, the Ministry of National Health Services (MNHS) announced that more vaccines would be registered in the coming weeks. MNHS spokes­­person stated, “The AstraZeneca has been registered in the country for emergency use and the vaccine will come through Covax, which has pledged to provide the vaccine that would cover 20 per cent of the country’s population.” This decision comes as Pakistan reported 2,521 new cases and 43 deaths on 17 January. (Ikram Junaidi, “More Covid-19 vaccines to be registered: official,” Dawn, 18 January 2021)

NAB rejects “malicious propaganda campaign” carried out by sections of the media
On 17 January, the NAB rejected “malicious propaganda campaign” being carried out in a section of media against the Bureau by portraying askew statements. A NAB spokesman said in a statement said that the Bureau would not bow down before any propaganda campaign about its working. These statements came in response to the remarks made by the Senate deputy chairman. (“NAB vows not to bow down to propaganda campaign,” Dawn, 18 January 2021)

Govt under PDM’s pressure to resign says PLM-N
On 17 January, PLM-N Spokesperson Marriyum Aurangzeb said that the government was under immense pressure from the PDM to resign by 31 January. She said, “Due to PDM movement to get the resignation of the ‘incompetent’ government, the PTI ministers are making a hue and cry as the people supported the stance of the opposition.” Further, she rejected the point that Maulana Fazlur Rehman can be pressurized. (Aamir Yasin, “Govt under PDM pressure to resign by 31st: PML-N,” Dawn, 18 January 2021)

Schools reopen across Pakistan
On 18 January, schools across Pakistan reopened for classes 9 to 12. Federal Minister for Education Shafqat Mehmood said the future of students is government’s “main priority” as on-campus learning resumed. Previously, on 16 January, the NCOC reviewed the decision to reopen educational institutions amid the second wave of COVID-19 and it was decided that classes will resume on 18 January. (“Reopening of schools: Shafqat Mehmood says future of students govt’s ‘main priority’,” The News International, 18 January 2021) Meanwhile, an editorial in The News International critical of this reopening, questions the preparedness of school to ensure safety as most schools lack the space to socially distance substantially enough to stop the spread of the virus. (“The school debate,” The News International, 18 January 2021)

PROVINCE
Two terrorists killed in Nargosa
On 18 January, the ISPR stated that at least two terrorists were killed by security forces during an intelligence-based operation (IBO) in Nargosa area of South Waziristan district, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. According to The Express Tribune, the two terrorists were active members of the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) Sajna group and were highly trained as well as involved in attacks on security forces. (“Security forces kill two terrorists in Nargosa IBO,” Dawn, 18 January 2021)

ECONOMY
Cabinet Committee on Energy to review the overall situation of gas supplies
On 18 January, the Cabinet Committee on Energy (CCoE) is set to meet in Islamabad to review the overall situation, including the discontinuation of gas supplies to several industries on a long-term basis. This comes as foreign traders of liquefied natural gas (LNG) default on supplies amid gas shortages. (Khaleeq Kiani, “Cut in gas supply to industry likely amid LNG crisis,” Dawn, 18 January 2021)

ON INDIA
‘Will continue to expose India's belligerent designs for Pakistan,’ says Imran Khan
On 18 January, PM Imran Khan stated, “I want to reiterate that my govt will continue to expose India's belligerent designs towards Pakistan & Modi govt's fascism.” Further, he said, “[International] community must stop India from its reckless, militarist agenda before the Modi government's brinkmanship pushes our region into a conflict it cannot control.” (“Will continue exposing India's belligerent designs for Pakistan, says PM Imran,” The Express Tribune, 18 January 2021)Echoing the same, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi stated that Pakistan would forcefully raise the issue of alleged Indian conspiracies and state terrorism at the world level. (“Pakistan to ‘forcefully’ raise issue of Indian state terrorism, conspiracies: Qureshi,” The Express Tribune, 18 January 2021)

 

 

"There should, in this 21st century, be no murders that are justified by the claim of upholding a non-existent ‘honour’. We should call them by what they are — dishonour killings."
- An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'Dishonour killings'

 


Vaccines will be procured in first quarter, says SAPM


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Vaccines will be procured in first quarter, says SAPM
Targets to vaccinate 70 million people to achieve herd immunity

On 15 January, the Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on Health Faisal Sultan said that the government is confident of securing vaccine doses in the current quarter. He specified that the date for procurement has not been decided as the government is proceeding with caution and looks forward to securing the vaccine with highest efficacy. 

Pakistan negotiates with various firms 
The SAPM said that the government would register vaccines from Cansino, a Chinese firm, with the Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan (Drap) once the tests are complete and results successful. Similarly, the government is negotiating with five “Russian and western companies” for the second phase of vaccine procurement. 

Further, Pakistan has also registered with the international vaccination drive, Covax; with this, the country would secure 50 million free doses of vaccine. 

Questions raised over vaccine funds
Meanwhile, the former health minister raised a question on the release of funds for vaccine procurement and its transparency. She urged to bring the issue to the notice of the Council of Common Interests (CCI). Similarly, Opposition leader Syed Qamar called for the same. However, the SAPM reiterated that there is no issue with funds.

Charts out vaccination drive 
In the first phase, frontline health workers and people above the age of 65 will be vaccinated, said the SAPM. The second phase would consist of remaining health workers and roughly seven million people between the age of 60 and 65. He said that around 100 million of the 200-million strong population is under the age of 18; therefore, they will not be vaccinated immediately. He said, the government aims to vaccinate at least 70 per cent of the population by November this year to achieve herd immunity. (Syed Irfan Raza and Ikram Junaidi, “Govt wants to obtain vaccine of highest efficacy,” Dawn, 16 January 2021)

 

PIA aircraft seized in Kuala Lumpur over legal issues
PIA calls Malaysia’s decision one-sided and unacceptable

Image Source: Dawn

On 15 January, a Boeing 777 aircraft of the PIA was seized in the Kuala Lumpur aircraft over a pending British case regarding a USD 14 million lease dispute. The dispute was initiated by the  Peregrine Aviation Charlie Limited;  two jets leased to PIA by AerCap, which leases aircrafts across the world, are part of the portfolio it sold to Peregrine Aviation. 

Pakistan’s aviation industry struggles
The latest blow to PIA comes as its accumulated losses amount to more than USD four billion. Further, a plane crash of a PIA flight left 97 passengers dead in May 2020. Following this, PIA flights were banned by several countries after a scandal regarding fake pilot licenses broke out. 

PIA calls for diplomatic channels to resolve matter
The PIA spokesman said that seizing the aircraft was “a one-sided decision.” The PIA statement termed the situation unacceptable and called on the Pakistani government to solve the matter diplomatically. (“PIA plane seized in Malaysia over $14m lease dispute,” Dawn, 16 January 2021)

 

Lashkar-i-Jhangvi, Lashkar-e-Taiba redesignated as FTO, SDGT
Pompeo makes announcement as Biden takes over next week

 Image Source: Dawn

On 14 January, the US Department of State announced that it had “amended the terrorist designations of the Lashkar-i-Jhangvi (LJ) and the ISIL Sinai Peninsula (ISIL-SP)” to bring other aliases of the groups under their purview. With this, LJ and Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) were redesignated as foreign terrorist organisations (FTO) and Specially Designated Global Terrorists (SDGT). The redesignation will block resources to the groups to execute any attacks. 

Announcement made as Biden is set to take over 
Mike Pompeo announced the above as the Biden administration will take office from 20 January. The announcement comes amid a series of foreign policies changes. This could possibly be an effort to help set the agenda for the incoming administration. (Anwar Iqbal, “US redesignates LJ, LeT as terrorist outfits,” Dawn, 16 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Nawaz Sharif’s passport not to be renewed 
On 15 January, the Interior Minister said Nawaz Sharif’s passport will not be renewed adding that PM Imran Khan has ordered for the same, which is why the interior ministry had decided accordingly. Further, while speaking about the PDM the minister stated that the PTI government was not afraid of the PDM protest, but it was time to observe whether the opposition would respect the law and the Constitution or not. (Ahmad Fraz Khan, "Rashid says PM asked him not to renew Nawaz’s passport," Dawn, 16 January 2021)

Broadsheet CEO says government knows who transferred $1 billion to the UK
On 15 January, Broadsheet LLC Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Kaveh Moussavi claimed that the PTI government knows who the suspicious account belonged to adding that he "voluntarily" identified a suspicious bank account in the UK of having an amount of $1 billion but the government of Pakistan has not shown any interest in tracing it. Further, he said that representatives from the government spoke about a "commission" for him if he identifying the bank account. (Zain Ul Abideen Siddiqui, "Broadsheet CEO claims Pakistan govt knows who transferred $1bn to UK," The Express Tribune, 15 January 2021)

Clarity on the vaccination procurement is what the people need, says editorial
An editorial in The News International critical of the global race for a vaccine and the government’s plans says that the people of Pakistan are still unclear not just on when individual people will get vaccinated but on when the country will even place an order for the vaccine. In this regard, the editorial says that the government must ensure that the people of the country understand the government’s plans and that Covid-19 managers must give a realistic timeline of when to expect a roll-out of a vaccine. ("Waiting for a vaccine," The News International, 16 January 2021)

PROVINCES 
KP witnessed a surge in terrorist incidents in 2020
The inspector general of police while speaking to The News said that there has been an increase in terrorist incidents reported in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa during 2020 while target killings, extortions and kidnappings dropped decreased in the last 12 months. Further, the official statistics of the Counter-Terrorism Department (CTD) revealed that 156 terrorist incidents were reported in KP in 2020, with the incidents have increased by around 50 per cent in 2020 compared to 2019. (Javed Aziz Khan, "Terror incidents in KP record increase in 2020," The News International, 16 January 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
‘In spite of the ‘gates’ that rocked the US, democracy stood firm,’ says opinion
An opinion in Dawn argues that although the quality of American presidents has been slowly falling, there are no signs that of the US is declining. However, America’s positive indicators are far stronger than those of a negative nature. Further, the opinion states that despite the riots at capitol hill which shook the US, America’s democracy stood firm owing to its robust democratic institutions. (Muhammad Ali Siddiqi, "America in decline?Dawn, 16 January 2021)

Trump administration appears to create a justification for an attack on Iran, says opinion
An opinion in The Express Tribune critical of Mike Pompeo’s disclosure on the Iran-Taliban nexus says that the timing of this declaration is important. The opinion says that the logic in the Trump administration is that any perceived linkage between the Taliban and Iran would spread panic and the Congress would block any reconciliatory move aimed at the US returning to the JCPOA. The move seems to be motivated by the powerful Israeli lobby, adding that the Trump administration appears to create a justification for an attack on Iran, targeting its nuclear installations. However, it says that the Trump presidency continues to be on the path of making bogus assertions misleading the American public. (Rustam Shah Mohmand, "Iran-Taliban nexus: the new US doctrine," The Express Tribune, 16 January 2021)

ON INDIA
British MPs strongly agreed with Pakistan’s positions on Kashmir, says editorial
An editorial in The Express Tribune said that British MPs in a discussion on Kashmir strongly agreed with Pakistan’s positions on the Modi government’s alleged brutal treatment of the residents of J&K. However, the FM during the discussion said that the region is of “particular concern” avoided taking a critical tone stating that it was not “appropriate” for the British government to intervene in a bilateral dispute. On the other hand, the Indian High Commission in London issued New Delhi’s response saying that India’s ‘internal issues’ are off-limits. ("Rare Kashmir debate," The Express Tribune, 16 January 2021)

 

"The current government must realise that constant bickering and poor governance will lead us nowhere. This ship needs a new captain who must be competent enough to sail it through these rough seas."
- An opinion in The News International
on 'inefficiency of Khan’s government'

 


Govt permits PDM to stage protest outside the ECP office


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Govt permits PDM to stage protest outside the ECP office
Says not to take the law into its own hands
Image Source: Dawn

On 14 January, the Interior Minister announced that the government has decided to allow the PDM to stage a protest outside the office of the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP). However, it warned that the alliance not to take the law into its own hands. Further, the minister hoped that the opposition would respect the “goodwill gesture” shown by the government and hold protest in accordance with the law. (“Govt allows PDM to stage protest outside ECP office,” Dawn, 15 January 2021)

PDM set to march towards to ECP office
PDM is set to start rallies from different areas of Rawalpindi and Islamabad on 19 January and then that would merge into one big rally before heading towards the office of the ECP in Islamabad.

Meanwhile…
While the scrutiny committee of the ECP audits foreign funding of the PTI met for a second consecutive day, the Information Minister said that the PTI was the only party that was managing its funds with complete transparency, adding, “PTI is the first party to have made a departure from the established practice of PML-N, PPP and JUI-F of receiving heavy donations from vested interest groups, land grabbers and other rogue elements and returning the favour to them at the cost people of Pakistan after the polls.” (Iftikhar A. Khan, “Under-fire PTI insists funds being managed transparently,” Dawn, 15 January 2021)
 

 

Laws are to apply when the constitution is quiet, says SC
AG argues SC is the appropriate forum for interpretation of the Constitution

Image Source: The Daily Times

On 14 January, the Supreme Court observed that if the Constitution does not mention the procedure to hold Senate elections, then the law will apply there. This came after the federal government said that the apex court being a constitutional court was obligated to interpret the Constitution. A five-member bench of the apex court, headed by Chief Justice of Pakistan Gulzar Ahmed resumed hearing in the presidential reference.

AG argues that for interpretation of the Constitution, SC is the appropriate forum
While inquiring about the difference between secret and open ballot, the chief justice asked as to where the procedure of Senate elections is written. Further, the bench also asked being a political matter why the government did not approach the parliament. To this, the attorney general argued, “For interpretation of the Constitution, Supreme Court is the appropriate forum, not the parliament,” adding, “On many occasions, the Supreme Court had interpreted the matters related to politics.” (Sohail Khan, “Presidential reference on Senate polls: Laws are to apply when constitution is quiet, says Supreme Court,” The News International, 15 January 2021)

Meanwhile…
On 14 January, PM Imran Khan said the government was committed to using all available resources to improve the justice system to provide relief and justice to people. Further, he called for stern action against corrupt element by strengthening the reward and punishment system. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Govt committed to improving justice system: PM,” Dawn, 15 January 2021)

 

Pakistan stands by Turkey in its fight against terrorism, says CAS
Both share a “unique and enviable” relationship

Image Source: The Express Times

Chief of Air Staff (CAS) Air Chief Marshal Mujahid Anwar Khan during his visit to Turkey said, Pakistan stands by Turkey in its fight against terrorism, stressing the need for mutual collaboration and cooperation to overcome this challenge. He said, “We know Da’ish. They are a clear and present danger,” adding, “We need to have mutual collaboration, and cooperation, to overcome these challenges.” Further, he said that Pakistan and Turkey enjoy “a unique and enviable” relationship, adding that the two countries have agreed to have a common vision to maintain regional stability, peace, and prosperity. (“Pakistan backs Turkey’s fight against Da’ish,” The Express Tribune, 14 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
3,097 new COVID-19 cases reported in a single day
On 14 January, the National Command and Operation Centre (NCOC) reported that there were 3,097 new cases and 46 deaths, the highest number of Covid-19 cases in a single day. Further, the positivity ratio, which remained at around five per cent also witnessed a spike to 7.45 per cent. (Ikram Junaidi, “Alarm as daily virus cases jump to over 3,050,” Dawn, 15 January 2021)

ECONOMY
Food inflation continues to prevail despite reducing prices
Food inflation continues to be a challenge for the government as prices of wheat flour, cooking oil and sugar have increased despite the constitution of a committee to curb prices in the country. Industry officials said that prices had been on the rise partly due to the return of middlemen to the supply chain of commodities. Apart from this, a surge in international prices of wheat and cooking oil has also impacted rates in the domestic market. Critical of the issue, Federal Minister for Industries and Production said food inflation is the only kind of inflation which is not declining whereas non-food and non-energy inflation has remained under control. (Salman Siddiqui, “Food inflation continues to persist,” The Express Tribune, 15 January 2021)

Private sector asked to invest in Africa
The High Commissioner-designate of Pakistan to Rwanda said that Africa provides a huge opportunity to Pakistan for goods export and the private sector should focus on the African region for promoting trade. Further, the Islamabad Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ICCI) President said that Pakistan should also make strenuous efforts to create space for it in Africa by focussing on countries such as Rwanda which is an important location in the African region and by initiating close business cooperation with it, Pakistan could get easy access to the huge African market. Further, the president added that Pakistan neglected Africa for business relations, however, with the current government focusing on the Look Africa policy, could help the private sector to gain better penetration into the African region. Currently, Pakistan’s trade volume with the region was only $3 billion mainly due to a lack of connectivity. (“Private sector urged to explore African market,” The Express Tribune, 15 January 2021)

ON INDIA
IHC asks govt to Govt contact India for the appointment of Jadhav's lawyer
On 14 January, the IHC asked the government to contact the Indian government to know whether it is willing to appoint a lawyer for Kulbhushan Jadhav. The court has adjourned the hearing of the case till 3 February. Meanwhile, the deputy attorney general told the court that the interior ministry had given no objection certificate to Ismail another detainee is likely to be released on 22 January through the Wagah border. (“Govt told to contact India for appointment of Jadhav lawyer,” Dawn, 15 January 2021)

 


PTI blames agents in foreign funding case


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PTI blames agents in foreign funding case
Elites cannot hide behind ‘victimisation’ cards, says Imran

On 13 January, the scrutiny committee of the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) met in a move to speed up the probe on PTI accounts which were booked under a foreign funding case against the party in 2014. According to sources in Dawn, the PTI had sent a written reply the scrutiny committee’s questionnaire; the party held that the responsibility of any funds “collected illegally through two US companies registered after Imran Khan’s written instructions,” lies with  their agents overseeing the two LLCs. 

Scrutiny committee refuses to share PTI documents, Akbar disapproves
The case against the PTI was filed by a founding member of the party, Akbar S. Babar. During the meeting, his lawyer disapproved that the scrutiny committee refused to share the PTI’s documents with Babar; they include 23 PTI bank statements, mostly concealed from the ECP, submitted per the State Bank of Pakistan’s directives. 

Akbar, critical of the scrutiny committee, said “When those who are under investigation influence the investigation process, how can there be progress?” Further, he claimed that the PTI pressured the committee into replacing an auditor. (Iftikhar A Khan, “PTI blames its agent in US for ‘illegal funding’,” Dawn, 14 January 2021)

Blame game between Imran and PML-N continues
On the same day, PM Imran Khan posted a series of tweets against Nawaz Sharif in the backdrop of the recent Broadsheet revelations. He said, “These elites cannot hide behind the ‘victimisation’ card on these international revelations…” Further, Imran referred to the Broadsheet CEO’s claim that USD one billion had been money laundered “by an influential person in Pakistan.” Imran said, USD one billion had been transferred from Saudi Arabia to the UK and hinted that Broadsheet investigation came to halt in 2002 after Nawaz left for Saudi Arabia during Musharraf’s era. 

In retaliation, the PML-N’s Information Secretary said that Imran seemed to forget about the corruption under his governance and listed out the sugar scandal, flour corruption, public medicine scam and corruption in LNG procurement. She accused the PM of “victimising the opposition to leverage an NRO for himself.” (Syed Irfan Raza, “Broadsheet has again put spotlight on Nawaz graft: PM,” Dawn, 14 January 2021)

Editorial criticises selective accountability
An editorial in Dawn doubts the credibility of Moussavi’s claims as the revelations have been made out of the blue. The editorial, while agreeing that white-collar crimes and money laundering need investigation, is critical that accountability is done selectively. It opines that some people are given benefit of the doubt, while some are targeted mercilessly. It terms the NAB “a handmaiden to political expediency.” Referring to the recent statements of the SC on the NAB, the editorial criticises the anti-graft body for “trampling on constitutional rights without any apparent fear of itself being held to account.” (“Broadsheet’s ‘revelations’,” Dawn, 14 January 2021)

 

Pakistan, Turkey, Azerbaijan to increase trilateral cooperation
Islamabad, Ankara increase cooperation to combat Islamophobia

Image Source: Dawn

On 13 January, the Pakistani Foreign Minister and his Turkish and Azerbaijani counterparts signed a trilateral agreement to broaden their cooperation and reaffirm support for each other on areas of mutual concern. During the second round of trilateral talks held in Islamabad, the three ministers discussed their common threats: “foreign-sponsored acts of terrorism, cyber-attacks, hybrid warfare, disinformation, and Islamophobia.” 

Kashmir a part of the trilateral agenda
A joint communique released after the meeting outlined that the ministers reaffirmed the “OIC resolution on the Jammu and Kashmir dispute adopted in Niamey.” The communique expressed that the three ministers were worried about the “grave human rights violations and efforts to change the demographic structure of Jammu and Kashmir.” They emphasised on adopting measures within the UNSC resolutions to resolve the Kashmir issue. 

Pakistan-Turkey relations take shape
The Foreign Office said that FM Qureshi and his Turkish counterpart appreciated the positive growth in the countries’ bilateral relations. Further, the Turkish FM and Pakistan’s Minister of Federal Education and Professional Training signed an MoU to improve cooperation in education. Apart from agreeing to increase bilateral cooperation trade, finance, and the like, the two foreign ministers reiterated that the two countries should work together to combat Islamophobia. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Defence, trade ties with Azerbaijan, Turkey to be expanded,” Dawn, 14 January 2021) (Shafqat Ali, “Pakistan, Turkey, Azerbaijan for regional peace,” The Nation, 14 January 2021)

 

PDM fight is against the government, says Fazlur
Aims to uphold the supremacy of the Constitution

Image Source: Dawn

On 13 January, the PDM reiterated that their fight was aimed at the government and not the army. The PDM leaders opined that the government had been “imposed” on Pakistan through rigging of elections. During the public meeting at Loralai, Maulana Fazlur Rehman said the PDM was launched to uphold the “supremacy of the Constitution.” He said the PDM pushed for a parliament “elected by the people in a free, fair and impartial election.” Referring to Imran Khan’s election rhetoric in 2018 - to be held accountable if Pakistan faces inflation under his rule - the Maulana said the PM does not care today. He warned that if the PTI continued to stay in power, it would cause economic and political devastation in Pakistan. 

Meanwhile, Maryam Nawaz and Bilawal Bhutto were not present at the public meeting. (Saleem Shahid, “PDM struggle against govt, not army: leaders,” Dawn, 14 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
COAS meets families of slain Hazara miners 
On 13 January, COAS Gen Bajwa met with the families of the slain Hazaras miners in Quetta, while assuring them that perpetrators of this heinous act shall be brought to justice. The army chief was given a security briefing at the HQ of Southern Command where he was briefed on the prevailing security challenges in Balochistan and the measures taken to curb them, including border management along the Pak-Afghan and Pak-Iran borders. (“Army chief meets families of slain Hazara miners,” Dawn, 14 January 2020)

Two soldiers killed in an attack in North Waziristan
Between 12-13 January, two soldiers were martyred and three others wounded in a terrorist attack on a security check-post in the Speenwam area of North Waziristan tribal district. The attack took place after terrorists launched an attack on the check-post with heavy weapons, leading to an exchange of fire between them and security forces. (“Two soldiers martyred in North Waziristan attack,” Dawn, 14 January 2020)

Attacks on polio teams show there is still resistance to polio vaccination, say editorials 
An editorial in Dawn critical of the recent attack on polio workers in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa says that this show there is still much resistance to polio vaccination owing to deceptive theories. The consequence of this is that thousands of children are not vaccinated against the disease with suspicious mindsets being the biggest impediment to polio eradication in the country. In this regard, the editorial says that rooting out this misinformation and persuade elected representatives to personally engage in raising awareness should be immediately carried out. (“Polio dangers,” Dawn, 14 January 2020) 
An editorial in The News International also critical of the resistance to polio vaccination and the attacks say that this shows the hostility with which people regard polio teams and the shootings suggest that they are doing everything to stop the children from receiving the polio drops. The editorial says that there is a need to rethink on how to safely deliver the drops to children across the country. (“
Attack on polio team,” Dawn, 14 January 2020)

ON GILGIT- BALTISTAN
Govt plans to announce economic package for GB
On 13 January, the federal government plans to announce a major economic package for Gilgit-Baltistan as promised. In a meeting with the government of GB, the ministry of planning and development created two technical groups to finalise the integrated development plan on the pattern of the recently announced Karachi Transformation Plan. The two committees are to hold a follow-up meeting in next 15 days and shortlist the most important areas for inclusion in the GB integrated development plan. (Khaleeq Kiani, “Govt to announce economic package for GB soon,” Dawn, 14 January 2020)

 

 

"If it wishes to rise above the fray and remain untainted by the hurly-burly of politics, the security establishment must take tangible measures to disengage itself from it. Remain on the same page as the government, but in a separate column."
- An editorial in Dawn
on the 'Military's role'

 


Broadsheet revelations vindicate struggle against elite, says PM


Photo: The Daily Times



In Focus
Broadsheet revelations vindicate struggle against elite, says PM
Government forms committee to investigate Broadsheet claims

On 12 January, PM Imran Khan, referring to the recent revelations by the Broadsheet LLC, said these developments were only the “tip of the iceberg.” He claimed that his struggle against Pakistan’s ruling elite was now vindicated by the assets recovery firm. He emphasised that “These elites come to power and plunder the country.” Therefore, he urged Broadsheet LLC to display complete transparency and disclose the names of those who allegedly hindered the firm’s investigation process. 

Imran targets Nawaz
In this context, Imran outlined the Panama Papers fiasco which led to the end of Nawaz Sharif’s regime and said the incident exposed the country’s ruling elite. With this he reiterated that the “ill-gotten” assets through money laundering is stashed abroad with an aim to use the political clout of the accused to secure an NRO. 

Government constitutes committee to address money laundering
On the same day, the Information Minister announced that a committee had been formed to investigate and monitor the revelations of the Broadsheet LLC. The committee will be chaired by the PM. The committee was formed in the backdrop of the Broadsheet CEO’s interview and a decision of a high court in England to impose a penalty on the NAB. (“
Broadsheet revelations 'tip of the iceberg': PM Imran,” The Express Tribune, 13 January 2021)

Previously…
On 11 January, the Broadsheet CEO, Kaveh Moussavi traced the beginning of his firm’s relationship with the Musharraf regime; Musharraf had hired Moussavi in 2000 “to retrieve alleged illegal offshore assets of Pakistani politicians and businessmen.” Though Musharraf wanted Moussavi to track the assets of the Sharif family, Moussavi declined claiming that he and his firm “would not be a tool of a political witch-hunt.” (Atika Rehman, “Moussavi says didn’t want to be part of witch-hunt,” Dawn, 11 January 2021) Subsequently, the firm was handed a list of around 200 targets including the Sharifs, Bhuttos, other retired judges, bureaucrats and businessmen. 

Further, in the latest interview, Moussavi claimed that Nawaz Sharif offered a bribe to Broadsheet LLC urging them to abandon a probe against his foreign assets. 

 

Complete full action plan by next month, FATF tells Pakistan
Lists out what Pakistan got right, what needs more focus

Image Source: Dawn

The Financial Action Task Force (FATF) has urged Pakistan to speed up and complete its full action plan by February as the deadlines for action plans expired. As per The News International, the FATF website says Pakistan has made progress regarding key areas and is yet to improve in some. 

Where Pakistan showed improvement
The key areas that showed marked improvement includes: identifying and sanctioning illegal Money or Value Transfer Services, “implementing cross-border currency and bearer negotiable instruments controls,” increased international cooperation in cases of terrorist financing, introducing amendments to the Anti-Terrorism Act, addressing Anti-Money Laundering and Counter Financing of Terrorism violations, and the like. 

What Pakistan needs to improve
The latest FATF notification listed out four strategic deficiencies of Pakistan: First, Pakistan needs to prove that law enforcement agencies are identifying and investigating terror financing activities; the LEAs also need to ensure that “investigations and prosecutions target designated persons and entities.” 

Second, Pakistan should show that the prosecution of the accused leads to “effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions.”

Third, Pakistan needs to focus on demonstrating effective implementation of targeted financial sanctions against all 1267 and 1373 designated terrorists. This would include prevention of movement of funds, freezing of assets etc. 

Lastly, Pakistan should demonstrate enforcement against TFS violations. (Wajid Ali Syed, “FATF asks Pakistan to ‘swiftly’ complete action plan by Feb,” The News International, 13 January 2021)

 

Polio vaccination team attacked 
Policeman killed while the health workers remained uninjured

Image Source: Dawn

On 12 January, just two days into the five-day national immunisation drive, a polio vaccination team came under attack in the Latamber area of Karak district, resulting in the death of a police constable while the health workers remained unharmed. According to Dawn, the constable was in duty with the polio vaccination team when attackers opened fire on them. As a result, Junaid­ullah was killed on the spot.

Nothing should be allowed to disrupt the polio campaign says editorial
An editorial in The News International critical of the immunisation drive in the country says that the country has witnessed several setbacks due to flaws in the administration of the programmes it has run against polio, as well as refusals by people in the wake of fake news about the negative impact of the vaccine. As the government devises a communication strategy to combat the issues with challenges already propping, the editorial says that nothing should be allowed to disrupt the polio campaign adding that the people must be made aware of the severe consequences. (“Pushing away polio,” Dawn, 13 January 2021)

PR Archives: The Polio Crisis in Pakistan
Pakistan is one of only two countries where wild polio and vaccine-derived polio strains remain. If the government fails to adopt transformative measures to eradicate poliovirus, the situation could become worse in the country. However, the task is not easy with issues stemming from societal misconceptions, failure of governance and attacks on polio workers itself. ( "The Polio Crisis in Pakistan," Pakistan Reader, 1 September 2020)


In Brief
EXTERNAL
Pakistan calls for reduced violence in Afghanistan
On 12 January, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi, in a meeting with the visiting leader of Hezb-i-Wahdat-i-Islami, Afghanistan, Ustad Karim Khalili, urged “all sides” for the reduction in violence leading to a ceasefire. Additionally, he emphasised that “The Afghan leadership should seize this historic opportunity to establish lasting peace in Afghanistan through intra-Afghan negotiations.” Similarly, PM Imran Khan in a separate meeting with Mr Khalili underlined that Pakistan’s message to all sides was to work together for a peaceful solution. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Pakistan urges warring Afghan sides to reduce violence,” Dawn, 13 January 2021)

 

 

"An end to faith-based violence can only be achieved if comprehensive peace in the region is pursued as a strategic objective...The objectives of establishing peace and security can only be achieved if the state promotes a culture rooted in constitutionalism, human rights, democracy and the rule of law."
- An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'Dynamics of religious militancy'

 


PDM struggle to continue until rulers stop oppressing poor: Fazlur


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PDM struggle to continue until rulers stop oppressing poor: Fazlur
Army rejects claims of having "backdoor contacts" with government

On 11 January, PDM Chief Fazlur Rehman reiterated that the opposition’s struggle against the government is a jihad which would continue until “rulers stopped oppressing the poor.” Addressing a rally in Bathkela, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the Maulana said that the opposition parties were putting up a fight against “those who had snatched the mandate of people.” He emphasised that the opposition parties were left with no choice but to form the PDM to restore real democracy in the country. According to him, Pakistan was placed under an undeclared martial law and demanded the army to clarify “whether it is neutral or a party in favour of Imran Khan.”

Bilawal comes down heavily on Imran 
At the rally, Bilawal Bhutto said the PTI had failed to implement the promises it made during the election campaigns. He accused the federal government of “trying to NFC Award from provinces and deny constitutional rights to the people of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.” 

Further, Bilawal referred to the recent Mach massacre of the Shia Hazaras and Imran’s response to it. He alleged that by calling the Hazara protesters blackmailers, Imran had proved that “blood of the people is cheaper in Naya Pakistan than their life.” Next, he accused the government of carrying a one-sided accountability process. 

Earlier during the rally, Fazlur had also termed the NAB process partial. He said the NAB only filed cases against the opposition leaders and turned a blind eye to the corruption of ruling party members. (Gohar Ali Khan, “PDM drive against govt termed ‘jihad’,” Dawn, 12 January 2021) (“Undeclared martial law in place: Fazlur Rehman,” The News International, 12 January 2021)

Army responds to PDM rally
In response to the PDM’s stand against the Army and a possible move to march to Rawalpindi, the DG ISPR Major General Iftikhar, on the same day, said he does not reason with the PDM’s logic to march to Rawalpindi. He rejected the PDM claims against the establishment saying that the “army saw no substance in opposition’s allegations.” He also appealed to the leaders to exclude the army from political rhetorics. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Army rejects allegation of meddling in political affairs,” Dawn, 12 January 2021)

Further, the DG ISPR also claimed that the military was apolitical and subordinate to the government and refuted claims that there was any backdoor contact between the two bodies. He therefore reiterated that the PDM does not have to march to Rawalpindi; if it does then the army will serve them “chai and pani.” (Muhammed Anis, “Absolutely no backdoor contact with PDM: ISPR,” The News International, 12 January 2021)

 

Pakistan launches first instant payment system
Cash economy an obstacle for people, says Imran

Image Source: The News International

On 11 January, PM Imran Khan launched Raast - Pakistan’s first digital payment platform which is part of his Digital Pakistan vision and is an initiative of the State Bank of Pakistan. He sees Raast as a way to include the poor and informal sections of society into the formal economy; it has been developed in collaboration with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and Karandaaz, Pakistan.

During the launch, Imran said Raast is testifies as a milestone in the SBP’s larger goal to digitise Pakistan. 

Raast will monitor the economy
As a digital instant payment platform, Raast will be able to document and monitor the economy and thereby help in increasing tax revenue, said the PM. He was critical of the fact that of the 220 million-strong population, only two million paid taxes. Within this, 3000 taxpayers paid 70 per cent of the tax.  (Syed Irfan Raza, “PM unveils first digital payment system,” Dawn, 12 January 2021)

Imran hints moving away from cash economy
Imran conveyed that the cash economy is an obstacle for the 220 million people of Pakistan. This is because during tax collection, Pakistan lost out on the informal sector. This, according to him, kept Pakistan from building infrastructure - hospitals, schools and the like. He said, with Raast, Pakistan can focus on poverty alleviation. (“No money for development: PM Imran Khan,” The News International, 12 January 2021)

 

Second drop in Covid-19 active cases
Active cases cut by 15,000 in one and a half months

Image Source: Dawn

On 11 January, an official the National Institute of Health stated “It is the second time that the number of cases has started dropping. Earlier, after surfacing of Covid-19 in the last week of February 2020, cases started increasing and the number of active cases surpassed well ahead of 50,000. In July active cases started dropping and only 5,831 active cases were left on Sept 13, 2020.”

In November 2020, the total number of cases had exceeded the figure of 50,000, however, as of 22 January, the number of active cases in the country was 35,246. Further, the National Command and Operation Centre (NCOC), 294 ventilators were occupied across the country. (Ikram Junaidi, “
Number of active Covid-19 cases coming down,” Dawn, 12 January 2020)


In Brief
INTERNAL
NEPRA sets up committee investigate power blackout
The National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) has decided to set up a high-powered committee of its top professionals to investigate the reasons and facts that led to the blackout in the country. The committee will comprise renowned protection engineers from the private sector. Further, the committee has would submit its recommendation to avoid such incidents. (“NEPRA to investigate power blackout,” The Express Tribune, 12 January 2020)

Govt plans to set up 48 nutrition centres under the Ehsaas programme 
On 11 January, the government under its Ehsaas programme plans to establish 48 nutrition centres to overcome common health problems like stunting, underweight and overweight in children under five years of age, especially in under-developed and poor areas of Pakistan. Initially, the government plans to set these centres will be set up in 13 districts. Under the three-year programme, conditional cash transfers will be delivered to vulnerable pregnant women, mothers and children under five and provide them specialised nutritious food, immunisations and health-awareness sessions. (Bakhtawar Mian, “48 nutrition centres to be set up under Ehsaas programme,” Dawn, 12 January 2020)

‘PML-N not in favour of in-house change’ says Iqbal
On 11 January, the PML-N announced that it was not in the favour of an in-house change as proposed by another party of the PDM. PML-N Secretary General Ahsan Iqbal said, “An in-house change can be a proposal by any other opposition party, but we are not in its favour as it is not a viable option. To do that, we will have to resort to horse trading, which we are against. In the Senate chairman election, we saw how 64 votes (of the opposition) were reduced to 52… this game will have to be played again for an in-house change.” This comes after the PLM-N announced that it would take part in the Senate polls and any option to resign from National and provincial assemblies would be weighed after that. (“‘PML-N not in favour of in-house change’,” Dawn, 12 January 2020)

Civil and Military leadership vow to bring Mach incident perpetrators to justice
On 11 January, PM Imran Khan and COAS General Qamar Javed Bajwa expressed the determination to bring the perpetrators of the Mach incident to justice. Further, at a meeting between the PM and Director General ISI Lt. Gen. Faiz Hamid the national security situation was also discussed. (“PM Imran Khan, General Qamar Javed Bajwa pledge to bring Mach incident perpetrators to justice,” The News International, 12 January 2020)

ECONOMY
Budget deficit ascends to Rs992 billion
On 12 January, The Express Tribune reported that the federal budget deficit soared to nearly Rs1 trillion in the first five months of the current fiscal year, which was largely in line with the annual budget target due to a continued crunch on defence and development spending and keeping some expenditures off the books. Further, the federal budget deficit widened to Rs992 billion which is 2.2 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) during the July-November period of the current fiscal year, which was five per cent higher than the same period of last fiscal year. (Shahbaz Rana, “Budget deficit soars to Rs992b,” The Express Tribune, 12 January 2020)

 

 

"If the state wants to be serious about eliminating sectarianism, it needs to stop pretending like sectarian groups are reborn just because they change their name...Neither can the state allow a new breed of hate to take root."
- An opinion in The Express Tribune
on 'The art of blackmail'

 

 


India stalling progress of Mumbai attack case, says FO


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 11 January 2021
Pakistan in the dark: The power blackout across the country
On Saturday night, the blackout started and spread across the country from Karachi in the south to Islamabad in the north. According to an initial statement from the energy ministry, it all started with a thermal power station in Guddu in Sindh. It then spread across, and most of the cities in Pakistan came under dark. By Sunday evening, the government claimed that it is attempting to restore power, and blamed a technical fault causing a massive frequency, that led to the calamity. According to the federal minister of energy, what happened in Guddu, started a “cascading effect on every power plant in the country, which, in turn, became dysfunctional, and resultantly the whole power generation system collapsed.”

This is not the first time Pakistan is facing the issue linked to the Guddu station. Similar things happened earlier during 2015 and then in 2016. What happened during the weekend then should be seen as a recurring problem, and be addressed accordingly. While technical issues need to be addressed within the powerplant, there are larger issues relating to the transmission lines as well. This is not peculiar to Pakistan alone; entire South Asia has a problem with electricity transmission. Besides the theft, South Asia wastes electricity due to its inefficient transmission. From the cables to transformers, Pakistan and the rest of the region have to invest and find long term solutions.

Back to Pakistan, the country’s energy sector suffers from multiple systemic problems, including power generation, power transmission and power distribution at the technical levels. However, the larger problem is the governance of the energy sector. Governments have politicised the sector and have pursued ad hoc arrangements; its approach towards the IPPs would exemplify the above approach.
 
In Focus
India stalling progress of Mumbai attack case, says FO
Imran accuses Modi government of causing unrest in Pakistan

On 10 January, the Foreign Office accused India of stalling the investigation process of the Mumbai attack case. The FO spokesperson said India was reluctant to send witnesses to the Pakistani court for cross examination. He claimed that “investigations, prosecutions and subsequent convictions, through due process,” are a testimony to the efficiency of the legal system in Pakistan. 

FO makes statement amid US response on Lakhvi’ conviction

The FO made the accusatory statement after the US State Department, while appreciating the conviction of Zakiur Lakhvi for financing terrorism, urged Pakistan to deem him accountable for “involvement in terrorist attacks, including the Mumbai attacks.” 

In response, the FO asked the US to reserve its concerns for India’s alleged  “aiding, abetting, planning, promoting, financing & execution of terrorist activities.” The FO claimed to have provided adequate evidence of the same. 

Pakistan concerned as India gets chairmanship of three UNSC panels

In the above context, the FO also raised concerns against India securing chairmanship of three key UNSC panels, including one on the Taliban sanctions and counterterrorism committees. The FO asked UNSC members to ensure that India does not “abuse its position as a non-permanent member of the UNSC.” 

With a reference to Kashmir, the FO spokesperson alleged that “India’s bellicose rhetoric and belligerent actions” were threatening “peace and security in the region and beyond.” (Iftikhar A Khan, “Pakistan holds India responsible for delay in Mumbai case,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

India is backing the IS to cause unrest, says Imran

On the same day, PM Imran Khan accused India of backing the Islamic State “to cause turmoil in Pakistan.” Highlighting the IS claims on the Hazara incident, Imran opined that India was backing the IS and that the Modi government operated with “a stated aim” to “spread unrest in Pakistan.” 

Imran said his government had been briefed by intelligence agencies that India had an agenda to fuel sectarianism in Pakistan by killing Shias and Sunnis and thereby widening the rift between the two communities. (“India backing IS to spread unrest in Pakistan: PM Imran on Hazara killings,” Dawn, 10 January 2021)

 

Power supply yet to be restored in cities after technical collapse in power plant
Opposition accuses PTI government of lying to “cover up failures” 

Image Source: Dawn

On 10 January, several cities remained cut off from power supply after a countrywide power breakdown took place the previous day. According to officials, a technical snag in the Guddu power plant - led to a drop in transmission frequency to zero; this tripped the three main 500kV transmission lines that in turn tripped other main lines across Pakistan. They estimated that power supply would be restored on Monday (today) as the National Transmission and Despatch Company (NTDC) has been working on the issue. However, the reason behind the technical fault has not been detected yet. (Khalid Hasnain, “Several cities await power supply as restoration efforts continue,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

Power outage reflects failure of protection system
The NTDC protection system should have isolated the technical failure in the Guddu power plant and prevented the subsequent tripping of other main grids. However, this did not happen due to inadequate maintenance and non-washing of transmission lines. Further, the latest outage is the third incident since 2015 thereby reflecting the failure to upgrade the protection system. (Khaleeq Kiani, “Failure of safeguards pinpointed as cause of outage,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

Committee constituted to investigate technical snag
Meanwhile, the NTDC formed a four-member inquiry committee to investigate the technical cause behind the power outage. Apart from addressing the technical aspect of the issue, the committee has been tasked to hold any officer/official accountable for negligence and to suggest preventive measures against such incidents in the future. The committee is expected to submit its report within seven days. (“Four-member panel to probe power breakdown,” The News International, 11 January 2021)

Government, Opposition engage in blame game
On 10 January, the Minister for Information and Broadcasting blamed the past governments for the failures in the power sector. Similarly, the Minister for Energy said the power transmission system was being improved now because the past governments did not do so. 

On the same day, opposition leaders accused the government of “telling lies to cover up its failure in the power generation sector.” The PML-N Secretary General said the Saturday incident was a proof that the current government was “inept” and “incompetent.” Further, the PML-N Information Secretary said the PTI press conference was a bulletin of lies. (Amjad Mahmood, “Govt telling lies to cover up power sector failures: opposition,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

 

Polio vaccination drive for 2021 begins in Pakistan
285,000 workers to vaccinate 40 million children 

Image Source: Dawn

Pakistan is set to start its first polio campaign under strict precautionary measures and protocols for the year 2021. As part of the campaign, a five-day national polio immunisation drive will start from during which over 40 million children under the age of five will be vaccinated across the country. Further, a supplementary dose of Vitamin A drops will also be administered to the children aged six to 59 months as a means to help build general immunity among susceptible children to protect them from polio and other diseases.(“Pakistan launches first polio vaccination campaign of 2021,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

285,000 workers to vaccinate children across the country
According to Dawn, data issued by the National Emergency Operations Centre (NEOC) for Polio stated that around 285,000 polio frontline workers will visit parents and caregivers at their doorsteps while adhering to strict Covid-19 precautionary measures and protocols while vaccinating children. (Ikram Junaidi, “Drive against polio begins as Covid cases cross 500,000 mark,” The News International, 11 January 2021)

Government seeks to ensure timely and repeated vaccination of children
The Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on National Health Services stated, “Our aim is to ensure timely and repeated vaccination of children. This is key to reducing immunity gap and protecting children against polio and other diseases. The government is committed to reaching the goal of a polio-free Pakistan which requires full support of the nation, especially from communities and the parents and caregivers of children under the age of five years.”

PR Opines: Pakistan’s polio crisis
Pakistan is one of only two countries where wild polio and vaccine-derived polio strains remain. If the government fails to adopt transformative measures to eradicate poliovirus, the situation could become worse in the country. However, the task is not easy with issues stemming from societal misconceptions, failure of governance and attacks on polio workers itself. This said Pakistan has no choice but to ensure that its campaign this year assists in reaching the end goal of a polio-free country.


In Brief
INTERNAL
NROs devastated economy says, PM Imran Khan
On 10 January, PM Imran Khan said, “Two NROs given by Pervez Musharraf had damaged the country to a great extent and overburdened the country under debts that half of the revenue today goes to debt payment, leaving the government with short of resources to spend on public welfare.” He added, “During the last 10 years, they [opposition leaders] had given NROs to each other and consequently the country’s debt swelled fourfold and there was the same NAB (National Accountability Bureau) which did nothing against them.” Further, he said, “Any NRO to the opposition leaders for their corruption cases would ease out my life but it would be disastrous for the country.” (Syed Irfan Raza, “Musharraf-era NROs devastated economy: PM,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

Did not want to be part of witch-hunt says, the owner of Broadsheet LLC 
On 11 January Dawn reported that Kaveh Moussavi owner of an international asset recovery firm, Broadsheet LLC, spoke about the beginnings of his firm’s relationship with the Musharraf regime as well as his attempts to offer his now liquidated company’s services to subsequent governments in an interview with a UK-based web channel. Moussavi said that he got into an agreement with Musharraf to go after elements across the political spectrum, not just Sharifs, adding, “Initially, the focus of Musharraf was to go after Nawaz Sharif and his government but we insisted we would not be a tool of a political witch-hunt and said previous governments should be looked at too.” (Atika Rehman, “Moussavi says didn’t want to be part of witch-hunt,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

Violent extremists as long as they are free will pose a threat to minorities across the country says editorial 
An editorial in Dawn critical of PM Imran Khan’s delayed visit and statement on the Hazaras says that the grieving community could do little but receive him with good grace, and hope that this time the state follows through. Further, the editorial critical of the plight of minorities in the country says that the government ensure than security forces hunt down violent extremists and bring them to trial, adding that as long as they are free, they will continue to pose a threat to minorities across the country. (“PM’s visit to Quetta,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

ECONOMY
Tax receipts surpassed Rs2,205 billion during the first six months (July-Dec)
On 1o January, in a meeting held to review the tax reform, PM Imran Khan was told that the tax receipts had surpassed Rs2,205 billion during the first six months (July-Dec) of the current financial year. The meeting informed that tax collection was being automated and taxpayers were being given incentives, adding that this automation would enhance transparency and reduce corruption and tax evasion. Further, the PM was briefed that growth in the number of taxpayers had been witnessed because of tax reforms. (“July-Dec tax receipts surpass Rs2,205bn, PM told,” Dawn, 11 January 2021)

 

 

"High rates of economic growth would not do; the state has to get actively involved in addressing the problem by directly aiding the poor.”
- An opinion in The Express Tribune on
'The state’s role in alleviating poverty'

 


Slain miners finally laid to rest


Photo: Dawn



In Brief

INTERNAL

Slain miners finally laid to rest

On 9 January, 10 coal miners from the Hazara community, who were brutally killed in an attack on 3 January, were laid to rest at Quetta's Hazara Town cemetery. This came after the protestors, who had earlier refused to bury the deceased unless PM Imran Khan visited them and addressed their concerns, continued to stay on the road after eventually agreeing to bury the deceased after successful negotiations with a government team. Soon after the agreement, an announcement was made to end the protest in Quetta, while similar messages were played at gatherings in other cities as well. (Ghalib Nihad, “Slain miners laid to rest in Quetta's Hazara Town,” Dawn, 9 January 2021)

Anti-terrorism court jails LeT leader for five years for terror financing

On 8 January, anti-terrorism court convicted Zakiur Rehman Lakhvi, leader of the banned Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT), on a charge of terror financing. The presiding judge announced the verdict and handed down a collective sentence of 15 years imprisonment with a fine of Rs300,000. Further, the judge awarded five-year rigorous imprisonment each to Lakhvi and ordered the government to confiscate dispensary Abu-Huraira situated in Pakpattan. (Wajih Ahmad Sheikh, “LeT leader jailed for five years for terror financing,” Dawn, 9 January 2021)

Three awarded death sentence, one 10-year jail for blasphemous content

On 8 January, the Anti-Terrorism Court (ATC) sentenced three persons to death and a ten-year imprisonment with a fine of Rs 100,00 to one person for allegedly posting blasphemous content online and disrespecting the religion respectively. Previously, an FIR had been registered against them as per the orders of the Islamabad High Court (IHC) in March 2017. (“Blasphemous content on social media: Three awarded death, another given 10-year jail,The News International, 9 January 2021)

ECONOMY

Remittances cross USD 2 billion for seventh consecutive month

On 8 January, the latest data from the State Bank of Pakistan showed that remittances stood at USD 2.436 billion crossing the USD 2 billion mark for the seventh month in the current financial year. With this, the remittances increased by 16.2 per cent year on year from USD 2.097 billion in December 2019. Over the year, remittances from Saudi Arabia were the highest at around USD 600 million per month, on an average since June 2020, followed by the UAE and the UK. The trend has been similar for the month of December. (Fayaz Hussain, “Remittances over $2bn for 7th month running,” Dawn, 9 January 2021)

EXTERNAL

COAS honoured with Bahrain Order award

On 8 January, COAS Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa was honoured with the Bahrain Order (first class) award by the Crown Prince, Deputy Supreme Commander and Prime Minister of Bahrain Prince Salman bin Hamad bin Isa Al-Khalifa for making significant contribution to defence cooperation between Bahrain and Pakistan. This came as the COAS was on an official visit to Bahrain from 6-8 January. During his visit, matters of mutual interest, bilateral defence and security cooperation and security situation in the Middle East were discussed, further, Bahrain pledges to keep working for even better ties with Pakistan. (“Army chief honoured with Bahrain Order award,” Dawn, 9 January 2021)

 

 


Pakistan successfully tests Multi-Launch Rocket System: ISPR


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Pakistan successfully tests Multi-Launch Rocket System: ISPR
Claims to be capable of “engagement deep in enemy territory”

On 7 January, the Inter-Services Public Relations said that Pakistan had successfully tested its extended-range guided Multi-Launch Rocket System (MLRS) called Fatah-1. The MLRS, produced indigenously,  has a range of 140 kilometres and has the capacity to carry a conventional warhead.

Pakistan seems to be responding to India’s capabilities, says Dawn

According to Dawn, with the development of the indigenous weapon, Pakistan appears to respond to India’s “development of its conventional capabilities.” (“Pakistan tests multi-launch rocket system,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

Series of missile tests in recent past

The latest test comes after Pakistan tested several missiles in 2020. In February 2020, the country “conducted a flight test of air launched cruise missile Ra'ad-II.” This missile has a range of 600 kilometres. At the time, Strategic Plans Division Director General said the test was a “major step towards complementing Pakistan’s deterrence capability.” (Naveed Siddiqui, “Pakistan conducts successful test of air launched cruise missile Ra'ad-II: ISPRDawn, 18 February 2020)

Similarly, in January 2020, Pakistan carried out a training launch of Ghaznavi, a surface to surface ballistic missile. This missile has the capability of launching multiple warheads up to a range of 290 kilometres. (“Pakistan successfully conducts surface-to-surface training launch of missile Ghaznavi,” Dawn, 23 January 2020)

Prior to this, Pakistan successfully tested a nuclear-capable surface-to-surface ballistic missile with a capability to strike up to 650 km; it has a capability to launch all types of warheads. (“Pakistan successfully test-fires nuclear-capable missile,” The Hindu, 18 November 2020)

Currently, Pakistan has a wide range of “Short Range Ballistic Missiles (SRBM), Medium Range Ballistic Missiles (MRBM), Battlefield Ballistic Missiles (BBM), Surface to Surface Cruise Missiles (SSCM) and Rocket Artillery.” (Muhammad Anis, “Pakistan conducts test flight of Fatah-1,” The News International, 8 Janaury 2021)

 

State Bank of Pakistan says trade deficit is increasing
Imran refutes figures; stresses on import substitution and self reliance

Image Source: Dawn

On 7 January, the State Bank of Pakistan data revealed that Pakistan’s trade deficit had increased by 32.04 per cent. With this the deficit amounted to USD 2.683 billion in December 2020 from USD 2.032 billion in December 2019 because of higher imports. Further, the imports rose by 16.69 per cent from November to December 2020. Since September, Pakistan’s imports have been on a rise; this could be because of the “rebounding imports,” after imports had been on a steady decline for a few years. (Mubarak Zeb Khan, “December trade deficit widens by 32pc,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

Imran disputes exports figures 

However, on the same, PM Imran Khan tweeted that the exports of India and Bangladesh displayed a negative growth; compared to this date, Pakistan had higher export figures. In 2020, the export figures of Pakistan stood at 8.32 per cent and 18.30 per cent in November and December respectively. In contrast, the figures for India in the respective months stood at -9.07 per cent and -0.80 per cent. In Bangladesh, the numbers were 0.76 per cent and -6.11 per cent respectively.

Ministry of commerce to draw plan for import substitution

On the same day, Imran met with the Apex Committee on Economic Outreach to discuss self-reliance. In the meeting, it was decided that the Ministry of Commerce will form a plan of action within a definite timeline to cement the trends of import substitution and increasing exports. He pushed for adopting some of the top international practices for priority sectors. He said “consultations with international experts is essential for achieving success.” (“PM Imran Khan greets economic team on increase of exports,” The News International, 8 January 2021)

Previously… 

On 5 January, the World Bank, in the Global Economic Prospects (GEP) 2021, had forecasted Pakistan’s economic growth rate for the current fiscal year to remain at 0.5 per cent. The World Bank said the figure would remain the same because of continued fiscal consolidation pressures and service sector weakness. However, on the same day, the SBP projected a real GDP growth in the range of 1.5 to 2.5 per cent in FY21. The SBP’s data was based on the current economic trends. (Khaleeq Kiani, “WB revises growth forecast down to 0.5pc,” Dawn, 6 January 2021 and Shahid Iqbal, “One day, two projections: State Bank says GDP to grow 1.5-2.5pc,” Dawn, 6 January 2021)

 

Maryam and Bilawal meet with the Hazaras
PM’s visit still not confirmed 

Image Source: Dawn

On 7 January, Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari and Maryam Nawaz addressed the participants of the sit-in staged by the mourners of the Hazara community. During the meeting, they urged PM Imran Khan to visit the families of slain coal miners to share their pain and sorrow. While addressing the gathering, Bilawal said, “I have come here to share the pain of the grieving families as I myself belong to a family of martyrs and am still waiting for justice,” adding, “Unless the state assures the citizens that their lives are safe, the security of the country and the federation will remain in jeopardy.” Similarly, Maryam warned that if he did not come to Quetta, the “nation will not allow him to sit on the chair in Islamabad.” (Saleem Shahid, “Maryam, Bilawal meet heirs of slain coal miners,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

Imran Khan’s visit to Quetta remains undecided, says not to blackmail him
As the pressure mounts on the PTI-led coalition government, PM Imran Khan’s visit to Quetta to meet the protesters remains undecided. However, PM Khan has directed the interior ministry to devise a foolproof security mechanism for the Hazara community that faced terror incidents in the past as well as to compensate the victims’ families in line with the government rules and policy (Saleem Shahid, “No decision yet on PM’s visit to Quetta,” The Express Tribune, 8 January 2021)
On 8 January, PM Khan reiterated his appealed to the Hazara community to bury the slain miners, calling on them to refrain from “blackmailing the premier.” Further, he said “We have accepted all of their demands. [But] one of their demands is that the dead will be buried when the premier visits. I have sent them a message that when all of your demands have been accepted [...] you don't blackmail the prime minister of any country like this.”  (“Don't blackmail me, PM tells Hazara protesters,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

PM should not delay his visit says an editorial 
An editorial in The Express Tribune critical of delay in Imran Khan’s visit states two reasons why there may be this delay. First, security may be one hindrance to the PM visiting the bereaved community. Second, the PM may not want to set a “bad” precedent of giving in to the demands of a protesting crowd. However, the editorial says that nothing should excuse the PM from delaying his visit to the griever in what is seen a barbarous act of terror, adding that he should have paid a visit to the grievers even without them requesting for it. (Saleem Shahid, “After the Machh tragedy,” The Express Tribune, 8 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
20.76 million lost livelihoods due to Covid-19 lockdowns says PBS
On 7 January, the Planning Commission said that according to a survey conducted by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) Pakistan’s 20.76 million workforce suffered livelihood losses due to coronavirus-related lockdowns and a large majority of them got back to work after July 2020. The Commission said the country’s 35 per cent which is about 55.74 million of the population of 10 years and older were working before the onset of Covid-19, but due to closure of activities after implementation of lockdowns, this declined to 22per cent which is about 35.04 million people. Further, 17.07 million households were affected due to lockdown restrictions. (Khaleeq Kiani, “20.76m lost livelihood due to lockdowns: survey,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

Abbasi denies rifts within the parties of the PDM
On 7 January, PML-N leader Shahid Khaqan Abbasi refuted reports of rifts within the PDM stating that if a party walked away from the alliance it would hurt itself politically. He argued, “The establishment’s interference in politics has to end and all the parties have had enough of it,” adding, “even if a party in the alliance is to break away for some reason, it will destroy itself politically. This interference has hurt all of us and simply cannot continue — all political factions know that.” Further, he said “There is no point talking to this government. It simply has to go.” (Atika Rehman, “Those who abandon PDM will be finished politically: Abbasi,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

Pakistan lauds easing of Gulf crisis over Qatar
On 7 January, FM Shah Mehmood Qureshi held a telephonic conversation with his Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Bahrain counterparts where he welcomed the easing of the Gulf crisis over Qatar. Further, he stressed the need for the strengthening of Islamabad’s relations with the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries. Further, the FO stated that the foreign ministers agreed to continue engaging on regional and global issues and continue working together to enhance bilateral ties. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Pakistan welcomes easing of Gulf crisis over Qatar,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

PPP re-elects Bilawal as chairman for four years
On 7 January, the PPPs media office stated that all the central office-bearers of the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), including Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, have been “re-elected” for another four-year term without having any contest. Besides Bilawal, Syed Nayyer Hussain Bukhari has been elected unopposed as the PPP secretary-general, Faisal Karim Kundi as secretary information and Rukhsana Bungash as secretary finance. Further, Bukhari dismissed the impression that the party elections had been kept a secret, stating that the process had been completed strictly as per the party’s constitution and rules. The intra-party elections at the federal level were held in Karachi on 6 January. (Amir Wasim, “Bilawal ‘re-elected’ PPP chairman for four years,” Dawn, 8 January 2021)

 


PM promises to visit mourning Hazaras in Quetta


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PM promises to visit mourning Hazaras in Quetta
MWM asks PM to act before it is too late

On 6 January, a federal cabinet member said that Prime Minister Imran Khan would visit Quetta soon to express his solidarity with the Shia Hazara community. Emphasising that he will not betray the trust of his people, the PM requested the protesters to bury the victims and promised that he would visit and “condole with all the families” soon. The cabinet member said Imran did not visit Quetta earlier citing security concerns. (Saleem Shahid and Amir Wasim, “PM plans ‘surprise visit’ to meet Hazara mourners,” Dawn, 7 January 2021)

Bilawal and Maryam visit Quetta today
On 7 January (today), Bilawal Bhutto and Maryam Nawaz are scheduled to visit the protesters in Quetta. Maryam will be accompanied by senior PML-N leaders and Bilawal by the Sindh CM. Simultaneously, a JUI-F delegation will also arrive in Quetta. (“Maryam Nawaz, Bilawal Bhutto to meet Machh tragedy victims in Quetta today,” The News International, 7 January 2021) 

Protesters continue sit-ins despite CM, SAPM visit 
Meanwhile, protests against the government continued for the fourth day and mourners refused to vacate the Western Bypass area; they refused to bury the miners even after Balochistan CM, Federal Minister for Maritime Affairs, and SAPM on Overseas Pakistanis visited them and tried convincing them. 

Protests erupt in different parts of Sindh
To express solidarity with the Hazara community, the Majlis-i-Wahdatul Muslimeen (MWM) and other Shia organisations demanded the federal government to hear out the demands of the community.

On 6 January, the Shia community in Hyderabad warned that they would block the Hyderabad bypass if the government did not adhere to the demands of the victims’ kin. Similarly, in Sukkur, leaders of local Shia organisations said the government had, on various counts, had failed to curb the “terrorism” that the Shia community has been facing for decades. (“Shia organisations stage protests against Mach incident in several Sindh towns,” Dawn, 7 December 2021)

On the same day, sit-ins continued for the fourth day in Karachi and the demonstrators called for “immediate action.” While the protests in the city brought traffic movement and flight schedules to a standstill, the MWM spokesperson said the protesters were only exercising their constitutional rights. The MWM said the protests would continue until the leaders at the Centre took a decision regarding the issue. He said, “We demand the government and Prime Minister Imran Khan to play their due role before it’s too late.” (“Sit-ins in solidarity with Mach victims expand to different parts of Karachi,” Dawn, 7 Janaury 2021)

Sindh Assembly passes resolution against Mach incident, urges PM to visit Quetta

On the same day, the Sindh Assembly adopted two clubbed resolutions, presented by the PPP and the MQM-P, against the massacre of the 11 miners. The Assembly members appealed to the PM to visit the Quetta protest site as soon as possible. The Sindh Information Minister emphasised on the need to reintroduce the National Action Plan “which he said was halted after the PTI came into power.” Further, the MQM-P highlighted that federal governments, even in the past, had failed the Hazara community. (Tahir Siddiqui, “Prime minister sahib, go to Quetta, demands Sindh Assembly,” Dawn, 7 January 2021)

Governments chose the easy way out to address the Hazara issue, says editorial

An editorial in Dawn, critical of the state response to the Hazara tragedy over the years, says the governments always chose the easier path to address the issue - to provide security to the community than “throw behind bars the violent extremists.” The editorial warns that anger at the sectarian killers is spreading, especially among the Shias. It highlights the attacks, which took place after a lull, are a reminder of “how tenuous is the triumph over militancy.” (“Hazara protest,” Dawn, 7 January 2021)

 

NAB reluctant to arrest influential people, observes bench
Justice Bandial urges NAB to be free from influence

Image Source: The Daily Times

On 6 January, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah of a three-member Supreme Court bench criticised the NAB and held that the anti-graft body exhibited a partial approach. He observed that the NAB was “reluctant to nab influential people.” Similarly, Justice Mazahir Naqvi said the NAB arrests government officials of lower ranks and does not arrest officials against whom evidence is abundant. The SC observed that the NAB would send people under minor allegations behind bars while letting those involved in mega corruption roam free. 

Justice Umar Ata Bandial urged for NAB to be strong and free from any influence or pressure. He pushed the NAB to enforce the law equally and held that “strict action would be taken against the NAB for not ensuring fair accountability as required by the law.” 

The bench was hearing a case of fake bank accounts case against Dinshaw Anklesaria. 

SC grants bail to accused in fake bank accounts case

The SC granted bail to Dinshaw Anklesaria in a fake bank accounts case and directed him to stay in Pakistan and cooperate with the NAB. The NAB alleged that Dinshaw, being an advisor to the CM, had sent two applications signed by him regarding allotment of plots in Bagh-e-Jinnah, Karachi. Further, Dinshaw also faces charges of availing loans through forged documents. 

After the SC granted bail to Dinshaw, the NAB conveyed that it was not against the bail. However, the NAB held that they will oppose the bail of government officials.(Sohail Khan, “Supreme Court not satisfied with NAB, warns of action,” The News International, 7 January 2021)

 

COVID an additionally challenge for Pakistan implies as opinion
Vaccine procurement and distribution the next big challenge 

Image Source: Dawn

 An opinion in The News International lists six issues to define ‘Pakistan in 2021’ arguing that they may be linked, directly and not-so-directly, to Covid-19. First, the availability of a vaccine and cheap rapid tests, however, the next challenge would entail storage and transport arrangements. Second, the need to clarify and contradict rumours and conspiracy theories propagated on social media on COVID-19 vaccination. Third, the effectiveness of Pakistan’s present economic policy responses to the impact of the pandemic. Fourth, how effectively the country bridges the digital divide between different parts of the county will determine whether Pakistan will be ready for the fourth industrial revolution in 2021. Fifth, major conventional sectors of the economy as agriculture and food security would need investment. Sixth, the possibility of a socioeconomic turnaround in 2021 will depend upon political stability in the country. (Dr Abid Qaiyum Suleri, “Pakistan in 2021,” The News International, 7 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Gwadar Port should be used as a free zone area says, President Alvi
On 6 January, President Dr Arif Alvi emphasised on the need of utilising Gwadar Port as a free zone area for transit trade with Afghanistan and Balochistan. He said that speedy flow of traffic at Gwadar port must be ensured and urged the authorities to accelerate development activities through consensus-building and consultations. Further, he said that strategy and vision were crucial for the successful completion and operationalisation of national projects like Gwadar port. (“‘Utilise Gwadar Port for transit trade with Kabul’,” Dawn, 7 January 2021)

ECONOMY
SBP report cleverly hides the negative trends says editorial 
An editorial in Dawn critical of the forecast made by the State Bank of Pakistan’s for the first quarter of FY2021 of 0.5 per cent growth may appear far too optimistic. It adds that the SBP had tamper its estimate by cautioning that the recovery faces downside risks owing to “intensification of the second wave of the pandemic.” Further, it says the problem with this report is that the SBP hides cleverly the negative trends such as the cost at which the external account stability is maintained, the low industrial output and the IMF mandate. To this, the editorial asks, when the suspended IMF programme is restored? Will the central bank still be as overly optimistic on the country’s growth prospects? (“SBP report,” Dawn, 7 January 2021)

EXTERNAL
Pakistan and South Korea held the third round of trade talks 
On 6 January, Pakistan and South Korea held the third round of the Joint Trade Committee meeting. The two sides discussed possibilities to expand the bilateral trade and investment linkages. Further, the problems faced by Korean companies operating in Pakistan were raised in the meeting, Pakistan assured complete facilitation in the resolution of all outstanding issues. Apart from this, the prospects of a Free Trade Agreement and investment opportunities in automobile and textiles were also discussed. The next round of talks is to be held in 2022 as both sided agreed to continue their commitment to extending the validity of the existing memorandum of understanding. (“3rd round of trade talks with S. Korea,” Dawn, 7 January 2021)

ON INDIA
PM Khan accuses BJP of a pogrom against Muslims and minorities
On 6 January, PM Imran Khan said the incumbent BJP movement had been implementing a pogrom against the Muslims and all other minorities in India and Jammu and Kashmir. He said that Modi was responsible for tense ties between the two countries with Modi being nonreciprocal of his invite to address issues. Further, he said that Modi’s whole election campaign was based upon increasing jingoistic and anti-Pakistan sentiments, adding “Modi’s government got rid of the special status of the disputed territory with its illegal actions of August in last year and now it was subsequently changing the demography of Kashmir.” (“India’s regime executing pogrom against Muslims, minorities: PM Imran Khan,” The News International, 7 January 2021)

 

"The past is, at best, helpful in avoiding the pitfalls on the road ahead, and no greater folly is known to humankind than forcing any people to live in their past. Many of our present day failures to deal with matters of the moment are due to our love for tradition and wrong choices of instruments of change.”
- I.A. Rehman on the 'Falling capacity to manage'

 


Supreme Court directs ETPB to rebuild Hindu Shrine in KP


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 6 January 2021
The Machh massacre: Hazaras are barking at the wrong tree
The massacre of eleven Shia miners in the Machh region is unacceptable. One should understand the pain of the relatives who lost their loved ones and also the fear of the Hazara community in Balochistan. They have been targeted systematically over the last few years. So their ongoing protests in Quetta demanding justice for the victims are totally justified. However, demanding an audience with the Prime Minister, as a precondition to bury the dead may not help their cause in the long run. The problem is not the Prime Minister or Islamabad. It lies elsewhere.

The problem is a systemic political failure – in the province, and also in Quetta, especially the provincial assembly. Compared to the other three provincial assemblies in Punjab, Sindh and KP, the one in Balochistan has always remained unstable. Political instability inside the provincial assembly, federal patronage and internal wrangling within the Baloch parties ensures no provincial accountability. The response of the Balochistan government spokesman would underline how the local government sees the problem. Dawn quoted him: "(The Hazaras) were earlier restricted to Hazara Town and another locality. But now they are free to move anywhere and even they are seen enjoying at picnic points."

Second, it is not Islamabad, but Rawalpindi, that calls the shots in Balochistan. Imran Khan as the Prime Minister would be as helpless as Jam Kamal Khan, the current Chief Minister of Balochistan. From fencing Gwadar to fighting militancy in the province, the decisions are made elsewhere.

Third – the institutions – from the judiciary to media, the attention on Balochistan is not consistent. Though from the days of Chief Justice Chaudhry, there has been an effort to improve the accountability and investigations into the disappearances, the province needs larger attention. For the media – print and electronic, Balochistan remains a third-page story, unless something like Machh happens.

The problem of Hazaras is not specific to minorities alone. It represents the larger systemic issues inside Balochistan. The former cannot be dealt with in isolation.
 
In Focus
Supreme Court directs ETPB to rebuild Hindu Shrine in KP
Incident brought international embarrassment to Pakistan, says CJP

On 5 January, the Supreme Court directed the Evacuee Trust Property Board (ETPB) to rebuild the Hindu shrine that was vandalised by a mob on 30 December 2020. The Chief Justice of Pakistan had previously initiated a suo motu cognisance of the issue. Expressing displeasure that the vandalism took place, the three-member SC bench headed by the CJP ordered the ETPB to submit a report of all Hindu temples and Gurudwaras in Pakistan, functional or otherwise. The Court emphasised that the “tragic incident had brought embarrassment and shame to the country at the international level.” 

SC comes down heavily on Chief Secretary, IG and ETPB

During the hearing, the Chief Secretary and the IG of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa conveyed that only one of the six ulemas present at the protest organised by JUI-F member Maulana Faizullah,  had incited the mob - Maulvi Sharif. Further, they said 92 police officers had been suspended for “dereliction of duty.” This included a Superintendent of Police and a Deputy Superintendent. However, the bench held that mere suspension was no solution. The CJP ordered the Chief Secretary “to recover money from those who set fire to the temple.” 

Justice Ijazul Ahsan, one of the members on the bench, asked how the mob vandalised the shrine, close to a police check post; he asked where the intelligence personnel were at the time. Along the same lines, the SC held that the ETPB chairman “should not sit on his seat with bureaucratic mentality.” The bench also accused the members of the Board of “indulging in their private business on the lands meant for the holy sites of the minorities.” (Nasir Iqbal, “SC orders rebuilding of vandalised Hindu shrine in Karak,” Dawn, 6 January 2021)

Pakistan Hindu Council disputes claims

The SC was informed that the ETPB did not look after the shrine because it was non functional. However, the Pakistan Hindu Council Chief said that 300-400 people visit the shrine every month and fairs were held regularly. (“Take money from molvi, followers to reconstruct demolished temple: CJP Gulzar Ahmed,” The News International, 6 January 2021)

 

FM Qureshi criticises Opposition for using Kashmir as political points
Situation would have been different if ZA Bhutto was alive, says Sherry Rehman

Image Source: Dawn

 

On 5 January, Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi, amid a blame game in the Senate over Kashmir, called on the Opposition to chart a plan on the same. However, prior to calling the opposition leaders for a dialogue, Qureshi criticised them for accusing the government of mishandling the Kashmir issue. He claimed that the Opposition was using the Kashmir issue for political gains and wondered how they could point fingers at the government. 

Later, he emphasised, “Let us join hands on this issue. This is a continuous battle and we will have to fight it collectively.” 

Sherry Rehman reminisces about ZA Bhutto

The PPP Senator, Sherry Rehman said that the Kashmir issue would have been handled differently had Zulfikar Ali Bhutto been alive; it may have been discussed at global platforms like the UN and the OIC. She said he would have made the Kashmiri voice heard. 

Opposition leaders take on the PTI government

During the debate, a JUI-F Senator said “Narendra Modi and Imran Khan had been brought into power under a plan for held Kashmir’s complete occupation by New Delhi.” Similarly, the PML-N accused the PTI of shelving the Kashmir dispute. 

On the domestic front, Sherry Rehman criticised the government’s crackdown on dissenting voices and the state of the economy. Further, she accused the NAB of showing double standards on handling leaders of the opposition and the ruling party. She said no minister under investigation was manhandled or handcuffed or remanded in NAB Custody. (Iftikhar A Khan, “Govt invites opposition for Kashmir action plan talks,” Dawn, 6 January 2021)

 

"Terrorists and their abettors will be defeated at all costs," says ISPR
Internal security, regional environment, and other issues discussed

Image Source: Dawn

On 5 January, the 238th Corps Commanders’ Conference was held at General Headquarters. At the meeting, the Army vowed that “Terrorists and their abettors will be defeated at all costs.” They also observed that “defeat of complete threat spectrum” needed a “comprehensive national effort” involving “all segments of the society.” Further, they also discussed the recent incidents of terrorism in Balochistan as part of their deliberations on internal security. (“No PR-1/2021-ISPR,” ISPR, 6 January 2021)

Besides internal security, the commanders discussed matter related to the regional environment, particularly situation along the borders, and other professional matters of the Army. At the meeting, COAS Gen Bajwa said, “Highest standards of capability and maintaining cutting edge at all levels is vital to meet all challenges in tandem with other elements of national power.” (“Army top brass vows to defeat terrorists at all costs,” Dawn, 6 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Hazaras continue to hold their sit-in for the third day
On 5 January, the thousands of Hazara mourners who have blockaded a highway in Quetta refused to end their sit-in which entered the third consecutive day. Their sit-in continues despite efforts made by the federal and provincial authorities. Leader of the Majlis Wahdat-i-Muslimeen (MWM) stated, “We will not call off our sit-in and bury our loved ones until Prime Minister Imran Khan personally meets the mourners.” Further, they have demanded the arrest of coal miners’ killers and removal of the provincial government. This comes after protests broke out over the cold-blood killing of 11 coal miners in the Mach area earlier this week. (“Hazara mourners continue to stage sit-in for third day,” Dawn, 6 January 2021)

IPPs unsatisfied by govt plan for dues settlement
Independent power producers (IPPs) have discarded a payment plan offered by the government for partial settlement of their dues and have demanded at least 50 per cent upfront cash payments before signing formal agreements for tariff discounts. According to Dawn, IPPs has stated that the payment plan offered by the government team was unacceptable and that it seems like the government wanted ‘renegotiations’ on the existing agreed terms and conditions of the memorandums of understandings (MoUs) signed in August 2020, adding, “The government should follow its side of the agreement in true letter and spirit.” (Khaleeq Kiani, “IPPs not impressed by govt plan for dues settlement,” Dawn, 6 January 2021)

ECONOMY
WB reduces growth forecast to 0.5 per cent, State Bank says GDP to grow 1.5-2.5 per cent
On 5 January, the World Bank in its Global Economic Prospects (GEP) 2021 forecasted Pakistan’s economic growth rate for the current fiscal year to remain subdued at 0.5 per cent. The Wb attributed this projection to the continued fiscal consolidation pressures and service sector weakness. On the same day, the State Bank of Pakistan in its first quarterly report stated, “Real GDP growth is projected to be in the range of 1.5 to 2.5 per cent in FY21. This is based on the current trends of economic activity.” (Khaleeq Kiani, “WB revises growth forecast down to 0.5pc,” Dawn, 6 January 2021) (Shahid Iqbal, “One day, two projections: State Bank says GDP to grow 1.5-2.5pc,” Dawn, 6 January 2021)

 

"Providing protection and security to its citizens is a state’s fundamental responsibility. Failure to safeguard the minorities is a system failure. One sure way of transforming the systems is to strengthen institutions so people have faith in the integrity of the systems.”
- An opinion in The Express Tribune
on the country’s worsening security environment

 


Hazara mourners refuse to bury Mach victims


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 5 January 2021
The Supreme Court orders the reconstruction of the Hindu shrine
Today (Tuesday, 5 January 2021), the Supreme Court of Pakistan, in a well-directed move, asked the Evacuee Property Trust Board (EPTB) to reconstruct the Hindu shrine in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP). Last week (30 December 2020), an extremist mob, led by local religious leaders in the Karak district of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, set one fire a Hindu saint that was hundred years old. The Chief Justice of Pakistan Gulzar Ahmed took suo motu notice of this; he asked the Chief Secretary and Inspector General of the KP province, and the Head of Minorities' Rights Commission, to prepare a report, after visiting the shrine that was damaged.

Today, with those three present in the hearing, he called the event as an "international embarrassment to Pakistan," and ordered Evacuee Property Trust Board (EPTB) to reconstruct the shrine. According to a Dawn report, Justice Ijazul Ahsan, who was also in the three-member bench, questioned the IG-KP: "Where were your intelligence agencies?." According to Dawn, the Chief Justice told the EPTB Chairman: "Your employees are doing business on the land meant for shrines. Arrest them and start the reconstruction of the temple…Money should be taken from Maulvi Sharif for reconstruction of the shrine." According to the IG-KP, it was Maulvi Sharif who incited the crowd.

Yesterday (4 January 2021), the one-man commission led by Shoaib Suddle (Head of Minorities' Rights Commission) submitted its report to the Supreme Court. According to available news, the report has detailed what happened on 30 December, and also provided a road map on what needs to be done, including a recommendation of opening four Hindu temples for international tourism. (Dawn, 5 January 2021)

The Supreme Court's intervention and the Shoaib Suddle report and media condemnation of the incident through its editorials are a welcome development in Pakistan. Now the federal and provincial governments have to act. A message has to be sent to the radical clergies and extremist political leaders, that this is unacceptable. Democratic and multi-ethnic States have a duty to protect its minorities.
 
In Focus
Hazara mourners refuse to bury Mach victims
Protesters call for provincial government’s resignation

On 4 January, the mourning protesters in Mach refused to bury the victims of the Machh killings. However, two of the victims’ bodies were sent to Afghanistan. Their decision came after protests over the gruesome killings of the 11 Hazara miners continued in Quetta for the second day; the protesters demanded that the attackers be arrested. Further, they also demanded a judicial probe into the matter and called for ousting the government. 

However, there were differences on the matter of burial. The Hazara Jirga and leaders of Hazara Democratic Party (HDP) wanted to carry out the burial on 4 January. But, Majlis Wahdat-i-Muslimeen leaders and kin of the victims disagreed with the Jirga and HDP thereby continuing the sit-in. 

Will continue sit-in until provincial government resigns: Balochistan MWM  

The Interior Minister tried to pacify and negotiate the Hazaras and agreed to adhere to their demands except one: the resignation of the provincial government. On this, the Balochistan MWM President emphasised that the protests were being held for the “protection of the Hazara people.” He warned that they would continue the protests if the provincial government did not resign. He also called for constituting a committee of retired and sitting judges of the Supreme Court to look into the matter. (Saleem Shahid, “Mourners refuse to bury Mach massacre victims,” Dawn, 5 January 2021)

SAPM accuses India of fuelling sectarian tensions in Pakistan

Meanwhile, The SAPM on Religious Harmony and Middle East accused India of “flaring up conspiracies to create anarchy and sectarian violence in Pakistan.” He called on international powers to take note of “Indian-sponsored terror activities inside Pakistan.” Further, religious scholars from various schools of thought condemned the killings of the miners but accused “Indian secret agencies” operating through global terror networks. (“Secret Indian, global networks behind Machh killings: Tahir Ashrafi,” The News International, 5 January 2021)

“The state has long abandoned the Shia Hazaras,” says editorial

An editorial in Dawn, condemning the Mach killings, criticises the State for abandoning the Shia Hazaras. The editorial highlights that the State, irrespective of the leader in power, has turned a blind eye to the violent extremism against the Hazaras in Balochistan “as long as these murderous groups also served to counter the Baloch insurgency.” On a sarcastic note, it wonders why a province that has the presence of security and intelligence personnel cannot track these extremists. It is open to the argument on foreign funding for the latest attacks, but emphasises that “the whole truth is far more nuanced.” (“Hazara miners’ slaughter,” Dawn, 5 January 2021) Another editorial in The News International says the lives of the Hazaras cannot be changed unless there is  sufficient political will and determination to end the militancy and violence. It calls for holding the central and provincial governments and security system accountable for the same. (“Blood and tears,” The News International, 5 January 2021)

 

Imran Khan says PDM not a threat to his government
Emphasises on PTI's economic achievements

Image Source: The Daily Times

On 4 January, PM Imran Khan said that he does not perceive the PAkistan Democratic Movement to be a threat to his government. Reiterating that he will not issue any National Reconciliation Ordinance (NRO), he said the opposition leaders started uniting only after “they started being held accountable.” He promised to continue the process of accountability because he believed that “no society could progress without accountability.”

He accused the previous governments of looting the national treasury and claimed that his government was inching towards developing the country. 

PTI aims at performance and delivery, says Imran on economy

In the meeting with his spokespersons, Imran also directed them to highlight the economic progress of the country. He held that the PTI government had “set the country's otherwise weak economy on the right path.” Further, the focus of his  government remains on performance and delivery. He said that Pakistan had attained a USD 447 million current account surplus for November 2020. (Rizwan Ghilzai, ”PDM poses no threat to government: PM Imran,” The Express Tribune, 5 January 2021)

Previously…

On 3 January, during the PDM’s Bahawalpur rally, Maryam Nawaz had criticised the government and claimed that Pakistan’s debt had doubled in two and a half years under Imran. She said people were fed up “from unemployment and inflation.” She said all of the money is going to the pockets of the ministers and called the PM corrupt. (Irfanul Haq, “No stepping back, will show cards at right time: PDM,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

 

LHC declares virginity test in abuse cases illegal
Orders federal and provincial governments to take necessary steps

Image Source: Dawn

On 4 January, the Lahore High Court has declared t the two-finger test (TFT) and the hymen test for the purposes of determining virginity of a female victim of rape or sexual abuse as illegal and unconstitutional. In a judgement the court stated, “The virginity test offends the personal dignity of the female victim and therefore is against the right to life and right to dignity enshrined in Articles 9 and 14 of the Constitution.” Further, the judge also stated that the virginity tests are discriminatory against the female victim as they are carried out on the basis of their gender, thus violates Article 25 of the Constitution. The court ordered both the federal and provincial governments to take necessary steps to ensure that virginity tests are not conducted in medico legal examination of the victims of rape and sexual abuse. (Wajih Ahmad Sheikh, “Virginity test in abuse cases illegal, declares LHC,” Dawn, 5 January 2002)

 

In Brief
INTERNAL
Firm hired to investigation Sharifs ends up asking for their help
The asset-recovery company which was asked to investigate the offshore property of Nawaz Sharif ended up asking the Sharif family for assistance to secure the outstanding funds owed to the firm by the National Accountability Bureau (NAB). According to Dawn, the Sharif family declined to help the company in its pursuit of recovering the outstanding dues owed by NAB after the lawyers representing Broadsheet and the Sharifs in early November 2020 corresponded. (“Firm hired to probe Sharifs ended up seeking their help,” Dawn, 5 January 2002)

EXTERNAL
Khalilzad meets with COAS Gen Bajwa
On 4 January, US Special Representative for Afghanistan Reconciliation Zalmay Khalilzad called on Chief of the Army Staff (COAS) General Qamar Javed Bajwa at the General Headquarters. During the meeting, issues related to mutual interest and overall regional security situation with particular reference to the ongoing intra-Afghan negotiations was discussed. Further, both side reiterated their commitment to the common goal of peace and stability in the region and agreed on continued engagement at multiple levels. Khalilzad’s visit comes as part of his visits to Central Asia, South Asia and the Middle East amid the resumption of talks in Doha. (“Peace talks begin today: Zalmay Khalilzad calls on General Qamar Javed Bajwa ahead of Doha talks,” The News International, 5 January 2002)

 

"The answer to sectarian killings is to go, with force, after those who perpetrate them. The answer also lies in demanding that those in power, in the centre, in the province, those responsible for keeping this country's citizens – all of them – safe are made to account for this senseless bloodshed. So that the graveyard in Hazara Town doesn't see yet more mourners.”
- An Editorial in The News International

 


Militants kill 11 Shia Hazara coal miners


Photo: The News International



PR Editorial, 4 January 2021
Another terrorist attack on the Hazara Shia community in Balochistan
On Sunday, eleven members of the Hazara Shia community, who were working in a coal mine in the Machh region in the Bolan district of Balochistan. Coal mining is one of the primary economic activities of the region, where not only the Hazaras work, but also other non-Baloch communities including the Sindhis and Punjabis and also other religious communities including the Hindus. Machh is a small town, south of Quetta, linking the provincial capital with Sibi, Dera Bugti and Sui in the east.

Clearly, those eleven were targeted specifically. According to a Dawn report, referring to an initial investigation, the perpetrators identified the Hazaras, kidnapped them and left the others. This is a case of targeted sectarian killing; during the recent years, there have been a series of such killings – some large scale massacre, and others isolated incidents. But, the target have been the Hazaras, living mostly in and around Quetta, the provincial capital.

The Islamic State in the past have claimed responsibility for similar attacks. Unfortunately, there was a reluctance within Pakistan to accept the presence of the IS; instead, the State would shift the blame to external actors – either Afghanistan or India. 

Balochistan has a sectarian problem, that gets carpeted under the larger Baloch militant violence. This is not the first time that the Hazaras are being targeted; unfortunately, this will not be the last.
 
In Focus
Militants kill 11 Shia Hazara coal miners
IS claims attack; PM terms it ‘cowardly inhumane act of terrorism’

On 3 January, 11 coal miners, all belonging to the Shia Hazara community, were held at gunpoint and slaughtered by unidentified persons in the Mach coal field in Bolan district. All victims were residents of Hazara Town in Quetta; however, according to officials, at least nine of them were from Afghanistan. After the news spread, people, including women, belonging to the community started protests near Hazara town. They refused the local administration to shift the bodies to Quetta and coal miners from the community blocked movement on the Quetta-Sukkur highway which connects Quetta to Sindh. 

PM, PPP condemn attack
On the same day, PM Imran Khan condemned the attack and labeled it a “cowardly inhumane act of terrorism.” He ordered the Frontier Corps to trace the attackers and assured families of the victims that the government will not abandon them. Further, Bilawal Bhutto also condemned the incident and demanded that those involved in the barbarian act must be taken to task. (Saleem Shahid, “Gunmen slaughter 11 coal miners in Balochistan,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

Security threats to the Hazara community
Over the years, the Hazara community has been targeted by Sunni extremists and terrorist organisations like the Taliban and the Islamic State. However, targeted attacks against the community had been concentrated in Quetta which is home to nearly 600,000 Hazaras, who emigrated from Afghanistan over two generations. Hazaras have traditionally worked in the coal mining sector since the time of Britishers. However, the number of Hazara coal miners in Balochistan have reduced due to sectarian violence. Further, “their economic activities in Quetta have dwindled to their ghettoised communities” in two enclaves: Marriabad and Hazara Town. (Muhammed Akbar Notezai, “Situationer: Mourning the butchered,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

Islamic State claims responsibility

The Islamic State has claimed responsibility for the latest attack. Apart from the IS, the Taliban and Lashkar-e-Jhangvi have targeted the Hazaras, other Shia groups “and nationalist groups seeking independence for the province.” (“Gunmen kill many Hazara Shia coal miners in southwest Pakistan,” Aljazeera, 3 January 2021)

 

PDM calls its fight against government ‘jihad’
Will show our cards at the right time, says Maulana

Image Source: Dawn

On 3 January, the Pakistan Democratic Movement, during its rally in Bahawalpur, termed its drive against the PTI government ‘jihad’ and emphasised that they would not step back from the alliance as it would be a “major sin.”

Referring to the large crowd, PPP’s Yousaf Raza Gillani called on the PTI ministers to notice the  “sea of people” in Bahawalpur before dismissing the PDM rally as a flop show. In the same context, Maryam Nawaz reiterated that the PM will have no place to hide if the people march to Islamabad. 

Resignations still on the cards
During the rally, Maulana Fazlur Rehman said, “We will show our cards at the right time which will leave the government shell-shocked.” Though he indicated that the PDM might change its strategy, its end goal will remain intact. Therefore, he urged the crowd to stay away from the “misleading” media and accused the media of portraying any change in strategy as a change in the PDM’s stand. He emphasised that the much speculated strategy to resign was not cancelled and will be carried out after consultation with legal bodies and PDM member parties. Maryam too echoed this statement and said “The day the PDM lawmakers resign, it will be the final day of the PTI government.” 

Islamabad under illegal occupation, says Maulana
After alleging that Islamabad was under illegal occupation, Fazlur Rehman said that the PDM would stage a sit-in outside the ECP offices in Islamabad on 19 January  to  pressure it into deciding on the PTI foreign funding case which has been pending for past six years. Further, on 21 January, the PDM will stage a ‘Israel not acceptable’ rally in Karachi and a rally on 5 February on to mark Kashmir Day. (Irfanul Haq, No stepping back, will show cards at right time: PDM,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

 

Gwadar port could change economic situation of region, says Djibouti delegation
Port could become guarantors for promoting shipping trade, says Port Authority Chairman

Image Source: Dawn

A delegation from Djibouti visited Gwadar over the weekend and invited Pakistani industrialists and business community over to Djibouti for boosting bilateral trade. The delegation was headed by Djibouti’s President of National Parliament who is also the acting Chairman African Union Parliament. He stressed on the importance of the strategic location of the Gwadar port and said it “could change the economic situation of the entire region.”

Similarly, Chairman Gwadar Port Authority told the delegation that the Port had become fully operational. He said “the Deep Sea Port could prove as guarantors for promoting shipping trade for the investors” from across the world. Further, the Director General of Gwadar Development Authority said the Gwadar was progressing towards becoming a modern industrial city. He also said they were working towards a “Gwadar Master Plan” aimed at setting up free economic zones. (“Djibouti delegation visits Gwadar port,” The Express Tribune, 4 January 2021)

 

In Brief
INTERNAL
PLM-N stands divided on upcoming Senate elections
The PML-N stands divided on whether to take part in the upcoming Senate polls with one side supporting the PPP’s stance they must challenge the ruling party, while the other advocates boycotting the contest seeing inadequate benefit for the party. According to Dawn, PML-N elders reveal that some people close to Maryam Nawaz have advocated for contesting the elections for the Upper House, however, the rest believe that the party must continue to stay with its principled stance of resigning from all elected houses as part of pressing the Imran Khan government to resign instead of exploring other options. (Amjad Mahmood, “Dissenting voices emerge in PML-N over Senate polls,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

NAB recovers Rs487 billion ill-gotten money
On 3 January, the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) released its three-year performance report stating a total recovery of Rs487 billion. Of the total Rs487 billion, the Rawalpindi NAB recovered Rs290 billion, followed by Karachi, which recovered Rs93.17 billion, Lahore Rs72.2 billion, Sukkur Rs26.16 billion, Multan Rs4.10 billion, Balochistan Rs1.81 billion and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Rs733.3 million. The Rawalpindi office showed the best performance among all seven regional offices of the NAB during the last period under review. (“Rs487bn ill-gotten money recovered in three years: NAB,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

Pakistan asks UN to get Asiya Andrabi released
On 3 January, Pakistan approached the UN secretary-general in New York and the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights in Geneva seeking the immediate release of Kashmiri activist and political leader, Asiya Andrabi. According to Dawn, the Foreign Office, the top UN officials have been informed that Andrabi’s life is in danger due to the imminent risk of "persecutory conviction" by an Indian court. Asiya was taken into custody by the National Investigation Agency (NIA), India’s federal anti-terror organisation, for allegedly “waging war against India” and other unlawful activities. (Iftikhar A. Khan, “Pakistan urges UN to get Asiya Andrabi released,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

PROVINCES
Punjab reports twice as many COVID-19 deaths as Sindh
On 3 January, Punjab reported twice as many coronavirus deaths, as compared to Sindh. According to Dawn, data released by the National Command and Operation Centre reported that 24 people lost their lives in Punjab, 12 in Sindh, 11 in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, three in Islamabad, two in Azad Kashmir and one in Balochistan. Further, the death toll in the country has surged to 10,311 while active cases across the country reached 35,663, with the national positivity ratio was 5.12 per cent. (“Punjab sees twice as many Covid deaths as Sindh,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

ON PAKISTAN OCCUPIED KASHMIR
High time policymakers prioritised a localised and inclusive economic development in ‘AJK’: Opinion
An opinion in The News International critical of the escalating food inflation across the country, says that the region of ‘Azad Jammu Kashmir (AJK)’ is its biggest causality. Over the last few months, the region has seen a 30 per cent increase in the price of wheat forcing people to come out in numbers and protest. In this regard, the opinion says that these protests highlight two important economics actors, small farmers and low-end consumers who are overturned by neoliberal policies across South Asia. Thus, apart from the political commitment, the matter requires a structural shift away from the neoliberal economic paradigm and adoption of localised community-based economic development based on the principles of social equity, economic fairness and ecological sustainability. (Danish Khan “Protests in AJK,” Dawn, 4 January 2021)

 


Pakistan This Week: The PDM differences, Gwadar fencing, and Lakhvi's arrest


Photo: Dawn



Pakistan This Week
The PDM differences, Gwadar fencing, and Lakhvi's arrest
D. Suba Chandran

The PDM differences: on resigning from the assemblies and taking on the Establishment
One of the new year plans of the Pakistan Democratic Movement (PDM) got shattered. It gets increasingly clear that the PPP is unlikely to resign from the Parliament and Sindh Provincial Council. Mass resignations of the PDM components in 2021 were one of the primary plans; it is engineered to be the final culmination, following the Islamabad march, forcing Imran Khan to resign.

It may be easier for the JUI-F and PML-N; though both have seats in the Parliament, they are not ruling any provinces. PPP is, as in the case of Sindh. Even within the JUI-F and the PML-N, there are reservations in pursuing the resignation course. There is support for the final march to Islamabad, and even a long dharna there, as the PTI did against Nawaz Sharif government. However, the idea of mass resignations does not have complete consensus within the PDM components. The PPP has a reservation against the idea, though Maryam Nawaz and Maulana Fazlur Rehman insist on it. Both have nothing to lose; they are not a part of the Parliament now; but others from the party, have a different position on the issue.

The last meeting of the PDM leaders on 1 January 2021, though could not have a breakthrough in getting a consensus on the resignation issue, has avoided any breakup. After the meeting, Maulana Fazlur Rahman has stated that the final decision on resignation and taking part in the Senate elections would be taken after 31 January (the deadline from the PDM to Imran Khan to resign).

Maulana also made another statement, after the above meeting. Dawn, quoted him saying: "Our target of criticism will now be the establishment which set up a fake government. We respect the army and generals, but now they have to decide to step back and focus on their constitutional responsibilities." Is this a rhetoric aimed at the PDM audience, or applying pressure against the Establishment?

There are strong reservations not only on resignations, even on pursuing the "State above the State" narrative. The statement that the march would move towards Islamabad and Rawalpindi is seen as casting a wide net for the PDM. A section within the PDM, especially the PML-N, would want to go slow in targeting the Establishment. They would want to go after only Imran Khan.

What this week highlighted is the fault lines within the PDM over the resignation issue. However, the 1 January meeting also underlines, the effort to build a consensus and buy more time. As of now, the PDM has got that, until 31 January.

Fencing Gwadar: Technically feasible, Politically disastrous
Early this week, a jirga comprising of the elders from different parts of Gwadar district held a meeting and rejected the government's latest initiative to fence the city. The provincial government of Balochistan recently started to erect a barbed fence surrounding the city, with limited entries into Gwadar. The stated objective is to make Gwadar "safe" and "smart", allowing people only with permits to enter into the city from outside. Gwadar would then become a like a garrison city.

Technically, it would be feasible to fence the city. With the Arabian Sea on one side, the fencing would cover rest of the city; with Gwadar being one of the small cities or a large town, the fencing should not cover more than 25 square km. Fencing would also make guarding it easier, with limited entry and exit points, perhaps a couple of them.

Politically, it would be a disaster. It would increase the distance between the Baloch people and the government – both provincial and federal. Besides the anti-government sentiments, it would also increase the anger against the Chinese. There is already an anti-Chinese sentiment in Balochistan over the CPEC projects. This would only increase it; it is obvious that the government is attempting to fence the city, to protect the Chinese, their interests and their investments.

Later this week, the provincial government has made a conciliatory statement on stopping the fencing and addressing the local people's concerns. According to the Home Minister of Balochistan, the fencing is being undertaken to protect the port city, and increase the city's investments. An interesting statement. Port cities in the rest of the world should take a cue from Balochistan; fence them, protect the city, and increase the investment!

Lakhvi arrested on terror financing charges
On Saturday, one of the top leaders of the Lashkar-e-Toiba (LeT) – Zakiur Rehman Lakhvi was arrested for terror financing, based on a case registered in Lahore during early December. There have been multiple cases and charges against Lakhvi; India considers him as a mastermind of the terrorist attack in Mumbai in 2008.

According to a UN Security Council sanction, "Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi is the chief of operations and military commander of Lashkar-e-Tayyiba (LeT)" and in that capacity, "Lakhvi has directed LeT operations, including in Chechnya Republic in Russian Federation, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Iraq, and South-East Asia." The UNSC summary provides a detailed profile of Lakhvi. It reads: "In 2003, Lakhvi instructed LeT operatives to conduct attacks in densely-populated areas. In the same year, he directed a LeT operative to travel to Iraq to assess the situation there. In 2004, Lakhvi sent operatives and funds in order to mount attacks on the forces of United States of America in Iraq. In 2006, Lakhvi instructed LeT associates to train operatives for suicide bombings. In past years, Lakhvi has played an important role in LeT fundraising activities, receiving donations from Al-Qaida (QDe.004) affiliates on behalf of LeT. He has also managed a training camp in Afghanistan."

This is not the first time Lakhvi is getting arrested. There have been multiple arrests earlier, and the courts have provided bail. The investigation on charges against him and the cases built was never strong enough for a conviction.

Why did Pakistan arrest him? And will it be different this time?

During 2020, there have been a series of legislations passed in the Parliament to satisfy the FATF conditions, so that the latter would remove Pakistan from the Grey list. Unfortunately for Pakistan, it did not happen. One of the primary concerns of the FATF is over terror financing and the lack of adequate legal action over the issue within Pakistan. In October 2020, the FATF met and decided to keep Pakistan in the grey list until February 2021. It wants not only legislations but also actions to prove Pakistan is serious. The case filed against Lakhvi in December 2020 and the arrest in January 2021 should be aimed at providing evidence to the FATF that Pakistan is serious. Islamabad has a February deadline on this

So Lakhvi would remain in prison, at least until the next FATF meeting.

 

"That the 11-party alliance will contest the by-elections on two National Assembly seats and six provincial assembly seats despite some of the members expressing reservations earlier shows that, while differences of opinion exist on some key issues, the PDM has the resolve to stay together and persist in its opposition to the government.”
Editorial, Dawn

 


PDM raises the pitch; targets the Establishment


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PDM raises the pitch; targets the Establishment
"Our target of criticism will now be the establishment which set up a fake government," says the Maulana

On 1 January, the PDM declared that its target was not Prime Minister Imran Khan as he was a “pawn” and the real culprits were those who had imposed him on the nation. Maulana Fazlur Rehman stated, “Our target of criticism will now be the establishment which set up a fake government. We respect the army and generals, but now they have to decide to step back and focus on their constitutional responsibilities.” He added, “For us the country comes first and we do not want to discuss this puppet [Imran Khan] as our drive is against him but those who are interfering in politics and install such governments.” (Zulqernain Tahir, “PDM says backers, not Imran, its target,” Dawn, 2 January 2021)

Maulana minced no words in criticising the establishment 
An article in The News International states that Rehman shares Nawaz Sharif’s frustration with Imran Khan and wants to see his ouster at any cost. However, he and his party have now also started feeling the heat as targeting the establishment has turned in their disadvantage and in favour of Imran Khan. Nawaz’s frontal attack against the establishment displayed of some indications of gradually detaching itself from political matters could have undermined this decision. However, as seen Maulana Rehman minced no words in criticising the establishment and holding it responsible for the present political crisis. (Ansar Abbasi, “Maulana Fazlur Rehman gets message of ‘non-interference’ from powers that be?,” The News International, 2 January 2021)

PDM plans ahead
At the marathon huddle held at the Jati Umra estate of the Sharifs the PDM “The PDM has decided to take part in the by-elections.” However, on the Senate elections, he said the decision on the matter would be taken at a later stage and also spoke about holding a long march on Rawalpindi. No consensus was reached on submitting resignations to assemblies, forcing the 11-party opposition alliance to defer the decision till 31 January. Further, the alliance also drew out a plan to hold demonstrations outside the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) and National Accountability Bureau (NAB) buildings. (“PDM decides to contest by-polls, defers decision on Senate election,” The Express Tribune, 2 January 2021)

PM Khan rubbishes opposition’s allegation of being ‘puppet’
PM Imran Khan stated that the people will pay no attention to the PDM’s call for ‘long march’ and rejected the opposition’s allegation of a ‘puppet’ premier. He said, “I can give in writing that Pakistani nation will not come out on the streets on the call of PDM.” Further, he argued, “If I am a puppet and if the army has asked me to hold talks with the opposition then why I am not doing so,” adding, “The fact is that army stands by me in implementation of my government’s manifesto. Army wants stability and progress of the country and that is why it is with me.”
He reiterated, “I am ready to hold negotiations with opposition on important national issues. I am ready to talk but I will commit treason if I give NRO to the opposition. Whatever they (opposition) will do, I will not give them NRO.” (“People won’t pay heed to PDM protest plans: PM,” Dawn, 2 January 2021)

 

Pakistan asks UN to prevent the “judicial murder” of a Kashmiri leader 
Asks the world to stop giving a “free pass” to India

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 1 January, Pakistan urged the UN to prevent the “judicial murder” of Aasiya Andrabi, a Kashmiri leader and human rights activist and to persuade India to drop all “fabricated charges” against her. In a letter addressed to the UN Secretary-General, Pakistan’s Permanent Representative to the UN Munir Akram said the world must stop giving a “free pass” to India over its “systemic crackdown on the legitimate and indigenous freedom movement in Kashmir.” Further, he said that the UN could “assist in breaking the vicious cycle of impunity and human rights violations in Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir (IIOJ&K).”

Who is Aasiya Andrabi?
Aasiya Andrabi is the founder of a Kashmiri rights group called the Dukhtaran-i-Millat, or Daughters of the Nation. Asiya was taken into custody by the National Investigation Agency (NIA), India’s federal anti-terror organisation, for allegedly “waging war against India” and other unlawful activities. (Anwar Iqbal, “Pakistan urges UN to prevent Andrabi’s ‘judicial murder’,” Dawn, 2 January 2021)

FO warns that Indian actions were endangering region’s peace
On 1 January, the Foreign Office reiterated that India’s actions were endangering region’s peace as it reaffirmed commitment to friendly ties with all neighbouring countries. The FO spokesman said, “Pakistan’s message is clear and consistent. We want peace and desire cordial relations with all our neighbours. Pakistan belie­ves that India’s irresponsible actions and belligerent statements are imperiling regional peace and security.” Further, the spokesman said, “Pakistan has repeatedly been saying that the onus is on India to create an enabling environment by rescinding its illegal and unilateral actions, ending state terrorism against the Kashmiri people, and agreeing to resolve the Jammu and Kashmir dispute in accordance with the relevant UN Security Council resolutions and the wishes of the people of Kashmir.” (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Indian actions a threat to peace in region: FO,” Dawn, 2 January 2021)

 

Without a culture of science, Muslims will continue consuming technology without producing much, says Prof Pervez Hoodbhoy

Image Source: Dawn

An opinion in Dawn by Pervez Hoodbhoy states that Muslims have come to accept numerous aspects of technology. Earlier fears that technology will destroy their faith are disappearing. While speaking about the importance of scientific culture he says that without this a country can only consume and trade. What will it take to bring science back into Islam? He says unlike what is happening in the country today with music and Islam together, he argues that separation is the key, domains of science and belief do not overlap. He highlights how Muslim scholars had readily absorbed Greek learning while keeping their religious beliefs strictly personal. This made possible major discoveries and inventions. In conclusion, he says whether one likes it or not, there is no other way to develop a culture of science. (Pervez Hoodbhoy, “Muslims and technology,” Dawn, 2 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
KP government will rebuild vandalised shrine: CM
On 1 January, the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government announced that it would reconstruct the Hindu shrine in Karak which was vandalised and burnt by a mob on 30 December. According to an official statement, the CM has already issued directives to the relevant authorities on the same. Further, Shoaib Suddle “of the one-man commission on minority rights,” discussed the matter with the CM and expressed his approval of the government’s stand. (“Govt to rebuild Karak Hindu shrine vandalised by mob,” Dawn, 2 January 2021) Meanwhile, an editorial in The Express Tribune says that those who carried out the vandalism belong to the “lunatic fringe of society.” The editorial appreciates the measures taken by the federal and provincial governments and the Chief Justice’s suo motu cognisance of the issue. It emphasises that Pakistanis need to understand that attacking places of worship of minority religious is prohibited in Islam and that it is their moral duty to protect religious freedom in the country. (“Attack on temple,” The Express Tribune, 2 January 2021)

CCPO Lahore transferred 
On 1 January, the Punjab government removed DIG Umar Sheikh from the post of capital city police officer (CCPO) Lahore and has posted him as the deputy commandant Punjab constabulary. The transfer comes barely months after he was appointed as CCPO amid controversies in September. Immediately after Sheikh’s appointment as CCPO, the PTI-led provincial government removed the then IG Punjab (IGP) Shoaib Dastagir as he “refused to work with Sheikh.” Now, Senior police officer Ghulam Mohammad Dogar has been appointed as the new CCPO. (Adnan Lodhi, “CCPO Lahore Umar Sheikh removed from post,” The Express Tribune, 1 January 2021)

ON INDIA
Editorial draws parallels between India and Israel; accuses them of rights abuses
An editorial in Dawn accuses India of killing innocents in “India-held Kashmir,” and compares it with the Israeli strategy in Palestine. The editorial says India, similar to Israel, is using the “armed-to-the-teeth military” forces and accuses powerful global actors of shielding "both Israel and India against criticism of such blatant rights abuses, and instead, tout their ‘democratic’ credentials.” It demands India to listen to the Kashmiris and chart a political solution instead of applying “violent tactics.” However, the editorial conveys that this cannot be expected at the moment because of the “Hindu chauvinist dispensation in New Delhi.” (“IHK killings,” Dawn, 2 January 2021)

 


PDM leaders meet today to discuss mass resignations, upcoming elections


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PDM leaders meet today to discuss mass resignations, upcoming elections
Durrani calls on Fazlur Rehman prior to PDM huddle

On 1 January (today), heads of the PDM will “go into a huddle” to discuss the mass resignations and participation in the upcoming elections in the national and provincial assemblies and the Senate. JUI-F Chief Maulana Fazlur Rehman indicated that a future course of action would be decided  in the meeting and viewpoints of all leaders, especially Bilawal Bhutto, will be considered. 

On 29 December, Bilawal had said that the PPP’s Central Executive Committee believed that if the Opposition jointly takes up the challenge of Senate elections, they could collectively “make a better impact and achieve larger success.” Therefore, on 31 December, Fazlur Rehman and PML-N’s Maryam Nawaz said they would like to hear from Bilawal about the same and then arrive at a consensus. (Amir Wasim, “PDM huddle today after PPP ‘somersault’” Dawn, 1 December 2020)

Find another way instead of pursuing a collision course, Durrani tells Fazl

On 31 December, PML-Function Secretary General Mohammad Ali Durrani called on the JUI-F chief and requested him to adopt an alternative way. Referring to the decision to hand in mass resignations, Durrani said such a collision “may lead to the wrapping up of the ‘democratic system’.” However, Fazl reiterated that there was no space for dialogue. He said “There can be dialogue (with the powers that be) only if Prime Minister Imran Khan resigns and fresh elections are called.”

The meeting between Durrani and Fazl comes after the former met Shehbaz Sharif in jail and requested him to facilitate a grand dialogue and also convince the Opposition to not quit. 

Maryam expresses disapproval of Durrani’s meetings 

Reiterating the Maulana’s stance, Maryam said the “time for any dialogue was over.” Further, Maryam expressed her annoyance over Durrani’s meeting with Shehbaz and accused the and the establishment of “arranging this meeting without the consent of Mr Shehbaz or the party.” (Zulqernain Tahir, “Durrani meets Fazl to coax him into avoiding confrontation,” Dawn, 1 January 2021)

 

FM Qureshi, Wang Yi reiterate enhancement of bilateral cooperation
China announces emergency vaccines, road development grant to Pakistan

Image Source: Dawn

On 31 December, in a telephonic conversation, Foreign Minister Qureshi and his Chinese counterpart Wang Yi, agreed to strengthen bilateral cooperation and reaffirm the All-Weather Strategic Cooperative Partnership. The Foreign Office said the two Ministers had “agreed to maintain strategic communication and consultation.” On the regional front, the two sides agreed to “promote mutual goals of peace and stability.” According to the FO, Qureshi accused India of bellicosity and said that New Delhi’s “irresponsible policies were imperiling regional peace and stability.” 

China to provide over one million doses of vaccines to Pakistan

Qureshi appreciated the role that bilateral ties were playing in addressing the pandemic. He conveyed that Phase-III trials of the Chinese firm CanSino’s Covid-19 vaccine were under progres in Pakistan. Further, he said that the Pakistan government had approved Sinopharm vaccines, again produced by China for emergency use in Pakistan; Wang said China would provide over one million doses of the vaccine for the same. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Chinese, Pakistani FMs agree on need to deepen cooperation,” Dawn, 1 January 2020)

China to grant USD 100 million and revive N5 Highway

On the same day, the Chinese Ambassador and Pakistan’s Minister for Economic Affairs signed an agreement for grant assistance. Under the agreement, China will “provide USD 100 million as grant assistance for rehabilitation of four sections of N5 National Highway between Hala and Moro in Sindh.” The project is aimed at facilitating north-south connectivity as the N5 highway, which was damaged during the 2010 floods, previously connected the southern part of Pakistan to the north-western border. (Amin Ahmed, “China to provide $100m grant for road project,” Dawn, 1 January 2020)

 

CJP takes suo motu cognisance of Hindu shrine vandalism
What support can the govt offer the beleaguered Hindu community, asks editorial

Image Source: Dawn

On 31 December, the Chief Justice of Pakistan took suo motu cognisance of the vandalism and burning of the Hindu shrine in Karak District of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa on 30 December. The CJP asked the KP Chief Secretary, Inspector General and Head of a commission on minorities’ rights for a report on the same by 4 January. On the same day, the police arrested 31 people including a local leader of the JUI-F in connection with the vandalism. According to The News International, several leaders involved in the crime had gone underground to evade the arrests and raids by the police. 

On 30 December, over 1,000 people led by a “religious party held a protest and demanded removal of the Hindu temple.” The temple in question had been built in 1920 for a Hindu saint, Param Hans, but was destroyed by a mob in 1997. Later, his followers tried to rebuild a temple and in 2014, the temple was back in controversy during a Supreme Court hearing of a “case relating to a bomb attack on a church in Peshawar.”  In 2015, the SC ordered the KP government to restore the shrine. ((Nasir Iqbal, “CJP asks for report on Hindu shrine incident by 4th,” Dawn, 1 January 2021 and “Vandalising Hindu temple in Karak: JUI-F district leader among 350 booked,” The News International, 1 January 2021)

An editorial in Dawn, critical of the vandalism, says that the government’s efforts to project religious harmony seem futile as large sections of the population “are steeped in bigotry and some have not even spared Muslim shrines.” Further, it refers to previous attacks on Hindu temples and asks what support the government can offer an already marginalised Hindu community amid these extremists incidents. It recalls that 2020 had been marked with attacks on minorities and hopes that 2021 will bring peace to all, especially the minorities in the country. (“Rule of the mob,” Dawn, 1 January 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
With two news schemes, Pakistan will move towards a welfare state, says PM
On 1 January, PM Imran Khan said that the government will soon announce two new projects to ensure universal healthcare through the Health Card Scheme and an initiative under Ehsaas Program to prevent any person from hunger. This, he claimed, would make Pakistan a welfare state. He emphasised that Pakistan was moving in the right direction and ensured that the country will experience economic growth in 2021. He said the government will provide incentives to the business community and the industrial sector thereby increasing exports. (“2021 to be year of growth for Pakistan: PM Imran,” The Express Tribune, 1 January 2021)

Journalists’ federation to launch movement for media freedom and job security
On 31 December, the Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ) announced that it will launch a movement aimed at freedom of expression and job security of media persons. The PFUJ’s President said Secretary General conveyed that 2020 had been the “worst” year for the media industry and highlighted that more than 8,000 media workers in Pakistan lost their jobs. Further, they said “the unholy alliance” between the government and media house owners had pushed the media industry into a financial crisis. Referring to the misuse of Pemra ordinance, they said the new rules were an attempt to gag media freedom. (“PFUJ to launch movement for security of jobs, freedom of expression,” Dawn, 1 January 2021)

Mufti Muneeb to launch anti-government campain on FATF legislation
On 31 December, Mufti Munee­bur Rehman announced that he would launch a campaign against the government over an FATF legislation -  Islamabad Capital Territory Waqf Properties Bill 2020 - passed in September. He opined that religious restrictions were prohibited in Islamic republics and if the government tried to impose them, they (Ulemas of various sects) would resist them. (“Mufti Muneeb announces drive against FATF-related law,” Dawn, 1 January 2021)

PROVINCES
Crackdown on smuggling of Iranian fuel puts thousands at jobs: BNP-M leader
On 31 December, MNA and BNP-M leader Mir Mohammad Notezai condemned the provincial government’s crackdown on smuggling of Iranian petrol and diesel. He claimed that these smuggling is the only source of income for the thousands residing in “undeveloped and far-flung border areas of Balochistan.” Further, he warned that the crackdown and a complete ban on Iranian fuel would render thousands of youth unemployed. (“Crackdown on smuggling of Iranian fuel criticised,” Dawn, 1 January 2021)

ON DANIEL PEARL
Sindh HC issues notice to jail authorities for not releasing four accused
On 31 December, the Sindh HC issued notices to the provincial and jail authorities after they failed to release four men accused of involvement in the Daniel Pearl murder case. The four petitioners claimed that since the SHC had set aside their conviction by a trial court and had also declared the preventive detention orders illegal, they should have been released. According to the counsel, the senior jail officials claimed that the Sindh chief secretary and additional chief secretary home asked to not release the petitioners. Meanwhile, the SHC bench has directed the respondents to file comments by 7 January. (Ishaq Tanoli, “Contempt plea filed against govt in Pearl case,” Dawn, 1 January 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Assess 'socio-economic and security perspectives in South Asia,' opinion urges Biden
An opinion in The News International outlines challenges that lay ahead for Biden. The author says, on the domestic front, Biden will have to manage the pandemic and the increased “polarisation that has plagued the overall system of governance.” He highlights two developments, Quad and the BECA. He says Biden must not look at South Asia from the prism of the US rivalry with China. Instead, he urges Biden to tap into the potential of the region which remains one of the least integrated regions. Therefore, he says to contain China, the Biden administration  must also “take into account the socio-economic and security perspectives of other countries in South Asia.” (Murad Ali, “Biden and South Asia - Part I,” The News International, 1 January 2021)

 

 

"It seems like the government’s attempts to show religious tolerance are futile when large sections of society are steeped in bigotry and some have not even spared Muslim shrines; our leaders rarely demonstrate the kind of resolve that is needed to eliminate intolerance”
- An editorial in Dawn,
on the Hindu shrine vandalism

 


Click below links for month wise archive

2023 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May
2022 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec
2021 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec
2020 - May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec