loader

Daily Briefs

PDM appears to be “confused and divided,” says Bilawal


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PDM appears to be “confused and divided,” says Bilawal
Rules out the possibility of rejoining the alliance

On 30 May, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said, “PDM leadership seemed divided and indecisive in their objective and strategy.” He was making these statement in reference to the PDM’s meeting on 29 May. He also ruled out the possibility of re-joining the alliance arguing that the group had deviated from its mission to achieve the desired results. He said, “Unless and until the action plan is brought back, there is no point rejoining the PDM,” adding that if all opposition parties collectively target PM Imran Khan’s government, it would be better for all. (“PDM leaders are divided, confused: Bilawal,” The Express Tribune, 31 May 2021) (“‘No point in joining PDM sans action plan’,” The News International, 31 May 2021)

“If they (PPP) want to return, they can approach the PDM,” says Rehman
Maulana Fazlur Rehman, while responding to a question on the return of the PPP into the alliance, said that the PPP was not part of the alliance and they neither discussed “this matter nor is this matter important enough to be discussed,” adding, “If they (PPP) want to return, they can approach the PDM.”

PDM's plan ahead: Rejects electoral reforms, announces schedule for rallies
After the meeting, Rehman stated that the PDM had rejected the government's “biased” electoral reforms and termed it a “scheme for pre-poll rigging.” He also announced a new set of anti-government protests in the country. Rallies are scheduled for the upcoming months, beginning with a demonstration in Swat on 4 July, followed by a rally in Karachi on 29 July and then another in Islamabad on 14 August. (“'Can't spare more time': Fazl says PPP issue not discussed in PDM meeting,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

Media opines on the future of the alliance
An editorial in The News International says that without defining their goal, random protests and actions, or a refusal to join in discussions on electoral reforms, will lead nowhere. It adds that the question of the PPP and ANP and the divide within the PML-N will also surface in the coming months. It says that only time will tell it’s the PDM’s next course of can shake what appears to be a solidly entrenched government.

An editorial in The Express Tribune says that the PDM is trying its best to get out of the stalemate it has been languishing in since the Senate elections in March. It stated that the conflict within the PDM as well as the contradictory narratives within the PML-N camp only bodes well for the PTI. Similarly, an editorial in Dawn argues that for the divide within the PML-N, matters are now coming to a head and the leadership will have to decide which strategy it wants to adopt. (“PDM in a bind,” The Express Tribune, 31 May 2021) (“PDM agenda,” The News International, 31 May 2021) (“PML-N’s dilemma,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

 

Pakistan launches the first green Eurobond by Wapda
One of Pakistan's biggest weaknesses is the implementation of projects, says PM

Image Source: Dawn

On 31 May, PM Imran Khan formally launched Pakistan's first green Eurobond by the Water and Power Development Authority (Wapda) at a ceremony in Islamabad. During his address, he expressed satisfaction at the progress on Mohmand and Bhasha dams and congratulated the authority on the achievement.
Further, he said, “Unfortunately, one of Pakistan's biggest weaknesses is the implementation of projects. In my government I am also seeing that some things lag behind when it comes to implementation,” adding, “Long-term planning was being done [...] they were thinking about future generations. And this is what builds the foundation of a great nation…A nation can't progress if you carry out planning from one election to the next.” (“PM Imran launches Pakistan's first green Eurobond,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)

The Indus bond launched by Wapda
On 27 May, the Water and Power Development Authority (Wapda) launched its first green Eurobond, called Indus bond, for 10 years to raise USD 500 million at a competitive price of about 7.5 per cent interest rate. The Green Euro is being issued based on Wapda's stable financial position instead of state-guaranteed and is being used towards the financing of Diamar Bhasha and Mohmand Dams. The launch of the bond has attracted several international investors, who offered Wapda investments worth USD 3 billion through the Indus. (“Wapda floats first green Eurobond for $500m,” Dawn, 28 May 2021) (“PM to formally launch Pakistan's first Green Euro (Indus Bond) today,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)

 

Hamas chief hopes PM Khan will take pragmatic steps to support the Palestinian cause
Urges Muslim countries to form a strategic partnership

Image Source: Dawn

On 30 May, Hamas chief Ismail Haniyeh in a recorded speech to “Labbaik Al-Quds Million March” in Peshawar said, “I hope Prime Minister Imran Khan would take practical steps for supporting cause of Palestine.” Further, he said that Muslim countries should form strategic partnership for defending holy lands. Further, Ismail Haniyeh acknowledging the Pakistan government’s efforts he said, “You (people of Pakistan) are equally involved in victory against the recent Israeli aggression.” (“Hamas chief urges Muslims to establish ‘strategic partnership’,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Opinion criticises increasing clampdown on journalists
An opinion in Dawn, critical of the attack on journalists and “the state’s attempts to control the media,” says that the Pakistan Media Development Authority (PMDA) Ordinance 2021 will bring the media under a draconian authority. The author explains that in passing of the Ordinance, media houses will be expected to have an annual NOC to operate, and may also face sudden suspension without an explanation from the government. She asks why the Information Minister insists that Pakistan is a free state for the media and criticises the government for creating an us-versus-them narrative against the media. This, she opines, makes the middle-class think of journalists under attack as anti-army traitors. Therefore, she says the solution to the crisis lays in the hands of the middle class who should “realise how critical an uncensored press is for their own freedom, safety and prosperity.” (Huma Yusuf, “Attempt to gag,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)

ISI denies involvement in attack on journalist 
On 29 May, a statement from the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting said that the ISI had  denied any role in the attack on journalist Asad Toor and “totally disassociated” from the same. Dawn quotes from the statement, “Such continued allegations against ISI show that the ISI is being a target of the fifth generation war under an organised conspiracy.” It outlined that the ISI was cooperating with the investigation into the attack on Asad Toor and had called for stern action against the perpetrators. (“ISI ‘totally disassociates’ itself from attack on journalist,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Report outlines role MPAs in tribal feuds
On 31 May, Dawn reported on a “secret” police report on the security situation in Sindh in the light of the recent killing of nine people in a tribal feud in Kashmore The report traces such incidents to 2012 but outlines that several leaders including lawmakers have allegedly supported the tribes. However, the tribal feuds are not restricted to Kashmore; several places like Jacobabad, Shikarpur, Khairpur also witness these feuds and have the support of the elected members of the provincial assembly (MPAs). (Imtiaz Ali, “Tribal chiefs, certain lawmakers unwilling to see peace in upper Sindh, says police report,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Government to consider “unbundling” K-Electric
On 31 May, Dawn reported that the government was deliberating on “unbundling” the K-Electric (KE) company. Dawn quoted the SAPM on Power & Petroleum to have said that government was open to recommendations “unbundle KE into separate generation, transmission, and more than one distribution company as opposed to handing over its management to yet another single buyer of an integrated utility company.” He explained that with this the risk of monopolies would be less and a “single point of management failure or success” could be avoided. (Khaleeq Kiani, “Govt mulls over proposal to unbundle K-Electric,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
Qureshi meets with Iraqi ministers; outlines need for enhanced cooperation
On 30 May, Foreign Minister Qureshi met with Iraq’s Minister for Interior. Qureshi outlined that Pakistan and Iraq could benefit from intelligence sharing and capacity building of the security forces especially to counter terrorism. Later, Qureshi met with the Iraqi Defence Minister; according to a statement from the Foreign Office, the two ministers were happy with the growth in bilateral defence cooperation. Meanwhile, during his visit, Qureshi also called for more people-to-people interaction because of the strong religious and cultural affinities between the two countries. (“Pakistan, Iraq to enhance security, defence cooperation,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)

Kuwait to resume issuing visas to Pakistanis
On 30 May, Kuwait announced that it would resume issuing visas to Pakistani; the move comes after the country had banned work visas to Pakistanis in 2011. Previously, in 2017, Nawaz Sharif  had announced that Kuwait had lifted the ban but necessary measures for the same had not been implemented. The latest decision came after the Interior Minister met with the Kuwaiti Prime Minister. The development has been welcomed as the Interior Minister outlined that several Pakistani businessmen had faced difficulties due to the ban since 2011. (“Kuwait lifts visa ban for Pakistanis after decade-long suspension,” The Express Tribune, 30 May 2021)

ON PAKISTAN-OCCUPIED KASHMIR
PML-N releasing funds amounts to pre-poll rigging, says PTI “AJK” president
On 30 May, the PTI’s “AJK” chapter president accused the “AJK” government of rigging the upcoming Legislative Assembly elections. He claimed that several funds were released to the PML-N on the grounds of various projects and employment schemes and this, he opined, was “tantamount to pre-poll rigging.” He said the PTI, on the other hand, called for free and fair elections and called on the Chief Election Commissioner to frame a code of conduct after consulting with all political parties. (“PTI accuses AJK govt of pre-poll rigging,” Dawn, 31 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                         
Maleeha Lodhi in an opinion in Dawn says that all parties face daunting challenges as they gear up for elections ahead. She argues that beyond each party’s challenges and choices, two interrelated trends are likely to continue: a regionalised outcome, with different parties forming governments in the provinces and a coalition government at the centre.

An opinion in Dawn states that the only way genuine intra-party polls can contribute to the development of democracy in Pakistan is if the ECP conducts these elections, arguing, how can there be democracy in the country if party leaders are a product of rigged party elections or selection?

An opinion in Dawn argues that the state’s attempts to control the media are blatant and blunt. If they succeed, Pakistan will be authoritarian in all but name.
 


"Focusing on skills and manners at this young age besides conventional education is perhaps the most successful way of producing a generation of socially responsible citizens...The so-called terbiyat is missing in the current school education which used to be an integral part of taleem. Poor schooling cannot be made up, even by the best college education, and therefore should be worked on."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'Beyond degrees and skills'

 


“We want neutral umpires on water sharing among provinces,” says Punjab Irrigation Minister


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
“We want neutral umpires on water sharing among provinces,” says Punjab Irrigation Minister
Water shortages for Sindh and Punjab move up to 32 per cent

On 28 May, Punjab Irrigation Minister Mohsin Leghari demanded the deployment of neutral monitors at all barrages across the country remove no-confidence among the federating units on water sharing. He said, “We want neutral umpires on water sharing among provinces. This step is necessary in the wake of Sindh’s reports of 39 per cent water transmission losses (evaporation into air and seepage into soil) which are maximum 9.0 per cent in Punjab this year.” He added that the monitoring teams should comprise one representative from Punjab and Sindh each and one from the Irsa as a neutral player.

The minister said, “The fact of the matter is that the southern province is facing 17 per cent and Punjab 22 per cent water scarcity, while authorities of the former underreport availability of water. We’ve demanded Irsa (Indus River System Authority) to deploy monitors particularly at the points where water enters and exits Punjab and Sindh to remove no-trust among the provinces on the availability and distribution of water.” (“Punjab seeks ‘neutral umpires’ at barrages,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

Water shortages for Sindh and Punjab went up to 32 per cent, says Irsa
On 28 May, the Indus River System Authority (Irsa) after reviewing the overall water situation said that the water shortages for Sindh and Punjab went up to 32 per cent as the river flows continued to drop and storages at both Mangla and Tarbela dams reaches dead level. Irsa spokesman in light of the existing situation said that the existing limited storage available in reservoirs and tumbling river flows, “it was inevitable to apply further cut on provincial shares,” however, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan would remain exempt from sharing of shortages. (“Water shortages worsen for Punjab, Sindh,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

 

NAB Ordinance extended for 120 days amid opposition protest
Opposition claims that speaker allowed the passage despite the absence of quorum

Image Source: Dawn

On 28 May, the National Assembly adopted a resolution seeking extension of the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) Ordinance-2021 for another 120 days amid strong protests from the opposition. The opposition claimed that NA Speaker Asad Qaiser had allowed the passage of a resolution for a second extension of the NAB Ordinance despite the absence of quorum due to which all business of the lower house of parliament should have been suspended.

“No Speaker had ever done this in the history of the parliament,” says PML-N lawmaker
PML-N lawmaker Murtaza Javed Abbasi, said, “Mr Speaker you have done this six times. Never before in history has a speaker done such a thing.” Similarly, PPP member Syed Naveed Qamar objected to placing the resolution for extension in the period of the accountability ordinance on the order of the day, saying that the speaker had committed that the opposition would be given prior information before taking up any important legislation in the House.

The National Accountability Bureau (NAB) Ordinance-2021
In February 2021, the President had promulgated the National Accountability (Amendment) Ordinance 2021 which allowed extension in tenure of the prosecutor general Accountability for three years. The ordinance amends Section 8(a) (iii) of the National Accountability Ordinance (NAO) 1999. The NAO 1999 does not permit extension or re-appointment of the prosecutor general Accountability.

The post seen as the most significant after NAB’s chairman as no reference can be filed without the PG’s approval. The ordinance not only led to the reappointment of Syed Asghar Haider as the prosecutor general (accountability) for another term of three years but also lifted the bar for another similar extension. Haider’s term had expired on January 28. This comes as opposition leaders have been calling for curtailing what they called “sweeping powers” of the anti-graft watchdog by amending the National Accountability Ordinance. (“National Assembly extends NAB ordinance amid protest,” Dawn, 29 May 2021) (“NA allows extension in accountability ordinance amid protest,” The News International, 29 May 2021) (“NA extends NAB Ordinance for 120 days amid opposition protest,” The Express Tribune, 29 May 2021)

 

Indian variant of coronavirus confirmed in Pakistan
Receives 100,000 doses of Pfizer Covid vaccine through Covax

Image Source: Dawn

On 28 May, the National Institute of Health (NIH) confirmed the first-ever case of the Indian variant of coronavirus in Pakistan despite a ban on travellers from the neighbouring country since April. In a statement, the institute said, “The sequencing results confirmed the detection of seven cases of B.1.351 [South African variant] and one case of B.1.617.2 [Indian variant]. This is the first in-country detection of the latter strain.”

Meanwhile, Unicef Pakistan via Twitter announced that Pakistan has 100,000 doses of Pfizer’s coronavirus vaccine through Covax, making it the second consignment of vaccines that Pakistan has received through the Covax facility. (“Pakistan receives 100,000 doses of Pfizer Covid vaccine through Covax,” Dawn, 29 May 2021) (“Indian strain of coronavirus confirmed in Pakistan,” The Express Tribune, 29 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
SNC for grades 6 to 8 approved; to be implemented next year
On 28 May, the Education Minister announced the unanimous approval of the Single National Curriculum (SNC) for grades 6 to 8. He opined, “The single national curriculum will end the class system and all citizens will get equal opportunities to move forward.” The SNC will be implemented for the above grades next year. Meanwhile, SNC will be introduced from August this year for grades 1 to 5. (“Single curriculum for classes 6 to 8 approved,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

Opposition questions decision to introduce new finance team
On 28 May, the opposition referred to Shaukat Tarin’s appointment as the Finance Minister and the recent replacement of the finance secretary just as the budget session closes in, and raised concerns over the same. A PPP Senator outlined that the changes have been made in a short time and opined that framing a budget in such a short time is difficult. He said, “These steps clearly indicate that budget-making exercise has not been carried out in the finance ministry. The ministry has been given a ready-made budget by the IMF.” In response, the Leader of the House defended the government’s decisions and said the opposition “cannot go beyond point scoring.” (Iftikhar A Khan, “Reshuffle shows budget being made by IMF: opposition,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

Civic authorities differ over cause of fires in Margalla Hills
On 29 May, Dawn reported that civic authorities in Islamabad are engaged in trying to put out fires in the Margalla Hills National Park. At least three fires were reported on 28 May in the MHNP which witnesses frequent fires. The Director General Environment of the Capital Development Authority (CDA) said the three fires were caused by high temperatures but also said that frequent fires otherwise could also be caused by human negligence. However, Chairperson Islamabad Wildlife Management Board (IWMB) said the three fires were a case of arson and said a probe will be launched into it. (Kashif Abbasi, “Civic authorities in a fix as fires continue to ravage Margallas,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Sindh passes bill for protection of journalists
On 28 May, the Sindh Assembly passed Sindh Protection of Journalists’ and other Media Practitioners’ Bill-2021. The bill aims to introduce a commission that will ensure protection of journalists. Further, it looks at helping journalists carry out their duty without hesitance and therefore calls for punishment of “ lawless elements harassing the media persons and threatening their lives.” (“Sindh PA passes journalists’ protection bill,” The News International, 29 May 2021)

ECONOMY
APCC estimates economic growth at 4.8 per cent
On 28 May, the Planning Minister announced that the Annual Plan Coordination Committee [APCC] had approved a 4.8 per cent growth rate for FY22. It estimated that inflation would stay at 8 per cent. Meanwhile, he said that the Gross National Product in FY21 had increased by 6.5 per cent owing to high remittances and termed it as the highlight of the FY. The Minister estimated that remittances would stand at USD 31.3 billion in the next year while the peak of this year will be around USD 29.3 billion. (Shahbaz Rana, “Economic growth target set at 4.8%,” The Express Tribune, 29 May 2021)

Pakistan’s regional exports stand 15.26 per cent of global exports
On 29 May, Dawn reported on the latest data from the State Bank of Pakistan which showed that regional exports of Pakistan stood at 1.818 per cent compared to 31 per cent of imports in the first 10 months of FY21. China was Pakistan’s biggest export base; however, along with other regional countries, the total regional exports stood at USD 3.191 billion which accounts for only 15.26 per cent of Pakistan’s global exports. Meanwhile, imports stood at USD 10.754 billion, reflecting a 30.97 per cent increase from USD 7.638 billion in the corresponding period last year. (Mubarak Zeb Khan, “Regional exports post paltry growth of 1.8pc,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

ENERGY
Pakistan signs agreement with Russia for gas pipeline
On 28 May, Russia and Pakistan signed an agreement regarding the Pakistan Stream Gas Pipeline. The pipeline would provide for gas transportation from Karachi to Kasur. The project has been described as a cornerstone to the strategic ties between the two countries. (“Russia, Pakistan agree to build gas pipeline,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
US chargé d’affaires meets COAS 
On 28 May, the ISPR said that the US chargé d’affaires called on the COAS; they discussed “matters of mutual interest, overall regional security situation, including recent developments in Afghan peace process, and bilateral cooperation in various fields.” The meeting between the two is reportedly part of the ongoing engagement on Afghanistan between the US and Pakistan. (“US envoy, Bajwa discuss post-withdrawal Afghanistan,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

ON INDIA
Adviser, former diplomats, officials opine that India is irresponsible 
On 28 May, an adviser to the Strategic Plans Division Khalid Banuri opined that India introduced nuclear weapons to the region and alleged that India was increasing its arsenal today. He accused India of irresponsible behaviour and said that Pakistan resorted to nuclear weapons to restore the regional equilibrium. Similarly, former permanent representative to the Conference on Disarmament and UN Zamir Akram said that India had increased its capabilities to counter China but these could be used against Pakistan as well. The remarks were made at a webinar on Pakistan’s nuclear capability; other speakers echoed these opinions. (“Reckless Indian attitude makes region more dangerous: adviser,” Dawn, 29 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                            
An editorial in The News International says that any more measures that may result in high inflation must be resisted even if they come from the IMF. It argues that it is true that financial discipline is key but if such discipline results in more hardships for the people of Pakistan, the government needs to find a way around the terms.

Fadh Husain in an opinion in Dawn titled ‘Elephant in the room’ looks at the establishment vis-à-vis the political parties and the general elections in two years. He says, “All parties are gradually accepting that they have to deal with the elephant. Question is: how does the elephant want to deal with them?”
 



"It is generally acknowledged that Pakistan’s justice system is flawed. Both criminal and civil justice systems need to be reformed. At present it is because of the flaws that innocent men and women are wrongly convicted and the guilty are acquitted. In the process, many lives are destroyed."
-An editorial in The Express Tribune on 'Faulty investigations'

 


SC registrar office returns the ‘curative review petition’ in Isa case


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
SC registrar office returns the ‘curative review petition’ in Isa case
PBC warns of protest if govt files for a second review

On 26 May, the Supreme Court registrar’s office returned the government’s ‘curative review petition’ in the Justice Qazi Faez Isa case ruling that the federation had misconceived the Supreme Court Rules of 1980 when it moved a set of five petitions. The order stated that the institutional branch of the Supreme Court explained that the ‘curative review petition’ was an application which provides information to initiate ‘suo motu’ proceedings under Articles 184(3), 187, 188 and 189 of the Constitution, read with Orders 26 and 33 of the Supreme Court rules.

Further, it added that its object of the present case amounting to a second review petition was thus not entertainable under Order 36, Rule 9 of the Supreme Court rules, which states that after the final disposal of the first application for review, no subsequent application for review will lie to the court and consequently will not be entertained by the registry. (“SC rules misread before filing of ‘curative review plea’ in Isa case, says registrar,” Dawn, 28 May 2021)

PBC cautioned the government against filing another review petitions
On 27 May, the Pakistan Bar Council (PBC) warned that lawyers would observe a countrywide strike to protest if the federal government files a second review petition of the case. In a statement, the council strongly condemned the government’s “nefarious” decision and act to file a “curative review petition” to challenge the top court's verdict on the review pleas in the Justice Isa case.

Further, the council alleged that the role, conduct and activities of the president, the prime minister and the federal law minister were aimed at undermining the independence of the judiciary and the democratic process, adding that it would not allow the government to succeed in its “nefarious design to target the independent judiciary.” (“PBC warns of protest if govt files second plea in Isa case,” The Express Tribune, 28 May 2021)

The government should let the matter rest and move on, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn critical of the recent developments says that the sad chapter of this case should stand closed. It states the move is nothing but desperation, and that instead of the government raking up the matter it is time for acceptance. It argues that the government should let the matter rest and move on for no one benefits if the judiciary is dragged back into a public controversy that has run its legal course. (“Time to move on,” Dawn, 28 May 2021)

 

Govt seeks higher economic targets with IMF consent 
Govt tells panel GDP growth rate for next year being targeted at five per cent

Image Source: Dawn

On 27 May, the government is setting higher benchmarks for rates of inflation, economic growth and fiscal and primary deficits for the next fiscal year with consent from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for a controlled expansionary stance.

A government team stated to a parliamentary panel that the GDP growth rate for next year was being targeted at five per cent instead of 4.2 per cent which was previously approved by the federal cabinet. Inflation was now anticipated to increase by 8.2 per cent instead of eight per cent. Similarly, the overall budget deficit limit has now been pitched at 6.3 per cent of GDP instead of six per cent, while the primary deficit would be around 0.6 per cent instead of 0.1 per cent. (“With IMF consent, govt sets higher economic targets,” Dawn, 28 May 2021)

Revised medium-term BSP presented in the National Assembly’s Standing Committee 
A revised medium-term Budget Strategy Paper (BSP) presented in the National Assembly’s Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue by Dr Waqar Masood-led team of the Ministry of Finance and Federal Board of Revenue stated that the next year’s Public Sector Development Programme had been increased to Rs900 billion from Rs800bn last year.

Further, he stated that certain changes had taken place, including the encouraging GDP growth rate of 3.94 per cent, which suggested that the growth process had begun and it had to be made sustainable. He said that while remaining within the IMF programme that required austerity, the process of expansion was also a major consideration of the government, adding that the government was still working with the IMF as part of the ongoing budget exercise.

He also stated that the government will try to impose less than Rs500 billion worth of additional taxes in the budget, while increase in the power tariffs has been deferred only for now. However, this statement by the SAPM marks a visible shift from the stance taken by Finance Minister who has said that there would be no increase in taxes and the electricity tariff. (“Govt trying to keep additional taxes under Rs500b, NA panel told,” The Express Tribune, 28 May 2021)

Treasury and opposition bench committees question the economic projections
Both the committee members from the treasury and opposition benches questioned the economic projections, arguing that the unrealistic numbers and similar arguments and objectives had been presented to different governments.

 

ISPR marks 23 years of Pakistan’s first successful nuclear tests
Opinion highlights Pakistan’s need for low-cost nuclear energy 

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 28 May, the ISPR recalled that Pakistan had “restored balance of power in the region by successfully establishing credible minimum nuclear deterrence” on 28 May, 1998. The Express Tribune outlines that Pakistan’s nuclear tests in Chagai came after India’s second nuclear tests on 11 and 13 May 1998. It traces the socio-political climate in the region as well as the political history of Pakistan’s nuclear weapons programme under Zlufikar Bhutto. (“On This Day: Pakistan becomes a nuclear power,” The Express Tribune, 28 May 2021) 

Opinion outlines non-military uses of nuclear energy for Pakistan
An opinion in The News International highlights that the discourse since 1998 has shifted towards non-military uses of nuclear technology. The author points out Pakistan’s need for a low-cost nuclear energy option given its acute energy crisis and its impact on the economy. He however says that the country’s contribution at a global level is meagre. He reasons that this could be because the international community has been unjust to Pakistan; “Lack of access to the international nuclear market and technology denial by global powers hurts Pakistan’s energy security.” He accuses the NSG of displaying double standards and says, “Such policies need to be changed to enable countries like Pakistan to realize their full potential for not only the betterment of their people but for all of humanity.” (Yasir Hussain, “Energy security and the nuclear program,” The News International, 28 May 2021)

 

In Brief
INTERNAL
Finance Secretary replaced days before presentation of new budget
On 28 May, Dawn reported that the Finance Secretary has been replaced; Kamran Ali who occupied the post has been made the secretary of the Ministry of Industries and Production. Meanwhile, Yusuf Khan has been appointed as additional secretary (in charge) of the finance division; he was the secretary Benazir Income Support Programme. The change comes days before the upcoming budget; sources told Dawn that since the appointment of Shaukat Tarin as the Finance Minister, Kamran had plans to switch ministries because Tarin “wanted to bring the men of his own choice to deliver for what he has been picked for this assignment.” (“Finance ministry’s top official removed,” Dawn, 28 May 2021)

Editorial highlights aspects and effects of food insecurity
An editorial in Dawn, referring to the PSLM survey 2019-20, explores the various aspects of the problem. The editorial opines that food insecurity is not restricted to market shortage, but is also characterised by absence of money to buy food, climate change, inflation and so on. It outlines, “It’s not surprising that the high food inflation experienced during the last two years has played a major role in increasing the numbers of the food-insecure population.” Further, it says that food insecurity also reflects “the growing regional economic and development gap.” This, it says, “has increased gender inequalities in the access to education, health, public facilities, and generally equal opportunities in life.” Therefore, it urges the government to rethink or tweak its policies in the upcoming budget. (“Food insecurity,” Dawn, 28 May 2021)

PROVINCES 
Punjab government announces stipend for transgender persons 
On 27 May, Special Assistant to the Punjab CM on Information announced an initiative under the Punjab Social Protection Authority under which transgender people will be paid a monthly stipend. According to the initiative, Rs 2,000 will be given to disabled transgender persons between the age of 18 and 40 every month, and Rs 3,000 to transgender persons above 40 years. (“Transgender persons in Punjab to be paid stipend by govt,” The News International, 28 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Wapda launches first green Eurobond
On 27 May, the Water and Power Development Authority (Wapda) introduced the Indus bond, the Authority’s first green Eurobond, to raise USD 500 million at nearly 7.5 per cent interest. Dawn reports that the bond for 10 years has attracted investments worth USD 3 billion already; Wapda aims at USD 2.2 billion over the next five years. The Wapda Chairman said, “This kind of willingness shows the belief and confidence the international investors have in Wapda in particular and Pakistan in general...This is unprecedented, as I have never seen such a favourable and congenial response for Wapda.” (Khalid Hasnain, “Wapda floats first green Eurobond for $500m,” Dawn, 28 May 2021)

PTI repays USD 7.25 billion debt, says Minister
On 27 May, the Minister for Economic Affairs said the PTI government had paid off USD 7.52 billion in the first 10 months of the current FY, despite the economic fallouts of the pandemic. This includes the principal amount of USD 6.31 billion and interest payments amounting to USD 1.21 billion. He claimed that the PTI was faced with a current account deficit challenge when it came to power; the debt servicing stood at nearly USD 10 billion every year. He said this was because of enhanced external borrowing of USD 49.76 billion, which included mostly short-term and expensive commercial loans worth USD 17 billion taken by the PML-N government. (“PTI pays off $7.52b debt in 10 months of FY21: Ayub,” The Express Tribune, 28 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
Russian Ambassador appreciates Pakistan’s efforts towards Afghan peace
On 27 May, the ISPR said that the Russian Ambassador had called on the COAS to discuss bilateral issues and matters of mutual interest. The two discussed the Afghan peace process and the COAS outlined peace in Afghanistan as a common goal for Russia and Pakistan. He also conveyed that Pakistan hopes for more military to military relations with Russia. Meanwhile, “the Russian Ambassador appreciated Pakistan’s sincere efforts for bringing peace and stability in the region, especially the Afghan reconciliation.” (“Russia hails Pakistan's efforts for Afghan peace process,” The Express Tribune, 28 May 2021)

ON CPEC
Senate passes CPEC Authority bill despite strong opposition 
On 27 May, the Senate passed a bill providing for the establishment of a CPEC Authority, while adding a supplementary agenda. The supplementary agenda was opposed and the opposition leaders staged a walkout. The government took the opportunity to pass the bill. Yousuf Gilani said he acknowledged the advantages of the bill but questioned why the government wanted to make it controversial through the supplementary agenda. (Waqas Ahmed, “Senate passes CPEC Authority bill,” The Express Tribune, 28 May 2021)

ON INDIA 
FO responds to S Jaishankar’s remarks on cross-border firing
On 27 May, the Foreign Office spokesperson announced that “Pakistan ‘categorically rejected the allegations of any cross-border infiltration’ by India.” He was reportedly responding to S Jaishankar’s remarks at the Hoover Institute, Stanford University, about cross border firing at the LoC; Dawn quotes him to have said, “We have seen a lot of that mainly because there has been infiltration from their side.” The FO spokesperson alleged that India was carrying out "brutalisation of Kashmiri people." (Naveed Siddiqui, “Pakistan rejects Indian FM's allegations of 'cross-border infiltration': FO,” Dawn, 28 May 2021)

Senior officials worried about “India’s aggressive posturing” in the region
On 27 May, senior officials were reportedly concerned about “India’s aggressive posture, including its plans for disarming pre-emptive strikes against Pakistan’s nuclear arsenal in a conflict…” The remarks were made at a panel discussion by Adviser to Strategic Plans Division Ambassador Zamir Akram and Director General Arms Control and Disarmament at the Foreign Office Kamran Akhtar. Ambassador Akram opined that with American support, India was looking into “integrating new warfare technologies — cyberwarfare, artificial intelligence, robotics and lethal autonomous weapons.” (“Concern voiced over militarisation of space and artificial intelligence by India,” Dawn, 28 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                    
An opinion in The News International says that while one can argue that nuclear weapons have been successful in preventing war between India and Pakistan yet tensions and risks have increased in the region. It adds that both need to demonstrate progress on arms control to help reduce nuclear risks.

An editorial in The News International in the context of a ‘new beginning’ with the US argues that what is needed is an honest appraisal by the US on what kind of relationship it is looking for with Pakistan.

An opinion in Dawn states that Pakistan is not responsible for Afghanistan’s weaknesses, but cannot escape the responsibility for the Taliban’s strength. However, arguing that Pakistan may not have influence with the Taliban but has some leverage. Adding, at stake is both countries’ future, which is regional connectivity, economic interdependence and a peaceful neighbourhood.
 


"When people ignore or rationalise systemic injustice, discrimination and exploitation continue to spread. While bloody revolutions have hardly produced optimal results, system justifying ideologies are also very harmful as they undermine collective action to alter structural distortions which advantage the few at the cost of disadvantaging the many."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'How, and why, we justify inequalities'

 


PSLM survey shows 16.4 per cent households experience food insecurity


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 27 May 2021
Intra PML-N divide and Shehbaz Sharif’s outreach to the PPP
The divide within the PML-N is getting sharper with Shehbaz Sharif on the one side and Maryam Nawaz on the other.

On 25 May 2021, Shehbaz Sharif, President of the PML-N and also the leader of the opposition in Pakistan’s Parliament hosted a dinner in Islamabad. The objective was to reach out to all the opposition political parties, including the PPP and ANP. Though Bilawal Bhutto, leader of the PPP did not attend, three senior leaders – Sherry Rehman, Yousuf Raza Gilani and Raja Pervez Ashraf took part, along with Amir Haider Khan Hoti of the ANP. However, Maryam Nawaz and Fazlur Rahman skipped it.
 
According to news reports, Sharif wanted the opposition parties to come together before the budget presentation. The revival of the PDM was also a point of discussion, though, according to a Dawn report, there was not much support for the same. The PDM is in limbo, ever since the PPP and the ANP left the opposition alliance; the situation became worse when the PDM issued a show-cause notice to the PPP
 
Subsequently, Shahid Khaqan Abbasi, one of the PML-N’s senior leaders and the PDM’s Secretary General stated he was against the idea of PPP’s return to the PDM. Dawn quoted him saying: “The PPP can't just rejoin the movement. They can only do so once they restore their trust in the PDM. The alliance does not have a revolving-door policy that you break its trust, leave the movement and try to come back again when you face difficulties.” Maryam Nawaz, PML-N’s Vice President agreed with Abbasi, and stated separately that Shehbaz Sharif’s dinner was not a PDM event. She was quoted saying: “We have still not received a response to the show-cause notice that was issued to the PPP. When that is received, we will sit down and see what has to be done so Abbasi has said the right thing.”
 
On 26 May, Bilawal Bhutto responded to the statements from Abbasi and Maryam Nawaz. The News quoted him saying: “We are not answerable to Maryam or Mian Sahab. We are answerable to the PPP and the PPP’s workers.”
 
Back to Shehbaz’s dinner and its objectives. While he wants to have a larger outreach to the opposition parties, a section within his own party seems to be looking at the PPP through the PDM lens. The other explanation could be, there is a divide within the PML-N with Shehbaz Sharif on the one side, and Maryam Nawaz on the other. If the latter is the case, then the next few weeks would highlight which side the PML-N would go.
 
For Shehbaz Sharif, it is not only the PDM but also his own party that is divided. He will have to reach out within if he has to reach out.


In Focus
PSLM survey shows 16.4 per cent households experience food insecurity
National level literacy rate remained at 60 per cent

A survey conducted by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) titled ‘Pakistan Social and Living Standards Measurement (PSLM) survey 2019-20’ showed that around 16.4 per cent of households in the country have reported that they are experiencing moderate or severe food insecurity. According to the survey report, Balochistan witnessed the highest level of moderate or severe food insecurity at 29.84 per cent, followed by Sindh 18.45 per cent, Punjab 15.16 per cent and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa 12.75 per cent. The percentage of insecurity has been evolved based on information on how many households suffer due to food insecurity by evaluating in terms of money, full of nutrition food and hunger over the past 12 months.

Additionally, the survey covered 176,790 households across rural and urban communities for collecting information on a range of social sector issues related to education, health and food insecurity by facilities and services.

National level literacy rate remained at 60 per cent
According to the survey, the national level literacy rate remained stagnant at 60 per cent in 2019-20 as in 2014-15. It showed the population of 10 years and older, who have ever attended schools, at the national level was 60 per cent in 2019-20. It added, 32 per cent of children were out of school across the country in 2019-20, with the number of such children is higher in rural areas (37 per cent) than urban areas (22 per cent). Further, the report reflects an increasing trend in indicators of education as the literacy rate for male increased to 71 per cent and that for female to 49 per cent. In the youth, the literacy rate increased to 72 per cent. However, youth literacy is higher in males (79 per cent) than in females (65 per cent).

33 per cent households have access to the internet
According to the survey, 33 per cent households have access to the internet, 93 per cent to mobile phone and 12 per cent to computers.

Punjab has the highest rate of migration
According to the survey, Punjab has the highest rate (7 per cent) of migration than the other three provinces.

94 per cent households have access to improved source of drinking water
According to the survey, 94 per cent households have access to an improved source of drinking water. The survey also shows that 83 per cent households have access to toilets. Additionally, 77 per cent get prenatal consultation during their last pregnancy. Skilled birth attendant was calculated at 68 per cent in 2019-20. Record-based immunisation was 70 per cent in 2019-20. (“16.4pc households experience food insecurity,” Dawn, 27 May 2021) (“Pakistan Social and Living Standards Measurement (PSLM) survey 2019-20,” Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, May 2021)

 

UNGA President meets with FM Qureshi in Islamabad
Both discuss Palestine, Kashmir and Afghanistan issues

Image Source: Dawn

On 27 April, United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) President Volkan Bozkir met with FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi at the Foreign Office (FO). The two discussed the situation in Palestine and the Afghan negotiations, Kashmir and other matters of mutual interest.

FM Qureshi appreciated the UNGA president's efforts in summoning an emergency session of the assembly over the Palestine issue, saying, “The ceasefire was the first step towards halting Israeli atrocities against Palestinians, and there was success on this front,” adding, “Peace in the Middle East will remain elusive without a permeant resolution to the Palestine issue.” Further, he said that peace in South Asia also cannot be established without resolving the Kashmir issue.

Pakistan committed to supporting the UNGA
In a press release, the FO stated, “Pakistan remains committed to supporting the United Nations General Assembly for the realisation of shared objectives of maintaining international peace and security; economic and social development; promotion and protection of human rights; peaceful settlement of international disputes; and developing friendly relations among nations based on the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples, as enshrined in the purposes and principles of the UN Charter.” (“FM Qureshi stresses resolution of Palestine, Kashmir issues in meeting with UNGA president,” Dawn, 27 May 2021)

Meanwhile…
On 26 May, PM Imran Khan held a telephonic conversation with Egyptian President Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi. According to a press release by the PMO, “The prime minister called for total withdrawal of Israeli forces from occupied Palestinian territories, including Jerusalem; restitution of the inalienable rights of the Palestinian people including their right to self-determination and the right of return to Palestine and the establishment of an independent, viable and contiguous Palestinian State, as part of a two-state solution, with pre-1967 borders, with Al Quds Al Sharif as its capital.” (“PM urges Israeli pullout in talks with Sisi,” Dawn, 27 May 2021)

 

District emir of JUI-F shot in alleged targeted killing
No one has claimed responsibility for the killing

Image Source: Dawn

On 26 May, Maulana Abdul Hayee Baloch, the district emir of the JUI-F and a prominent religious scholar, was killed in an armed attack in Panjgur. According to the police, armed motorcyclists opened fire at his car. Further, a senior police officer said, “It seems to be an incident of targeted killing,” adding, “We are investigating the incident from different angles and hope that the killers will be arrested soon.” No one has claimed responsibility for the killing so far. (“Hayee Baloch of JUI-F shot dead in Panjgur,” Dawn, 27 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PPP will consider Shehbaz’s stance as official PML-N policy, says Bilawal
On 26 May, Bilawal Bhutto said that the PPP will consider Shehbaz Sharif’s remarks as the PML-N’s official policy because of the latter’s designation as the National Assembly’s Opposition Leader and party president. Regarding Maryam’s statement that the PPP did not respond to the PDM’s show cause notice, Bilawal said that the party is not answerable to Maryam or the PDM Secretary General Shahid Abbasi. Abbasi had earlier said that the PPP and ANP can rejoin the PDM if they explain themselves. Bilawal added, “We are answerable to the PPP and the PPP’s workers and we think the real joy will be in doing politics together with the PPP’s workers.” (Asim Hussain and Asim Yasin, “Shehbaz stance taken as PML-N policy: Bilawal,” The News International, 27 May 2021)

Dawn questions hesitance of government to address attacks on journalists
An editorial in Dawn, referring to the latest attack on a journalist, says that those “who want critical voices silenced have gone one step further and demonstrated that they have no qualms about ‘disappearing’ journalists or subjecting them to brutal assault.” Highlighting that such incidents are taking place during the governance of a democratically elected state, the editorial asks why the government hesitates to take a stance that silencing criticism in this manner is intolerable. Further, it outlines that the latest attack took place just weeks after a bill to protect journalists was tabled in the NA. However, it asks, “Once the bill is passed, will the government ensure the law’s enforcement in letter and spirit?” (“Attack on journalist,” Dawn, 27 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Imran launches health cards in Punjab
On 26 May, Imran Khan launched Sehat Sahulat health cards in Sahiwal and Dera Ghazi Khan. The Sehat Sahulat health card owners  are eligible to “avail medical treatment worth Rs720,000 at all public and private hospitals in the province.” Imran also said that the Punjab Health Minister had previously announced that Rs 300,000 would be given to deserving families additionally. On the occasion, Imran laid the foundation for a mother-and-child hospital worth  Rs 5.73 billion citing that mortality rates among children and pregnant mothers were significantly high in Pakistan. (“PM launches health cards for Sahiwal, Dera Ghazi Khan,” Dawn, 27 May 2021)

Bilawal calls for new system for water distribution
On 26 May, Bilawal Bhutto criticised the federal government alleging that Sindh was being discriminated against with regard to the Indus water distribution. He, therefore, called for a system where water distribution would be based on “justice and equality.” He referred to the 1991 Water Accord and opined that it was charted out by the then “selected” government and was hence unviable. However, he said, “We should implement the accord in short and medium term but our target should be to evolve a new consensus for distribution of water in the country on the basis of equality and justice.” (“Bilawal seeks new water accord,” The Express Tribune, 27 May 2021)

Four suspected TTP terrorists killed: CTD
On 26 May, the CTD spokesman said that four suspected TTP terrorists, including their commander, were killed in an operation in Quetta’s Killi Aghbarg area; two terrorists escaped. The operation was carried out based on intelligence inputs; the commander “was involved in terrorist attacks on security forces and an attack on Civil Hospital Quetta in 2016.” During the operation, the CTD also recovered several arms and ammunition. (“TTP commander, 3 other terrorists killed in Quetta: CTD,” Dawn, 27 May 2021)

ECONOMY
ECC approves second phase of Ehsaas cash programme
On 26 May, the Economic Coordination Committee approved the launch of the Ehsaas Emergency Cash Programme’s second phase wherein the number of beneficiaries of the Ehsaas Kafalat will be increased to 8 million by June. The second phase is expected to be worth Rs 48 billion and the beneficiaries are entitled to a six-monthly tranche of Rs 12,000. The ongoing National Socio-Economic Registry Survey (NSER)  will help identify an additional 4 million beneficiaries. (Khaleeq Kiani, “ECC okays Rs48bn for Ehsaas cash handouts,” Dawn, 27 May 2021)

Nine mega projects worth Rs 361 billion approved 
On 26 May, the Executive Committee of the National Economic Council approved nine mega projects worth Rs 361 billion. The projects include a 306 km-long Hyderabad-Sukkur motorway, the Gomal Zam Multipurpose Project, and so on. Some of the projects were approved for the second or third time at revised costs. (Shahbaz Rana, “ECNEC approves Rs361b projects,” The Express Tribune, 27 May 2021)

ON COVID-19
Nearly 100,000 people did not turn up for second dose, say sources
On 26 May, unnamed health officials said that nearly 100,000 people who had been inoculated with the first dose of the coronavirus vaccine are yet to approach the health centres for their second dose in Sindh. This constitutes nearly 25 per cent of the registrations. Sources said of the 405,673 eligible to receive the second dose, only 300,949 came to the vaccination centres. A senior official said that some people may have chosen not to come due to rumours on the side effect of taking the jabs. Meanwhile, registration for those aged above 19 years began on 27 May. (Sameer Mandhro, "100k citizens fail to return for second jabs in Sindh," The Express Tribune, 27 May 2021)

ON CLIMATE CHANGE
Pakistan dedicated to the cause of addressing climate change, says PM
On 27 May, Imran Khan stated that his government remained dedicated in its cause to addresses the challenges of climate change. He said, "We remain dedicated to the cause and are trying to improve the environment in different ways." Further, on the country hosting World Environment Day on 5 June he said, "This is a great honour and acknowledgement of the fact that Pakistan is among a handful of countries trying to reduce the impact of climate change and global warming. (“Govt remains dedicated to addressing challenges of climate change: PM Imran,” Dawn, 27 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                          
An editorial in Dawn says that Sindh’s dacoit problem has become too big to ignore, arguing law and order cannot be sacrificed to political expediency. Similarly, an editorial in The Express Tribune says that stability and peace need to be maintained by working together with tribes.

An opinion in Dawn says that the Americans seem to be keeping the focus on Afghanistan, whereas the Pakistani side is repeatedly underlining the “bilateral relationship” arguing, they both have good reasons for their stance.
 



"If journalism is democracy’s watchdog and the journalist ‘the watchful eye of the people’, we must ask those who watch from the sidelines and find refuge in silence, or become willing puppets in the hands of persecutors: who is the Pakistani press supposed to serve – and how, if it continues to be beaten into silence?"
-An editorial in The News International on 'A dangerous place'

 


Govt will not provide US bases in the country, says Qureshi


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 26 May 2021

241st Corps Commanders’ Conference: Durand Line returns to haunt Pakistan

The focus on Afghanistan should help stabilize the situation for Kabul, and not undermine it.

Yesterday, chaired by the Chief of Army Staff Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa, the 241st Corps Commander meeting took place at the GHQ. The meeting was attended by Imran Khan along with a few federal ministers. According to a Dawn report on the meeting, quoting ISPR said, “Taking serious note of the recent cross-border firing incidents from Afghanistan and regrouping of terrorist leadership / outfits across, the forum expressed the hope that Afghanistan soil will not be used against Pakistan… In light of emerging regional security situation, Pakistan has taken effective border control/management measures and the same is expected from Afghanistan to deny any space to spoilers of peace, the forum reiterated.”

The concern on what is happening along the Durand Line, comes a few weeks after the Army Chief’s meeting with the Afghan President Ashraf Ghani, and the Chairman of the High Council for National Reconciliation of Afghanistan Dr Abdullah Abdullah. The ISI Chief also accompanied the COAS for the above Afghan meeting that took place during the second week of this month. Following the above meeting, Ashraf Ghani, in an interview to a German magazine Der Spiegel, commented: “The US now plays only a minor role. The question of peace or hostility is now in Pakistani hands…Pakistan operates an organized system of support. The Taliban receive logistics there, their finances are there and recruitment is there. The names of the various decision-making bodies of the Taliban are Quetta Shura, Miramshah Shura and Peshawar Shura – named after the Pakistani cities where they are located. There is a deep relationship with the state.” Pakistan did immediately condemn the statement, as “irresponsible statements, baseless allegations.”

The focus of the Corps Commander meeting on the Durand Line, also comes in the backdrop of the American troops withdrawal, the US-Pakistan discussion on allowing/not allowing ground space for the former by the latter, and an unstable internal situation within Afghanistan owing to the failure between Kabul and the Taliban.

While the Establishment has a right to be concerned about what is happening now in Afghanistan, its response should not undermine. Increasing instability in Afghanistan as a reason to Pakistan’s involvement in its western neighbourhood has been the past history. Hope the Establishment puts it to rest, and does not repeat it.


In Focus
Govt will not provide US bases in the country, says Qureshi
NSA presents a blueprint for ‘ties’ to Biden administration

On 25 May, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi rejected the possibility of providing the country’s military bases to the United States for counterterrorism operations in Afghanistan. He rejected the reports and made it clear that the government would never provide military bases to the US, nor would they allow drone attacks inside Pakistan. These remarks came after a Pentagon official stated that Pakistan had allowed the US military to use its airspace and given it ground access so that it could support its presence in Afghanistan. (“No US bases to be allowed in country, says FM,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

Meanwhile…
The United States Department of Defence stated that it is discussing options with Pakistan and other countries in the region, including the potential for having bases there, however, the talks remain inconclusive. (“US talking to Pakistan, others for maintaining access to Afghanistan,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

NSA presents “Pakistani plan” with US counterpart
On 26 May, The Express Tribune reported that National Security Adviser Dr Moeed Yusuf during a meeting with his US counterpart Jake Sullivan presented a “Pakistani plan” that entailed the future of the Pakistan-US relationship. According to the plan, Pakistan is seeking bilateral cooperation with the US not based on security and defence but economy, trade and business, as Pakistan is seeking a “paradigm shift” in its approach as far as ties with the US are concerned. (“Pakistan presents blueprint for ‘ties’ to Biden admin,” The Express Tribune, 26 May 2021)

Relations with Washington are a key pillar of Pakistani foreign policy, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn on the recent meeting in Geneva between the Pakistani and American national security advisers says that relations with Washington are a key pillar of Pakistani foreign policy, thus the challenge before Pakistan’s foreign policy establishment will be to cultivate relations with these important capitals equally, and not be pressured by other countries in its choice of friends and allies. (“Geneva meeting,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

 

PPP and ANP can rejoin PDM if they apologise, says Fazl 
Opposition seems to be least of the government’s problems, says editorial

Image Source: Dawn

On 25 May, Maulana Fazlur Rehman stated that the PPP and ANP can re-join if they apologise to the alliance for going against its decisions. He said that both PPP and ANP had been given sufficient time to get back to the PDM leadership, however, they have not done so, adding, "There are currently no proposals to invite PPP and ANP at the PDM meeting on May 29," This statement during his meeting with PML-N President and Leader of the Opposition in the National Assembly Shahbaz Sharif. (“Fazl makes PPP, ANP's comeback to PDM conditional,” The News International, 26 May 2021)

PDM unity depends on PML-N and PPP, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn says that as the PDM is meeting to decide the future course of action and PML-N leaders also stating that they want all parties to unite once again against the government, the outcome of this is essentially up to Shahbaz and the PPP leaders. (“PDM and the future,” The News International, 26 May 2021)

Opposition seems to be least of the government’s problems, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn says that with the PDM dysfunctional and the PML-N locked into a battle with itself, the opposition appears to be the least of the government’s problems. It argues that the PML-N’s duality is sowing the seeds of confusion within the party and is weakening its political efficacy at a time when the party should be thinking and planning clearly for the next elections, adding that PTI is a natural beneficiary. (“Intra-party divisions,” The Express Tribune, 26 May 2021)

 

Sindh govt demanded immediate removal of IRSA
Water tensions between Sindh and Punjab intensify 

Image Source: Dawn

On 25 May, the Sindh Assembly proceedings witnessed chaos as the PPP criticised the federal government for water shortages in the province. They also demanded the immediate removal of the chairman of the Indus River System Authority (Irsa) for his “uncalled-for” behaviour with the authority’s member belonging to Sindh.

Sindh Information Minister stated that the IRSA’s chairman had embarrassed Sindh’s member during the IRSA meeting who was advocating due water share for the province. Further, the speaker also expressed grave concern over the behaviour of the Irsa chairman and advised the PPP member to move a resolution against him, saying, “He threw a book on the face of Sindh’s Irsa member. It is too much. He must be removed from the post immediately.” (“Sindh demands removal of IRSA chairman,” The News International, 26 May 2021) (“PA demands removal of Irsa chairman for ‘insulting’ Sindh’s member,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

Tensions over the opening of TP link canal 
Tensions over water distribution intensified between the IRSA members from Sindh and Punjab with the opening of TP link canal from Indus at a time when the low riparian federating units are craving for water even for drinking purposes. On 25 May, the IRSA authority held a meeting for the review of the water situation after giving its new estimates under which the country will experience 17 per cent water shortages during the period from 21 May to 10 June. (“Opening of TP link canal: Tug of war on water between Sindh, Punjab intensifies,” The News International, 26 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Journalist attacked by unidentified men
On 25 May, unidentified assailants attacked journalist-Youtuber Asad Toor in Islamabad; the attackers fled the scene. Asad later said that the attackers questioned the source of his funds. Previously, in 2020, Asad had a court case against him on allegations of insulting the military and involvement “in propaganda against Pakistan and its institutions on social media for long.” However, the charges were later absolved by the Lahore High Court. (Munawer Azzem and Ikram Junaidi, “Journalist assaulted,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

Nadra begins issuing smartcards to Afghan refugees
On 25 May, the National Database and Registration Authority (Nadra) began issuing Proof of Registration (PoR) smartcards to the 1.4 million Afghan refugees. This is a part of the UN-supported Documentation Renewal and Information Verification Exercise (DRIVE) led by the government. The UNHCR representative in Pakis­tan said since DRIVE is designed to “provide updated information on registered Afghan refugees and their immediate family,” it helps the UNHCR to plan and support the Pakistan government and the refugees along with the host communities. (Bakhtawar Mian, “1.4m Afghan refugees begin receiving new smartcards,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

TikTok blocks 800,000 videos in Pakistan 
On 25 May, Counsel for Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) briefed the Peshawar High Court that TikTok had “blocked around eight million objectionable videos and around 400,000 accounts” which published them. The PHC was hearing a petition filed by 40 people who sought a ban on TikTok “to the extent of violation of the constitutional provisions, which don’t allow acts contrary to Islamic code of life.” The PTA however maintained that more regulators had been appointed to check the content and clarified that they cannot check the content before the videos are published. (“8m TikTok videos blocked, court told,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

PROVINCES
PM calls on Interior Minister to look into rising “lawlessness” in Sindh
On 25 May, Imran Khan ordered the Interior Minister to meet the Sindh Rangers, citing the increasing “lawlessness” in the province. The PM’s directive came after the Information Minister met with the Sindh Governor and the Planning Minister. The News International reported that the Planning Minister had raised apprehensions over “Sindh’s administrative mismanagement, especially law and order situation, and rising level of crime in the province.” (“Rising crimes in Sindh alarm Centre,” The News International, 26 May 2021)

Four terrorists killed in Quetta
On 26 May, The News International reported that the CTD had killed four terrorists during an operation in the suburbs of Quetta. The CTD spokesperson said that the CTD had intercepted a group of terrorists headed towards Quetta with an aim to launch a major attack; two terrorists escaped. Further, “Four kg of explosives along with a four meter detonating cord and four detonators were recovered alongside two motorcycles, four pistols and 80 rounds.” (Salman Ashraf, “CTD Quetta kills four TTP terrorists,” The News International, 26 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Current account records USD 773 million surplus
On 25 May, the State Bank of Pakistan data showed that the current account (C/A) deficit had reduced by 61 per cent to USD 200 million in April compared to USD 510 million in the same period last FY. The CA deficits have been on a decline since December 2020. Further, the data reflected a USD 773 million surplus during the first 10 months of FY21 owing to the increase in remittances and exports. Previously, the SBP had outlined that Pakistan had witnessed a surplus after 17 years. (Shahid Iqbal, “Current account posts $773m surplus in 10MFY21,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

Foreign debt stands at USD 10 billion
On 25 May, the Ministry of Economic Affairs said that Pakistan’s foreign borrowings stood at USD 10 billion in the first 10 months of the current FY, reflecting a 35 per cent increase from the corresponding period in the previous FY. The data showed that in the 10 months, non-project related borrowings stood at USD 8.8 billion or 88 per cent of the total loan. The Federal Minister for Economic Affairs said that the USD 10 billion worth of loans were necessary to repay “obligations inherited on account of debt accumulated by the previous government to finance historic high current account deficits.” (Shahbaz Rana, “Foreign loans jump over 35% to $10b,” The Express Tribune, 26 May 2021) On 25 May, a press release by the Ministry said that the World Bank had assured Pakistan of its continued support towards development objectives. In a meeting with the WB Country Director, the Economic Affairs Minister conveyed the importance of rural development projects in agriculture and water infrastructure to boost the rural economy. Further, he outlined the need for rural-urban connectivity to tap into the potential of remote areas. (“WB pledges support to achieve uplift objectives in Pakistan,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

ON CPEC
China to invest USD 12 billion more, says Asim Bajwa
On 25 May, the CPEC Authority Chairman said China would invest USD 12 billion into the CPEC in addition to the USD 13 billion that it has already invested. He said an announcement for the extension of visas for three months to two years for the Chinese investors will be made soon. He opined that CPEC had helped establish more economic zones which will attract more investments and foreign investors. (“China to bring more investment under CPEC: Bajwa,” The Express Tribune, 26 May 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
Corps Commanders Conference stresses need for secure Afghan border
On 25 May, the  241st Corps Commanders Conference was held; the ISPR said the commanders held a “comprehensive review of the global, regional and domestic security environment with particular focus on the situation along the borders especially the Line of Control/Working Boundary and Pak-Afghan border.” While the Conference reiterated its support for a peaceful border with Afghanistan to maintain regional peace, the commanders also noted recent cross-border firings and hoped that Afghanistan's soil ‘will not be used against Pakistan’.” (Naveed Siddiqui, “Army huddle takes 'serious note' of cross-border firing incidents, asks Afghanistan to regulate border,” Dawn, 26 May 2021)

ON PAKISTAN-OCCUPIED KASHMIR
Imran sends advice to induct two senior lawyers
On 25 May, officials said that Imran Khan had sent an advice to induct senior lawyers to the “AJK” Supreme Court as judges. The “AJK” President had sent the names of Khawaja Mohammad Nasim and Raja Raza Ali Khan to Imran. Further, Imran also sent an advice to confirm Justice Sadaqat Hussain Raja as permanent chief justice (CJ) of the “AJK” High Court. (“AJK supreme court to have two judges,” , 26 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                               
 
An editorial in The Express Tribune on the water issue says that waste of water in a water-deficient country is a grave issue and needs to be tackled with urgency.
 



"No electoral reform can ensure people’s choice in the context of Pakistan where feudal and religious lords prevail, unless the government curtails the control of
fearful over voters."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'Problems with electoral reforms'

 


Pakistan and US NSAs meet in Geneva


Photo: The News International



In Focus
Pakistan and US NSAs meet in Geneva
No US military or airbase in Pakistan, says FO

On 23 May, Pakistani NSA Dr Moeed Yusuf met with his US counterpart Jake Sullivan in Geneva, the first high-level face-to-face contact since the Biden administration took charge. According to the office of NSA and White House, “The national security advisers of Pakistan and the United States of America met in Geneva yesterday. Both sides had a positive conversation on a range of bilateral, regional and global issues of mutual interest and agreed to advance practical cooperation on these issues.”
Meanwhile, Moeed Yusuf via Twitter said, “Pleased to meet US NSA yesterday. Pakistan and the US delegation held positive discussions on bilateral, regional and global issue of mutual interest. Both sides agreed to continue the conversation to advance cooperation in Pak-US bilateral relations.” (“Pakistan tells US it wants ties beyond Afghan cooperation,” The News International, 25 May 2021)(“Pak, US NSAs meet in Geneva for crucial talks,” The Express Tribune, 25 May 2021)

FO denied the presence of any US military or airbase in Pakistan
On 24 May, the Foreign Office (FO) denied the presence of any US military or airbase in Pakistan, saying such speculations are “baseless and irresponsible” and should be avoided. FO spokesperson said, “There is no US military or air base in Pakistan, nor was any such proposal envisaged. Any speculation on this account is baseless and irresponsible and should be avoided.” This statement came after a Pentagon official said that Pakistan had allowed the US military to use its airspace and given ground access so that it can support its presence in Afghanistan. (“No US military or air base in Pakistan: FO,” Dawn, 25 May 2021)

Opposition seeks clarification on FO's US military base statement
After the FO statement, the Opposition leaders sort clarification from the government to provide more information over a US official’s statement that Pakistan would continue to provide air and ground access for Afghanistan operations and rumours that the country would give a military base to the US. (“Opposition seeks further clarification on FO's US military base statement,” The News International, 25 May 2021)

 

SBP supports the 3.94 per cent growth rate estimate
Says that the rebound was fuelled by a well-calibrated policy response

Image Source: Dawn

On 24 May, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) via Twitter expressed complete satisfaction over the new estimate of 3.94 per cent GDP growth for FY21 saying, “FY21 growth is expected to rise to 3.94pc, as post-Covid recovery underway since last summer has strengthened. The 9-mth current account is also in surplus for the 1st time in 17 yrs and FX reserves at a 4 yr high. This rebound was fueled by a well-calibrated policy res­ponse. Given high public debt, fiscal support was targeted to the most vulnerable, notably through the globally-acclaimed Ehsaas program. At the same time public debt and deficit were kept under check which has supported market sentiment, investment outlook, and economic recovery.”

Further, it added, “SBP provided a targeted economic stimulus of Rs2 trillion to support the recovery through interest rate cut, principal deferment & loan restructuring, Rozgar payroll finance scheme to prevent layoffs, and concessional finance for investment in industry and health facilities.”

Previously…
On 22 May, the National Accounts Committee (NAC) released the estimate of 3.94 per cent GDP growth for FY21, an estimate which was higher than all the previous estimates of the SBP, International Monetary Fund and World Bank. The State Bank’s earlier estimate was 3 per cent against 1.5 per cent of IMF and 1.3 per cent predicted by the World Bank. (“SBP fully backs 3.94pc growth rate estimate,” Dawn, 25 May 2021)

 

Electoral reforms must ensure transparent polls, says Fawad Chaudhry
Says electoral reforms can only guarantee fair elections

Image Source: Dawn

On 24 May, Federal Information and Broadcasting Minister Fawad Chaudhry stated that the electoral reforms were imperative to ensure free, fair, and transparent elections in the country. He said, “We want to hold elections in such a manner that no one should point finger at them. The electoral reforms can only guarantee fair elections.” (“Electoral reforms must to ensure transparent polls: Fawad,” The Express Tribune, 25 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PM meets with ISI officials; discusses national and regional security
On 24 May, Imran Khan, senior military officers, and some cabinet members met with ISI officials. The ISI officers, including the DG ISI, briefed the government officials on the national regional security situations. Imran appreciated the ISI’s efforts of ensuring national security but also called for the  “commitment to uplift the weak segments of the society on the principles of state of Madina.” He believed that the belief that law is paramount in Madina resulted in quick development. (Mumtaz Alvi, “ISI briefs PM on national, regional security,” The News International, 25 May 2021)

Shehbaz calls on opposition to unite against upcoming “anti-people” budget
On 24 May, Shehbaz Sharif hosted a dinner for major opposition leaders; however, Bilawal Bhutto, Maryam Nawaz, and Fazlur Rehman did not attend the same. No details regarding the dinner were announced; however, sources told Dawn that Shehbaz had called on the opposition to unite against the upcoming budget reasoning that the opposition has the duty to stand up against “anti-people” decisions in the budget. The source also said that the PPP and ANP needed time to decide on the above. The PML-N Information Secretary said the dinner was an informal meeting but confirmed Shehbaz’s request to the other parties. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Shehbaz attempts to revive PDM in Bilawal’s absence,” Dawn, 25 May 2021)

Peshawar HC accepts bail plea of SCBA president 
On 25 May, the Peshawar High Court accepted the bail plea of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) President who has been charged with abetment of the killing of anti-terrorism judge and his three family members. The SCBA President Lateef Afridi was named by the late judge’s son. Dawn reports that the lawyers for Afridi argued that “there was no evidence on record to show that the petitioner had either provided any weapon to the attackers or participated in any meeting wherein the plan to kill the judge was made.” (“SCBA chief’s bail confirmed in judge murder case,” Dawn, 25 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Speculations rise over Chaudhry Nisar’s sudden return
On 24 May, the Punjab Assembly Secretary said he would check with the Lahore High Court if there had been any stay orders against the oath-taking of Chaudhry Nisar. This comes after Nisar could not take his oath on 21 May due to the non-availability of the Speaker and Deputy Speaker; he was planning to take oath three years after he was elected in 2018. Nisar is an “estranged” PML-N member; Dawn quotes a PTI leader who said that the PML-N may attempt “to overthrow the Buzdar government if deposed prime minister Nawaz Sharif accepted the former interior minister back into the party fold.” (“Nisar’s long-delayed return to assembly foiled for now,” Dawn, 25 May 2021) Meanwhile, an editorial in Dawn opines that Nisar, who has been an influential figure for over three decades, “is not likely to have taken the decision to return to active politics without a clear plan.” It says the weeks leading to the budget may paint a clearer image about Nisar’s return. (“Chaudhry Nisar’s return,” Dawn, 25 May 2021)

Sindh condemns Irsa decision to cut down province’s water share 
On 24 May, the PPP came down on the federal government claiming that the latter had violated the 1991 Water Accord by cutting down Sindh’s water share. However, the PTI retaliated alleging that PPP resorted to creating an artificial shortage. The Sindh Assembly adopted a resolution: “This House condemns Indus River System Authority (Irsa) decision to cut down Sindh’s water share by three-tier formula which is a violation of the 1991 Water Accord. The province’s agriculture sector contributes at least 23 per cent to Pakistan’s GDP. Not only is the economy at stake but also the livelihoods of many farmers across the province.” (Tahir Siddiqui, “Sindh Assembly slams Irsa for slashing province’s water share,” Dawn, 25 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Government sets Rs 5.8 trillion tax target for FY22
On 24 May, sources in the Finance Ministry said that the government is aiming at a 5.2 per cent growth rate. Further, they said the government had set a Rs 5.8 trillion tax target for the next financial year. However, this falls short of Rs 163 billion compared to the IMF suggestions. The government suggested introducing revenue measures worth Rs 350 billion in the coming FY; this will include Rs 81 billion tax that came into effect through an ordinance in March.  (Shahbaz Rana, “Govt pitches Rs5.8tr tax target,” The Express Tribune, 25 May 2021)

ON PAKISTAN-OCCUPIED KASHMIR
Will not tolerate attempts to put polls on hold, says “AJK” cabinet
On 24 May, the “Azad Jammu and Kashmir” cabinet said it would not tolerate any attempt to halt the upcoming polls. The cabinet reiterated its support to the “AJK Election Commission” to ensure that the polls are “timely, impartially and justly.” Previously, on 23 May, the “AJK” PM expressed his apprehensions about Imran Khan’s remarks on the polls; the “AJK” PM had tweeted, “I’ve serious reservations about PMIK’s sweeping assertion on the upcoming AJK polls. He should avoid saying, let alone doing, anything as could compromise [the] Central Govt’s neutrality in this sensitive region’s election process. We’ll however issue a specific response after tomorrow’s cabinet meeting.” (Tariq Naqash, “Haider warns against putting AJK polls on hold,” Dawn, 25 May 2021)
 
Also read...                                                                                     
An editorial in Dawn argues that unless Pakistan’s cities are reshaped to become a source of economic opportunity and democratisation, they will spawn greater social discontent and crime.

An editorial in The News International states that in Pakistan, and in many other countries, often the state machinery takes it upon itself to decide about the bona fides of a claim to citizenship, arguing this matter
needs to be taken more seriously.

Similarly, an editorial in The Express Tribune says that the recent IHC verdict, it is indeed an important one in articulating the right to citizenship in Pakistan, expressing hope that judges and leaders take one step forward in recognising our ‘stateless’ fellow citizens as well.
 



"Pakistan still faces grave challenges in providing high-quality and adequate education to eligible children...Pakistan has the opportunity to dramatically improve its education system. The right policies need to put in place for this generation of students to benefit."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'Public-private partnership key to improving education'

 


Pakistan allows US military air, ground access, says Pentagon


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Pakistan allows US military air, ground access, says Pentagon
Access granted to support its presence in Afghanistan

On 24 May, Dawn reported that a Pentagon official announced that Pakistan has allowed the US military to use its airspace and given ground access so that it can support its presence in Afghanistan. The report said that the Assistant Secretary of Defence for Indo-Pacific Affairs told the US Senate Armed Services Committee, “Pakistan has played an important role in Afghanistan. They supported the Afghan peace process. Pakistan also has allowed us to have overflight and access to be able to support our military presence in Afghanistan,” adding, “We will continue our conversations with Pakistan because their support and contribution to the future of Afghanistan, to future peace in Afghanistan, is going to be critical.” 

Pakistan’s engagement regarding Afghanistan
Previously, on 22 May, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi during his time in New York told lawmakers in Pakistan was seeking a broad-based, strategic partnership with America, which would also cover Afghanistan. He stressed the need for “a broad-based strategic partnership” that looks after the interests of both countries. Further, during a congressional hearing on Afghanistan in Washington several lawmakers and America’s chief negotiator for Afghanistan, Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad underlined Pakistan’s role in the Afghan negotiations and stated their desire to enhance bilateral ties. (“Pakistan to continue giving air, ground access, says Pentagon,” Dawn, 24 May 2021)

 

Income tax rates for salaried class will not be increased, says Tarin 
PML-N rejects govt claim about economic performance, says figured are fudged

Image Source: The Express Tribune

 

On 23 May, Finance Minister Shaukat Tarin stated that the income tax rates for the salaried class will not be increased in the upcoming budget, adding that the government will use “innovative methods” to enhance the collection in the next fiscal year 2021-22. Additionally, he promised to bring legislation to put tax evaders behind bars.

Economic growth controversy
With regard to the provisional economic growth rate of 3.94 per cent, he said that the growth was the result of prudent policies of the PM and that he hoped that in the next fiscal year 2021-22 the government can achieve a five per cent economic growth rate. He added, “The 3.94% economic growth figure should not be controversial because it has been worked out in a very transparent manner by the Ministry of Planning and the Finance Ministry has nothing to do with it.” (“No tax increase for salaried class in budget, says Tarin,” The Express Tribune, 24 May 2021)

PML-N rejects govt claim about economic performance
On 24 May, Dawn reported that the PML-N alleged that the PTI government has fudged figures, including those about the population of Pakistan, to lie about its economic performance. PML-N leader Miftah Ismail and former governor of Sindh Mohammad Zubair stated that the PTI government had failed at all three indicators, its GDP growth, inflation rate and budget deficit which are the top three indicators of any economy. Further, they claimed that the PTI government while calculating the GDP growth took Pakistan’s population as 210.10 million, however, the actual population was 220.80 million according to the 2017 census which had increased by 2.4 per cent since then. (“PML-N rejects govt claim about economic performance,” Dawn, 24 May 2021)

 

WHO awards Pakistan for its anti-tobacco campaign
Award had been given to Pakistan due to efforts made during the last decade

Image Source: Dawn

On 24 May, the World Health Organisation (WHO) regional office for the eastern Mediterranean has announced the World No Tobacco Day 2021 Award for Pakistan for its effective anti-tobacco campaign. Former technical head of the Health Ministry’s Tobacco Control Cell (TCC) and Focal Person for WHO’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) Dr Ziauddin Islam said the award had been given to Pakistan due to efforts made during the last decade. However, anti-tobacco advocates have criticized the government’s policies and its failure to implement the Pictorial Health Warning (PHW) due since 30 June 2020. (“Pakistan wins WHO’s award for anti-tobacco campaign,” Dawn, 24 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PTI will not bow down before any “mafia,” says Imran 
On 23 May, Imran Khan said that the PTI would stand its ground against “all mafias and their rhetoric and reaction” to ensure accountability. He said, “Our entire political struggle has been for the rule of law and we will ensure that no matter what...I didn’t even treat my political opponents unfairly, then why would I do so with one of my own [party members].” Sources said the PM had dismissed the idea of issuing an NRO to anyone. In a reference to Jahangir Tareen and his group of like-minded lawmakers, the Science and Technology Minister explained that Imran would ensure that “every corrupt individual” will be brought to justice regardless of their status or party. (“PTI will remain unbowed amid ‘mafia’ pressure: PM,” Dawn, 24 May 2021) (“PM rules out NRO even for PTI's own,” The Express Tribune, 24 May 2021)

Shehbaz to host dinner to revive PDM; PPP confirms attendance
On 24 May, Shehbaz Sharif will be hosting a dinner to bring together the PDM; however, Dawn referred to political experts who maintained that it is unlikely that there will be any major breakthrough for the alliance. Sources say Shehbaz will put forth a plan of action for the PDM’s future and will deliberate on a move to resist the passage of the upcoming budget. Meanwhile, the PPP Information Secretary cleared the air on speculations that the party will not attend the dinner; he confirmed that Yusuf Raza Gilani, Raja Pervez Ashraf and Sherry Rehman will be present. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Shehbaz move to heal PDM rift unlikely to pay off,” Dawn, 24 May 2021) (Rameez Khan, “PPP to attend PML-N’s dinner,” The Express Tribune, 24 May 2021)

Ring Road corruption investigation in a fix as fact-finding committee dissolves
On 23 May, The Express Tribune reported that the investigation into the Ring Road corruption case had come to a standstill because of the dissolution of the fact-finding committee. The committee, constituting of three members, was expected to submit three reports - “substantiating allegations of earning commission and bribery, loopholes in the policy that led to the corruption, and submitting detailed proposals regarding the development projects in Rawalpindi.” One of the members refused to sign the first report and subsequently, the Punjab government did initiate any measures to reconstitute the body, thereby resulting in the current uncertainties. (“Dissolution of RRR fact-finding committee puts probe in jeopardy,” The Express Tribune, 23 March 2021)

Bilawal demands apology from Imran for “economic crimes” 
On 23 May, Bilawal Bhutto called Imran Khan an “economic criminal” claiming that the economic situation of Pakistan was not as bad during the world economic crisis compared to the situation after Imran came to power. He said, “Imran Khan would leave behind stories of economic ruin and leave the country like [former premier] Shaukat Aziz and [former military ruler] Pervez Musharraf.” He accused Imran of patronising with mafias and demanded that the PM apologise to the common man for his “economic crimes.” (“Imran biggest ‘economic criminal' in country: Bilawal,” The Express Tribune, 24 May 2021)

ENERGY
Koto-HPP to be completed by December 
On 24 May, Dawn referred to the assistant project director of the Koto hydropower project (Koto-HPP); he said the project would be completed by December. The plant is expected to generate  40.8MW electricity adding to the national grid. Further, the project aims “to develop power potential in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa on a sustainable basis to provide environment-friendly energy to the consumers.” (“Koto hydropower project to be completed by Dec,” Dawn, 24 May 2021) 

EXTERNAL
Pakistan to host World Environment Day this year
On 24 May, The News International reported that Pakistan will be hosting the World Environment Day on 5 June for the first time. Islamabad will witness a mega environmental event on the same day. On June 4, Imran Khan would virtually preside over the World  Environment Conference wherein the UN Secretary General, the Pope, and the German Chancellor will be present. This year will mark the commencement of the “UN Decade on Ecosystem Restoration 2021 – 2030.” (Ayaz Akbar Yousufzai, “In a first, Pakistan to host World Environment Day 2021,” The News International, 24 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Opinion highlights Western media’s reluctance to call Israel an aggressor 
An opinion in Dawn outlines the Western media’s coverage of Israel and Palestine and highlights the downplaying of Israel’s role. The author highlights the difference in language used by the Western media and gives the example of how the AP building “‘collapsed after a missile strike’, just like Palestinian children are never killed, they simply die.” He says the Western media does not name Israel as the aggressor. He reasons that this could be because criticism of Israel is often met with accusations of being anti-Semitic. Further, the hesitance is also a product of “Western guilt at the Holocaust.” However, he reiterates that “the West cannot be allowed to wash this historic stain from its hands with the blood of Palestinian children. The white man’s burden is his own to bear.” (“Zarrar Khuhro, “Heart of darkness,” Dawn, 24 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                     
An editorial in Dawn says that the fear of being rendered stateless is a very real one for many Pakistani citizens, arguing to render someone stateless is a grave violation of rights, both according to domestic and international law.

An opinion in Dawn says that the delays in the judicial system lies in the interests and capacities of the various players that drive the judicial set-up. It argues that change in the system can be achieved only through change the stakes and interests of each of its players.

An opinion in The News International argues that attending to Balochistan’s economic needs apart from necessary political measures would require a major rethink in the corridors of power.
 



"The true tragedy of the digital revolution is how an unforgiving culture of wanting to be seen and heard is voraciously consuming lives all because we do not give such people the courtesy they deserve in the real world. That is something that banning platforms will never solve."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'Dying to be heard'

 


National Accounts Committee estimates GDP growth at 3.94 per cent


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
National Accounts Committee estimates GDP growth at 3.94 per cent
Figure defies IMF, WB projection and exceeds even SBP estimate

On 21 May, the National Accounts Committee under the Chairmanship of Secretary Ministry of Planning, Development and Special Initiatives held a meeting to review the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). According to the press release, “The provisional growth of GDP for the year 2020-21 has been estimated at 3.94% which is based upon growth estimates of the agricultural, industrial and services sectors at 2.77%, 3.57% and 4.43%, respectively. The growth for 2019-20 was revised downward from -0.38% to -0.47%.” (“National Accounts Committee Meeting Held On 21st May, 2021,” Press Release)

Growth rate higher than the SBP and IMF estimates
The growth figures came in contrast to the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) which had estimated GDP growth at three per cent. Additionally, the International Monetary Fund and World Bank’s estimate was between 1.3 per cent and 1.5 per cent for the fiscal year 2020-21.

Sector-wise: Agriculture, industrial and services sectors lead recovery
According to the statement, the agriculture sector grew by 2.77 per cent in 2020-21 as against 3.31 per cent in 2019-20. The growth of important crops during this year is 4.65 per cent on the back of historic highest ever production of wheat, rice and maize while sugarcane registered second highest-ever production. The industrial sector witnessed a positive growth of 3.57 per cent. While the Services sector remained a major growth driver for many years witnessed a growth of 4.43 per cent in the provisional estimates.

GDP size stands at Rs47.709 trillion for 2020-21
Pakistan’s GDP size stands at Rs47.709 trillion for 2020-21, compared to Rs41.556 trillion the previous year, showing a growth of 14.8 per cent. However, the GDP size surged to USD 296 billion in 2020-21 against USD 263 billion in 2019-20, an increase of USD 33 billion or 12.54 per cent. The size of the economy grew in dollar terms as the rupee strengthened against the greenback.

Higher GDP growth reflects the success of his government’s economic policies, say PM 
Following the announcement, PM Imran Khan took via Twitter said that the higher GDP growth reflects the success of his government’s economic policies while managing the Covid-19 pandemic. He said, “This reflects the success of our economic policies while managing the pandemic. Our V-shaped recovery is balanced between three major sectors — agriculture, industry and services.” (“Pakistan's economic growth rate projected at 3.94pc,” Dawn, 22 May 2021) (“4% GDP growth beats gloomy forecasts,” The Express Tribune, 22 May 2021)

Govt need not celebrate the growth, says experts
Dr Ashfaq H Khan, economist and the Principal and Dean, School of Social Sciences & Humanities, NUST stated that the government need not celebrate the GDP growth of 3.94 per cent as this number has appeared reasonable because of the lower base effect. In an interview with The News International, he said, “This is a provisional number which will be revised somewhere at 4.8-5% after the end of the current financial year. This figure has emerged because of the lower base effect.” (“Govt need not celebrate 3.94pc GDP growth: experts,” The News International, 22 May 2021)

 

One year after the Karachi plane crash
Investigation remains inconclusive amid accused of delaying the insurance claims

Image Source: Dawn

On 21 May, Aircraft Accident and Investigation Board (AAIB) released an interim statement stating that the probe was under progress for the formulation of conclusion and safety recommendations. It said, “The AAIB has planned supplementary field visits, and continues to exchange information/data, teleconferences and emails with all stakeholders to evaluate all possible aspects related to the accident.” Adding, “Subsequent to the conclusion of investigation and preparation of draft final report, member states will have the opportunity to review and comment on draft final report. After necessary reconciliation/addressing of the comments received from the member states, the final report shall be forwarded to the Govern­ment of Pakistan for approval and public release.”

Probe into Karachi plane crash remains inconclusive
As the probe into the PK-8303 crash that claimed several lives on May 22, 2020, remains inconclusive, the national flag carrier has also been accused of delaying the insurance claims of a majority of the victims’ families on the basis of not having signed an indemnity agreement that would release internationally all parties from liabilities.

Families await justice
Majority of the relatives of the victims do not agree with the assertion made by the AAIB statin that they been trying to seek justice but it seems their efforts are far from bearing fruit. Additionally, most of them have not been provided with the insurance money because they refused to sign a Release, Discharge Agreement (RDA) that would restrict them from suing the airline, however, the PIA claimed that it was merely facilitating them in filing the insurance claims with the National Insurance Company Limited (NICL), the victims’ relatives said it was forcing them to sign the RDA. (“One year on, probe into Karachi plane crash remains inconclusive,” Dawn, 22 May 2021)

 

‘Unfortunately, a woman’s life is cheap in Pakistan,’ says editorial
Despite harsher punishments in the anti-honour killing law such murders are pervasive in Pakistan

Image Source: The Daily Times

 

An editorial in Dawn critical of the killing of a woman and man in Mansehra which was classified as an ‘honour’ killing says that despite the inclusion of harsher punishments in the anti-honour killing law of 2016, such murders are pervasive in Pakistan. The editorial argues that such killings are rooted in an entitled and deeply patriarchal culture that attempts to control women’s bodies and agency. Further, with little accountability or access to justice for victims, conviction rates continue to remain low and as long as this remains, it is unlikely that any law that is passed will act as a deterrent.

Further, the editorial highlights a jail petition in September 2020 where Justice Qazi Faez Isa remarked that the word ‘honour’ should be dropped when referring to such acts of violence, to remove justification, however, it says, unfortunately, a woman’s life is cheap in Pakistan. (“No honour in sight,” Dawn, 22 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Tareen’s supporters meet Punjab CM
On 21 May, the Punjab Chief Minister assured Jahangir Tareen’s group of like-minded lawmakers that cases against Tareen would be investigated fairly and that he would not be treated with “injustice.” Further, the CM also eight ministers to “woo” the Tareen group; the eight ministers will engage with four members each. They are expected to address the group’s concerns over bureaucracy, development funds and the like and in return, Tareen’s group is expected to keep away from issuing controversial statements. Later, the group’s “focal person” told the media that they were satisfied with the way matters were proceeding. (“Group ‘satisfied’ with probe against Tareen,” The Express Tribune, 22 May 2021)

Shehbaz, Maryam condemn "cowardly" act against Nawaz Sharif
On 21 May, the PML-N condemned a “cowardly and sinister” attack on Nawaz Sharif in London. Shehbaz Sharif tweeted that the attackers “seemed to be armed and clearly had a sinister design but thankfully, could not succeed.” According to a source, the attack took place on 20 May wherein “four men, three of whom were wearing hoodies and masks, attempted to enter the Sharif family office” pretending that they had an appointment with him; they turned violent when the staff disputed this. They said the attackers were not Pakistani; Maryam Nawaz said her father’s voice will not be silenced through such acts of criminality. (Atika Rehman, “PML-N condemns attempt to harass Nawaz in London,” Dawn, 22 May 2021)

Third incident of chain collision due to stubble burning takes place within a month

On 22 May, Dawn reported that due to poor visibility owing to stubble burning, more than three dozen vehicles, including buses, were caught in a chain collision on the Lahore-Islamabad Motorway leaving several people injured. According to a motorway police officer, this was the third such incident within a month; he said the Sheikhupura deputy commissioner had sought the imposition of Section 144 from the home department citing the dangers behind such incidents. On 21 May, the motorway police officials took up the matter with the district authorities “reminding them that such activities could prove fatal if not stopped forthwith.” (“Stubble smoke triggers chain collision on Lahore-Islamabad Motorway,” Dawn, 22 May 2021)

PROVINCES
SC to hear contempt petition against Punjab govt on 28 May, reports Dawn
On 22 May, Dawn reported that the Supreme Court is expected to hear the contempt petition against the Punjab government on 28 May. The contempt petition was filed by 15 chairmen of different zila councils and mayors wherein they challenged the provincial government’s dissolution of the local government. On 25 March, the SC had directed the Punjab government to restore the local administrations; however, the provincial government did not do so and filed a petition seeking the order’s annulment. The SC will also hear the petition on 22 May. (“SC likely to hear contempt plea against Punjab govt,” Dawn, 22 May 2021)

Seven killed, 14 injured in blast in Chaman
On 21 May, seven people were killed and 14 were injured in a bomb blast during a Palestine solidarity rally in Chaman district. The deceased include three leaders of the Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam (Nazar­yati). Dawn refers to officials who claim that the main target was the JUI-N’s Maulana Abdul Qadir Luni, who survived the blast, with minor injuries. The police said the explosives were planted on a motorbike near Luni’s vehicle. (Saleem Shahid, “Seven killed in Chaman motorcycle bomb blast,” Dawn, 22 May 2021)

ECONOMY
FDI falls by 32.5 per cent to USD 1.55 billion
On 21 May, data from the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) showed that FDI had reduced by more than 32.5 per cent in the first 10 months of the current FY. The FDI for July-April FY21 stands at USD 1.553 billion compared to USD 2.301 billion in the corresponding period in FY20, thereby reflecting a decrease of USD 748 billion. Further, foreign private investment also declined by 40 per cent. According to the data, investment from China had dropped significantly to USd 708 million in the said period compared to USD 865.3 million in the same time in FY20. However, China still accounted for 46 per cent of the FDI, followed by Hong Kong. (Shahid Iqbal, “Foreign direct investment falls by 32.5pc in 10MFY21,” Dawn, 22 May 2021)

External debt falls in Q3
On 21 May, the SBP data showed that Pakistan’s external debt and liabilities had fallen by USD 806 million and stood at USD 116.309 billion during Q3 in FY21. The external debt was recorded at USD 117.115 billion in December 2020. However, in 12 months (from March 2020 to March 2021), the total external debt had increased from USD 110.035 billion to USD 116.309 billion. (“External debt declines in Q3 by $806m,” Dawn, 22 May 2021)

ENERGY
Natural gas production figures fall since February 2017
On 22 May, Dawn reported that flow of natural gas from three major gas fields has come down since February 2017 when the highest production was recorded at 4,126 Million Cubic Feet per Day (mmcfd), to 3,597mmcfd currently. This includes: production from the Qadirpur field falling by 43 per cent to 191mmcfd currently from 337mmcfd (in February 2017); the flow from Kandhkot fell by 37pc to 130mmcfd from 208 mmcfd; and, Sui flows dropped to 348mmcfd from 444mmcfd. Apart from the three major gas fields, production in Nashpa and Makori East fell by seven per cent and eight per cent respectively. However, some fields recorded an increased natural gas production. (Aamir Shafaat Khan, "Country’s natural gas production in decline," Dawn, 22 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
Pakistan observes Palestine Solidarity Day
On 21 May, Pakistan observed Palestine Solidarity Day. Imran Khan opined that it is a positive sign that the world's opinion on Palestine is changing and therefore, "the day is not far away when Palestinians will get their just rights." He added, "In the past, I had never seen Western media and politicians criticising Israeli atrocities." The Express Tribune reported that he attributed the changing opinions to social media "which played a major role in exposing the Israeli assault on Palestinians." He also called on the international community to "take urgent actions to stop Israeli attacks against Palestinians, prevent the desecration of holy places, especially the Al Aqsa mosque, and facilitate a just and lasting solution in line with the relevant UN resolutions and the two-state vision." ("Changing world opinion will force powerful nations to stop backing Israel: PM," The Express Tribune, 22 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
US and European countries are silent on Israel’s atrocities, says opinion
An opinion in The News International highlights the death toll of children in the recent escalation of violence between Israel and Palestine; the author says “The apathy of the international community, particularly the US and Europe, to the misery of the Palestinians has shattered all fundamental standards of humanity.” She questions the silence of the “champions of international human rights” and asks why these powers have not condemned Israel yet. She opines that the calls for a ceasefire are an insult to the Palestinians, UN Charter and the UDHR, if the aggressor is not named and penalised. She asks, “If Iraq could face UN sanctions for invading Kuwait, sanctions that literally sent its people into starvation and children into malnutrition, why can’t Israel be accorded somewhat similar treatment?” She concludes that today power defines the worth of a human wherein “children are first identified by their status and then considered children.” (Mashal Arbab, “Children of a lesser god,” The News International, 22 May 2021)

ON INDIA
Qureshi says Kashmir solution key to peace in South Asia
On 22 May, The News International reported that the Foreign Minister said that Imran Khan supports the Kashmiri people and that “the dispute is an important pillar of Pakistan's foreign policy.” Qureshi also reportedly said that Imran will not “sell out” Kashmir and opined, “Peace cannot be restored in the south Asian region without resolving the Kashmir dispute.” He said the Kashmir issue is similar to the Palestine issue and said, “Like Palestine, the people of Kashmir are demanding the right to self-determination.” However, he maintained that problems between India and Pakistan can be talked out adding, “So, let's sit down together and seek solutions to the problems. With our issues amicably tackled, we can live together like good neighbours.” (“PM Imran Khan will not sell out Kashmir: FM Qureshi,” The News International, 22 May 2021)

 

 
 
Also read...                                                                           
 
An opinion in The News International says the recurring loss of life, property and livelihood due to natural catastrophes, associated primarily with the changing climate in the region is the new normal in the everyday remote and impoverished mountain communities, adding that this is the real evidence of the direct human cost of climate change in this part of the world.
 


"An effort towards reforming the election system will be incomplete if it did not address its inability to yield a representation of all economic classes, ethnicities, religious minorities, and sexes in the elected houses. Tangible measures are required enabling it to transform the political, ethnic, and religious diversity in Pakistan into a strength rather than a source of division and fragmentation."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'Making the system truly democratic'

 


70 years of Pakistan-China friendship


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
70 years of Pakistan-China friendship
Both vow to further strengthen ties between the two states

On 21 May, Pakistan and China observe the 70th anniversary of the establishment of bilateral diplomatic relations. To mark the day, PM Imran Khan and his Chinese counterpart Li Keqiang exchanged letters and vowed to further strengthen ties between the two states. Further, they also vowed to cooperate with each other in the fight against Covid-19 and complete the much ambitious Chine-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) despite “adverse background.”

Committed to the CPEC projects
According to the PM Office, Pakistan is committed to the expeditious completion of CPEC projects which would open up tremendous opportunities for growth and development in the region. adding, “I am confident that under your leadership our ‘All-Weather Strategic Co-operative Partner­ship’ will further strengthen and flourish creating a bri­ghter and promising future for our people.” Further, the Chinese prime minister said China and Pakistan were friendly neighbours linked by mountains and waters, adding that China had been consistent to prioritise Pakistan in its foreign policy, and was willing to make joint efforts with Pakistan, to develop the all-weather strategic cooperative partnership to a higher level over the next 70 years. (“Imran, Li reiterate stronger Pak-China ties,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)

Alvi, Xi vow to deepen Pak-China ties
President Dr Arif Alvi and Chinese President Xi Jinping also vowed to deepen bilateral cooperation and achieve high-quality development of the CPEC. Additionally, they also exchanged congratulatory letters to each other extending greetings to each other on behalf of their respective governments and people. (“Alvi, Xi vow to deepen Pak-China ties, achieve high quality CPEC development,” The News International, 21 May 2021)

Karachi Nuclear Power Plant Unit-2 (K-2) inaugurated
On 21 May, PM Imran Khan virtually inaugurated the Karachi Nuclear Power Plant Unit-2 (K-2). He said that the project will help to train manpower and facilitate technology transfer from China. Further, he said, “We are confident that China will be standing with us in all difficult times. It is fortunate that Pakistan has strong ties with an emerging power and a developed country like China," adding, “China has faced problems similar to the ones Pakistan is facing today and we have a lot to learn from them,” he said. Pakistan can learn a lot from China on pollution control, ending poverty and corruption.” (“K-2 nuclear power plant unit to produce 1,100 MW of clean energy, says PM Imran,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)

 

COAS in Ukraine for an official visit 
Pakistan keen to bolster defence ties with Ukraine

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 20 May, COAS Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa met with the Ukrainian cabinet of ministers where he held separate meetings with the Prime Minister and Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Strategic Industries of Ukraine. During the meetings, matters of mutual interest, regional security situation, particularly the Afghan negotiations were discussed. Additionally, the Ukrainian leadership appreciated Pakistan’s contributions to conflict prevention in the region.

Both sides agreed to further optimise military-to-military ties
During the meeting, both sides agreed to further optimise military-to-military ties especially in defence production, training, counter-terrorism and intelligence domains.

COAS visits Ukrainian military test site
COAS Bajwa visited a military test site in the Kharkiv region of Ukraine and witnessed field tests of various weapons and equipment. He said, “Pakistan is keen to enhance defence cooperation with Ukraine on the basis of Transfer of Technology (ToT) and Joint Ventures (JVs) in future as both sides can benefit from each other's experience.” (“Pakistan keen to bolster defence ties with Ukraine: Gen Qamar,” The Express Tribune, 21 May 2021) (“Ukraine lauds Pakistan’s efforts for conflict prevention,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)

 

ECP constitutes committee for procurement of EVMs
Reviews presidential ordinance on EVMs and overseas Pakistanis right to vote

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 20 May, the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) decided to constitute a committee for the procurement of electronic voting machines (EVMs) and to enable overseas Pakistanis to exercise their right to vote while staying in their country of residence. The committee which is under the supervision of the ECP secretary will forward its recommendations in the next meeting. (“ECP constitutes committee on EVMs,” The Express Tribune, 21 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PML-Q to stay as an ally to PTI 
On 20 May, the PML-Q President reiterated that the party will stay an ally to the federal and the Punjab government despite the PTI’s unfulfilled promises. He said, “When we go with anyone, we do not betray them. [Therefore], there is no chance of any change in Punjab. Inshallah, we will never have no confidence against the government.” Further, referring to Jahangir Tareen’s newly formed group of like-minded lawmakers, the  party president conveyed that the group is unlikely to cause harm to the PM. (“PML-Q will not betray PTI ‘despite unfulfilled promises’,” The Express Tribune, 21 May 2021)

PTI’s financial documents’ perusal completed
On 20 May, the scrutiny of the PTI’s financial documents was completed; however, sources said that no original bank statements of the party have the permission to be perused, “including the 23 PTI bank statements requisitioned by the State Bank of Pakistan.” The petitioner said that whichever documents have been perused constitute “the tip of the iceberg.” Dawn explains that unless the permission to scrutinise the original documents is obtained, the focus will now be on the final findings which will be submitted and made public shortly. (Iftikhar A Khan, “Perusal of PTI’s financial documents concluded,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)


Faulty investigations, weak prosecution lead to 80 per cent acquittal in rape cases
On 20 May, Dawn reported that nearly 80 per cent of those accused of rape in Islamabad were acquitted; the high rate of acquittal has been attributed to “faulty investigation, poor prosecution and out-of-court settlements.” However, the high figures come despite the government’s strict legislation. Further, the problem also arises because despite the recent ordinance empowering all session judges to handle rape cases, “only one additional district and sessions judge (ADSJ), Ata Rabbani, is authorised to entertain complaints in rape cases.” Therefore, to address the gap, the law ministry has forwarded a notification to the Islamabad HC seeking authorisation for all session judges to handle the rape cases. (Malik Asad, “80pc acquittal recorded in rape cases in Islamabad,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Punjab Minister accuses Sindh of tampering with data on water availability
On 20 May, the Punjab Irrigation Minister accused Sindh of “tampering with water availability data in the province.” He said that the Indus River System Authority (Irsa) has been detecting more water in various barrages than what was reported by Sindh. He claimed that Punjab irrigation officials had also raised doubts regarding the same; however, he said, the Irsa did not take any action despite receiving reports from the officials. On the other hand, a spokesperson of Irsa acknowledging the claim said the authority has doubts on Sindh’s data on water availability but did not outline the steps taken to address the issue. (“Sindh accused of fudging water availability data,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
Child sexual abuse higher among male minors than female, highlights opinion 
An opinion in Dawn refers to latest statistics on child sexual abuse which highlight that an alarming number of victims are male minors (aged under 10 years); the author cautions against the widespread misconception that male minors are not vulnerable to sexual abuse. She says, “This unnatural, culturally constructed masculine image puts male minors at a great disadvantage...male minors fall victim to strangers as well acquaintances and are assaulted in both open and closed spaces.” She brings out the difference in the reported number of cases wherein there are more cases reported in urban areas but says the situation might be similar in rural areas as well. She lists two reasons for underreporting: culture of silence along with absence of child protection laws, and family pressure to keep the identity of the perpetrator safe. Therefore, she calls for “a top-to-bottom approach to child abuse” wherein the government’s measures are practical and child-centred. (Maria Taimure, “Failing our children,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Rice export association rejects SAPM’s remark on basmati export
On 20 May, the  Rice Exporters Association of Pakistan (REAP) Chairman disputed claims by the SAPM on Agriculture wherein the latter claimed that Pakistani farmers insisted on exporting basmati rice; he said they should instead produce the same for local consumption only. However the REAP Chairman said that they export more than USD 800 million worth of basmati rice annually. He said such remarks by a senior official harms their measures to safeguard the “heritage for centuries in basmati rice besides billions invested in rice mills, export market brand equity etc.” He also accused the SAPM of supporting Indian application in the EU for the GI. (“Rice exporters assail remarks of prime minister’s aide,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)
 

EXTERNAL
Qureshi meets UN Secretary General and UNGA President to discuss Palestine 
On 21 May, the Foreign Office said that the Foreign Minister had met with the UN Secretary General. According to the FO, Qureshi reiterated Pakistan’s support to the Palestinian cause and their right to self determination. Previously, on 20 May, Qureshi had met with the UNGA President wherein he expressed that all Paksitanis were “outraged at Israel’s use of indiscriminate and disproportionate force against innocent Palestinians.” He also “reiterated Pakistan's calls for an immediate ceasefire, and to ensure Israel’s full compliance with international humanitarian and human rights laws.” (Naveed Siddiqui, “Qureshi stresses Pakistan's unwavering support for Palestine in meeting with UN chief,” Dawn, 21 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                  
 



"Pushing through hydel projects decades ago would have helped fend off what was then an impending water crisis. Instead, today, we are smack in the middle of a crisis that is crippling agriculture growth and life in general for regular citizens."
-An editorial in The Express Tribune on 'New dams'

 


Qureshi calls for joint action to end Palestine crisis


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Qureshi calls for joint action to end Palestine crisis
Arrives in New York to attend emergency UNGA session 

On 19 May, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi called for collective efforts to end the human tragedy in Palestine and avert threats to regional peace while urged the international community to persuade Israel to end its aggression against the Palestinians. He also stressed the need to take concrete steps for a solution to the Palestine issue. He made these statement at a dinner meeting ahead of the UNGA emergency session scheduled for 20 May.

“We hope the UNGA meeting will send a strong message,” says FM 
During the meeting, Qureshi said, “We hope the UNGA meeting will send a strong message … to end the Israeli aggression and to take concrete steps to find a solution to the Palestine issue.” Further, the discussion focused on the worsening situation in Gaza and ways to formulate a unified and unequivocal response from OIC member states to Israeli aggression. The meeting was attended by foreign ministers of Turkey, Tunis, Palestine, President UNGA along with the foreign ministers of OIC member states.

Previously, met with Palestinian counterpart
Before his departure to the US, Qureshi met in a meeting with his Palestinian counterpart Riyad al-Maliki exchanged views over the situation, he also conveyed the resolve of the Pakistani leadership, to continue supporting the Palestinian struggle for their right to self-determination. (“Qureshi urges global action to end Israeli assault on Palestine ahead of UNGA session,” Dawn, 20 May 2021) (“UNGA session: Pakistan calls for joint strategy to draw world’s attention towards Palestine crisis,” The News International, 20 May 2021) (“FM Qureshi calls for collective efforts to end human tragedy in Palestine,” The Express Tribune, 20 May 2021)

Meanwhile…
On 19 May, thousands of people across Karachi came together at the Press Club to stand in solidarity with the Palestinians and demand the Israeli government to put an end to systemic genocide on the civilians of Palestine. These protests are said to be organized by student-led bodies from universities and colleges in Pakistan. (“Karachiites march for Palestine, demanding an end to Israeli aggression,” The Express Tribune, 20 May 2021)

 

Fafen urges for immediate review of the FPTP system 
Calls for debate on proportional representation system

Image Source: The News International

On 19 May, the Free and Fair Election Network (Fafen) in a report called on the parliament to immediately consider the review of the inefficacy of the first-past-the-post (FPTP) system to yield truly representative legislatures and governments. The network also urged for a wide-ranging discourse and negotiations on the adoption of a proportional representation (PR) system that guarantees translation of more than 95 per cent of votes cast into representation.

The report said, “The obsoleteness of FPTP is becoming more pronounced as the elections are becoming more competitive with polled votes splitting in triangular and at times quadrangular races as higher number of political parties and independent candidates are vying for national and provincial assemblies’ general seats.”

Analysis indicates that more than half of the votes polled did not translate into any representation
According to the report, an analysis of official election results indicates that more than half of the votes polled for the general seats in the National Assembly and Provincial Assemblies during the last four general elections did not translate into any representation. As a result, the assemblies created after these elections represented only a minority of the polled votes as well as the registered votes and the overall population. Further, the federal and provincial governments formed after the elections represented even smaller proportions of the respective electorate.

FPTP one of the key contributors to political instability
Fafen noted that factoring out the majority vote by the FPTP has been one of the key contributors to political instability in the country and the formation of weak federal and provincial governments. It advised that with the parliament set to discuss the Elections (Amendment) Bill, 2020, it should also take stock of issues of representation and strengthen the elected houses by choosing a system that truly and realistically represents the will of the people in the shape of their political choices, making each vote not only count but to also translate into representation. (“Fafen calls for debate on proportional representation system,” Dawn, 20 May 2021)

 

Irsa warns of worsening water shortage
Says that the next 48 hours are crucial

Image Source: Dawn

On 20 May, Dawn reported that as temperatures drop in catchment areas, national water shortages have risen close to 30 per cent, against earlier calculations of 10 per cent. According to the Indus River System Authority (Irsa), the next 48 hours are crucial, adding that has currently been distributing water at 18 per cent shortages because of national storages and if the temperatures keep the current pattern, “we would be in trouble.” (“Irsa warns water shortages may aggravate,” Dawn, 20 May 2021)

Meanwhile, an opinion in The Express Tribune warned that any mismanagement in the accumulation and distribution of resources can turn into a national crisis. It adds given that the country has seen it unfold as the country slipped into an unprecedented spiral of load shedding in the previous decade, the same may happen again in the shape of a water crisis the ground realities are ignored. (“Water politics,” The Express Tribune, 20 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Islamabad HC dismisses pleas regarding auction of Nawaz’s properties
On 19 May, the Islamabad High Court dismissed three pleas which had challenged an accountability court’s decision to auction three properties of Nawaz Sharif on 20 May. The IHC raised several objections to the pleas, including that the petitioners could have filed a petition with the same accountability court. The three properties include a house in Lahore and two agricultural lands in Sheikhupura. The court has directed Lahore and Sheikhpura deputy commissioners to auction the above within 60 days. (Malik Asad, “Pleas against auction of Nawaz’s properties dismissed,” Dawn, 20 May 2021)

Tareen and group to support PTI govt in budget sessions
On 19 May, the Interior Minister said that Jahangir Tareen and his group will support the PTI government in the upcoming budget session of the National Assembly, as well as the Punjab Assembly. This comes a day after Tareen formed a group of like-minded lawmakers in the NA but said they would remain a part of the party. The Interior Minister conveyed that such groups in a big political party like the PTI are a routine matter. Meanwhile, Tareen accused the Punjab government of using vindictive tactics against his group members. (Wajih Ahmad Sheikh and Aamir Yasin, “Tareen slams Punjab govt’s ‘vindictiveness’,” Dawn, 20 May 2021)

Mob attacks a consequence of not addressing regressive ways of society, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn refers to the latest attack on a police station in Islamabad and opines that such incidents reflect “a deep distrust of the judicial system.” The editorial laments the vigilantes’ insistence on imposing their “barbaric” idea of “justice” and terms it the result “of not addressing the regressive ways of society.” It says that beside exposing the weakness of the state, these incidents bring out the failure of the “weak judicial system that often tends to favour the rich and powerful rather than protect the vulnerable.” Therefore, it calls for an urgent but fair rule of law. (“Mob attack,” Dawn, 20 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Special squad established to curb money laundering
On 19 May, the Islamabad Director of the Fed­eral Investigation Agency (FIA) said that the agency had formed a special squad to bring down money laundering and illegal currency exchanges. This step was in line with the FATF conditions. The special squad will be under the Additional Directors and has been instructed to “take strict action against illegal currency trade and branches of money exchange companies, if they were found involved in illegal business.” (Mohammad Asghar, “FIA sets up special squad to curb money laundering,” Dawn, 20 May 2021)

SECP issues guidelines for gender bonds
On 20 May, Dawn reported that the Secu­rities and Exchange Com­mission of Pakistan (SECP) had issued guidelines on Gender Bonds (GB). The concept of GB is a move to boost the financial inclusion of women and push entrepreneurship among women. The guidelines state that money raised through the GB should be assigned to projects focussing on women upliftment and ease access to credit, MSME development and the like. (“Guidelines for gender bonds issued,” Dawn, 20 May 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
Ghani’s remarks on Pakistan stirs conversations in the US
On 20 May, Dawn reported on the proceedings in the US House Foreign Affairs Committee on 18 May. A Congresswoman referred to the Afghan President’s claim that Afghanistan’s future is in the hands of Pakistan, and asked Afghan Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad about Afghanistan’s intentions. She asked “What specifically are you doing to push Pakistan’s leaders and to ensure that they do step up the way we want them to?” To this, Khalilzad said that COAS Bajwa and PM Imran Khan “recognise that this economic benefit is where the future is. Gen Bajwa has said countries do not develop, regions develop.” He added that Gen Bajwa’s visit to Kabul seems to be successful and the two sides are working with the UK to improve the bilateral ties. Previously, Ashraf Ghani had said in an interview that “The US now plays only a minor role. The question of peace or hostility is now in Pakistani hands.” (Anwar Iqbal, “Pakistan's key role in Afghanistan echoes in US Congress,” Dawn, 20 May 2021)

ON INDIA
NGO lists numbers of prisoners still in India and Pakistan despite finishing their terms
On 20 May, The Express Tribune referred to a report by an NGO and reported that “67 Pakistanis are awaiting repatriation process in Indian prisons despite having completed their terms.” Some prisoners had reportedly finished their term more than a decade ago. The founder of the NGO “Aghaz-e-Dosti” says that of the 263 Pakistani prisoners, 67 have completed their sentence; some prisoners, he said, are deaf and mute. Similarly, “there are 49 Indian nationals in Pakistani jails. Of them, 32 have completed their sentences, and 18 prisoners served their sentences more than five years ago.” (Asif Mehmood, “67 Pakistanis in Indian jails despite serving terms,” The Express Tribune, 20 May 2021)

Editorial criticises Modi amid serious COVID-19 situation in India
An editorial in The Express Tribune outlines the COVID-19 situation in India and says that the current situation could have been avoided “like many of Modi’s previous bungles.” The editorial says that India could have decided to not export vaccines until securing the necessary supplies for its own population but carried on exporting because “he (Modi) wanted to project a power image abroad.” The editorial opines that despite the above, Modi’s approval ratings stand close to 60 per cent and says that “You don’t have to be a bigot to vote for the BJP, but it does help. For those people, Modi’s excuses, however weak, are statements of fact.” It concludes by saying, “Instead of fixing its mistakes, as the US did, Modi did what he does best — tell lies. How much it will cost him remains to be seen.” (“Modi’s new clothes,” The Express Tribune, 20 May 2021)

ON COVID-19
NCOC partially relaxes COVID-19 SOPs
On 19 May, the National Command and Operation Centre decided to relax some of the COVID-19 SOPs. The NCOC has allowed for the reopening of “educational institutions in districts with less than five percent COVID-19 positivity ratio,” from 7 June, operation of outdoor dining restaurants, and conducting outdoor marriage ceremonies  with maximum 150 guests. (Muhammad Anis, “NCOC allows staggered relaxation in Covid SOPs,” The News International, 20 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                   
 



"Pakistan needs to choose between decline under an authoritarian state or the renewal of the vision of its founding father to be a democratic, enlightened and progressive republic. Both the state and the republic need to converge around this democratic way forward."
-An opinion in Dawn on 'A reform agenda'

 


PBS releases the 6th Population and Housing Census 2017


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 19 May 2021
Remittances from the Gulf continue to increase
While there is so much negative news on trade and investment, remittances to Pakistan from its workforce has been continuously on the rise.

According to the latest data released by the State Bank of Pakistan, the remittances received by Pakistan during April 2021 was USD 2778 million, a record. Last year, for the corresponding month, it was only USD 1785 million. Compared to last year, there was an increase this year close to 1000 million USD.

There has been an upward trend in Pakistan's remittances since June 2020. Between January and June during the last year, the remittances were hovering around 1700-1900 million USD. Since June 2020, the remittances constantly remained over 2000 million USD. In 2021, during January-March, it was 2273, 2265, 2724 million USD, respectively. 

What happened in April 2021 was not an exception; it has been a part of the trend in Pakistan's remittances. There is another trend as well, in terms of where the remittances come from. In April 2021, of the total 2778 million USD, most of it came from Saudi Arabia (664 million USD), UAE (549 million USD) and other GCC countries (297 million USD). The Middle East constitutes a significant chunk of Pakistan's remittances. However, one could also note, there is an increase in the remittances from other countries as well – from the US to Australia.

The Roshan Digital Account initiative has been considered as one of the primary reasons for the jump in remittances. One needs more data to determine whether this jump is due to the Roshan Digital Account, thereby using the formal channels to send remittances instead of the informal hawala transactions. In April 2021, the Roshan Digital Account crossed USD one billion. 

Pakistan needs this remittance boost from its workforce, given the issues facing in the trade deficit and issues relating to attracting foreign investment.

In Focus
PBS releases the 6th Population and Housing Census 2017
Count includes 106m males, 101m females, 321,744 transgender persons

On 19 May, Dawn reported that the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) posted the final results of the 6th Population and Housing Census 2017. According to the Bureau, the country’s total population stands at 207.68 million, with an annual growth rate of 2.4 per cent. The population includes 106.018 million males, 101.344 million females and 321,744 transgender persons.

Annual growth dropped to 2.4 per cent
According to the final results of the 2017 census, Pakistan’s annual growth dropped to 2.4 per cent from 3.06 per cent and 2.69 per cent, as recorded in the 1981 and 1998 censuses, respectively. The total population in 1981, 1998 and 2017 was recorded at 84.25 million, 132.35 million m and 207.68 million, respectively. The total count in the 2017 exercise included 132.013 million rural and 75.670 million urban population.

Data for the provinces
The population of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa jumped to 30.51 million in 2017. The number of people in the erstwhile Fata increased to 4.99 million. Punjab’s population saw a jumped to 47.85 million people in the 2017 census. However, Balochistan’s population almost tripled to 12.34 million. Similarly, the population of Islamabad Capital Territory increased six-fold to two million.

Further, the Bureau said, “With a -0.043pc difference with the provisional results, the country’s population, as per final results of census 2017, is 207.68m with a population growth rate of 2.40pc from 1998 to 2017 with 106.3m males and 101.3m females.”

The delay
The census result has been released after a three-year delay, where the federal cabinet had approved it in December 2020. Further, since Sindh had opposed the exercise, it also rejected the release of the final results that were approved by the CCI in April 2021.

Previously…
“The Council of Common Interests (CCI) on Dec 16, 2016, decided to conduct the census in two phases with the support of the armed forces. The PBS demarcated the whole country into small compact areas called census clocks comprising 200 to 250 houses on an average, with a total number of over 1.68 million blocks with well-defined boundaries and maps. The entire delimitation process was carried out with the close coordination of provincial governments, local governments, revenue department and district administrations.” (“Pakistan’s population is 207.68m, shows 2017 census result,” Dawn, 19 May 2021) (“Final Results Census-2017,” Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, 19 May 2021)

 

‘Climate change to cost Pakistan USD 3.8bn yearly,’ says study
Study warns country may face up to 2.5 degrees Celsius increase in temperature by 2050

Image Source: Dawn

On 18 May, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and World Bank (WB) released a joint study titled “Climate Risk Country Profile” for Pakistan. The study put Pakistan among the top risk-prune countries in terms of increase in average temperatures and resultant economic and social losses. The study noted that there is an urgent need for further research and delivery of effective adaptation and disaster risk reduction measures.

Warns of a 2.5 degrees Celsius increase in temperature by 2050
The study warned of an increase of up to 2.5 degrees Celsius in temperature over the next two decades saying, “Pakistan faces increases in average temperatures significantly above the global average with a potential rise of 1.3°C-4.9°C by the 2090s over the 1986-2005 baseline,” adding that Pakistan faced “some of the highest disaster risk levels in the world, ranked 18 out of 191 countries by the 2020 Inform Risk Index.” Further, it noted that the rises in the annual maximum and minimum temperature are projected to be stronger than the rise in average temperature, likely amplifying the pressure on human health, livelihoods, and ecosystems. Additionally, changes to Pakistan’s rainfall and runoff regimes, and hence its water resources, are highly uncertain, but an increase in the incidence of drought conditions is likely.

The frequency of extreme climate events projected to increase 
The study said that the frequency and intensity of extreme climate events are projected to increase, increasing disaster risk particularly for vulnerable poor and minority groups. It said, “an increase in the number of people affected by flooding is projected, with a likely increase of around 5 million people exposed to extreme river floods by 2035–2044, and a potential increase of around 1 million annually exposed to coastal flooding by 2070–2100.” Further, the study estimated that Pakistan is facing up to USD 3.8 billion in annual economic loss due to climate change. (“‘Climate change to cost Pakistan $3.8bn yearly’,” Dawn, 19 May 2021) (“Climate Risk Country Profile: Pakistan,” Asian Development Bank, May 2021)

 

Tareen denies split from PTI
Says likeminded group was formed in response to Punjab government's retaliatory action 

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 19 May, Jehangir Khan Tareen rejected media reports on parting way with the PTI saying, "Let me make it clear that we are and will continue to be a part of the PTI." This came after Tareen launched a group of like-minded lawmakers in the lower house of parliament as well as the Punjab Assembly on 18 May.

Says group was formed in response to Punjab government's retaliatory action 
Tareen said that the likeminded group was formed in response to the Punjab government's retaliatory action against his group, adding, "Prime Minister had promised to deliver justice but then Punjab government began retaliatory activities against us and pressurising us." He said, "We decided that we will raise our voice in the Punjab Assembly. The entire responsibility [of this development] lies on Punjab government," adding, "We have not formed a forward bloc; we have appointed a focal person to represent us in the assembly." These statements came as he appeared before a court in Lahore in the money laundering case registered against him. (“Tareen announces like-minded group,” The Express Tribune, 19 May 2021) (“Tareen defends group, says formed in response to Punjab govt's retaliatory actions,” The Express Tribune, 19 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Perusal of PTI’s financial documents lead to disclosure of undeclared bank accounts
On 18 May, sources said that during the scrutiny of PTI’s financial documents, more undeclared bank accounts were disclosed. The sources said, following the disclosure of these accounts, the petitioner Akbar S Babar called for the scrutiny of “all original accounts requisitioned through the State Bank of Pakistan which have been kept secret by the ECP Scrutiny Committee.” the petitioner later said he hopes that the ECP will make sure that every detail was presented before it and then chart a final conclusion. Meanwhile, the scrutiny process is scheduled to end on 19 May (today). (“More undeclared bank accounts of PTI found,” Dawn, 19 May 2021)

Government to begin electoral reforms debate on 24 May
On 18 May, the Information Minister said the government will be tabling the ECP report 2019-20 in the National Assembly to initiate the electoral reforms debate on 24 May. He said, “We will start debate from Monday even if the opposition does not take part in it.” He said the government had previously promulgated an ordinance seeking the use of EVMs in the next general elections. Further, he maintained that an e-voting system for overseas Pakistanis would ensure transparent elections. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Govt decides to begin debate on electoral reforms in NA,” Dawn, 19 May 2021)

Interior Ministry seeks early hearing in SC challenging LHC order on Shehbaz
On 18 May, the government sought, from the Supreme Court, an early hearing of a petition challenging the Lahore High Court’s decision to grant conditional permission to Shehbaz Sharif to travel abroad for medical reasons. The Interior Ministry’s application read, “And if the petition is not fixed for early hearing, the petitioner will suffer an irreparable loss and injury to its rights” and that “The balance of convenience also lies in favour of the petitioner.” Prior to this, on 17 May, the Interior Ministry filed its first petition in the court maintaining that the law did not justify a single judge in the chamber. (Nasir Iqbal, “Govt seeks early SC hearing of its plea against LHC order on Shehbaz,” Dawn, 19 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Five die in Karachi during dust storm 
On 19 May, The News International reported that at least five people had died after a heavy dust storm and light rain led to a roof collapse in Karachi on 18 May; casualties include a woman and two children. The Chief Meteorological Officer said, “The dust storm was partly a localized development and partly due to changes in the winds in the Arabian Sea under the influence of tropical cyclone Tauktae that made a landfall on the coast of Indian Gujarat…” Prior to the dust storm, temperature in Karachi was recorded at 41 degree Celcius. (M Waqar Bhatti, “Cyclone Tauktae: Five killed as dust storm, gales hit Karachi,” The News International, 19 May 2021)

Article calls for preparedness of utility companies during calamities
An article in Dawn says the sudden climatic shift - from the hot temperature to the dust storm and rains - in Karachi was not surprising, and outlines that there was some degree of preparedness while Tauktae took shape in India. The author urges the Sindh government, federal government and the utility companies operational in the province to not take the incident lightly, reminding them of the impact of rains in Karachi 2020, especially in the provision of electricity. The author says, “The provincial government and K-Electric should make arrangements on war footing to pre-empt episodes that could make citizens’ lives miserable.” (Peerzada Salman, “And then the wind blew,” Dawn, 19 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Tarin says growers will receive 35 to 40 per cent higher returns in the absence of middlemen
On 18 May, the Finance Minister emphasised the necessity to bring down the dominance of middlemen which would, in turn, result in 35 per cent to 40 per cent higher returns to the growers of agricultural produce. He pushed for interest-free farm loans, reasoning that they would eliminate the exploitation by middlemen and make way for sustainable farming. He also called for charting a method that would disburse “microcredit to farmers with smaller land holdings.” (“Curbing role of middlemen to boost farmers’ returns by 40pc: Tarin,” Dawn, 19 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Opinion outlines possible reasons behind the West's silence on Israel
An opinion in The News International says that several Western powers are silent on the "Israeli atrocities" in Palestine. The author asks how would the West react if China “targeted a building housing various Western media outlets in Xinjiang?” He says one reason behind the silence could be history; speaking against Israel, a country created by Jews who migrated from the West, is a reminder of the latter’s own colonial atrocities. He says the hardliner Zionists are repeating the mantra of the colonial powers - “brutalities in the name of religion.” He opines that Israel is using “sledgehammer tactics” similar to those the colonial powers used against the indigenous people. He acknowledges those in the West standing up for the Palestinians, calling them a beacon of hope, but says that largely “It is the past of the Western powers that prevents them from condemning the atrocities of the Zionist forces.” (Abdul Sttar, “Western silence,” The News International, 19 May 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
Editorial calls for use of appropriate forums to address bilateral differences
An editorial in The News International traces the trends in the Pak-Afghan ties and refers to the latest comments by the Afghan President wherein he had said that Pakistan served a support system for the Taliban. The editorial opines that such issues can be resolved through the necessary channel like the Afghanistan-Pakistan Action Plan for Peace and Solidarity (APAPPS); it says this forum is underutilised. It says that Pakistan particularly needs to clear the air on the allegations as “any statement from the Kabul government the world community takes on face value.” Further, it outlines that this would help curtail the erosion of trust and calls for the retraction of groundless accusations by either side. (“Pak-Afghan ties,” The News International, 19 May 2021) 

 
Also read...                                                                   
An opinion in The Express Tribune argues that Pakistan needs to dismantle from society the prevailing educational apartheid and invest in a universal education system that imparts knowledge with wisdom, morality with ethics, civic sense, and the skills to prepare our youth for the fourth industrial revolution.

An editorial in Dawn says that The Ring Road scandal is refusing to pass the smell test and the odour is reaching up to high places, arguing that the PTI government must now lay itself open for ruthless accountability.

An editorial in Dawn critical of the government’s ability to carry out its plan to develop agriculture argues that the government is still not addressing the root causes of the decline in agriculture.
 



"Pakistan’s ability to steer its way to economic progress and political stability will largely depend on a clear understanding of what it wants and needs in the present and future. Our leaders have been used to giving messages to the people that are haphazard and frequently contradictory. There has to be consistency and resolve in what we want to achieve."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'Governing in a complex environment'

 


FO calls Ashraf Ghani's remarks on Pakistan irresponsible and baseless


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
FO calls Ashraf Ghani's remarks on Pakistan irresponsible and baseless
Pakistan operates organised support system for Taliban, alleges Ghani 

On 17 May, the Foreign Office rejected the recent allegations by President Ashraf Ghani as “irresponsible and baseless,” warning that such statements could undermine mutual trust. The FO said, “Pakistan has conveyed its serious concerns to the Afghan side by making a strong demarche with the Ambassador of Afghanistan in Islamabad on the recent irresponsible statements and baseless allegations made by the Afghan leadership.” Further, the FO said, “Pakistan has emphasised that groundless accusations erode trust and vitiate the environment between the two brotherly countries and disregard constructive role being played by Pakistan in facilitating the Afghan peace process.”

Ghani alleged that Pakistan operates an organised system of support for the Taliban
In an interview, Ghani alleged that Pakistan operates an organised system of support for the Taliban insurgents, who receive logistics and financial support from them. He further alleged that there was a deep relationship between the Taliban and the Pakistani state and attempted to back his assertion by claiming that various decision-making bodies of the Taliban were named after Pakistani cities where they were supposedly based. (“FO rejects Ghani’s remarks on support for Taliban,” Dawn, 18 May 2021)

Previously…
On 10 May, COAS Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa met with President Ashraf Ghani in Kabul. During the meeting, he assured the Afghan leadership of Pakistan’s support for “inclusive power-sharing arrangement” and “elections as a right of Afghans to self-determination,” reiterating that “a peaceful Afghanistan means a peaceful region in general and a peaceful Pakistan in particular.” Further, he stated that “We will always support 'Afghan led-Afghan owned' Peace Process based on mutual consensus of all stakeholders.” Additionally, Gen Bajwa met with the Chairman of the High Council for National Reconciliation of Afghanistan Dr Abdullah Abdullah and discussed matters related to the negotiations. (“COAS backs ‘inclusive Afghan power sharing’,” The Express Tribune, 11 May 2021) (“In Kabul visit, Gen Bajwa reiterates support for Afghan peace process as violence surges,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

 

Remittances rise to an all-time high in April
PM terms overseas Pakistanis ‘greatest asset’

Image Source: Dawn

On 17 May, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) said that remittances by overseas Pakistani continued to surge, rising to an all-time high of USD 2.8 billion in April, 56 per cent higher than a year ago. Further, the central bank said that cumulatively, during the July-April FY21 workers’ remittances rose to USD 24.2 billion, up by 29 per cent, compared to the same period last year. Additionally, these have also surpassed the full FY20 level by over USD 1 billion, creating a new record.

Inflows 
The SBP stated that the inflows during the July to April period were mainly sourced from Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom, and the United States. It said, “Proactive policy measures taken by the government and the SBP to encourage more inflows through formal channels, limited cross-border travel in the face of Covid-19, medical expenses and altruistic transfers to Pakistan amidst the pandemic, and orderly foreign exchange market conditions are continuing to contribute to this sustained rise in workers’ remittances.” (“Remittances rise to an all-time high of $2.8bn in April,” Dawn, 18 May 2021)

PM lauds the overseas Pakistanis
In response to the development, PM Imran Khan praised the overseas Pakistanis for sending a record USD 2.8 billion in remittances, saying, “I have always believed Overseas Pakistanis to be our greatest asset.” Further, he said, “Remitting $24.2bn in first 10 months of FY21, you have broken the record level achieved in the entire FY20. Thank you for your faith in Naya Pakistan.” (“PM Imran lauds overseas Pakistanis for sending $2.8b in remittances,” The Express Tribune, 18 May 2021)

 

COAS Bajwa meets with EU Ambassador Kaminara
Says Pakistan desired strong ties with the EU

Image Source: Dawn

On 17 May, COAS Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa met with Ambassador of European Union Androulla Kaminara. During the meeting, he said that Pakistan desired strong ties with the European Union adding, “Pakistan values its relations with EU and earnestly looks forward to enhance mutually beneficial multi-domain relations based on common interests.” The two also discussed the regional security situation, including recent developments in the Afghan negotiations. Meanwhile, the EU ambassador also met federal Minister for Information and Broadcasting where the matters related to the humanitarian situation in Gaza and the pandemic were discussed. (“Pakistan desires strong ties with EU: Bajwa,” Dawn, 18 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PHC rules NAB arrest warrants for Safdar had element of mala fide
On 18 May, Dawn reported that the Peshawar High court had ruled that the NAB’s warrant to arrest PML-N’s Captain Safdar had an element of mala fide. The judgement reasoned that the element of mala fide came due to Safdar’s criticism of the government and the NAB. The judges observed that Safdar received several call up notices in 2018 when he criticised the present government; in 2019, he did not do so and hence there were no call up notices against him. However, the Court also directed Safdar to cooperate with the NAB in any inquiry as failure to do so provides the anti-graft body to approach the PHC to recall the ruling. (“NAB arrest warrants for Capt Safdar tainted with mala fide, rules PHC,” Dawn, 18 April 2021)

SAPM Bukhari steps down amid Ring Road controversy 
On 17 May, SAPM Zulfikar Bukhari resigned from his position amid allegations that he was a direct beneficiary of the Rawalpindi Ring Road (RRR) project. He justified the resignation saying  that the PM believed “that if a person has been named rightly or wrongly in any inquiry, he should cease to hold any public office till his name has been cleared of charges.” On the same day, the Aviation Minister was also named in the allegations. However, he said he would take up the matter in the cabinet on 18 May (today). (Syed Irfan Raza, “PM’s aide Zulfi Bukhari steps down over ring road scam,” Dawn, 18 May 2021)

Those who looted national wealth cannot be released, says Imran
On 18 May, The Express Tribune reported that Imran Khan said Shehbaz Sharif was not allowed to travel abroad because of the corruption cases against him. Imran was quoted, “I have no personal issue with anyone but those who have looted national wealth cannot be released.” On 17 May, Shehbaz was placed on the ECL by the Interior Ministry. (Rizwan Ghilzai, “Shehbaz can’t fly abroad due to corruption cases: Imran,” The Express Tribune, 18 May 2021)

Mob attacks police station demanding custody of blasphemy case suspect
On 17 May, a mob attacked Islamabad’s Golra police station “in an attempt to lynch a man detained on a charge of blasphemy.” Dawn reported that the policemen had to protect themselves and the detained suspect “by locking themselves up in the lock-up and other rooms.” They were rescued through police reinforcement, anti-terrorism squad and anti-riot unit personnel, and counterterrorism department, personnel. The suspect has been moved to an undisclosed location. (Munawer Azeem, “Mob attacks police station in capital,” Dawn, 18 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
NA passes resolution condemning violence in Palestine
On 17 May, the National Assembly unanimously passed a resolution condemning the “systematic and institutionalised oppression of Palestinians by Israel.” As per The Express Tribune, the resolution “denounced the systematic and brutal disenfranchisement, exclusion and ethnic cleansing of the people of Palestine.” It urged the OIC to act with urgency to protect the Palestinians and put an end to the blockade of Gaza by Israel. (“NA unanimously passes resolution against Israel's atrocities in Palestine,” The Express Tribune, 18 May 2021) On the same day, on Imran’s instructions, Foreign Minister Qureshi left for the emergency UNGA session being held in New York on the same issue. (Khalid Mehmood, “FM Qureshi off to New York to attend UNGA on Palestine,” The Express Tribune, 18 May 2021)

ON PAKISTAN-OCCUPIED KASHMIR
PM asks “AJK” President to appoint permanent CJ 

On 17 May, officials said that Imran Khan had sent a note to the “AJK” President to confirm Justice Raja Saeed Akram Khan as the permanent chief justice of the “AJK” Supreme Court. The position has been vacant since March 2020 after the retirement of the previous CJ. Dawn explains that the “AJK” President has the powers to appoint the acting CJs in both the supreme and high courts; however, he cannot appoint the permanent CJs “without an advice to this effect from the Prime Minister of Pakistan in the latter’s capacity as chairman of AJK council.” (Tariq Naqash, “AJK Supreme Court to have permanent CJ,” Dawn, 18 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                        
An editorial in The News International says that Pakistan needs the US as a partner in its efforts to develop as a nation which is not isolated and is able to play a role at various international forums., arguing, any misunderstandings must then be patched over, and efforts made to rebuild the relationship of the past, without allowing the US to dominate as far as Pakistan’s policy decisions go.

Similarly, an editorial in Dawn argues that Pakistan has traditionally enjoyed very close relations with both Washington and Beijing and now is the wrong time to start prioritising one over the other, arguing that this balancing act may not be easy, but it is necessary if Pakistan wants to maintain a healthy relationship with the two major powers.
 



"The mass civilian deaths terrorists cause is a huge threat that forces states to relax laws to crush them, thus undermining due process...Thus, our Anti-Terrorism Act must be revised for its overly broad definition of terrorism."
-An opinion in Dawn on 'Who’s a terrorist?'

 


Irsa increases water supply to Sindh, asks PPP not to politicise the matter 


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Irsa increases water supply to Sindh, asks PPP not to politicise the matter 
Bilawal criticises the federal govt for ‘reducing Sindh’s water cut

On 16 May, the Indus River System Authority (Irsa) increased the water supply to Sindh. The water regulator said, “As of today the share of Sindh, with immediate effect, has been increased from 66,000 cfs (cubic feet) to 71,000 cfs,” adding, the province was reporting 39 per cent losses in its areas against a permissible limit of 30 per cent. Irsa’s spokesman said, “All the provinces, including Sindh, agreed that the expected shortage was manageable with efficient water application and distribution practices. The distribution of provincial shares was as per the Three Tier formula to which Sindh also agreed.”

Further, the water regulator asked the PPP leadership to refrain from politicising a technical matter. Additionally, Isra also rejected Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s other allegations saying it had neither heard of any plans nor received any NOC request from any quarter for construction of a powerhouse on Taunsa-Panjnad link Canal. (“Irsa increases water supply to Sindh,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)

Bilawal criticised the federal govt for failing to ensure fair distribution of water
On 16 May, Bilawal accused the federal government of failing to ensure fair distribution of water and depriving Sindh of its share, stating that “Water supply to Karachi has been severely reduced due to this [inadequate supply to Sindh].” He said that the Isra has misused its authority by reducing the water level in Sindh by 15-20 per cent, demanding that it should stop the process of causing permanent damage to Sindh under its controversial three-tier formula as well as name the officials on whose orders it illegally reduced the province’s share of water.

Further, he said, “The puppet prime minister and his government have artificially created a water crisis in Sindh and it would have serious repercussions,” adding that the PTI government must be held “responsible for any consequences.” (“Bilawal slams 15-20% Sindh's water supply ‘cut',” The Express Tribune, 17 May 2021) (“Bilawal blames Centre for depriving Sindh of water share,” The News International, 17 May 2021)

 

Qureshi demands immediate end to ‘senseless’ Israeli aggression
PM discusses Palestine situation with Mahathir

Image Source: Dawn

On 16 May, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi called for immediate protection of Palestinians against “senseless Israeli aggression,” implementation of United Nations resolutions, and accountability of Israel’s crimes against humanity. He also reiterated Pakistan’s support for the Palestinian people. He said, “There are no words strong enough to condemn the systematic and barbaric crimes against the Palestinians. The deteriorating conditions in the Occupied Palestinian Territories due to the illegal practices of Israel, its colonial policies, and its continued aggression, siege and collective punishment, are sickening,” adding, “The latest spate of Israeli aggression cannot be justified or condoned.”

Further, he added, “Let me conclude by reaffirming Pakistan’s abiding support for the Palestinian people in their just struggle to secure legitimate rights, particularly their inalienable right to self-determination. I also reiterated Pakistan’s support for a two-state solution per the relevant United Nations and OIC resolutions, with the pre-1967 borders, and Al-Quds Al-Shareef as the capital of a viable, independent and contiguous Palestinian State.” These statements were made during a virtual emergency meeting of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) executive committee to discuss Israel’s aggression against Palestine. (“Qureshi in OIC meeting demands immediate end to ‘senseless’ Israeli aggression,” The Express Tribune, 17 May 2021)

Meanwhile…
FM Qureshi held a telephonic conversation with US Secretary of State Anthony J Blinken during which he conveyed the concerns of Pakistani people over the Israeli aggression against unarmed Palestinian civilians and children. (“Qureshi conveys concerns over Palestine issue to US counterpart,” The Express Tribune, 17 May 2021)

Additionally, in a rejoinder to the UN Security Council, Pakistan said, “We also strongly condemn: Israel’s deliberate and systematic assault against Palestinian worshippers in the Haram-al-Sharif, including the Al-Aqsa mosque during the holy month of Ramadan; its violation of the sanctity of these holy sites,” adding, “it is regrettable that the Council has been unable to even hold this meeting and to take action to halt Israeli aggression for so long.” (“Pakistan deplores Israel’s systematic aggression against Palestinians,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)

PM discusses Palestine situation with Mahathir
On 16 May, PM Imran Khan and former Malaysian prime minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad exchanged views on the situation in Palestine. The two condemned the situation and expressed their solidarity with the Palestinians. (“PM discusses Palestine situation with Mahathir,” The News International, 17 May 2021)

The Muslim world is doing little other than issuing statements, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn critical of the situation says that the OIC and Arab League are doing little other than issuing statements, adding that the Arab states who have recognised Israel recently have done little to convince Tel Aviv to stop their butchery. Further, the editorial questions the role of the international community in stopping this mass murder, asking whether the Palestinians, not count when the high and mighty wax eloquent about human rights and the rule of law? (“Palestine bloodbath,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)

 

FM Qureshi speaks with US Secretary of State Blinken
Says Pakistan “a broad-based and comprehensive” partnership with America

Image Source: Dawn

On 16 May, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi in a telephonic conversation with US Secretary of State Antony Blinken said that Pakistan desires “a broad-based and comprehensive” partnership with the US, adding, that they seek a “close economic cooperation, enhanced regional connectivity and common vision for a peaceful South Asia.” The two also spoke about “bilateral relations and important regional developments.” This was the second telephonic conversation between the two ministers, previously, they held a telephonic conversation after the Supreme Court decided to release Omar Saeed Sheikh, who is accused of abducting and murdering Daniel Pearl. (“Pakistan wants broad-based partnership with US, Blinken told,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Shehbaz Sharif stays on ECL after cabinet approval
On 17 May,  the Interior Minister announced that Shehbaz Sharif had been placed on the Exit Control List. The development came after the federal cabinet’s approval. The minister said that Shehbaz had not produced any medical documents or specified the treatment he needed abroad. He said Shehbaz was the guarantor for Nawaz Sharif and also added, “If Nawaz Sharif did not return then why would Shehbaz? This is a matter of common sense.” Meanwhile, Shehbaz can file an review application within 15 days. (“Shehbaz's name has been added to no-fly list, says Sheikh Rashid,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)

Federal government plans to rationalise pay and pension for employees
On 17 May, The Express Tribune referred to sources who outlined that the federal government is formulating plans to “rationalise the pay and pension of the government employees.” Some proposals for this include doing away with the differences in salaries across the ministries, departments and the like, a system to bring down the pension bill and fixing a basic pay for those who complete 25 years in service. The sources said that “a proposal for a temporary relief of 15 to 20% in the salaries of government employees was under consideration” for the upcoming budget. (Irshad Ansari, “15-20% raise in salaries expected in budget,” The Express Tribune, 17 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Punjab CM expresses disappointment in previous federal governments
On 16 May, Punjab CM Usman Buzdar said that by giving people of south Punjab their due rights, the PTI-led federal government had rectified mistakes of the previous PML-N government. He claimed that previous governments had used funds allocated to south Punjab to develop other regions. He said, “The PML-N government fooled and hoodwinked the people of South Punjab in the name of development.” (“PTI govt rectified PML-N’s mistakes in South Punjab, says Buzdar,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)

Karachi takes precautions against Tauktae
On 16 May, Dawn reported on the meteorological department’s warning which said that Karachi is likely to “experience hot/very hot weather with gusty winds” for two days as the Tauktae cyclone moves towards Gujarat in India. The department also asked fishermen to not go out in the sea. Further, temperatures were expected to rise to 41 degree Celsius to 43 degree Celsius. In accordance with the warning and anticipating an emergency situation, the city commissioner called for contingency plans. (“Extreme weather conditions keep most Karachi citizens indoors,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Exports to China see 31 per cent increase
On 16 May, the Adviser to Prime Minister on Comm­erce and Investment tweeted that exports to China had risen by 31 per cent in the first nine months of the current FY. Therefore, Pakistan’s exports to China during July 2020-April 2021 stood at USD 1.951 billion compared to USD 1.491 Billion in the same period in the previous FY, thereby indicating an increase of USD 459 million. He attributed part of the growth to the Second Phase of Pakistan-China FTA (FTA-II) which has been operational since January. (“Exports to China rose by 31pc, says Dawood,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)

Remittances are appreciable but highlight lack of opportunity at home, says editorial
An editorial in The News International cites the increase in remittances during the first three quarters of the current FY attributes the same to the Roshan Digital Account, crackdowns due to the FATF, decrease in travel expenses due to the pandemic. The editorial says by building stronger ties with other countries, Pakistan should protect the stability in remittances that has been achieved. It says Pakistan should persuade “nations to slow down or halt policies which place tough travel restrictions on Pakistanis or refuse them visas.” While appreciating the positive development, it also highlights the “talent Pakistan may have lost to other nations.” For several reasons, including high population and unemployment, people seek out jobs elsewhere. Therefore, it pushes for more entrepreneurial and employment opportunities in the country. (“Remittance report,” The News International, 17 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
Opinion outlines impact on girls' access to formal education amid pandemic
An opinion in The Express Tribune highlights the impact that closure of schools for long periods, due to the pandemic, affects girls more than boys. The author cites a study titled “Girls’ Education & Covid-19 in Pakistan” which concludes that access to formal education for girls is likely to regress because of the decrease in household incomes during the pandemic. She says that “many girls of school-going age are expected to either enter labour to supplement their household incomes or simply be withheld from returning to school to curtail household expenses.” Therefore she calls for a “fiscal space to steadily increase investment in education” and revamp the “frail” education system. However, she does not have high hopes because of the repeated failure “to bring any substantial increase in its (Pakistan’s) education development expenditure” in the last 20 years. She says the least that can be done is that provincial and federal education ministers present a strong case during the upcoming budget. (Areebah Shahid, “Rescuing education from the pandemic,” The Express Tribune, 17 May 2021)

ON PAKISTAN-OCCUPIED KASHMIR
Sardar Masood Khan calls arrest of Serai sons manifestation of India’s “fascism”
On 17 May Dawn reported that “AJK” President Sardar Masood Khan criticised the arrest of Ashraf Serai’s sons. According to Dawn, the “AJK” President called it a “manifestation of the worst form of fascism by India.” Further, he alleged that the arrests took place when Serai’s family “was mourning his custodial killing at the hands of Indian authorities.” He said, “Freedom and the right to self-determination are fundamental human rights of the Kashmiri people and they will continue their struggle for the realisation of these rights.” (Tariq Naqash, “Arrest of Ashraf Sehrai’s sons condemned,” Dawn, 17 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                           
 



"The PDM is finding it hard to look like a united alliance, with most of them too willing to cast arrows at each other. This is not a good sign and will hurt democracy in the country as well as make it impossible for the opposition, which is engaged in infighting, to keep an eye on the handling of government and the affairs of the nation."
-An editorial in The News International on 'Opposition and governance'

 


COAS meets with the US Charge d' Affairs


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
COAS meets with the US Charge d' Affairs
Says seeks ‘cooperation’ with the US in all domains

On 12 May, COAS Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa said that he hopes for “greater cooperation” between Pakistan and the US in all domains, as Islamabad's efforts to reset ties with Washington have so far met with a lukewarm response from the Biden administration. This statement came during a meeting with US Charge d' Affairs. (“COAS seeks ‘cooperation’ with US in all domains,” The Express Tribune, 13 May 2021)

Meets with the US Charge d' Affairs
COAS Gen Bajwa met with Angela Aggeler, US Charge d’ Affairs to Pakistan. During the meeting, matters of mutual interest, overall regional security situation, bilateral cooperation in various fields, fight against Covid-19 and recent developments in the Afghan peace process were discussed. Further, he said that Pakistan had sincerely supported the Afghan negotiations and a prosperous, stable and peaceful Afghanistan was in the best interest of the region. Conversely, the US Charge d’ Affairs acknowledged and appreciated Pakistan's efforts for peace and stability in the region and pledged to enhance bilateral relations between the two countries. (“Bajwa, US diplomat discuss Afghan peace process,” Dawn, 13 May 2021)

 

Pakistan, Turkey vow to stop Israeli atrocities on Palestinians
FM Qureshi urges European Muslims to speak up

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 12 May, PM Imran Khan and President Recep Tayyip Erdogan vowed to work together in mobilising the international community to help stop the attacks by Israel on Palestine. The two leaders exchanged views during a telephone call on Israel’s attack on Al-Aqsa Mosque and the worshippers inside as well as on Gaza during Ramazan, violating all norms of humanity and international laws. They also agreed that the foreign ministers of both countries would be working closely together to raise the Palestinian issue at the international level, especially at the United Nations. Further, they discussed the strengthening of bilateral relations and agreed that the momentum of high-level exchanges between Pakistan and Turkey would continue. (“Pakistan, Turkey join hands to stop Israeli atrocities on Palestinians,” The Express Tribune, 13 May 2021)

FM Qureshi urges European Muslims to speak up for the Palestinians 
On 13 May, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi urged the Muslims residing in Europe to play an active role and raise their voice against the attacks by Israeli forces on the Palestinians. He said that the Muslim Parliamentarians in Europe and Britain are effective voices and they should raise the Palestine issue and play a part in solving the ongoing crisis in Palestine. Further, he said, “Pakistan is making efforts to mobilize the international community to intervene for the safety of Palestinians from the brutalities of Israeli forces.” (“FM Qureshi urges European Muslims to speak against Israeli atrocities in Palestine,” The Express Tribune, 13 May 2021)

 

Pakistan celebrates Eid-ul-Fitr amid strict SOPs
President Alvi, PM Imran urge the nation to follow SOPs

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 13 May, Pakistan celebrated Eid-ul-Fitr while observing precautionary measures to curb the spread of the coronavirus. All mosques have been directed to follow strict SOPs to ensure social distancing. Meanwhile, President Dr Arif Alvi and PM Imran Khan have urged all citizens to strictly adhere to protocols while celebrating, stating that the measures were necessary to avoid a massive outbreak. (“Pakistan celebrates yet another Eid overshadowed by pandemic,” Dawn, 13 May 2021) (“Namaz Eid ul Fitr: Namaz Timing in Lahore,” The News International, 13 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Cabinet subcommittee recommends keeping Shehbaz on ECL
On 12 May, the Interior Minister said the federal cabinet will soon accept the recommendation of a cabinet subcommittee to keep Shehbaz Sharif on the Exit Control List (ECL). He said the decision was taken after the NAB requested a special meeting of the committee. He opined that Shehbaz could not be given “special treatment” when other people were on the ECL. He said that Shehbaz was the guarantor of Nawaz Sharif and added, “He [Shehbaz] chose the time of Sehri to run away knowing that the [Hudaibiya Paper Mills] case was about to be reopened.” (“Cabinet body wants Shehbaz's name on ECL,” The Express Tribune, 12 May 2021)

Senior legal fraternity unhappy with online campaign against judges
On 13 May, Dawn reported that senior lawyers were shocked at a “coordinated” online campaign against certain judges, following the Supreme Court’s verdict on Justice Isa on 26 April. The former president of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) said a campaign of character asssasination had been launched against several judges, mainly Justice Isa after the verdict. This comes after Justice Isa’s wife had written two open letters on 8 May and 11 May questioning a former Attorney General’s interview on YouTube wherein he did not accept the SC verdict; she alleged that he had been “threatening her with criminal prosecution.” Similarly, Dawn quoted a senior lawyer who opined that individuals have the freedom to criticise any judgement delivered by a judge or a bench of the superior judiciary. However, it “should not be seen as a deliberate attempt to bring the judiciary into disrespect or disrepute or lower the authority of the court or scandalise a judge in relation to his office.” (Nasiq Iqbal, “Onslaught against judiciary shocks senior lawyers,” Dawn, 13 May 2021)


ECONOMY
Exports to EU increase to USD 7.4 billion
On 13 May, Dawn cited data from the Ministry of Commerce, reporting that Pakistan’s exports to the EU had increased by 17 per cent in the first 10 months of the current FY. The exports stand at USD 7.474 billion during July-April in the 10 months compared to the USD 6.367 billion in the corresponding period last year. The highest exports have been made to Germany, the Netherlands, Spain, Italy and Belgium. Further, the overall increase in the figures has been attributed to the Generalised System of Preferences-Plus (GSP+) scheme. (Mubarak Zeb Khan, “Exports to EU rise by 17pc in 10 months,” Dawn, 13 May 2021)

First shipment of goods under multilateral treaty arrives from Uzbekistan
On 12 May, the Adviser to the Prime Minister on Commerce announced that the first shipment of goods under the Convention on International Transport of Goods had arrived from Uzbekistan. The multilateral treaty, ratified by Pakistan in 2016, provides for “no payment of customs duties and taxes.” The Adviser said, “This is the beginning of a new era where trucks from both sides will take trade cargo to and from Karachi and Gwadar ports.” (“First shipment from Uzbekistan under multilateral treaty arrives,” Dawn, 13 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
Qureshi provides highlights of Imran’s visit to Saudi Arabia
On 12 May, Foreign Minister Qureshi said Imran Khan’s visit to Saudi Arabia had put on hold a few players’ intentions to damage Islamabad’s relations with Riyadh. He outlined that five agreements signed between the two countries will be operational through an “institutional liaison consisting of three pillars” which include security and politics, economy, and cultural relations. Further he said that under the Crown Prince’s Vision 2030 aimed at creating jobs for Pakistanis, job quotas will be framed for Pakistan. (“'PM’s visit has thwarted plans of those wishing ill on Pak-Saudi relations',” The Express Tribune, 13 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Editorial calls on international community to condemn Israel’s actions 
An editorial in The News International, referring to the ongoing violence in Gaza, calls on the ICC to form a commission probing and highlighting “the most serious nature of Israeli atrocities.” The editorial opines that the Western actors have largely remained equivocal and have not condemned Israel and has asked both sides to restrain themselves. It says, “the language the international community is using is mild and is tantamount to condoning these war crimes by treating both parties equally.” It cites the evictions of Palestinians and says, “When this happens, the victims have to retaliate in one way or the other and confront the occupation.” (“Gaza bleeds again,” The News International, 13 May 2021)
 
Also read...                                                                                                
An opinion in Dawn says let the pandemic be a lesson on the need for South Asia to invest more in healthcare rather than bombs that cannot help us breathe. It argues, that it is time for SAARC to be revitalised and for its member countries to cooperate with one another, adding, let the people’s online voices of peace materialize. 

An editorial in Dawn critical of the PM’s statement on the foreign services officers says communication on any issue of foreign policy must be unambiguous and consistent, arguing that there is simply no room for such blunders in matters as delicate as foreign policy.
 




"Peace must be people led and inclusive, or it will not sustain. The signs are there but it will require bold decisions by both sides to take the initiative."
-An opinion in Dawn on the recent news of backchannel dialogue between thegovernments of Pakistan and India.

 


Pakistan to receive USD 500 million loan from Saudi Arabia 


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 12 May 2021
Imran Khan on the Foreign Office, again
"It is not easy being a Pakistani diplomat, justifying domestic developments within Pakistan in any international forum"

On Tuesday, Imran Khan was quoted to have made another statement on Pakistan’s foreign office, after an outburst last week against the same. This time, it was more of a conciliatory one, telling that the foreign office is doing a great job. 

What made Imran to change his mind about the foreign office, within a week? Perhaps, the harsh response from within Pakistan to his outburst against the foreign office. Perhaps, he realized that his meeting and statements went too far. According to media reports, Inamul Haque, president of the Association of Former Ambassadors, wrote to Imran Khan that his statement “was ill advised and reflected a lack of understanding of the work that our diplomatic missions are performing despite major constraints and impediments.” Anyone following Pakistan’s foreign ministry’s role would agree. Consider, how they had to deal with the responses to terrorist attacks in Mumbai in 2008. How did they put up a brave face to address questions over the killing of Osama bin Laden in the heart of Pakistan in 2011? How did they respond to the trial of Daniel Pearl and the release of his killers? How did they respond to the FATF queries, and the reasons behind them? 

It is not easy being a Pakistani diplomat, justifying domestic developments within Pakistan in any international forum. 

Consider the above, amidst the structural issues – from politicization and intervention from other institutions, especially the Establishment. How much space does Pakistan’s foreign ministry has to pursue a coherent policy externally? And how internal developments impinge on their image elsewhere; consider the following cases: blasphemy, rise of the TLP, repeated release of militant leaders like Hafiz Saeed, AQ Khan, Aasia Bibi, Malala, Mukhtaran Mai etc. It is not easy to defend Pakistan at the international forum during the last two decades. 

But has the foreign ministry not been doing just that?

 

In Focus
Pakistan to receive USD 500 million loan from Saudi Arabia 
PM got nothing except drawing more charity from KSA visit, says Bilawal
Image Source: The News International
 

On 12 May, The Express Tribune reported that Saudi Arabia has committed to providing funds worth USD 500 million to help develop infrastructure, hydropower projects, infrastructure development, and renewable energy initiatives in Pakistan. Further, Saarc Chamber of Commerce and Industry President highlighted that under one of the seven MoUs signed between the two countries, Saudi Arabia would finance energy, infrastructure, water, transportation and communication projects in Pakistan. (“Riyadh commits $500m loan to Pakistan,” The Express Tribune, 12 May 2021)

Meanwhile, FM Qureshi said that the PM’s visit helped defeat the plans by those trying to drive a wedge between Islamabad and Riyadh, adding that under the renewed engagement economic ties would grow and the two countries would have increased bilateral investment and trade. (“New direction set in ties with Saudi Arabia: FM,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)

PM got nothing except drawing more charity from KSA visit, says Bilawal
Bilawal Bhutto Zardari criticized PM Imran Khan saying, “Unfortunately, the incumbent PTI-led federal government does not have the capability or policy for controlling the hoarding and profiteering. The federal government should at least enforce the government rates of commodities in letter and spirit.” He said, “The selected prime minister achieved nothing except 19,000 bags of rice in charity from Saudi Arabia in the form of Fitra and Zakat and the price of rice bags got in charity is comparatively cheaper then the expenses accured on the tour to the kingdom by Prime Minister Imran Khan, along with his friends and ministers.” (“PM got nothing except drawing more charity from KSA visit: Bilawal,” The Express Tribune, 12 May 2021)

Pakistan must continue a balanced policy in the Middle East while according a high priority to Saudi Arabia, says Editorial
An editorial in Dawn commenting on the PM’s visit to Saudi Arabia says that is important that both countries make a concerted effort to improve their relationship, given the changing events in the region. Adding that the visit is timely and it is hoped that the visit can inject fresh vigour into the relationship. Further, it says that Pakistan should take no step, or agree to any demand, that can harm national sovereignty, adding that it must take independent decisions, free from pressures and expectations while keeping its national interest supreme. The editorial concludes by saying given that Pakistan has always followed a balanced policy in the Middle East, it must continue to do so while according a high priority to Saudi Arabia. (“PM’s Saudi visit,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)

 

Fafen proposes referendum on EVMs, proportional representation system
Asks govt not to amend Elections Act in haste 

Image Source: Dawn

On 11 May, the Free and Fair Election Network (Fafen) released a statement in which it proposed a referendum on the introduction of electronic voting machines (EVMs) and list proportional representation system. The network also urged the government to avoid making a hasty move to amend the Elections Act saying that the haste with which the government was pushing for electoral reforms, including the introduction of electronic voting and biometric machines, was worrying.

Quotable
“Notwithstanding the importance of technology in inculcating efficiency, transparency, and uniformity of the electoral process, the introduction of EVMs and biometrics is a significant shift. It should not be introduced without a more extended public and political discourse. An ordinance is undoubtedly not the way to take measures meant to strengthen democracy.”

The Referendum processes
According to the statement, the referendum process would allow all political parties to freely take up their positions on the use of technology with Pakistani citizens. It explained that such a step would also give a much-needed sense of political empowerment to Pakistani citizens, adding that each of them would then be part of shaping the framework of future elections in the country.

Calls for public debate, political discourse on electoral reforms
The network said, “Only citizens should have the right to decide on matters that relate to their constitutional right to vote. For such issues of public importance, the framers of the Constitution had included the provision of a referendum.” It called for a broader public debate and political discourse on the much-needed electoral reforms. Further, the network said that unless structural and systemic issues compromising the integrity and credibility of the election processes and its outcomes were not addressed, democracy would continue to gasp for breath. (“Fafen suggests referendum on EVMs, proportional representation system,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)

 

PM Khan retracts criticism of envoys
There is need for a more serious approach on foreign policy matters, says opinion 

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 11 May, PM Imran Khan going back on his criticism of the foreign service officers he said, “The foreign service has done a wonderful job as far as diplomacy is concerned. They advocated Kashmir cause very well.” Previously, PM Khan lashed out at the foreign service officers for not serving the expatriate community well and harbouring a colonial mindset. (“Imran retracts criticism of foreign service officers,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)

Meanwhile, an opinion in Dawn critical of PM Khan’s ability in running foreign affairs says that his virtual address to Pakistani envoys not only exposed a limited understanding of diplomacy but also a disdain for the foreign service. The opinion warns that such unwarranted public remarks from the country’s leadership is highly demoralising for the foreign service. Further, it adds that foreign policy issues must not be used for public grandstanding, adding, there is a need for a more serious approach on foreign policy matters. (Zahid Hussain, “Blaming envoys for the mess,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PM’s adviser justifies reopening of Hudaibiya case 
On 12 May, Dawn reported that the Adviser to the Prime Minister on Parliamentary Affairs believed that reopening the Hudaibiya Paper Mills case “will not only be valid but also legal and constitutional.” He opined that Shehbaz Sharif can undergo investigations in the case since he was previously not tried in the same. He reasoned that under Article 13, Shehbaz or any Sharif family member was not exempt from being investigated or prosecuted by the NAB in the case. (Nasir Iqbal, “Shehbaz can be tried in Hudaibiya case: PM’s adviser,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)

NAB to challenge bail granted to Shehbaz
On 12 May, Dawn cited a press release by the NAb and reported that the anti-graft body had decided to challenge the bail granted to Shehbaz Sharif by the Lahore High Court. The NAB will move the Supreme Court for the same. Further, the Interior Minister also confirmed that the NAB had asked the interior ministry to keep Shehbaz from going abroad by placing his name in the “no fly list.” (“NAB to challenge LHC bail relief for Shehbaz,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)

IWMB introduces strict rules in Margalla Hills National Park to curb littering
On 12 May, Dawn reported that the capital police will help the Islamabad Wildlife Management Board (IWMB) to implement rules preventing smoking, barbecuing and littering in the Margalla Hills National Park. The latest notification from the IWMB also banned encroachment and felling of trees. The imposition of anti-littering rules came after a video of the British High Commissioner posted a picture of two bags of garbage he had filled by picking up the waste left behind by the people in the national park. (Jamal Shahid, “Environmentally-hazardous practices in Margalla Hills outlawed,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Pakistani exports to US increase by 26 per cent
On 11 May, the Adviser to Prime Minister on Commerce tweeted that Pakistan’s exports to the US stood at USD four billion in the first 10 months of the current FY. This marked a 26 per cent increase in exports to the US from USD 3.2 billion in the corresponding period in FY20. The Express Tribune cited data from the State Bank of Pakistan and reported that esports to US, the UK and 27 EU countries had increased in the first quarter whereas exports to China and the UAE remained stagnant. (Usman Hanif, “Exports to US jump 29% to $4b during 10MFY21,” The Express Tribune, 12 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S WORLD VIEW
Dawn warns of "new intifada"
An editorial in Dawn outlines the triggers behind the recent violence in the Al Aqsa mosque and says the tensions had been brewing for years; the lava just exploded now. The editorial criticises Trump’s move to recognise Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and also takes on the “the rush by many of the Palestinians’ Arab ‘brothers’ to establish ties with Israel” despite knowing that the Jewish state will not adhere to a two-state solution. It opines that the Al Aqsa incident proves that Israel had been “itching for a fight” and urges the western countries and the Arab partners to “convince Tel Aviv to halt the slaughter of Palestinians, or deal with the consequences of a new intifada.” (“A new intifada?,” Dawn, 12 May 2021)

Palestinians rely on themselves as global voices support Israel, says editorial
An editorial in The Express Tribune opines that the “Palestinian resistance has questioned the narrative enforced by the media and the role of global leaders” while several global players have expressed their support to Israel. It highlights that Muslim leaders have stood up for Palestinians for the time being but until a solution is found, “Palestinian resistance shall continue on its own, with the rock as the only weapon and symbol of the indigenous population defending its land.” Until then Palestinians have been left alone to defend themselves. (“Left on their own,” The Express Tribune, 12 May 2021)

ON COVID-19
PMA calls for compensation to families of doctors who died in line of duty
On 12 May, the NCOC recorded 2,869 COVID-19 cases, the lowest figure since 16 March when 2,351 cases were detected. Meanwhile, the Pakistan Medical Association’s press release revealed that 202 doctors had died from COVID-19 since the beginning of the pandemic and called on the government to provide a compensation package. They asked for the disbursement of the Shuhuda package for healthcare workers. (“PMA urges govt to provide Shuhuda package compensation to families of over 200 doctors,” The News International, 12 May 2021) Meanwhile, the NCOC chief announced that registration for vaccination for those aged above 30 years will begin on 16 May since the “vaccine supply continues to improve and vaccination capacity gets enhanced in all federating units.” (“Vaccine drive for citizens aged 30, above to commence from May 16,” The Express Tribune, 12 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                             
 
An editorial in The News International says that Pakistan’s long stay in the FATF’s grey list and the persistent sword of the black list hanging over the country is not a good sign for the economy and is detrimental for its international standing too. It argues that real success can come only when the country is off the grey list and back on the white list.
 



"It is not the scarcity of resources that has caused Balochistan to lag behind sister provinces, but it has been the scarcity of vision that has swallowed it to regression...If Balochistan is lucky, the equation will be reversed or else it is always business as usual!"
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'Reversing the equation'

 


COAS Gen Bajwa meets with President Ghani


Photo: Dawn



PR Editorial, 11 May 2021
Gen Bajwa in Kabul
Was the Taliban announcement of a three-day ceasefire a coincidence or an outcome of Gen Bajwa's Kabul visit?

On Monday, after his return from Saudi Arabia, Pakistan's Chief of Army Staff Gen Qamar Bajwa (along with Director-General of the Inter-Services Intelligence Lieutenant General Faiz Hamid) visited Kabul and had meetings with President Ashraf Ghani, and the Chairman of the High Council for National Reconciliation of Afghanistan Dr Abdullah Abdullah. He was also accompanied by the Chief of the Defence Staff of the United Kingdom, General Sir Nicholas Patrick Carter. So, it was a high profile meeting between the leaders of Pakistan, Afghanistan and the UK.

The meeting took place in the immediate aftermath of the surge in violence in Afghanistan, following the withdrawal of the US troops. The Taliban also made a surprise announcement of a three days ceasefire. So, the timing of the meeting was also important.

The statements from the office of the Afghan President and from Pakistan's ISPR were bland. The ISPR statement mentioned discussing "matters of mutual interest, current developments in Afghan Peace Process, enhanced bilateral security & defence cooperation and need for effective border management between the two brotherly countries." The statement also underlined Gen Bajwa talking "that a peaceful Afghanistan means a peaceful region in general and a peaceful Pakistan in particular" and Pakistan will always support "Afghan led-Afghan Owned" Peace Process based on "mutual consensus of all stakeholders". According to the statement issued from the office of the Afghan President, Ghani told the visitors "that there is no military solution for the ongoing war in Afghanistan and that Taliban's insistence to stick to a military solution is unacceptable for the people of Afghanistan who are seeking just and enduring peace through dialogue and negotiations." 

The presence of General Sir Nicholas Patrick Carter, UK's Chief of the Defence Staff, is interesting. However, there has been a pattern; UK seems to be working behind the doors to bring the Pakistani and Afghan leadership together. According to a news report in Dawn, UK "had in March facilitated a meeting of Pakistani and Afghan military and intelligence chiefs in Bahrain." With the US taking a backseat, it is a welcome development.

So what did they discuss? Was the Taliban announcement of a three days ceasefire a coincidence or an outcome of Bajwa's Kabul visit? If it is the latter, then it should underline Pakistan's (especially the Establishment's) outreach into the Taliban's decision making. In that case, the Establishment in Pakistan should pressurize the Taliban to yield to a long term ceasefire.


In Focus
COAS Gen Bajwa meets with President Ghani
Exports to Afghanistan increase by 15 per cent

On 10 May, COAS Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa met with President Ashraf Ghani in Kabul. During the meeting, he assured the Afghan leadership of Pakistan’s support for “inclusive power-sharing arrangement” and “elections as a right of Afghans to self-determination,” reiterating that “a peaceful Afghanistan means a peaceful region in general and a peaceful Pakistan in particular.” Further, he stated that “We will always support 'Afghan led-Afghan owned' Peace Process based on mutual consensus of all stakeholders.”

Additionally, Gen Bajwa met with the Chairman of the High Council for National Reconciliation of Afghanistan Dr Abdullah Abdullah and discussed matters related to the negotiations.

The COAS was accompanied by the Director-General of Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) and British Chief of Defence Staff Gen Nicholas Patrick Carter. (“COAS backs ‘inclusive Afghan power sharing’,” The Express Tribune, 11 May 2021) (“In Kabul visit, Gen Bajwa reiterates support for Afghan peace process as violence surges,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

Exports to Afghanistan increase by 15 per cent, says MOC
On 10 May, the Ministry of Commerce Adviser stated that Pakistan’s exports to Afghanistan during July-April 2021 have grown by 15 per cent to USD 869 million from USD 754 million a year ago. In a series of tweets, the Adviser said, “MOC [Ministry of Commerce] is glad to share that Pakistan’s exports to Afghanistan during Jul-Apr 2021 have grown by 15% to USD 869 million as compared to USD 754 million during Jul-Apr 2020. The exports of Fruits, Vegetables, Meat, Dairy products, Chemicals, Electrical equipment, Machinery, Paper & Paperboard have contributed to this increase. We continue to encourage legal, secure, transparent, consistent & reliable trade with Afghanistan. Exporters are urged to aggressively market their exports to Afghanistan. We also commend the efforts of MOC’s Trade & Investment Counsellor & urge him to provide even greater facilitation to our exporters.” (“Pakistan’s exports to Afghanistan up by 15pc in 10MFY21: Razak,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

 

PM Khan orders fresh investigation into the Hudaibya Paper Mills
PML-N says move proves all cases are based on political vengeance

Image Source: Dawn

On 10 May, PM Khan ordered for a fresh probe into the Hudaibya Paper Mills (HPM) case against Nawaz Sharif, Shehbaz Sharif and other members of the family. According to the Information Minister, the government decided to hold fresh investigations into the HPM case, because it was the starting point of the Sharif family’s corruption.

Further, the minister stated that the government has decided to task the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) with the fresh investigation and once the FIA takes up the case, it would have to start the investigation within 14 days-time, adding that the agency “is likely to take up the case within the next couple of days.”

Meanwhile, the government also decided to challenge the recent Lahore High Court (LHC) decision to grant bail Shehbaz Sharif and permission to go abroad for medical treatment.

PML-N strongly opposes the decision 
PML-N strongly opposed the PM’s decision, saying that the statement proved that all cases against the Sharifs were part of political vengeance. Further, they recalled that the Supreme Court had already suppressed an appeal and upheld the LHC’s decision in 2014 that had disposed of the case in favour of the Sharif family.

Further, PML-N Information Secretary said by ordering a fresh investigation into Hudaibya Paper Mills, PM Khan had proved that all the cases against Mr Shehbaz till date were “fictitious, false and political victimization.” (“Imran orders fresh probe into Hudaibya case against Sharifs,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

Meanwhile…
On 10 May, Shehbaz Sharif is to file a contempt of court petition against the PTI government and the FIA in the LHC on 17 May for stopping him from leaving the country for London despite the court orders. PML-N deputy secretary-general stated, “Shehbaz Sharif after consulting his legal team has decided to file a contempt of court petition in LHC on coming Monday (May 17) against the Imran Khan government and the FIA for stopping him from leaving the country to have his medical treatment in London. There was a clear order from the LHC in this regard and by stopping him at the Lahore airport to catch up his flight on ‘phony reasons’ amounts to contempt of court.” (“Shehbaz to file contempt petition against govt, FIA on 17th,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

 

Govt optimistic about introducing the single national curriculum
NCC chief says it will be introduced at the primary level this year

Image Source: The News International

On 11 May, Dawn reported that the federal government is optimistic about introducing the Single National Curriculum (SNC)across the country from the upcoming academic session starting in August. While interviewing the head of National Curriculum Council (NCC), Rafique Tahir said, “We have completed our arrangements and now books are being printed. From August this year single national curriculum will be introduced across the country at primary level,” adding, “Earlier, Sindh had some reservation, but now it too has agreed to adopt core subjects but it will do make some addition that is its right and good thing.” (“Govt optimistic about introducing single curriculum from August,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)1)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PBC should take a stand in favour of Islamabad-based lawyers, says source
On 11 May, Dawn referred to an informal source who said that no formal decision was arrived at by the Pakistan Bar Council (PBC) on the demolition of lawyers’ chambers and the suspension of licenses. The PBC had met on 7 May to discuss the above. One of those present in the meeting accused the PBC of having abandoned their brethren. He called on the PBC to take a stand in favour of the Islamabad lawyers whose licenses had been suspended following the violence at the Islamabad High Court. He said, “The lawyers from Islamabad are in extreme pain and agony, but we have become silent spectators.” (Nasir Iqbal, “PBC’s silence on chambers demolition hurts lawyers,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

Editorial urges government to adopt inclusive method on electoral reforms
An editorial in Dawn, citing recent presidential ordinance to the ECP to procure EVMs, says the reform process started on a bad note. The editorial, while acknowledging the need for electoral reforms, criticises the government’s approach. It outlines that all stakeholders need to be on board for introducing electoral reforms, it opines that by choosing the controversial approach, “the government is ensuring that the electoral process becomes even more divisive than it already is.” Therefore, it calls on the government to move away from “adversarial approach” and debate each proposed item in the parliament. Lastly, it calls on the opposition to “let go of its obduracy and sit down with the government to build a consensus on these reforms.” (“Divisive move,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

ECONOMY 
Cotton import bill increases by 46 per cent
On 11 May, Dawn reported that Pakistan had spent USD 1.838 billion on cotton imports during the first nine months of the current FY. This is a 46 per cent increase from USD 1.258 billion in the corresponding period in FY20. Cotton exports during the nine months stood at USD 10.411 billion indicating an increase of USD 212 million, from USD 10.269 in the corresponding period in FY20. Meanwhile, production of cotton dropped 5.6 bales; the government had set a target of 10.5 bales for the season but “cotton brokers suggest that production would be around 8m bales.” (Shahid Iqbal, “Cotton import bill hits $1.84bn in 9MFY21,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

EXTERNAL 
Qureshi condemns Israeli attack on worshipers in Al Aqsa mosque
On 11 May, Foreign Minister Qureshi condemned the Israeli forces’ attack on Palestinians at the Al Aqsa mosque in which at least 20, including nine children, died. He opined that the attack on worshipers was against any norm; he reiterated that Pakistan’s position was in line with that of the Palestinians. He said if the international community is concerned about rockets fired by Hamas, “then they would also be worried about the rubber bullets, stun grenades and tear gas fired upon the worshipers.” (“'Pakistan highly condemns attack on Palestinians by Israeli forces',” The Express Tribune, 11 May 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
Internal actors equally responsible for the destruction in Afghanistan, says Dawn
An editorial in Dawn, citing the latest attack on a school in Kabul, says such attacks indicate red flags amid the withdrawal of troops. The editorial wonders whether Afghans will be subject to more such atrocities once foreign troops exit the country. It asks whether Afghanistan will be pushed into complete chaos again, under the Taliban. It opines that though Soviet forces and American troops “bear major responsibility for destabilising Afghanistan,” internal players including warlords, the Kabul elite, Taliban and so on have an equal share in the destruction. Therefore, it says the Afghan elites must take responsibility and “the onus is on the Taliban to fully participate in the peace process and work with the Kabul government to ensure a power-sharing formula.” (“Kabul massacre,” Dawn, 11 May 2021)

ON INDIA
Nothing about Jammu and Kashmir is India’s internal matter: Qureshi
On 10 May, Qureshi retracted his words that Kashmir was India’s internal matter and said “ Jammu & Kashmir is an internationally recognised dispute” and the solution to the same lies in UN resolutions which includes an impartial plebiscite. He is quoted to have said, “Nothing about J&K can be India’s internal matter.” The retraction comes after the opposition parties lashed out at Qureshi’s statement on a TV interview where he reportedly remarked that Article 370 is India’s internal matter and “meant nothing for Pakistan.” (Iftikhar A Khan, “FM retracts his ‘India’s internal matter’ remarks,” Dawn, 11 May 2021) (“Jammu and Kashmir not India’s internal matter: FM,” The News International, 11 May 2021)

ON COVID-19
Government working towards increasing vaccination supply, says NCOC head
On 11 May, the Planning Minister, who is also the head of the National Command and Operation Centre, said efforts were being made to increase vaccine supply and improve the vaccination capacity. He said the government was strategising the vaccination process beginning the process from the elderly because of the “finite availability of vaccines globally.” He reasoned that despite only seven per cent of the population being above 60 years, around 53 per cent deaths were recorded in the age group therefore making it necessary to vaccinate them first. (“'Govt making concerted efforts to increase vaccine supply, expand vaccination capacity',” The Express Tribune, 11 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                    
An opinion in The Express Tribune on FM’s fillip in the Middle East argues that for the first time in over seven decades of Pakistan’s existence, the country’s foreign policy was wound around the spindle of “responsible neutrality.”

An opinion in Dawn says that the government has set a bad precedent in its handling of TLP, arguing that if a government negotiates with a party immediately after banning them for being terrorists, it is doubtful they can make a greater mockery of governance.
 



"In a democratic setup, the opposition plays a significant role and it should be allowed to do so. What Pakistan needs is a situation where the political parties, which together form the democracy of Pakistan, can at least engage in dialogue and negotiations with each other on crucial matters."
-An editorial in The News International on 'Political moves'

 


Pakistan’s relation with Saudi Arabia has strengthened, says PM Khan


Photo: The News International



PR Editorial, 10 May 2021

Pakistan’s exports to Afghanistan decline
Dawn, in its latest report titled Dwindling Pak-Afghan trade referred to the declining Pakistan’s Afghan exports referring to an earlier report by the State Bank of Pakistan. According to the SBP data accessed by Dawn, “Pakistan’s exports to Afghanistan fell 5.5 per cent from $790 million to $746.3m during the first nine months of the current fiscal year.”

Another report, published last month referred to Pakistan’s declining exports not only to Afghanistan, but also to the other regional countries including China, Iran, Maldives and Sri Lanka. There are larger structural issues, that have been discussed by the economists on the bigger problem in which declining export potential is only a part. Pakistan had to start looking at the structural issues, regional ones, and then its export potential to Afghanistan.

However, with Afghanistan, there are certain specific issues, that hinder the potential. Afghanistan, during the recent years, has started looking at Central Asia and Iran as trade diversion. Cement and iron, which used to top Pakistan’s export basket to Afghanistan is now being imported by the latter from its other neighbours. 

Politics and trade barriers are two other issues, that have significantly reduced Pakistan’s exports to Afghanistan. Despite the Afghanistan and Pakistan Trade and Transit Agreement, there are systemic issues between the two countries. Along with trade infrastructure, these are long term issues. Pandemic related decline is only a small part of the story in Pakistan’s exports to Afghanistan.

In Focus
Pakistan’s relation with Saudi Arabia has strengthened, says PM Khan
Bilawal asks PM to ‘reveal reasons’ for repaying the loan to Saudi Arabia

On 9 May, PM Khan said that Pakistan’s relations with Saudi Arabia had strengthened further and that Pakistanis have an immense emotional attachment with the kingdom, as they have always stood by them. He said that Pakistan would have defaulted had Saudi Arabia and the UAE not helped shore up its foreign reserves, saying, “If we had defaulted, there would have been severe consequences.” Further, he said that Saudi Arabia not only helped with its foreign reserves but also gave it oil on deferred payments.

PM Khan’s who was on a three-day visit to the Kingdom met with Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman as both affirmed their commitment to fortify the ‘upward trajectory’ in Pakistan - Saudi Arabia bilateral relations. This visit was preceded Gen Bajwa’s who was on a four-day visit to the Kingdom. (“Pak-KSA ties on solid footing, says PM,” The News International, 10 May 2021)

Bilawal criticises PM Khan for ‘travelling all over the world asking for charity’
On 10 May, Bilawal Bhutto asked PM Khan to reveal the reasons behind repaying USD three billion to Saudi Arabia. He said, “Imran Khan has been traveling around the world with a begging bowl. Undoubtedly, you're experienced in asking for charity, but countries are not run on charity.” Further, he said, “Imran Khan borrowed from China to repay a loan of $3 billion to Saudi Arabia. Premier should reveal to the nation why he repaid the money to the kingdom. (“Bilawal asks PM Imran to 'reveal reasons' for repaying $3b to Saudi Arabia,” The Express Tribune, 10 May 2021)

Iran-Saudi rapprochement will simplify the equation for Pakistan, says opinion
An opinion in The Express Tribune highlights two reasons for the reset in Pak-KAS ties. First, the election of Joe Biden as US president, arguing unlike Trump, President Biden has made it clear he would not give blanket support to Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen, the first cause of a major hiccup in Pakistan’s relationship with Saudi Arabia. Second, the Iran-Saudi rapprochement will simplify the equation for Pakistan. Further, the opinion says that one change that Pakistan is seeking is not seeking financial support from Saudi Arabia rather, the focus would be on project financing and investment thus, Pakistan would not be under any obligation to follow certain policies. (“Reset in Pak-Saudi ties,” The Express Tribune, 10 May 2021)

 

 

Govt to introduce new rules to meet FATF conditions 
Specialised agencies to probe money laundering cases

Image Source: Dawn

On 10 May, Dawn reported that the government is set to introduce new rules on forfeiture, management and auction of properties and assets relating to Anti-Money Laundering (AML) cases and transfer of investigations and prosecution of AML cases from police, provincial anti-corruption establishments (ACEs) and other similar agencies to specialised agencies to achieve the remaining conditions of the FATF.

Specialised agencies to probe money laundering cases
The new rules are a part of two sets of rules including the AML (Forfeited Properties Management) Rules 2021 and the AML (Referral) Rules 2021 under the National Policy Statement on Follow the Money. These rules and related notifications for certain changes in the existing schedule of the Anti-Money Laundering Act 2010 (AMLA) would come into force immediately to be followed by the appointment of administrators and special public prosecutors for implementation.

These measures were approved by the federal cabinet. Based on these measures, the FATF would decide if Pakistan has complied with three outstanding requirements, out of 27, that blocked its exit from the so-called grey list in February 2021.

Previously…
The FATF found Pakistan non-compliant on three action points (out of a total of 27) include (i) demonstrating that terrorist financing (TF) investigations and prosecutions target persons and entities acting on behalf or at the directive of the designated persons or entities; (ii) demonstrating that TF prosecutions result in effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions; and (iii) demonstrating effective implementation of targeted financial sanctions against all designated terrorists, particularly those acting for them or on their behalf. (“New rules in the works to meet FATF conditions,” Dawn, 10 May 2021)

 

Pakistan Navy participates in the focused Operation Chinook Archer
Aim of the exercise was primarily to demonstrate interoperability between navies

Image Source: Dawn

On 9 May, the Pakistan Navy in a press release stated that Pakistan Navy Ship (PNS) Saif participated in the focused operation Chinook Archer along with ships and aircraft of the United States and Canada in the Arabian Sea. PNS Saif participated in the passage exercise with the US naval ship USS Laboon and Canadian ship HMCS Calgary. The exercise aimed to demonstrate interoperability between the participating navies and interdict illegal smuggling and trade emanating along the hash highway. (“Pakistan Navy participates in exercises with US, Canada,” Dawn, 10 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Sewage water samples show no traces of the polio virus
On 10 May, The Express Tribune reported that detection of the polio virus from sewage water had started reducing after samples from over 60 locations across Pakistan showed negative results. A sewage water sample forms “the basic parameter to determine if polio vaccination drive is being carried out successfully.” The latest samples collected from 8 April to 23 April,  from Karachi, Islamabad, Rawalpindi, Lahore, Peshawar, Nowshera, Quetta and so on showed no traces of the virus. (Razya Khan, “Polio starts disappearing from sewage across the country,” The Express Tribune, 10 May 2021)

5000 seminaries register with DGRE 
On 9 May, the head of the Directorate General of Religious Education (DGRE) said 5,000 of the estimated 35,000 seminaries in Pakistan had been registered with the Education Ministry since the DGRE was established in September 2019. He expected that 5,000 more would register by the end of 2021. The development comes after the Ittehad Tanzeemat-i-Madaris representatives held meetings and subsequently gave its green signal to the registration; however, chiefs of several sects and seminaries, including Fazlur Rehman, have not attended meetings on the matter. The DGRE head also said the seminaries will have to adopt the single national curriculum which is scheduled to be introduced in August. (Kashif Abbasi, “5,000 seminaries registered across country,” Dawn, 10 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Three soldiers killed, one injured in attack on Bolan post
On 9 May, officials said unidentified gunmen killed three Frontier Corps personnel and injured one in an attack in Bolan district’s Margat area. The attackers had opened fire at the Khalid check-post. According to sources, the attackers escaped despite the FC personnel immediately returning the fire. (Saleem Shahid, “Three FC soldiers martyred in attack on Bolan post,” Dawn, 10 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Exports to Australia increase by 29 per cent
On 9 May, the Adviser to the Prime Minister on Commerce, Textile, Industry and Production said Pakistan’s exports to Australia had increased by 29 per cent during July 2020-April 2021 of the current fiscal year. His tweet conveyed that the exports stood at USD229 million during the period compared to USD 177 million in the corresponding period last fiscal year. With this, he urged “exporters to aggressively export to this relatively untapped market.” (“Exports to Australia up by 29pc: Razak,” Dawn, 10 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
Women’s issues need solutions other than just law-making, says editorial
An editorial in The News International cites various instances of emotional, physical and sexual abuse against women. The editorial says that so many culprits walk free because “the authorities themselves may too be sympathetic to the idea of ‘honour’ killings and punishment of women for behaving outside of the set moral framework.” It opines that though increased reporting may have led to an increase in figures, Pakistan has not turned more civilised, rather has gone worse. It says that realities on ground vary starkly despite legislative efforts; “even getting laws across the table on this issue has been a major hurdle for various provincial governments.” Therefore it calls for a concerted effort to address the issue and not just confine the solutions to lawmaking. (“Vulnerable women,” The News International, 10 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
PM condemns attack on Al Aqsa mosque
On 9 May, Imran Khan condemned the attack on Palestine’s Al Aqsa mosque and called on the OIC and the international community to initiate immediate measures to protect “Palestinians and their legitimate rights.” The statement came during his visit to Saudi Arabia; he also met the OIC Secretary General and urged the organisation to address the situation. (Syed Irfan Raza, “PM slams Israeli attack, urges OIC to combat Islamophobia,” Dawn, 10 May 2021) 

Editorial disapproves of US response to Al Aqsa clashes
An editorial in Dawn says the reason behind the attack is the “Jewish state’s greed for land.” The editorial however notices the differences between the calls for de-escalation from the EU and the US. It cites the EU statement which said that the “potential evictions” were worrisome as they are “illegal under international humanitarian law.” On the other hand, the US asked to avoid “steps that exacerbate tensions…” The editorial opines that “By avoiding a reference to the illegality of the action by Israel, the US was creating a false equivalence between the Palestinians and Israeli police...US policy remains wedded to blind support for the Jewish state.” It says unless some of Trump’s policies are reversed, like shifting the Israeli capital to Jerusalem, tensions are likely to continue. (“Al Aqsa clashes,” Dawn, 10 May 2021)

ON AFGHANISTAN
Editorial warns of Taliban resurgence and repercussions on Pakistan
An editorial in Dawn, referring to a few recent attacks claimed by the TTP and simultaneously linked to the Afghan soil by the army, says resurgence of the Taliban and its like is a grave concern amid the US troop withdrawal. The editorial opines that the TTP is using the “safe havens in Afghanistan controlled by the Taliban'' and terms it the latter’s payback to the former for the “hospitality” during the American invasion of Afghanistan. Therefore, it calls on Pakistan to make it clear to the Afghan Taliban that “allowing the TTP or other anti-Pakistan groups to use space under their control will not be tolerated.” It says, though the onus lies on the Taliban, the Afghan government must also “ensure the security of the country, and eliminate ungoverned spaces which militants can use to spread havoc in the region.” (“Safe havens,” Dawn, 10 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                           
Maleeha Lodhi in an opinion in Dawn argues public confidence in government institutions has declined. If this is to be reversed governance has to substantially improve and make an appreciable difference in the lives of citizens, arguing, transformational change in the apparatus of governance is an imperative, not a choice.

An opinion in Dawn argues that even if Shehbaz Sharif is allowed to leave he will have a mountain to climb in London to bring Nawaz Sharif over to his side getting the latter to abandon his route of confrontation.
 

"Parliament must make a single-minded effort to ensure that both pieces of legislation are enacted without unnecessary delay. Their passage will send the signal that this country is prepared to address two issues that have long been a blot on its global image and are completely at odds with a democratic system...At the end of the day though, implementation will make the difference between a law merely on the books, and one that actually protects the citizens."
-An editorial in Dawn on the cabinet's approval of the Journalists and Media Protection Bill and the Forced or Involuntary Disappearance (Criminal Law Amendment) Bill

 


FIA stops Shehbaz from flying abroad 


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
FIA stops Shehbaz from flying abroad 
Prevented from leaving despite LHC’s orders to go for medical treatment

On 8 May, PML-N spokesperson Marriyum Aurangzeb stated, “When Shehbaz Sharif came to the airport today, FIA officials stopped him and said he could not travel because there was another list, a 'person-not-in-list'.” She adding that according to the FIA, the system had not been updated yet after the court order. 

Previously, on 7 May, the Lahore High Court (LHC) permitted Shehbaz “one-time" to travel abroad for medical treatment.

PML-N terms the move as a “malafide”
Aurangzeb termed the move as a “malafide” intention, adding that the present government's priorities were focused on “Shehbaz Sharif” and political opponents instead of providing electricity, water, sugar and wheat to citizens. Further, she termed the FIA's notice as “lies” and a violation of the LHC's order, adding, “This is tantamount to contempt of court and we are holding legal discussions on this.”

FIA says Shehbaz name has not been removed from the lost 
According to FIA immigration officials, Shehbaz Sharif's name has not yet been removed from the blacklist by the Interior Ministry. The official stated, “No clearance was issued in the system, he [Shehbaz Sharif] will be allowed to board the plane once the name is cleared.” Meanwhile, Information Minister Chaudhry said that the FIA director general holds the authority to add or remove a person's name from the blacklist, however, “Shehbaz's lawyers have not submitted any request to the DG FIA to remove [Shehbaz's name] from the blacklist as per the court's decision. The record cannot be changed on the basis of verbal talks.” (“FIA stops Shehbaz from flying abroad despite LHC order: PML-N,” Dawn, 8 May 2021) (“Shehbaz Sharif offloaded from plane as he prepared to leave for Doha,” The News International, 8 May 2021) (“Shehbaz Sharif barred from flying to UK by FIA,” The Express Tribune, 8 May 2021)

 

PM Khan meets with Crown Prince Salman 
Both commit to ‘fortify upward trajectory’ in bilateral relations

Image Source: The Daily Times

On 8 May, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated that PM Imran Khan and Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman affirmed their commitment to fortify the ‘upward trajectory’ in Pakistan - Saudi Arabia bilateral relations. Further, the ministry said, “The two leaders reaffirmed the strong and historic bonds between the two countries rooted firmly in shared beliefs, common values, mutual trust and longstanding tradition of mutual support.” (“Imran arrives in Jeddah, holds talks with Saudi prince,” Dawn, 8 May 2021)

Agreements signed 
After the PM Khan’s arrival, the two sides decided to form a ‘Supreme Coordination Council’ which is designed to impart strategic direction to the development of Pakistan-Saudi relations. PM Khan expressed the hope that the SPSCC will play a catalytic role in fostering enhanced bilateral cooperation in all fields. Further, the two signed several bilateral agreements/Memorandums of Understanding (MoUs), including Agreement on Cooperation in the Field of Combating Crimes; Agreement on Transfer of Convicted Individuals (Prisoners); MoU on Combating Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs; Psychotropic Substances and Precursor Chemicals; and Framework MoU for the financing of projects (totalling up to USD 500 million) in energy, hydropower generation, infrastructure, transport and communication and water resource development. (“PM Imran, Crown Prince Salman commit to 'fortify upward trajectory' in bilateral relations,” The Express Tribune, 8 May 2021)

Discussions held 
During their meeting, special emphasis was laid on increasing Saudi investments in Pakistan, collaboration in the field of energy, and increased job opportunities for Pakistanis in Saudi Arabia. Acknowledging the role of more than two million Pakistani diasporas in the kingdom, the two discussed ways to maximize mutual benefit from cooperation in the human resource sector. Further, PM Khan appreciated the Crown Prince's recently launched “Green Saudi Arabia and Green Middle East” initiatives. 

FM terms the visit as ‘highly productive’
On 8 May, FM Shah Mahmood Qureshi termed PM Imran Khan's visit to Saudi Arabia as highly productive. He said, “Talks between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia were marked by warmth and cordiality.” Further, FM Qureshi along with the Interior Minister and other senior officials held delegation-level meetings. (“PM Imran's visit to KSA highly productive: FM Qureshi,” The Express Tribune, 8 May 2021)

Previously…
PM Khan’s visit is preceded by talks between the Pakistani and Saudi military leadership during which they discussed bilateral cooperation for regional peace and security. Gen Bajwa’s meetings who is on a four-day visit to the Kingdom met with the Saudi Crown Prince and Deputy Defence Minister. 

 

All session courts designated as special courts to handle rape charges
Development to help provide speedy and expeditious justice for victims of rape 

Image Source: Dawn

On 7 May, President Dr Arif Alvi designated all sessions courts in the country as special courts to proceed against those facing rape charges. According to a notification issued by the Ministry of Law and Justice, “in pursuance of the powers conferred by sub-section 3 of section 3 of the Anti-Rape (Investigation & Trial) Ordinance, 2020, the President of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, in consultation with the Hon’ble Chief Justice of Pakistan has been pleased to designate all courts of sessions judges throughout Pakistan as Special Courts under the Ordinance.” Further, the statement added that this development is a stepping stone towards the provision of speedy and expeditious justice for victims of rape and sexual offences in a more humane and gender sensitised manner. ("Sessions courts designated to handle rape cases," Dawn, 8 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
CTD Punjab lodges FIR against four TLP leaders

On 8 May, Dawn reported that FIRs had been filed against TLP’s senior leaders by the counter Terrorism Department in Punjab. The FIR has been filed on grounds that four accused - Ghulam Abbas Faizai, Ghulam Ghaus Baghdadi, Khurram Riaz, Dr Shafiq Amini and Pir Zaheerul Islam - fuelled a new agitation against the French ambassador. Accusations include fanning hate and instigating the public against the government. FIR have been registered “under section 11-W under the Anti-Terrorism Act (ATA) 1997.” (Asif Chaudhary, FIRs against TLP for instigating fresh unrest in Lahore,” Dawn, 8 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Mismanagement by federal government led to acute water shortage in Sindh: Bilawal
On 8 May, The News International reported that Bilawal had accused the federal government for the acute water shortage in Sindh. He maintained that the acute water shortage was the result of filling the Mangla Dam beyond the approved limits. This, he claimed, “ created up to 27 per cent water shortage in the Sukkur Barrage and 44 per cent shortage in the Kotri Barrage.”  He alleged that the mismanagement by the federal government had led to this situation; despite receiving abundant rainfall, the mismanagement “had left the water supply from the Guddu Barrage completely depleted.” (“Bilawal blames Centre for Sindh water crisis,” The News International, 8 May 2021)

ECONOMY
LSM records 22.39 per cent growth in March
On 7 May, data from the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics showed that large-scale manufacturing (LSM) had increased by 22.39 per cent in March. The PBS data highlights that 12 of the 15 sub\sectors in LSM recorded a growth in the month. The industries which recorded phenomenal growth include cement, automobile, pharmaceuticals and the like. The LSM sector’s growth in March comes after it had slowed in January. (Mubarak Zeb Khan, “Large-scale manufacturing surges by 22.4pc in March,” Dawn, 8 May 2021)

IMF considers helping Pakistan through COVID-19 crisis
On 8 May Dawn reported on the IMF’s news briefing on 6 May. The Director for Communications said the IMF will consider the COVID-19 crisis in Pakistan and help the country address the problem and also “ensure the objective of debt sustainability with strong and sustainable growth.” The development comes after Shaukat Tarin said it would be difficult to implement the “tough” IMF conditions due to the pandemic and the prevailing economic conditions. (Anwar Iqbal, “IMF ready to help Pakistan navigate a difficult situation,” Dawn, 8 May 2021)

Tarin indicates Rs 900 billion for development projects
On 7 May, Shaukat Tarin outlined that the government will allocate Rs 900 billion for development expenditure in the upcoming fiscal year starting July. Further, he estimated the growth rate at five per cent and projected a 40 per cent increase in large-scale infrastructure projects. He opined this would boost employment. He said, “We need 2 million jobs every year...If we do not go into growth mode, we will have a major crisis on the streets.” (“Rs900 bn to be earmarked for development in 2022: Shaukat Tarin,” The News International, 8 May 2021)

ON INDIA
FO calls for investigation on uranium seizure 
On 8 May, the Foreign Office raised concerns over “uranium seizure from unauthorised persons in India.” The FO spokesperson called for a thorough investigation into this “as to how such sizeable quantity of uranium could become available outside of state control and identify the gaps which made this possible.” He emphasised that all countries should prioritise safeguarding the nuclear arsenal. (“Pakistan expresses concern over uranium seizure in India,” The Express Tribune, 8 May 2021)

ON CPEC
China wary of extending USD six billion loan for ML-I project
On 8 May, The Express Tribune quoted senior Pakistani officials who said that China is reluctant to approve a USD six billion loan for the Mainline-I (ML-I) railway track of the CPEC project. According to the officials, China was apprehensive of Pakistan’s debts and the same were conveyed in a meeting in March. The Express Tribune quoted a correspondence which read, “The Chinese side expressed concerns about Pakistan’s debts, including IMF’s requirements for the Pakistani government to avail loans and about the impact of restrictions under the G-20 Debt Servicing Suspension Initiative (DSSI) on the financing of the ML-I project.” (Shahbaz Rana, “China reluctant to approve $6b ML-I loan,” The Express Tribune, 8 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                 

An editorial in Dawn says debate on electoral reforms is going nowhere. Rather it says both the government and opposition need to take off their boxing gloves and really think of the chaos the country will be plunged into if yet another general election takes place in the midst of serious challenges, adding, a sincere debate on a truly free election is in everyone’s interest.

Pervez Hoodbhoy in an opinion in Dawn argues that for Pakistan to keep its GSP-Plus status it will have to show the EU that it treats its blasphemy accused fairly.

An editorial in Dawn argues that there is no possibility of decreasing the overall budget deficit and controlling growth in public debt without rapidly raising tax collection, it argues for that the PTI government will have to undertake tax reforms, which may hurt powerful lobbies.

 



"This recent episode appears to be a continuation of the tendency in the present government to blame everyone else – for mere optics and headlines. It is about time the government set its own house in order rather than continuing with the blame game it has been playing for years now."
-An editorial in The News International on 'Lecturing envoys'

 


Speaker sets up committee for poll reforms


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Speaker sets up committee for poll reforms 
PPP, PML-N challenge the move, say they no more trust govt 

On 6 May, National Assembly Speaker Asad Qaiser constituted a five-member “parliamentary committee” comprising members of the federal cabinet to engage the opposition on the issue. This came after several weeks of waiting for the opposition parties to nominate members for a special parliamentary committee on electoral reforms. 

PPP and PML-N raise objection 
After the announcement both PPP and PML-N rejected the speaker’s decision, saying that he had no right and powers to form any committee without the approval of the house and that they did not have trust in the speaker and the PTI government. PML-N senior vice president said, “Perhaps, the speaker does not know the rules. He has no authority to do so. This is the job of parliament. Any committee, other than the standing committees, is constituted with the approval of the house.” Similarly, PPP secretary-general said, “The selected and hybrid regime of Imran Khan itself is a product of political engineering and manipulation and, therefore, is incapable of addressing these issues,” adding, “The offer of talks is only for optics, not substantive. PPP rejects it.” (“Speaker sets up body to engage opposition on poll reforms,” Dawn, 7 May 2021) 

Pakistan badly needs voting reforms, says editorial 
An editorial in The News International says that Pakistan needs a voting system that can ensure transparency for balloting. It adds that there also need to be a change in the perception among voters and political parties that the ballot is manipulated or changed in any fashion.  With the government introducing some confidence-building measures with the opposition which is sceptical of the government’s intentions, the editorial says that the key factor must be unanimity or at least collective work by the parties and satisfaction among voters that their ballots are being fairly and transparently counted without any wrongdoing. (“Voting matters,” The News International, 7 May 2021)

 

COAS Bajwa meets Saudi Crown Prince Salman 
PM Khan leave for a three-day visit to Saudi Arabia 

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 7 May, COAS General Qamar Javed Bajwa met with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman bin Abdulaziz and KSA’s Deputy Defence Minister Prince in Jeddah. During the meeting, he said that Pakistan is committed to safeguarding the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Saudi Arabia and defence of the two holy mosques. The Crown Prince said, “The relations between KSA and Pakistan are based on bonds of brotherhood and mutual trust and both nations will continue to play their part for peace, stability and betterment of Muslim Ummah.” 

Further, they also discussed matters of mutual interest, the regional security situation including developments in the Afghan peace process, bilateral defence, security, collaborating for regional peace and security. (“Army chief Bajwa meets Saudi Crown Prince Salman,” The Express Tribune, 7 May 2021) 

PM leaves for a three-day visit to Saudi Arabia 
On 6 May, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs announced that PM Imran Khan would be on a three-day official visit to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia from 7 May (today). The PM will be accompanied by a high-level delegation, including Foreign Minister and other members of the federal cabinet. According to the statement, “During the visit, the prime minister’s consultations with the Saudi leadership will cover all areas of bilateral cooperation including economic, trade, investment, energy, job opportunities for Pakistani workforce, and welfare of Pakistani Diaspora in the Kingdom.” PM Khan is visiting the kingdom on the invitation of the Crown Prince. (“PM Imran to embark on three-day visit to Saudi Arabia today,” The Express Tribune, 7 May 2021) 

 

China gets Tarbela extension project 
Power Construction Corp of China awarded USD 355 million  

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 7 May, The Express Tribune reported that the Water and Power Development Authority (Wapda) has awarded a contract worth USD 354.6 million for civil works on the 1,530-megawatt Tarbela 5th Extension Hydropower Project to Power Construction Corporation of China Limited (PCCCL). The contract was awarded through an international competitive bidding. 

The project is scheduled to start generation by mid-2024 and will set to provide 1.347 billion units to the national grid every year. Further, after completion, the Tarbela dam’s power generation potential would stand fully harnessed its installed capacity of 4,888MW at present to 6,418MW. (“Contract awarded for Tarbela extension project,” The Express Tribune, 7 May 2021) (“Chinese firm awarded $355m Tarbela project,” Dawn, 7 May 2021) 

 

In Brief
INTERNAL
Cabinet approves two bills for journalists, and forced disappearances
On 6 May, the federal cabinet approved two bills aimed at protecting journalists and other people in the media and criminalising forced disappearances. The two bills are Protection of Journalists and Media Professionals Bill and Forced or Involuntary Disappearance (Criminal Law Amendment) Bill. The Minister for Human Rights said the above bills will now be tabled at the National Assembly, and no other details were shared. (“Cabinet okays bills about journalists’ protection, forced disappearances,” Dawn, 7 May 2021)

Vote recount in NA-249 to take at least two more days
On 7 May, The Express Tribune cited sources who said that vote recounting of the Karachi NA-249 by-polls will likely take two more days. They said votes from 60 polling stations were recounted on 6 May despite the boycott by PML-N, MQM, PTI and PSP. They also claimed that the vote tally of the candidates had changed in the process. Further, the returning officer said, “Each and every vote will be re-checked in the presence of all candidates of different political parties and their chief polling agents. We will try to finish the task in a day, but I believe it will take more time.” (“'Recount of votes of all 276 polling stations in NA-249 may take two more days',” The Express Tribune, 7 May 2021)

Traders apprehensive about COVID-19 SOPs during Eid
On 6 May, General Secretary of the All Pakistan Anjuman Tajiran (APAT) expressed concerns over the COVID-19 SOPs for businesses during Eid. He said businesses should be allowed to operate ahead of Eid “so as to avert rush of people and spread of virus.” He said, “At present we are worried about small traders/retail markets, where the Eid shopping is getting momentum, and not the wholesale markets...I personally fear that if the police forcibly get the small markets closed, where the small traders are yet to dispose of their goods to end consumers, clashes may take place. Traders also opine that the weeklong holidays, with the closure of public transport from 8 May, “has not only panicked the business community, especially the traders but also the people who thronged the markets for shopping due to limited working hours.” (“Traders ‘warn of clashes’ with LEAs if business disallowed,” Dawn, 7 May 2021)

Ahsan Iqbal placed on Exit Control List
On 7 May, the Interior Ministry included PML-N’s Ahsan Iqbal on the Exit Control List (ECL) following the NAB’s request which is probing him on the Narowal Sports City Complex corruption reference. The NAB allegation includes that “Iqbal illegally directed the Pakistan Sports Board (PSB) and NESPAK to increase the project's scope, enhancing the cost to Rs97.52 million.” (“PML-N leader Ahsan Iqbal now on Exit Control List,” The News International, 7 May 2021) 

Shehbaz Sharif seeks removal from ECL
On 6 May, Shehbaz Sharif moved the Lahore High Court seeking the removal of his own name from the ECL for traveling abroad for medical treatment. He said there was a vile campaign against him by the government. His petition says placing his name of the ECL despite the removal from the same “by this court vide order dated March 26, 2019 is not only illegal, perverse but also contemptuous as the same is a blatant attempt of sitting over the judgment of this court.” (“Shehbaz seeks removal of his name from blacklist,” The Express Tribune, 7 May 2021)

PROVINCES
CTD to launch crackdown on TLP financiers
On 6 May, an official told Dawn that Punjab’s Counter Terrorism Department will crackdown on financiers of the Tehreek-i-Labbaik (TLP), most of which include businessmen, industrialists and traders. He said around 72 financiers were based in south Punjab and in cities like Karachi, Lahore, Faisalabad and Gujranwala. He said the CTD had traced “328 big businessmen, industrialists and traders with complete particulars including name, kind of business they were running and the mode of transaction of the money.” (Asif Chaudhary, “Punjab CTD set to act against banned TLP’s financiers,” Dawn, 7 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Trade deficit for first three quarters stands at 3.6 per cent of GDP
On 6 May, data from the Finance Ministry showed that the fiscal deficit,  during July 2020-March 2021 of the current FY, had increased to USD 1.652 trillion. This amounts to 3.6 per cent of Pakistani’s GDP, “despite a drastic cut in development, almost static defence expenditure, healthy provincial cash surpluses and record petroleum levy collections.” The revenue collection increased 6.45 per cent in the nine months against an increase in total expenditure to 4.2 per cent. In the first two quarters, total revenue was poor but had higher expenditures when compared to the third quarter. (Khaleeq Kiani, “Nine-month fiscal deficit widens to 3.6pc,” Dawn, 7 May 2021)


PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
Opposition criticises proposed anti-rape ordinance
On 6 May, opposition MNAs raised concerns over the Anti-Rape (Investigation and Trial) Ordinance which provides for setting up special courts and appointing their judges to hear rape cases. The Standing Committee on Law and Justice of the NA discussed the same; however, a PPP member of the committee opined that instead of the above, existing session courts should be empowered to hear rape cases. On the other hand, a PML-N committee member said some people were not open to the idea of an independent judiciary. While the session was later postponed, the President “approved empowering sessions courts to hear rape cases until special ones were set up for this purpose.” (Saqib Virk, “Anti-rape courts draw ire of opposition MNAs,” The Express Tribune, 7 May 2021)

Opinion calls for increased participation in all fields
An opinion in Dawn cites various reports on gender and human development, political participation, peace and the like to look at Pakistan’s position on them, which she concludes is poor on all the above. The author opines that women are not present on decision-making platforms. She highlights the male-dominated society and next, outlines remarks by the apologists who say women have achieved diplomats’ positions or politicians. However, she terms them exceptions and says, “Women need to make their mark in all fields in sufficient numbers in order for countries to develop peacefully and sustainably.” (Nikhat Sattar, “Missing women,” Dawn, 7 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
US troop withdrawal brings challenges for Afghanistan’s neighbours, says Blinken
On 6 May, the US Secretary of State appeared on BBC wherein he conveyed that the US troop withdrawal from Afghanistan outlined challenges for the country’s neighbours. He opined that Afghanistan’s neighbours have benefitted from the US and NATO presence; he said, “They now have to decide, including Pakistan, where their interests lie, and, if they have influence, how to use it.” Further, he added, “I don’t think a single neighbour of Afghanistan’s, starting with Pakistan, has an interest in the country winding up in a civil war, because that would produce a massive refugee flow [to Pakistan].” (Anwar Iqbal, “US pullout from Afghanistan a test for Pakistan, other neighbours,” Dawn, 7 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                            

An editorial in Dawn says that there are systemic issues that need to be fixed when it comes to consular services, adding, instead of demoralising the entire service, the prime minister should have engaged with honest and respectable officers to identify how solutions can be found.  

Similarly, an editorial in The Express Tribune says that the problem goes back to the widespread belief about foreign service among CSS applicants. “You get paid better” and “you can see the world” are the selling points. “You get to represent Pakistan to the world” never seems to attract applicants. 

 



"The foreign funding case against the PTI has become a never-ending tale...The nation has a right to know the truth of the matter under scrutiny. The PTI also deserves a decision so that the matter is settled once and for all."
-An opinion in Dawn on 'Foreign funding case'

 


Pakistan’s third COVID-19 wave


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Pakistan’s third COVID-19 wave
Number of active cases falls by seven per cent 

On 5 May, data according to the National Command and Operation Centre (NCOC) showed that the number of active cases has fallen by seven per cent in less than a fortnight. However, Pakistan reported 119 deaths and 4,113 cases in a single day with the positivity ratio at 9.17 per cent.

Pakistan vaccinates over 200,000 people in a day, says Asad
Federal Minister for Planning and Development Asad Umar said that the number of registrations for the coronavirus vaccine have been increasing significantly as over 200,000 people got vaccinated against the virus on 4 May. Further, he noted that the number of registrants of the coronavirus vaccines in the country has exceeded the five million mark. Additionally, an official from the Ministry of National Health Services said, “The concentrate prepared by CanSino has been imported from China and will be sufficient to produce 125,000 doses of vaccine. As machinery and staff are ready, within a few days we will start manufacturing vaccine.” (“Number of active Covid cases falls by 7pc in less than fortnight,” Dawn, 6 May 2021)

Pakistan may yet again be standing at a crossroads where the pandemic is concerned, says editorial
An editorial in Dawn reflecting at the same time last year says that Pakistan may yet again be standing at a crossroads regarding the pandemic. It warns that the slightest loosening of SOP protocols could send the country in the direction of the situation in India. Further, it says the government’s decision to call on the army’s assistance to enforce SOPs appears to be bearing fruit adding, if this is sustained beyond the Eid holidays, Pakistan could ride out the third wave without the health system buckling. (“Proceed with caution,” Dawn, 6 May 2021)

 

PML-N wins PP-84 Khushab seat as per unofficial results 
PTI comes in second place

Image Source: The News International

On 5 May, PML-N candidate Barrister Moazzam Sher Kallu won the PP-84 Khushab, according to provisional results released by the ECP. He is said to have secured the election by a wide margin after securing 73,081 votes. Further, the unofficial results showed that PTI's Ali Hussain in second place with 62,903 votes. Independent candidate Amjad Raza came in third with 8,340 votes, followed by TTP’s candidate Hafiz Muhammad Asghar Ali, who secured 5,782 votes. The by-polls were held after it fell vacant due to the death of PML-N’s Waris Kallu who had won it four times consecutively. The party gave the ticket to his son, Moazzam. (“PML-N secures victory in PP-84 Khushab by-election,” Dawn, 6 May 2021)

PML-N celebrates the victory
In a tweet, Shehbaz Sharif celebrated the win and said the people had rejected the “flour and sugar thieves,” adding, “This is also an acknowledgement by the people of the service rendered by the PML-N during its tenure. And this vote is the vote for the development of Pakistan under the leadership of Nawaz Sharif!”
Additionally, Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari said, “The consistent wins by the opposition clearly show how disillusioned the people are with the PTI and its anti-people policies. The people of Pakistan continue to give their verdict against the PTI, but the selected government refuses to listen.” (“PML-N wins Khushab by-polls by almost 10,000 vote margin,” The Express Tribune, 6 May 2021)

 

Trade deficit widens by 21.6 per cent in 10 months
Imports jump 17.67 per cent and exports 13.49 per cent in July-April FY21

Image Source: Dawn

On 5 May, data released by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) showed that Pakistan’s trade deficit widened by 21.6 per cent to USD 23.83 billion in the 10 months of 2020-21 from USD 19.59 billion over the corresponding period last year. In April 2021, the trade deficit increased by 33.24 per cent to USD 2.99 billion as against USD 2.24 billion over the corresponding month of last year. The trade gap has been widening since December 2020; however, the surges has been mainly led by exponential growth in imports with comparative slow growth in exports proceeds from the country. Additionally, the bureau reported that imports jump 17.67 per cent and exports 13.49 per cent in July-April FY21. (“Trade deficit widens by 21.6pc in 10MFY21,” Dawn, 6 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Four political parties outline discrepancies in NA-249 recount, announce boycott 
On 6 May, the PTI, PML-N, MQM and the Pak Sarzameen Party boycotted the vote recount of the Karachi NA-249 by-polls. The four parties said the returning officer (RO) had not provided them Form 45 and Form 46 and had also broken the seal of the ballots. The PML-N candidate said when he questioned the missing seal, the RO said the seal would have fallen off. On the other hand, the PPP candidate who had won the election said lies were being spread and also opined, “Defeat has become the destiny of the PML-N.” (Qazi Hussain, “Four political parties boycott NA-249 Karachi by-poll recount,” Dawn, 6 May 2021)

ECP tells NADRA to restore i-voting system: Sources
On 6 May, The Express Tribune reported that the ECP had asked the National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA) to restore the internet voting system within seven days. Also known as the i-voting system, NADRA had reportedly “abolished” without the ECP’s permission in October 2018 after it was launched in September the same year. A committee on electoral reforms has sought a report on the i-voting system by 31 May. (Saqib Virk, “NADRA told to restore i-voting in seven days,” The Express Tribune, 6 May 2021)

Opinion outlines ways to address child sexual abuse 
An opinion in Dawn cites data by a rights organisation which says that eight children were sexually abused in the country in 2020, reflecting an increase four per cent from the previous year. The author outlines that as long as children are “educated and empowered,” laws alone will not be enough to address the situation. She calls for a continued communication between the parents and the children about awareness of sexual abuse and not restrict it to a one-time session. This, she opines, “will encourage children to communicate their concerns to their parents if ever someone tries to cross a line, and to know that their word will be trusted and action taken against the perpetrator.” She refers to expert opinions who say that “the more the more children understand the issue and learn how to say ‘no’, the greater their ability to identify potentially abusive situations.” Until then, child abuse remains a grim reality. (Huma Khawar, “Protecting children,” Dawn, 6 May 202)

Illegal wildlife trade result in 80 per cent loss of pangolins and other species
On 5 May, the World Wildlife Fund Senior Director (Biodiversity) said that Pakistan had lost 80 per cent of its pangolins and around 80 per cent or more of its freshwater turtles due to illegal smuggling. He said though farming has been the main driver of this, a sharp decline in the numbers has been fuelled by illegal trade with China especially, “where demand by the growing middle class for their scales and meat has increased significantly in the last ten years.” He said due to increased cooperation with the customs department, there has been confiscation of pangolin scales in recent years. He said, “It’s a good thing that they are failing smuggling attempts. It’s not a good thing because it is still being smuggled out of Pakistan.” He called on other professionals like journalists, international organisations and the like to help the WWF address the problem. (Jamal Shahid, “80pc of country’s pangolins lost to illegal hunting: WWF,” Dawn, 6 May 2021)

ECONOMY
ECC approves payment of Rs 90 billion to IPPs
On 5 May, the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) gave its green signal to pay “Rs90 billion to 35 independent power producers (IPPs).” This would be the first installment of the payment to the IPPs worth Rs 403 billion. The ECC also allotted Rs 27.5 billion to the National Disaster Management Authority under the PM’s Karachi package. Further, the ECC also agreed “to give a last chance to K-Electric (KE) for settling Rs212bn payments and inking an agreement for additional power intake.” (Khaleeq Kiani, “ECC okays Rs90bn payment to IPPs,” Dawn, 6 May 2021)

EXTERNAL 
Saudi Arabia assures support towards regional stability; PM to visit Kingdom on 7 May
On 6 May, the Chief of General Staff (CGS) of the Saudi Armed Forces assured Pakistan’s COAS of the Kingdom’s support towards regional peace and stability. Dawn referred to the ISPR statement and reported that the two discussed the “regional security situation including Afghan peace process, and military-to-military bilateral cooperation.” Meanwhile, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said Imran Khan will begin his three-day visit to Saudi Arabia; he will be accompanied by the Foreign Ministers and others from the cabinet. (“Saudi Arabia assures Pakistan of support in peace efforts,” Dawn, 6 May 2021) (“PM Imran to embark on three-day visit to Saudi Arabia tomorrow,” The Express Tribune, 6 May 2021)

ON INDIA
India is deliberately avoiding court proceedings on Jadhav, says Attorney General 
On 5 May, the Islamabad High Court resumed hearing on the Kulbhushan Jadhav case. According to Dawn, the Attorney General argued that the Indian government deliberately avoided the court proceedings, raised objections to a trial in a Pakistani court and did not appoint a counsel on the grounds fearing it “is tantamount to surrendering sovereign rights.” The IHC Chief Justice alleged that the Indian High Commission questioned the legitimacy of the court while it had previously approached the court for “release of five prisoners and had secured decision in their favour.” Dawn quoted the CJ, “We are not against sovereign immunity of the Indian government but they should at least tell us how we would proceed to implement the ICJ’s decision.” Further the Attorney General said, had the matter not been pending before the IHC, “ the Indian authorities would have filed a contempt of court [petition] against Pakistani government with the ICJ for ‘non-compliance’ of latter’s decision.” Next hearing will be held on 15 June. (Malik Asad, “India reminded of Jadhav case ramifications,” Dawn, 6 May 2021)

ON PAKISTAN-OCCUPIED KASHMIR
Pakistan calls for humanitarian medical corridor in Kashmir
On 5 May, the Parliamentary Committee on Kashmir called on the UN, WHO, and the ICRC, “to set up an international humanitarian medical corridor” in “India-held Kashmir.” Citing the gravity of the pandemic in India, Foreign Minister Qureshi said, “Pakistan offered assistance due to the challenging situation. We have not received any response from India yet. Illegally Indian Occupied Jammu and Kashmir (IIOJK) is also suffering and we feel very strongly as we are connected to them historically and religiously.” (“Pakistan suggests medical corridor for people of occupied Kashmir,” Dawn, 6 May 2021) 

 
Also read...                                                                     
An opinion in Dawn argues that government officials continue to call human rights standards alien to Pakistan’s ground realities. It says that it is time that all branches of the state end their doublespeak on human rights and adopt a clear public position recognising their legitimacy and significance, only then that human rights discourse can truly flourish and improve the lives of the people of Pakistan.

Fahd Husain in his column says Pakistan, India backchannel at a delicate point and could go either way depending on the response from New Delhi. However, for now, Islamabad has adopted a policy of wait and see. 
 


"In sharp contrast to Pakistan’s lofty claims before international forums, international human rights largely remain a maligned concept domestically and the government actively resists any scrutiny of Pakistan’s human rights record...It is time that all branches of the state end their doublespeak on human rights and adopt a clear public position recognising their legitimacy and significance — it is only then that human rights discourse can truly flourish and improve the lives of the people of Pakistan."
-An opinion in Dawn on 'Mixed signals on rights'

 


COAS Bajwa arrives in Saudi Arabia


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
COAS Bajwa arrives in Saudi Arabia 
Visit takes place ahead of PM’s trip to the kingdom 

On 4 May, ISPR said, “COAS has reached KSA (Kingdom of Saudi Arabia) on an official visit.” The COAS is scheduled to meet with the civilian and military leadership. Further, he is expected to lay the basis ahead of PM Imran Khan’s trip to the kingdom scheduled for 7 May, which is expected to revive Saudi Arabia’s assistance to Pakistan. 

Gen Bajwa's previous visit
Gen Bajwa visited Saudi Arabia in August 2020 after a strain in bilateral relations, which was caused by FM Qureshi’s statement on the OIC for its failure to convene a special meeting of the foreign ministers of the member countries for a discussion on the Kashmir dispute. Following this, Saudi Arabia recalled most of the assistance it had extended to Pakistan in 2018. 

Role of the military diplomacy 
According to Dawn, diplomatic sources expect that much of that Saudi Arabia’s attitude is going to change as military diplomacy has reportedly played a major role in thawing the relation between the two countries. (“Bajwa in Saudi Arabia on official visit,” Dawn, 5 May 2021) 

 

ECP orders recount of NA-249 votes
Recount to open door for scrutiny of many seats, says Bilawal

Image Source: Dawn

On 4 May, the ECP accepted PML-N candidate Miftah Ismail's plea and ordered recounting in the NA-249 constituency. The ECP has asked lawmakers to reach the office of the returning officer (RO) on 6 May for the recount. The decision was welcomed by Shehbaz Sharif who said, “narrow difference in votes necessitated this in the interest of transparency. Credibility of vote is a sure foundation of democracy.” (“ECP accepts PML-N's plea, orders recounting in NA-249,” The Express Tribune, 5 May 2021)

NA-249 recount to open door for scrutiny of many seats, says Bilawal
Bilawal Bhutto Zardari stated that the ECP’s order to hold recounting in the NA-249 constituency will lead to scrutiny of many seats that had narrow winning margins. In a tweet, he said, “PPP welcomes new precedent set by allowing consistency [constituency] wide recount without specific ps [polling stations] complaints. Many seats from 2018 fall within 5% threshold & candidates have not been given this chance.” (“NA-249 recount to open door for scrutiny of many seats: Bilawal,” The Express Tribune, 5 May 2021)

 

“If ever there was need for partnership, it is now,” says Munir Akram
Says defeating the pandemic should be the top priority for all nations

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 4 May, Pakistan’s UN envoy Munir Akram said, “If ever there was need for partnership, it is now.” While addressing the annual Partnership Forum, organised by the ECOSOC, Akram outlined several areas where partnerships could be used to contain Covid-19 and achieve the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Further, he urged all nations to work together to prevent millions from descending into extreme poverty and destitution, saying, “This means helping the poorest people with direct and indirect economic support and social safety nets,” adding, “It means providing the poorest countries with fiscal space through debt relief, emergency grants and concession financing to save lives and livelihoods.” (“Now is time for global partnership, Pakistan tells UN memberst,” Dawn, 5 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Cabinet approves two electoral reform ordinances 
On 4 May, the cabinet approved two key ordinances on electoral reforms. The first ordinance will enable the ECP to introduce EVMs and the second ordinance allows it “to take steps to give voting right to the overseas Pakistanis.” The federal Information Minister said that the EVMs had been developed in Pakistan “and the government has unveiled its legislation agenda for the purpose, while work is underway on biometric and e-voting mechanism.” On the issue, the Minister for Science and Technology opined the major opposition parties were reluctant to give voting rights to the overseas Pakistanis. (Rizwan Shehzad, “Cabinet approves vote reform ordinances,” The Express Tribune, 5 May 2021)

Yaum-i-Ali processions held despite COVID-19 restrictions
On 4 May, flouting COVDI-19 SOPs, huge Yaum-i-Ali processions were held by Shia devotees in different cities to mark the anniversary of Hazrat Ali’s martyrdom. The gatherings were held despite the government’s ban on religious processions. Further, the police, rangers, law enforcement agencies were arranged for the security of the mourners. (“Yaum-i-Ali processions taken out in major cities despite ban,” Dawn, 5 May 2021) Meanwhile, Dawn reported that the NCOC is deliberating on “closing the Adult Vaccination Centres (AVCs) on the first three Eid holidays.” Eid holidays begin on 10 May and last until 15 May. (“Vaccination centres likely to remain closed on all three Eid days,” Dawn, 5 May 2021)

Dawn says condition of human rights in the country is not so heartening 
An editorial in Dawn, referring to the annual report of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan published recently, and recalls various instances of rights violations in the country. This includes enforced disappearances, and the rise in inequalities due to the pandemic over 2020. The editorial outlines the loss of access to education to many children due to the shift to online platforms and says it will have a significant impact on literacy in the long run. Further, it highlights the rise in domestic and sexual violence during the pandemic as people were confined to their homes. With this, it concludes: “The picture is not a heartening one.” (“Human rights 2020,” Dawn, 5 May 2021)

PROVINCES
Gunmen kill three for honour 
On 4 May, gunmen shot dead three people, including a woman of their family in Khyber tribal district for honour. The gunmen shot at a schoolteacher on his motorcycle and the woman was killed in her house on suspicion of having an affair with him; another teacher who was the pillion rider succumbed to his injuries. (“Three shot dead for honour in Khyber,” Dawn, 5 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Cement sales increase by 24.3 per cent
On 4 May, the data from the All Pakistan Cement Manufacturers Association (APCMA) showed that cement sales had increased to 4.066 million tonnes in April 2021 from 3.271 million tonnes in the corresponding period last year, thereby reflecting a 24.3 per cent increase. Further, exports recorded an increase of 25 per cent; domestic sales are also on the rise and the APCMA spokesperson expects that total cement exports will surpass nine million tonnes by June. (Aamir Shafaat Khan, “Construction boom lifts cement sales up 24.3pc,” Dawn, 5 May 2021)

SBP providing Rs 36 billion to renewable energy options, says governor
On 4 May, the State Bank of Pakistangovernor said Rs 36 billion had been provided for 521 projects in the Financing Scheme for Renewable Energy (FSRE). He said this would be included in Pakistan’s steps towards diversifying its energy mix and reducing the impact of climate change. He explained there would be various “financing options ranging from Rs400 million to Rs6 billion” which could be used for captive energy units, commercial projects, as well as “individual consumers who may share excess production with the national grid.” (Shahid Iqbal, “State Bank gives Rs36bn financing for renewable energy adoption,” Dawn, 5 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
Four FC personnel killed after alleged terrorist from Afghanistan open fire
On 5 May, the ISPR said “terrorists from Afghanistan” opened fire on Pakistan’s Frontier Corps personnel who were fencing the border between the two countries. Four FC personnel died and six were injured in the incident which took place in the Manzakai Sector of District Zhob in Balochistan. (“Four FC personnel martyred in cross-border terrorist attack from Afghanistan,” The News International, 5 May 2021)

Will not take dictation from West, says Information Minister
On 4 May, the Information Minister said the government will not dictate their decisions to Pakistan, when asked about the EU Parliament's decision to review the GSP Plus status. He opined that the "the government is firm in its stance that it will not take any dictation on internal issues" which included the action against the TLP. (Syed Irfan Raza, "West can’t dictate decisions, vows minister," Dawn, 5 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                  
An editorial in Dawn argues that flexibility should not be problematic for the IMF given that the government only wants to pursue a different strategy to put its economic house in order, without leaving the programme or abandoning its targets.

An opinion in Dawn critical of the government’s ability to address religious matter argues the criticism received from the West reflects the country’s failure to counter rising religious intolerance and bigotry, and also exposes a diplomatic debacle

An opinion in The News International says results of the NA-249 by-polls shows that Karachi is distancing itself from the ethno-regional parties that kept voters hostage for the past 30 years.
 



"Unlike a tsunami or an earthquake, the calamity of population acts more imperceptibly. It slowly sinks a country into quicksand that is not easy to recover from...It is time for Pakistan’s people to take charge of their future and demand that the government wakes up to respond to the reality of this existential threat."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on 'Population quicksand'

 


PM Khan urges OIC to vehemently counter Islamophobia


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
PM Khan urges OIC to vehemently counter Islamophobia
Says govt will not compromise on blasphemy law

On 3 May, PM Imran Khan urged the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) to vehemently counter Islamophobia and falsely equating of Islam with radicalism and terrorism. During a meeting with over 30 OIC ambassadors, he said that Muslim countries have failed to convince the West that the blasphemy of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) hurt the sentiments of over 1.5 billion Muslims in the world and was not an issue of freedom of expression. He stated that whenever an incident of terrorism occurred, the West maligned the entire Muslim world which was wrong, arguing, “An act of any individual should not be called an act of the entire Ummah,” adding, the whole Muslim world strongly condemned terrorism perpetrated, “But the whole Muslim Ummah should not be blamed for an act of an individual. Linking Islam with terrorism is absolutely unjustified.”

Islamophobic acts fan inter-religious hatred and disharmony
He stated that Islamophobic acts fan inter-religious hatred and disharmony among civilisations, calling on the need to address the underlying reasons for the rise in such incidents worldwide, he said, “Falsely equating Islam with radicalism and terrorism was leading to marginalisation and stigmatisation of Muslims.”

He also reiterated Pakistan’s commitment to dialogue and cooperation with all members of the international community for promoting universal values of tolerance, mutual respect and peaceful co-existence across the world. (“Imran asks OIC to counter Islamophobia,” Dawn, 4 May 2021)

Meeting to review EU Parliament’s resolution on Pakistan’s blasphemy laws
On 3 May, the federal government decided not to compromise on the country’s blasphemy law in line with the resolution of the European Parliament calling for reviewing Pakistan’s Generalised Scheme of Preferences Plus (GSP+) status amid an “alarming” number of blasphemy cases.

During the meeting, PM Imran Khan stated that there has been an alarming increase in accusations of blasphemy online and offline in Pakistan over the past year, saying, “many of these accusations target human rights defenders, journalists, artists and the most marginalised people in society," said the resolution titled “the Blasphemy laws in Pakistan, in particular the case of Shagufta Kausar and Shafqat Emmanuel.”

However, the government has decided to introduce new legislation for various aspects of human rights in line with its agreements with the European Union. (“Govt not to compromise on blasphemy law,” The Express Tribune, 4 May 2021)

 

IMF asked to relax conditions, says FM
Govt to take alternative measures to reduce circular debt

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 4 May, Dawn reported that Finance Minister Shaukat Tarin stated that the International Monetary Fund (IMF) would be convinced to relax conditions particularly those related to power tariff hike as stabilisation is no more affordable for Pakistan’s economy. He said, the higher power tariff was leading to corruption and affecting economic growth and that the conditions agreed to under the IMF programme were very harsh. Further, he stated that IMF was being convinced to have a sympathetic view towards Pakistan amid the third wave of coronavirus. However, he added that unless the country moved to higher economic growth, nothing would improve, neither revenue collection, nor job opportunities would be available to people or the productive capacity of the economy could improve.

Govt to take alternative measures to reduce circular debt 
Tarin claimed that the government would take alternative measures to reduce circular debt instead of tariff increases. He also said that the tax net would be expanded instead of an increase in taxes to achieve revenue targets. However, stated that state-owned entities that the government was unable to run in the public sector would be privatised. (“IMF being urged to relax harsh terms, says minister,” Dawn, 4 May 2021)

 

Positivity ratio of COVID-19 cases declines
Govt to vaccinate 70 million people by the end of the year

Image Source: Dawn

On 3 May, a Microbiologist while talking to Dawn stated that the country was witnessing a downward trend but warned that things could be worse during the upcoming Eid holidays. This comes after a continuous rise in Covid-19 cases for almost three months. During the third wave of Covid-19 in February, the positivity ratio stood three per cent and then increased to 11 per cent in April. However, the number of daily cases and positivity ratio have been declining since the start of May.

Further, Special Assistant to the Prime Minister (SAPM) on Health said the government has promised to vaccinate 70 million people by the end of the current year. (“Covid-19 cases, positivity ratio start declining,” Dawn, 4 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
Important PTI documents removed from scrutiny table
On 3 May, sources claimed that PTI’s HBL account’s statements for perusal by the scrutiny committee, in the foreign funding case against the party, was removed from the table. Sources said the said document was removed after the PTI raised objections; the committee informed the DG law of the same, who then called for the “the removal of the HBL bank statements from the scrutiny table.” Following this development, the petitioner “blamed the committee for obstructing the perusal process.” (Iftikhar A Khan, “Scrutiny body withdraws PTI’s document in foreign funding case,” Dawn, 4 May 2021)

Peira announces 20 per cent concession to parents paying school fees above Rs 8000
On 3 May, the Private Educational Institutions Regulatory Authority (Peira) announced a 20 per cent concession in school fees to “parents paying more than Rs8,000 per month.” This is in contrast to the 20 per cent concession announced in 2020 for those paying more than Rs 5000. The Peira Deputy Director said most demands for the concession came from parents of children going to “upscale schools”; therefore, the benchmark was revised to Rs 8000. Further, an official at the Education Ministry outlined that “some schools are struggling for survival” for which the “government is exploring options for a bailout package.” (Kashif Abbasi, “20pc concession for parents paying more than Rs8,000 fee,” Dawn, 4 May 2021)

Bilawal pushes for electoral reforms to keep establishment away
On 3 May, Bilawal Bhutto welcomed the idea of electoral reforms but maintained that the main aim of the reforms should be to do away with the alleged interference of the establishment. However, he referred to the PTI government’s suggestion to introduce the reforms and said, “Preventing rigging is a major issue, [but] those who rigged the elections can do nothing to stop it [rigging].” Further, he took on the PML-N and criticised the party for “seeking military’s involvement in the election process” after the NA-249 by-polls. He opined, “As long as the establishment continues to interfere in the elections, transparent elections would not be possible.” (“Electoral reforms must keep establishment out: Bilawal,” The Express Tribune, 4 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Tarin calls for import of four million metric tons of wheat
On 3 May, the government “decided to import four million metric tons of wheat” for the current year for domestic consumption. The National Price Monitoring Committee estimated that it would require USD 1.2 billion for the import. Prior to this, the Committee had decided to import three million metric tons of wheat for 2021-22; newly appointed finance minister Shaukat Tarin revised the same. As of May 2021, Pakistan has imported 3.6 million metric tons of wheat for USD 983.3 million in the current FY. (Shahbaz Rana, “Govt decides to import 4m MT of wheat,” The Express Tribune, 4 May 2021)

PAKISTAN’S GENDER DEBATE
Editorial calls for sensitising ECP, NADRA officials to close gender gap in electoral rolls
An editorial in The Express Tribune cites the latest report on the gender gaps in Pakistan's electoral rolls and largely attributes it to the low female literacy rate. The editorial opines that the role of men is limited if females themselves are unaware of their rights. Referring to the ECP’s directive for close coordination with the NADRA officials, the editorial says “Officials of the two organisations should be sensitised in this respect.” (“Gender gap in electoral rolls,” The Express Tribune, 4 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
Chinese ambassador calls on COAS
On 3 May, the Chinese ambassador to Pakistan met with the COAS. The ISPR said the two discussed “matters of mutual interest, recent developments in Afghan peace process, progress on CPEC, regional security and current situation of Covid-19.” The COAS thanked China for its contribution to Pakistan’s fight against COVID-19; on the other hand, the ambassador appreciated Pakistan for its “sincere efforts for peace and stability in the region, especially the Afghan peace process.” (“Chinese envoy meets Bajwa,” Dawn, 4 May 2021)

ON INDIA
Diplomats discuss reports of backchannel talks with India
On 3 May, former diplomats discussed the “backchannel talks” between India and Pakistan. They opined that “ground realities, context and strategic dilemmas, fuels suspicion about the engagement.” Further, they alleged that “Indian move to engage in backchannel could be a tactical one for trapping Pakistan in talks.” They also referred to the news reports of backchannel talks and said the “optimism in Islamabad” was not reflected in India’s “stoic silence.” Maleeha Lodhi said, “We all seek peace with honour, but not at the expense of compromising our fundamental position on Kashmir because then that kind of normalization will neither be lasting nor would it be politically acceptable to the people of Pakistan.” Other dignitaries also echoed her opinion. (Kamran Yousaf, “Former diplomats, generals caution on backchannel talks with India,” The Express Tribune, 4 May 2021)

Pakistan accuses India of violating DGMOs understanding
On 3 May, Pakistan accused Indian forces of “crossing over Charwa Sector of Sialkot and resorting to unprovoked firing.” Dawn reports that the foreign affairs ministry has written to the Indian High Commission on the same and called the alleged movement the “first serious and grave violation of Directors General Military Operation (DGMOs) understanding in 2021.” It accused Indian BSF of using small arms and mortars against Pakistani posts without provocation. (Malik Asad, “Pakistan protests Working Boundary crossing, firing by Indian troops,” Dawn, 4 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                           
An editorial in Dawn welcoming the government’s proposal of extensive electoral reforms argues that a rigging-proof system, which cannot be manipulated through technical delays, is possible if stakeholders sit together.

An editorial in The Express Tribune critical of the inflation rate says that it is also worrying that this is being coupled with rising unemployment. It argues, yelling is not going to fix the problem, rather more thinking on the necessary macro-level reforms might.

An opinion in Dawn on TLP and the by-elections argues that Pakistan has always made space for Islamist parties electorally, highlight the factors that have played a role in the emergence of the TLP in elections, rather than just a growing radicalisation of voters.
 



"Overcoming inequality will lead to significant progress in human development...With the will to reduce privileges, prioritise human development and improve working conditions, inequality can be overcome and — with that — the overall development of Pakistan accelerated."
-An opinion in The Express Tribune on the UNDP’s Pakistan National Human Development Report (NHDR) 2020 on Inequality.

 


Next budget to focus on GDP, inflation and development: PM Khan


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
Next budget to focus on GDP, inflation and development: PM Khan
Instructs economic team to prepare the budget per public requirement

On 2 May, PM Imran Khan while chairing a meeting held to discuss the annual budget said that the next budget would “give special attention to development projects and measures to control the inflation.” He said that besides ensuring the completion of ongoing development projects, new projects should be designed in accordance with the public needs. Further, he stated that the next budget should be development-oriented with full attention towards the improvement of the growth ratio.

Sought proposal from party leadership for the budget
PM Khan also sought proposals from the senior party leadership for the next budget. Further, the country’s economy, a strategy to control inflation, and development projects for the next fiscal year were also discussed at the meeting. They were also told that the next budget should be development-oriented with full attention given to the improvement of the growth ratio by expediting the development work and new projects to enhance economic activities, GDP growth and revenue collection besides generating jobs. Additionally, the PM was also briefed on a comprehensive strategy devised to control inflation and revenue collection amid the COVID-19 situation. (Syed Irfan Raza, “Next budget to focus on GDP, inflation, uplift projects: PM,” Dawn, 3 May 2021) (“With inflation in focus, PM seeks proposals for next budget,” The Express Tribune, 3 May 2021) 

 

 

Govt enhance protocols on borders with Iran and Afghanistan amid COVID-19
Inbound pedestrians to be sealed from 5 May 

Image Source: Dawn

On 2 May, the National Command and Operations Centre (NCOC) after reviewing the existing land border management policy with Afghanistan and Iran said, “With the emergence of various variants and to restrain import of any new mutation to Pakistan, current policy of land border management with Afghanistan and Iran has been reviewed to ensure regulated inbound pedestrian movement and effective management of COVID protocols at Border Terminals (BTs).” Further, the NCOC said that strict mobility control measures will be enforced in the country from 8-16 May to curb the spread of the disease.

Pakistan’s third COVID-19 wave
As of 2 May, the number of active cases reported was 89,661 while the death toll has reached 18,070. Meanwhile, vaccination of people in the age bracket of 40-49 years is set to begin on 3 May (today). (Ikram Junaidi, “Controls on Afghan, Iran borders being beefed up to fight Covid,” Dawn, 3 May 2021) (“Afghan, Iran borders for inbound pedestrians to be sealed from May 5: NCOC,” The Express Tribune, 3 May 2021)

 

PML-N asks CEC to keep NA-249 ballots in army’s custody
PPP asks PML-N not to accuse their victory with the support of the “establishment”

Image Source: Dawn

On 3 May, the PML-N submitted an application to the chief election commissioner (CEC) asking for the election material, including ballot papers, to be placed under the supervision of the Army or Rangers. The application was submitted by Miftah Ismail, the PML-N candidate in the constituency after the PPP “welcomed” the decision of the ECP to stay announcement of official results for a recount. Further, they also asked the PML-N not to accuse the party of winning the seat with the support of the “establishment.” (Amir Wasim, “PML-N urges CEC to place NA-249 ballots in army’s custody,” Dawn, 3 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
PDM should apologise to PPP, says party Secretary General
On 2 May, the PPP questioned the PDM’s show-cause notice to the party and asked the alliance to withdraw the same. The News International quoted some PPP lawmakers who claimed that “The PPP formed the PDM. Who are these people who want us to approach them to rejoin the PDM?” They also conveyed that the PDM should apologize to the PPP. Further, the party’s Secretary General blamed the PML-N for the rift within the alliance, reiterating that the PPP had no issues with the long march and a no confidence motion against the government. (“PPP asks PDM to withdraw notice, seek apology,” The News International, 3 May 2021)

Editorial outlines need for freedom of press
An editorial in The News International, marking the World Press Freedom Day, says that the risks of practising journalism in Pakistan are increasing by the day. The editorial outlines that though the media’s relationship with the state has always been tense, “the past few years have seen an unprecedented increase in these challenges.” It opines that increased attacks on journalism and journalists, is a reflection of the “collective failure of government and state institutions,” not just in Pakistan but anywhere in the world. Therefore, it urges the government to take up the matter seriously; after all, “A free press is vital to the healthy functioning of any democracy,” It concludes that “a journalist fearful of doing his/her job translates into a society that is silenced.” (“Freedom of the press?,” The News International, 3 May 2021)

Information minister outlines govt’s commitment to independent media
On 3 May, the Information Minister said the present government is committed to ensuring independent and free media. He said, “There is no concept of media censorship in the country...Media in Pakistan enjoys unprecedented freedom. The government neither believes nor practices any press advice. Rather, it encourages self-regulation by the media.” He said the government was deliberating on measures to ensure a conducive environment for journalists and their welfare. (“Information minister reiterates govt's commitment to ensure free, independent media,” The Express Tribune, 3 May 2021)

PML-N reject Imran’s proposal to use EVMs
On 2 May, PML-N's Shehbaz Sharif Imran’s suggestion to use EVMs; he was quoted saying, “such decisions cannot be made by one individual.” Similarly, the party secretary general termed the suggestion "yet another drama to rig the elections.” He said the PTI government is suddenly pushing for electoral reforms because of repeated failures in the by-polls. He said, “If the PTI  government is serious about electoral reforms, then it should send suggestions related to the reforms to the chief election commissioner.” (“Electronic voting 'another drama by PTI to rig elections', says Ahsan Iqbal,” The News International, 3 May 2021) (“Shehbaz rejects voting machine proposal,” The Express Tribune, 3 May 2021)

ECONOMY
Exports surpass USD two billion again
On 2 May, the Adviser to the Prime Minister on Commerce and Investment said that exports had crossed the USD two billion mark for the seventh consecutive month, “for the first time since 2011.” In the July 2020- April 2021, the exports stood at USD 20.879 billion compared to USD 18.408 billion in the corresponding period in the last FY. This therefore marked a 13 per cent increase in the exports. (“Exports cross $2bn mark for seven months, says PM aide,” Dawn, 3 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
PM to chair meeting on EU parliament decision to review GSP Plus status
On 3 May (today), Imran Khan will discuss the EU parliament’s decision to review Pakistan’s GSP Plus status. The News International reported that Imran will meet with the Foreign Minister, commerce advisor, Minister for Religious Affairs, and the Interior Minister along with others. Previously, the EU parliament’s decision was criticised by the Foreign Office; the FO statement opined that the decision “reflects a lack of understanding in the context of blasphemy laws and associated religious sensitivities in Pakistan – and the wider Muslim world. The unwarranted commentary about Pakistan’s judicial system and domestic laws are regrettable.” (“PM Imran Khan to discuss European Parliament's resolution on Pakistan’s GSP plus status today,” The News International, 3 May 2021)

ON CPEC
Eastbay Expressway to be completed in October
On 2 May, The CPEC Authority Chairman said the Eastbay Expressway Gwadar project would be completed by October. He said “14.5 km offshore expressway had already been completed while the remaining 4.5 km onshore road was under construction.” The Expressway is expected to “connect the port with the second phase of the Free Trade Zone” aimed at boosting conditions for business activities. It will also “ensure smooth logistic transportation of import, export and transit goods.” (“Eastbay Expressway to be completed in Oct: CPEC chairman,” The News International, 3 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                  
Maleeha Lodhi in an opinion in Dawn on the opening of a backchannel between Pakistan and India argues that peace with honour should remain the immutable principle of Pakistan’s engagement with India.

An opinion in The Express Tribune critical of the power sector says that the policies followed by governments in the power sector after 1977 have greatly damaged the country’s economy, arguing that with immense hydroelectric potential the country has continued to rely only on thermal sources instead.

An editorial in The Express Tribune critical of the PIA split argues whether PIA is split in two, four, or a hundred, its problems will not go away as long as it stays in government hands.
 



"Leaders are considered as role models and ‘belief managers’, especially by the youth. They strongly shape their followers’ beliefs through their words and their actions. They need to lead by example and embody the very ideals they preach."
-An editorial in The Express Tribune on 'The need to lead by example'

 


TLP files appeal against the ban 


Photo: Dawn



In Focus
TLP files appeal against the ban 
Minister says body to decide on request in 30 days

On 30 April, the proscribed TLP filed an appeal with the interior ministry, seeking revocation of the ban imposed on the party. The Interior Minister confirmed the development and said the appeal was received on 29 April and had been taken up for consideration in a meeting on 30 April. The minister stated that the TLP was informed that its appeal had been received and the review process had started. Further, the minister said that a committee, comprising two representatives of the interior ministry and one from the law ministry, will be formed to decide on the appeal within 30 days.

The provision for filing an appeal 
According to Dawn’s sources, a right of review was available under section 11C (1) of the Anti-Terrorism Act which reads: “Where any proscribed organisation is aggrieved by the order of the Federal Government, made under section 11B, it may, within thirty days of such order, file a review application, in writing before the Federal Government stating the grounds on which it is made and the Federal Government shall, after hearing the applicant, decide the matter on reasonable grounds within ninety days.”

The ban on TLP
The decision to formally place the TLP on the list of banned terrorist organisations came after the party had stage three days of violent protests against the arrest of their leader, Saad Hussain Rizvi while demanding the expulsion of the French ambassador among others. The interior minister issued a notification saying, “The federal government has reasonable grounds to believe that Tehreek-i-Labbaik Pakistan was engaged in terrorism, acted in a manner prejudicial to the peace and security of the country, involved in creating anarchy by intimidating the public, caused grievous bodily harm, hurt and death to the personnel of the law enforcement agencies and innocent bystanders, attacked civilians and officials, created wide-scale hurdles, threatened, abused and promoted hatred, vandalised and ransacked public and government properties, including vehicles, and caused arson, blocked essential health supplies to hospitals, and has used, threatened, coerced, intimidated and overawed the government [and] the public and created sense of fear and insecurity in the society and the public at large,” adding, “Therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 11B(1) of the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997, the federal government is pleased to list Tehreek-i-Labbaik Pakistan in the First Schedule to the said Act as a proscribed organisation for the purposes of the said Act.” (“TLP files appeal with interior ministry against ban,” Dawn, 1 May 2021)
 

 

EU parliament to review GSP+ status with Pakistan
Govt expresses disappointment over resolution adopted on Pakistan’s blasphemy law

Image Source: The Express Tribune

On 1 April, Dawn reported that the European Parliament has adopted a resolution seeking a review of trade relations with Pakistan and ending its eligibility for the Generalised Scheme of Preferences (GSP) status. The resolution was passed with a majority of 662 to 3, with 26 not voting. Further, the resolution has linked the review to Pakistan’s blasphemy laws.

The resolution called for space for religious freedom
The resolution demand Pakistan to allow space for religious freedom and urged the EU authorities to review the country’s GSP+ status amid an “alarming” number of blasphemy cases over the past year. It noted that blasphemy cases incite harassment, violence and murder against those being accused. It said, “Judicial procedures in blasphemy cases in Pakistan are highly flawed,” adding that there are low standards of evidence. Further, it stated, “Pakistan continued to deteriorate in 2020 as the government systematically enforced blasphemy laws and failed to protect religious minorities from abuses.”

It stated, “repeated and deceptive attacks against the French authorities” by radical groups and statements made by the government on the issue have escalated, adding that although a ruling party member tabled a resolution in the National Assembly demanding a debate on the expulsion of the French ambassador and said “violent demonstrations and attacks against France [are] unacceptable,” it said, “[The European Parliament is] deeply concerned by the anti-French sentiment in Pakistan, which has led French nationals and companies to have to leave the country temporarily.”

Govt irked by the resolution 
Pakistan’s Foreign Office Spokesperson said, “The discourse in the European Parliament reflects a lack of understanding in the context of blasphemy laws and associated religious sensitivities in Pakistan – and in the wider Muslim world,” adding, “The unwarranted commentary about Pakistan's judicial system and domestic laws are regrettable." The spokesperson added, “We are proud of our minorities, who enjoy equal rights and complete protection of fundamental freedoms as enshrined in the Constitution. Judicial and administrative mechanisms and remedies are in place to guard against any human rights violations.” Similarly, Human Rights Minister Shireen Mazari reacted to the development saying, “We have issues to resolve but there has been more movement now on our HR Int Convention commitments than in previous govts. The way forward is dialogue & negotiations, which we have been doing, not extreme public positioning.” (“EU Parliament move to review trade ties with Pakistan,” Dawn, 1 May 2021) (“Blasphemy law: EU Parliament’s decision to review GSP+ status irks Pakistan,” The Express Tribune, 1 May 2021)

 

PM asks Balochistan Governor to resign
Says ‘transformed political challenges Pakistan faces require change’

Image Source: Dawn

On 1 May, Dawn reported that PM Imran Khan in a letter asked Governor Balochistan Justice (retd) Amanullah Yasinzai to resign, saying “this does not in any way reflect on your competence; it is just that the transformed political challenges Pakistan faces at present require change.” He said, “I intend to appoint a new governor in Balochistan and would, therefore, request you to resign.”

Further, the letter said, “It has been a pleasure to have worked with you, striving for creation of a welfare state and especially looking after the problems of people of the province of Balochistan,” adding, “However, given the current political situation, dexterity and deftness is needed at this Juncture for a delicate balancing act to simultaneously ensure political inclusion and fulfilment of our commitment towards the people of Pakistan.” (“PM Imran asks Balochistan Governor Amanullah Yasinzai to resign,” Dawn, 1 May 2021) (“PM Imran asks Balochistan governor to resign,” The Express Tribune, 1 May 2021)


In Brief
INTERNAL
SAPM accuses Memon of tax evasion
On 30 April, SAPM Shahbaz Gill accused former Federal Investigation Agency head Bashir Memon of tax evasion; he alleged that Memon had established three industries in tax-free tribal areas. He also claimed that Memon politicised his removal from the FIA because he “knew that all his black deeds will be exposed.” However Shahbaz clarified that his remarks were not final judgements and acknowledged the need for an investigation. (Ayed Irfan Raza, “Gill accuses former FIA chief of tax evasion,” Dawn, 1 May 2021)

ECONOMY
PIA records 55 per cent contraction is net loss 
On 30 April, the PIA’s profit and loss statement revealed that its net loss stood at Rs 7.51 billion in the first quarter ended March 31, 2021, in comparison to a net loss of Rs 16.90 billion in the same period last year. This signifies 55 per cent contraction of net loss. The reasons behind the contraction include the “Covid-19 pandemic, low jet fuel prices and a significant gain from rupee depreciation.” (“PIA’s net loss contracts 55%,” The Express Tribune, 1 May 2021)

Revenue collection crosses RS 350 billion target for April
On 30 April, provisional data from the Federal Bureau of Revenue showed that the revenue collection stood at Rs 384 billion in April, thereby surpassing its target of Rs 350 billion. Further the revenue collection also showed an increase by 57 per cent compared to the corresponding period last year when the FBR collected Rs 244 billion. With this, the revenue collection for July 2020-April 2021 stands at Rs 3.78 trillion, which is a 14 per cent increase from Rs 3.320 trillion in the corresponding period last year. (Mubarak Zeb Khan, “FBR surpasses revenue collection target by Rs34bn in April,” Dawn, 1 May 2021)

EXTERNAL
PTA extends technical support in Sri Lanka for mobile number portability
On 1 May, Dawn reported that the Pakis­tan Telecommunication Au­­thority (PTA) had extended its “training and technical support to the Telecom­mu­nica­tions Regulatory Commis­sion of Sri Lanka.” This move aims at “successful implementation of Mobile Number Portability (MNP)” which allows users to change their network without changing the number. (“PTA helps Sri Lanka with mobile number portability,” Dawn, 1 May 2021)

Extended Troika asks Afghan govt and Taliban to ensure security to other countries 
On 1 May, Dawn reported that Pakistan along with the US, Russia, and China, called on the Afghan government “and Taliban to ensure that terrorist groups and individuals do not use Afghan soil to threaten the security of any other country.” The group is referred to as the “Extended Troika on Peaceful Settlement in Afghanistan.” The Troika also urged the Afghan government and the High Council for National Reconciliation to engage with the Taliban; further, the four countries tried to get the Taliban join the Afghan government by calling for a UN review of the group’s designation as a terrorist organisation. (Anwar Iqbal, “Pakistan, US, China and Russia seek end to cross-border attacks from Afghanistan,” Dawn, 1 May 2021)

Hungarian delegation meets Imran and Qureshi
On 30 April, Imran Khan met with Hungary’s Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade and his delegation. The Foreign Office later said that Hungary had announced a USD 84 million credit line “for Hungarian companies to do business with Pakistan.” The Hungarian Minister met Qureshi wherein they discussed bilateral ties and issues of regional and global importance. They also presided over the signing of trade agreements between Pakistani and Hungarian companies, mainly in dairy, pharmaceuticals and cyber security areas. (Baqir Sajjad Syed, “Imran calls for enhanced ties with Hungary,” Dawn, 1 May 2021)

ON COVID-19
Pakistan faces travel restrictions from multiple countries
On 1 May, The News International referred to a Singapore Health Ministry’s statement which read that the country had imposed a ban on Pakistani travellers entering it because of the rising COVID-19 cases. Similarly, Norway had also imposed a ban on Pakistani travellers fearing a risk of spread of the Indian variant. The Justice and Public Security Minister of Norway said, “. In order to limit the risk of imported cases of new COVID-19 variants, we are now introducing stricter entry restrictions for travellers arriving from India and its neighbouring countries, as well as Iraq.” Iran, too, closed its southeastern borders with Pakistan; the restriction would only allow Iranian and Pakistani nationals to return to their home countries. (“Singapore bars Pakistani travellers from transiting and entering country,” The News International, 1 May 2021)

Pakistan to restrict inbound flights from 5 May
On 1 May, the National Command and Operation Centre announced that the number of inbound flights would be reduced to 20 per cent from 5 May to 20 May, keeping in mind “the prevailing global and regional disease trends.” While complete details on which routes will be suspended are not yet announced, the NCOC said it would conduct a review on 8 May. (“Pakistan to slash international flights by 20pc from May 5 to 20 to curb Covid-19 cases,” Dawn, 1 May 2021)

 
Also read...                                                                                 
Fadh Husain in his opinion in Dawn commenting on similarities between the Daska and Karachi by-polls says that incompetence is accepting incompetence and not questioning incompetence.

An editorial in The Express Tribune critical of the NA-249 by-polls argues that another parliamentary election failed to determine which party people actually voted for. However, it argues that no amount of probe could lift the PTI to the top position to retain this National Assembly seat. Another editorial in The News International argues the low voter turnout shows that there is declining interest of the people in the electoral process, a dangerous trend that never bodes well for democratic rights and traditions.
 




"Only public legitimacy through judicial reform and effective constitutionalism can secure judicial independence."
-An opinion in Dawn on the Justice Isa judgement

 


Click below links for month wise archive

2023 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May
2022 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec
2021 - Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec
2020 - May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec